High Quality
Open the downloaded document, and select print from the file menu (PDF reader required).
b77c98fa-adc9-4fd7-81c3-4a4be6f7a375Electronically signed by Maria Beesley (501-187-561-9309)
Page 5192UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTCENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIASOUTHERN DIVISIONTHE HON. CORMAC J. CARNEY, JUDGE PRESIDINGUNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ))PLAINTIFF, ))VS. ) NO. SACR 08-00139-CJCWILLIAM J. RUEHLE, )DEFENDANT. ) _________________________________)REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGSSANTA ANA, CALIFORNIATUESDAY,DECEMBER 15, 20099:00MARIA BEESLEY-DELLANEVE, CSR 9132OFFICIAL FEDERAL REPORTERRONALD REAGAN FEDERAL BUILDING411 W. 4TH STREET, ROOM 1-053SANTA ANA, CA 92701(714) 564-9259
b77c98fa-adc9-4fd7-81c3-4a4be6f7a375Electronically signed by Maria Beesley (501-187-561-9309)
Page 51931
APPEARANCES:
2
FOR THE PLAINTIFF:
GEORGE S. CARDONA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY3 BY: ANDREW STOLPERAND ROBB ADKINS,4 GREG STAPLES,ASSISTANT UNITED STATES ATTORNEY5 411 W. 4TH STREET, 8TH FLOORSANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA 92701678910
FOR THE DEFENDANT RUEHLE:
SKADDEN ARPS SLATE MEAGHER
BY:
RICHARD MARMARO, ESQ.11 AND JACK DICANIO, ESQ.MATTHEW UMHOFER, ESQ.12 300 SOUTH GRAND AVENUELOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 9007113 (213)687-553514
FOR HENRY SAMUELI:
MCDERMOTT WILL & EMERY
BY: GORDON GREENBERG, ESQ.15 2049 CENTURY PARK EAST, SUITE 3800LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90067-321816 (310) 551-939817FOR HENRY NICHOLAS: WILLIAMS & CONNOLLY LLP18 BY: BRENDAN SULLIVAN, ESQ.725 TWELFTH STREET N.W.19 WASHINGTON D.C. 20005(202) 434-54602021
FOR DAVID DULL:
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLVER & HEDGES
BY: JAMES ASPERGER, ESQ.22 AND SETH ARONSON, ESQ.865 S. FIGUEROA ST 10TH FL23 LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 900172425
b77c98fa-adc9-4fd7-81c3-4a4be6f7a375Electronically signed by Maria Beesley (501-187-561-9309)
Page 51941
SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA; TUESDAY, DECEMBER 15, 2009
2
-OOO-
3
THE CLERK:
ITEM NUMBER ONE, SACR 08-139-CJC. UNITED
4
STATES VERSUS WILLIAM J. RUEHLE.
5
COUNSEL, PLEASE STATE YOUR APPEARANCES FOR THE RECORD.
6
MR. ADKINS:
GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. ROBB ADKINS,
7
GEORGE CARDONA, ANDREW STOLPER, AND GREG STAPLES ON BEHALF OF THE
8
UNITED STATES.
9
THE COURT:
GOOD MORNING, GENTLEMEN.
10
MR. MARMARO:
GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. RICHARD MARMARO
11
AND JACK DICANIO FOR MR. RUEHLE, WHO IS PRESENT.
12
THE COURT:
GOOD MORNING.
13
AND I THINK WE HAVE SOME OTHER LAWYERS; RIGHT? AND
14
PARTIES?
15
MR. SULLIVAN, I SEE YOU THERE, SIR.
16
MR. SULLIVAN:
BRENDAN SULLIVAN OF WILLIAMS AND CONNOLLY
17
FOR DR. HENRY NICHOLAS.
18
MR. ASPERGER:
GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. JIM ASPERGER
19
AND SETH ARONSON FOR MR. DULL.
20
MR. GREENBERG:
GORDON GREENBERG ON BEHALF OF DR. HENRY
21
SAMUELI, WHO IS PRESENT BEFORE THE COURT.
22
THE COURT:
GOOD MORNING TO ALL OF YOU.
23
WHAT I THOUGHT I WOULD DO IS READ INTO THE RECORD MY
24
DECISION, AND THEN I'LL GIVE EVERYONE A NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY TO
25
SAY WHATEVER THEY WANT TO SAY ON THE RECORD.
Add a Comment