Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Duxbury Motion Denied by Middlesex Superior Court

Duxbury Motion Denied by Middlesex Superior Court

Ratings: (0)|Views: 83 |Likes:
Published by Duxbury Clipper

More info:

Published by: Duxbury Clipper on Jul 18, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

07/18/2012

pdf

text

original

 
COMMONWEALTEOFMASSACHUSETTStv1IDDLESEX,
55.
)))))
CALMGOLF,INC.andCHARLESLANZETTA,)Defendants,)
))))
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
))
)))
)
JOHNSONGOLFMANAGEMENT,INC.,Plaintiff,
v.
andTOWNOFDUXBURY,andNORTHHILL
ADVISORYCOMMITTEE,
consisting
of
MICHAELDOOLIN,
CHAIRMAN,
SCOTTW~I-IITCOMB,ROBERTM.MUSTARD,
JR.,
tv1ICHAEL
MARLBOROUGH,ANTHONYFLOREANO,MICHAELT.RUFO,THOMASK.GARRITY,RIel-lARDMANNING,W.JAMESFORD,andGORDONCUSHING(EXOFFICIO),Defendants/Thi
rd-
PartyPlaintiffs,
v.
ROBERTS.TROY,Third-PartyDefendant.
PILGRIMGOLF,
LLC,
Intervenor.
SUPERIORCOURTDEPARTMENTCIVILACTIONNO.08-04641
DEFENDANTTOWNOFDUXBURY'STHIRD-PARTYCOMPLAINTAGAINSTROBERTS.TROY
1.Defendant/Third-PartyPlaintiffTownofDuxbury(the"Town")bringsthisthird-partycomplaintagainstThird-PartyDefendantRobert
S.
Troy("Troy")forcontributionforandindemnificationagainstanyliabilitythattheTown
may
incurtoPlaintiffJohnsonGolfManagement,Inc.("JohnsonGolf')inthisactionandforotherdamages.
 
JURISDICTION2.ThisCourthasjurisdictiontohearthisclaimunderG.L.c.212,§4andtopermitimpleaderofthethird-partyunderMass.
R.
Civ.P.14(a).
PARTIES
3.TheTownisabodypoliticdulyincorporatedunderthelawsofMassachusettswithabusinessaddressat878TremontStreet,Duxbury,MA02332-4499.4.TroyisanattorneypracticingatTroyWallAssociates,90Route6A,Sandwich,MA02563-1866.Atallrelevanttimes,TroyservedasTownCounseltotheTown,andherepresentedtheTowninthisactionuntilMay2012.PLAINTIFF'SCLAIMSAGAINSTTHETOWN5.InitsAmendedComplaint,JohnsonGolfclaimsthattheTownimproperlyfailedtoaward
it
acontracttomanageapublicgolfcourseknownasNorthHillCountryClub("NorthHill")inviolationofG.L.c.30BandG.L.c.93A.Morespecifically:a.InSeptember2008,JohnsonGolfthemanagerofNorthHillunderapreviouscontract,submittedaproposa1inresponsetoarequestforproposalsbytheTownunderG.Lc.30BtomanageNorthHillforafive-yearterm2009-2013("RFPI").Itallegesthat
it
submittedthehighestpriceproposaloftheeligible,qualifiedproposersandshouldhavebeenawardedthecontract.
It
allegesthattheTownviolatedG.
L.
c.30BinrejectingallproposalsreceivedinresponsetoRFPI,includingJohnsonGolf's,b.InJanuary2009,JohnsonGolfsubmittedanotherproposalinresponsetoasecondrequestforproposalsbytheTownforNorthHill("RFPII").
It
allegesthatitagainsubmittedthehighestpriceproposaloftheeligible,qualifiedproposersandshouldhavebeen
2
 
awardedthecontract.ItallegesthattheTownviolatedG.
1.
c.30BinawardingthecontracttoDefendantCALMGolf.
FACTS
6.TroyservedascounseltotheTownthroughouttheentirebiddingprocessforNorthHill.HeadvisedanddirectedTownofficials'actionsthroughoutthatprocess.7.In2008,attheoutsetofthebiddingprocess,RichardMacDonald,.DuxburyTownManagerandchiefbiddingofficer,instructed
Troy
tooverseethebiddingprocessforNorthHilltoensurethatitwasconductedinstrictcompliancewithallapplicablelawsandregulations.8.TroyrevieweddraftsofRFPIthatwerecompiled
by
GordonCushing,theTown'sRecreationDirector,andrecommendedamendments.Oneoftheamendmentsthathedraftedandrecommended,providingthat"comparablebusinessenterprises"wouldbeeligiblebiddersalongwithcompaniesthathadmanagedgolfcourses,basbeenafocusofJohnsonGolf'sclaimsthatRFPsIandIIviolatedG.L.c.30BandevidencethattheTownviolatedG.L.c.93A.9.InOctober2008,theTownreceivedfiveproposalsinresponsetoRFP
T,
includingonesfromJohnsonGolfand
CALM
Golf.
It
appointedthreeevaluatorstoevaluatethenon-pricepartsofthoseproposals.
-
~
10.InNovember2008,Townofficialsreviewedtheevaluationsandnotedthattwooftheevaluatorsbadnotcompletedtheirnon-priceevaluationsproperly.Mr.MacDonaldsoughtTroy'sadvice
011
thatissue.11.TroytoldMr.MacDonaldthathehadbeenadvisedbytheInspectorGeneral'sofficethattheTownshouldrejectalltheproposalsandstartover.BasedonTroy'sadvice,MacDonaldrejectedthoseproposalsandinstitutedanewprocesstoissueRFPII.12.InDecember2008,JohnsonGolfbroughtthisaction.
3

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->