Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
P. 1
Administration Brief Voter ID

Administration Brief Voter ID

Ratings: (0)|Views: 261 |Likes:
Published by lauraeolson

More info:

Published by: lauraeolson on Jul 19, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

10/06/2013

pdf

text

original

 
INTHECOMMONWEALTHCOURTOFPENNSYLVANIAVIVIETTEAPPLEWHITE,
etal.,
Petitioners,.
v.
CaseNo.330MD2012THECOMMONWEALTHOFPENNSYLVANIA,THOMASCORBETT,Governor,andCAROLAICHELE,SecretaryoftheCommonwealth,Respondents.BRIEFINOPPOSITIONTOPETITIONERS'APPLICATIONFORPRELIMINARYINJUNCTIONLINDAL.KELLYAttorneyGeneralPATRICKS.CAWLEYSeniorDeputyAttorneyGeneralAttorneyId.No.85575CALVINR.KOONSSeniorDeputyAttorneyGeneralAttorneyId.No.32536OfficeofAttorneyGeneralCivilLitigationSection15
th
Floor,StrawberrySquareHarrisburg,PA17120Phone:717-783-3146Fax:717-772-4526pcawley@atforneygeneral.govGREGORY
R.
NEUHAUSERChiefDeputyAttorneyGeneralChief,CivilLitigationSection0
0;~~
..__:~~I","
4
c.._:--,")
f~"'...
'"
..:,.,_),-_-"
'j
.........:J':.~'".:.-_~
I
CJl.:,.:,'~:
.
:'1
,i....
t.-..
Date:July18,2012
\D
>
~~,/:J
-I
 
TABLEOFCONTENTSINTRODUCTION1STATEMENTOFJURISDICTION3STATEMENTOFTHESCOPEANDTHESTANDARDOFREVIEW4STATEMENTOFQUESTIONINVOLVED5STATEMENTOFTHECASE6FACTUALBACKGROUND7HouseBill9347RequirementsofAct188PennDOTDriverLicensesandNon-DriverPhotoIDCards10DepartmentofStateEffortstoEnsurethatVotersHavePhotoID11SUMMARYOFARGUMENT:14ARGUMENT16A.NoImmediateandIrreparableHarm17B.PetitionersAreNotLikelyToSucceedOnTheMerits18
1.
TheCommonwealthandtheGovernorasImproperParties192.ArticleI,Section5ofthePennsylvaniaConstitution203.EqualProtectionunderArticleI,Sections1and26ofthePennsylvaniaConstitution234.ArticleVII,Section1ofthePennsylvaniaConstitution29
 
EVIDENCETOBEPRESENTED31CONCLUSION
33
11

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->