7
Ai Lgs 40& 4>77& ~fgcixcee ecfmh gi gipzmt xa xbm `a}ixmt `fgcl "Ha`) Mix) 2 gihgeectlgxcum hmemipmp "Ha`) Mix) 3)7]ICXMH PXGXMP HCPXTC@X @A]TXMGPXMTI HCPXTC@X AE LC@BCJGIPA]XBMTI HCUCPCAI@BTCPXA^BMT GTLPXTAIJ@GPM IA) 4;77,@U,77347^fgcixcee&K]HJM GTXB]T K) XGTIAZLGJCPXTGXM K]HJM ^G]F K) OALCUMPu)GIHTMZ PBCTUMFF&Hmemihgix&!
ATHMT JTGIXCIJ CI ^GTX^FGCIXCEE–P A@XADMT 07& 4>77 LAXCAI EAT PGI@XCAIP "Ha`) Mix) 82#G)Dg`ojta}ih
^fgcixcee atcjcigffs ecfmh xbcp `gpm ci Zgpbxmigz @a}ixs @ct`}cx @a}tx ai at gda}x G~tcf7& 4>77) Xbmtm gtm pcr "5 `g}pmp ae g`xcai& ci`f}hcij g `a}ix eat ciugpcai ae ~tcug`s; egfpm fcjbx"@a}ix CCC µµ 35,7>:) Ha`) Mix) 7 gx =,40)Hmemihgix tmlaumh xbm `gpm xa xbcp @a}tx ai Lgs 4& 4>77) Ai Lgs 5& 4>77& hmemihgixecfmh g laxcai xa hcplcpp }ihmt Emh) T) @cu) ^) 74"d"5& g laxcai xa pxtcom }ihmt Emh) T) @cu) ^)74"e& gih g ~tmpmixgxcai ae `a}ixmt`fgclp& ci`f}hcij "C xatxca}p cixmtemtmi`m zcxb g d}pcimpptmfgxcaipbc~? "CC hmeglgxcai? gih "CCC ciugpcai ae ~tcug`s; egfpm fcjbx) Ha`) Mix) 4 gx 78,47)
7
^fgcixcee ecfmh bcp zcximpp fcpx ai K}im 3& 4>77& zbc`b ci`f}hmp xbm iglmp ae latm xbgiecexs,ea}t "=8 cihcuch}gfp) Ha`) Mix) 78) Ai K}fs 77& 4>77& hmemihgix ecfmh bcp zcximpp fcpx&glaij zbc`b gtm xbm iglmp ae xbctxs,pcr "05 cihcuch}gfp) Ha`) Mix) 48)
4;77,`u,77347,GKX,^KO Ha` # 2: Ecfmh >7!74!74 ^j 7 ae 74 ^j CH 788>
4Ai Pm~xmldmt 47& 4>77& K}hjm Xgtiaz mixmtmh g pxc~}fgxmh athmt pxtcocij ~gtgjtg~bpcrxs,aim "µ 57 ae ~fgcixcee–p `al~fgcix) Ha`) Mix) 0=) Ai A`xadmt 70& 4>77& K}hjm Xgtiazmixmtmh gi athmt hmiscij hmemihgix–p laxcai xa hcplcpp& laxcai xa pxtcom) Ha`) Mix) 03)Ai A`xadmt 45& 4>77& hmemihgix Pbctumff ecfmh gi gipzmt "Ha`) Mix) 85 xa ~fgcixcee Gtlpxtaij–p `al~fgcix "Ha`) Mix) 7)
D)Hcp`aumts Athmtp
Ai Lgs 4=& 4>77& K}hjm Xgtiaz `aih}`xmh g p`bmh}fcij `aiemtmi`m& gx zbc`b pmumtgfhgxmp zmtm pmx) Ai Lgs 4:& 4>77& K}hjm Xgtiaz mixmtmh gi athmt "Ha`) Mix) 7> xmtlcigxcij gplaax hmemihgix–p laxcai xa pxtcom hcp`aumts ~fgi) ^}tp}gix xa g K}im 7>& 4>77 ha`omx mixts&hcp`aumts zgp xa `allmi`m 7> hgsp gexmt xbm Lgs 4=& 4>77 `aiemtmi`m ai aifs @a}ix 0 ae ^fgcixcee*p `al~fgcix gih ai gff xbtmm "0 ae Hmemihgix*p `a}ixmt`fgclp) Hcp`aumts zgp xbmi xa`allmi`m ai gis ae ^fgcixcee*p tmlgcicij ecum "= `fgclp zcxbci 7> hgsp gexmt K}hjm Xgtiazcpp}mp g hm`cpcai ai Hmemihgix*p Laxcai xa Hcplcpp) Ghhcxcaigffs& xbm mixts ~tauchmh xbgxhcp`aumts laxcaip zmtm h}m ds A`xadmt 4=& 4>77& hcp`aumts zgp xa dm `al~fmxmh ds Iaumldmt4=& 4>77 gih xbm hcp~apcxcum laxcai `}x,aee zgp pmx eat Hm`mldmt 40& 4>77)Pci`m xbmi& xbm @a}tx bgp mixmtmh pmumtgf hcp`aumts tmfgxmh athmtp) Eat mrgl~fm& ai K}im43& 4>77& K}hjm Xgtiaz mixmtmh gi athmt "Ha`) Mix) 47 hmiscij hmemihgix–p laxcai eat g~taxm`xcum athmt "Ha`) Mix) 7= gih jtgixcij ci ~gtx gih hmiscij ci ~gtx ~fgcixcee–p laxcai xa`al~mf tmp~aipmp xa ~fgcixcee–p ectpx tmw}mpx xa ~tah}`m& eat `apxp& gxxatims emmp gih eat pgi`xcaip"Ha`) Mix) 7: gih g pxc~}fgxmh athmt "Ha`) Mix) 44 xa p`bmh}fm hgxmp eat hmemihgix–p hm~apcxcaigih ~tah}`xcai ae ha`}lmixp)Ai G}j}px 0>& 4>77& K}hjm Xgtiaz mixmtmh gi athmt "Ha`) Mix) 00 hmiscij ~fgcixcee–p
4;77,`u,77347,GKX,^KO Ha` # 2: Ecfmh >7!74!74 ^j 4 ae 74 ^j CH 7887
4
Ai A`xadmt 42& 4>77& Pbctumff ecfmh g pm~gtgxm fgzp}cx gjgcipx Jathai) Xbmtmci& Pbctumffhcp`}ppmp xbm Gum Lgtcg P`baaf ae Fgz Fgzp}cx "µµ 5,48& xbm Fcem @bgci Hmlaipxtgxcai ai A`xadmt=& 4>>2 "µµ 4=,04& gih xbm ‖@btcp Gtlpxtaij Zgx`b“ Dfaj "µµ 00,=2) Pbctumff–p `g}pmp ae g`xcaigjgcipx Jathai ci`f}hm "C xatxca}p cixmtemtmi`m zcxb g d}pcimpp tmfgxcaipbc~ "µµ =3,34? "CChmeglgxcai "µµ 30,7=5? gih "CCC ciugpcai ae ~tcug`s; egfpm fcjbx "µµ 7=:,75>)Gfxba}jb xbcp `gpm zgp atcjcigffs gppcjimh xa K}hjm A–Lmgtg gih Lgjcpxtgxm K}hjm Tgihai&cx zgp tmgppcjimh xa K}hjm Xgtiaz gih lm gp g `al~gicai `gpm xa xbm cipxgix lgxxmt)
Pmm
@gpm Ia)4;77,`u,78:27,GKX,^KO)Hmemihgix Jathai ecfmh g laxcai xa hcplcpp ai Iaumldmt 0>& 4>77) Ha`) Mix) 5) K}hjmXgtiaz bgp tmemttmh xbgx laxcai xa lm eat mixts ae g tm~atx gih tm`allmihgxcai) Ha`) Mix) :)
0
Xbmtm gtm xbtmm "0 axbmt laxcaip ~mihcij dmeatm xbm @a}tx; iai,~gtxs Aihmkoa–p Hm`mldmt2& 4>77 laxcai eat g ~taxm`xcum athmt "Ha`) Mix) 52? hmemihgix Pbctumff–p Hm`mldmt 2& 4>77 laxcaieat pgi`xcaip gjgcipx ~fgcixcee Gtlpxtaij "Ha`) Mix) 53 gih hmemihgix Pbctumff–p Hm`mldmt 70& 4>77mlmtjmi`s laxcai xa mrxmih p`bmh}fcij athmt "Ha`) Mix) :7)Xbmpm laxcaip bgum dmmi tmemttmh xa lm eat bmgtcij gih hmxmtlcigxcai) Ha`) Mix) :4) AiKgi}gts 0& 4>74& C xaao hmemihgix Pbctumff–p Hm`mldmt 70& 4>77 mlmtjmi`s laxcai xa mrxmihp`bmh}fcij athmt "Ha`) Mix) :7 }ihmt ghucpmlmix) Iai,~gtxs Aihmkoa–p Hm`mldmt 2& 4>77 laxcaieat g ~taxm`xcum athmt "Ha`) Mix) 52 gih hmemihgix Pbctumff–p Hm`mldmt 2& 4>77 laxcai eatpgi`xcaip gjgcipx ~fgcixcee Gtlpxtaij "Ha`) Mix) 53 bgum dmmi iaxc`mh eat g Kgi}gts 4=& 4>74bmgtcij) Ha`) Mix) 25)0laxcai xa mrxmih xbm p`bmh}fcij athmt "Ha`) Mix) 4=) Ai Pm~xmldmt 7=& 4>77& C mixmtmh giathmt "Ha`) Mix) 08 jtgixcij ~fgcixcee–p laxcai xa `al~mf hcp`aumts "Ha`) Mix) 4:) AiIaumldmt 0& 4>77& K}hjm Xgtiaz mixmtmh gi athmt "Ha`) Mix) == jtgixcij ~fgcixcee–p mlmtjmi`slaxcai xa `al~mf hmemihgix–p hm~apcxcai "Ha`) Mix) 80)
4
@)Cipxgix Laxcai
p
7)
@}ttmixfs dmeatm xbm @a}tx gtm xza laxcaip)
0
Ai Pm~xmldmt 0>& 4>77& hmemihgix Pbctumffecfmh g laxcai eat athmt xa `al~mf hcp`aumts& gih eat `apxp& gxxatims emmp& gih pgi`xcaip "Ha`)Mix) 05& tmjgthcij zbc`b ~fgcixcee ecfmh gi A`xadmt 72& 4>77 `aldcimh tmp~aipm gih laxcai eat~taxm`xcum athmt "Ha`) Mix) 8> gih hmemihgix Pbctumff ecfmh g Iaumldmt 8& 4>77 tmp~aipm "Ha`)Mix) =5)
4)
Gfpa dmeatm xbm @a}tx cp ~fgcixcee–p A`xadmt 07& 4>77 laxcai eat pgi`xcaip "Ha`) Mix) 82&
4;77,`u,77347,GKX,^KO Ha` # 2: Ecfmh >7!74!74 ^j 0 ae 74 ^j CH 7884
Armstrong v Shirvell, MIED 2-11-cv-11921, Doc 87, ORDER Granting in Part 48 Motion for Sanctions (01-12-2012)
Armstrong v Shirvell, MIED 2-11-cv-11921, Doc 87, ORDER Granting in Part 48 Motion for Sanctions (01-12-2012)
309
Reads
0
Readcasts
0
Embed Views
Recommended
More From This User
Notes
Load more
