Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
3532

3532

Ratings: (0)|Views: 2,724 |Likes:
Published by lc_nichols5019

More info:

Published by: lc_nichols5019 on Aug 06, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

10/26/2013

pdf

text

original

 
H(CE,VEO
OFFICEOF
CLERKOF
COURTS
2012AUG-
J
PH3:3S
DAUPHINCDT\(
PENNA
COMMONWEALTHOFPENNSYLVANIA:INTHECOURTOFCOMMONPLEASOFDAUPHINCOUNTY
v.
TIMOTHYM.CURLEY,
Defendant
NO.CP-22-CR-5165-2011CHARGES:PERJURY;PENALTIESFORFAILURETOREPORTCOMMONWEALTHOFPENNSYLVANIA:INTHECOURTOFCOMMONPLEAS:OFDAUPHINCOUNTYv.:NO.CP-22-CR-5164-2011GARYCHARLESSCHULTZ,
Defendant
.CHARGES:PERJURY;PENALTIES:FORFAILURETOREPORTCOMMONWEALTH'SREPLYTODEFENDANTS'MOTIONFORDISCOVERY
AND
NOW,
comestheCommonwealthofPennsylvaniabyitsattorneys,AttorneyGeneralLinda
L.
KellyandChief.ofStaffBruce
R.
Beemer,whofilethisCommonwealth'sReplytoDefendants'MotionforDiscovery,andinsupportthereofaverasfollows:1.Admitted.2.Admittedinpartanddeniedinpart.AdmittedthatdefensecounseldidsendthefivelettersreferencedinDefendants'MotionforDiscovery
11
2a-e.Denied
 
thatanylettersentonNovember22,2011andreferencedasDefendants'2acouldconstituteanefforttoresolvediscovery,inasmuchasitpredatedthePreliminaryHearingheldinthismatteronDecember16,2011,andpursuanttoPa.
R.
Crim.P.573andotherapplicableRulesofProcedurethedefendantswerenotentitledtodiscoveryatthattime.3.Admitted.4.Admitted.5.AdmittedthatdefendantsareapparentlyrequestingmaterialslistedinPa.R.Crim.P.573(8)(2).DeniedthatdisclosureofsuchitemsismandatoryabsentanOrderofCourt.Itisfurtherdeniedthatalloftherequestsarematerialtothepreparationofthedefenseand/orreasonable.6.Admitted.7.AdmittedtotheextentthatthisstatementaccuratelyrecitesPa.R.E.404
(b).
8.
TheCommonwealthwilladdressthemanyalphabetizedsubpartsofthisavermentinthesamemannerasoutlinedintheDefendants'MotionforDiscovery.a.Admittedinpartanddeniedinpart.TheCommonwealthhasandwillcontinuetohonoritsdiscoveryobligationsasitrelatestopreparedinterviewstatementsbyinvestigators.Anystatementthatispreparedduringthecourseofthisongoinginvestigationhasbeenorwillbedisclosedtothedefense.Thisavermentisdeniedtotheextentthatitseeksnotesorotheritemsutilizedby
2
 
investigatorsinthepreparationofanywitnessinterview.SeeCommonwealthReplyfiledinthismatteronMarch30,2012.b.TheCommonwealthhasprovidedandwillcontinuetoprovidethesematerials.c.ThematterofGrandJurytestimonyhasbeenandcontinuestobedealtwithpursuanttoPa.RCnm.P.230.TotheextentthatanyrequestsintheDefendants'MotionforDiscoveryseeksotherwiseprotectedGrandJurymaterials,theappropriateremedyistoseekrelieffromtheSupervisingGrandJuryJudge.Itisspecificallydeniedthat
Commonwealthv.Hemingway
providesrelevantauthorityforanorderofdiscovery.d.Therearenoreportsmeetingthisdescription.e.DeniedtotheextentthatthisrequestasksforanymaterialorcommunicationunderPa.RCrim.P.230.Totheextentanyoftherequestedmaterialshouldbedisclosed,theappropriateremedyistoseekrelieffromtheSupervisingGrandJuryJudge.f.TheCommonwealthspecificallydeniesthatthisisanappropriatediscoveryrequestpursuanttoPa.R.Crim.P.573and230.Evenifthesoughtmaterialwasappropriatefordiscovery;however,thecorrectforuminwhichthedefendantsshouldseekreliefisbeforetheSupervisingGrandJuryJudge.g.TheCommonwealthhascompliedwiththerequestforcriminalrecordsbyprovidinginformationcontainingcriminalhistoriesofthe
3

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->