Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
P. 1
Mizvat Yishuv Eretz Yisrael

Mizvat Yishuv Eretz Yisrael

Ratings: (0)|Views: 79|Likes:
A chabura on Mitzvat Yishuv Eretz Yisrael. When where how why and is it even a mitzvah at all?
A chabura on Mitzvat Yishuv Eretz Yisrael. When where how why and is it even a mitzvah at all?

More info:

Published by: Aqibha Y. Weisinger Etc on Aug 12, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

06/19/2014

pdf

text

original

 
Mitzvat Yishuv Eretz Yisrael
All Accusations of Heresy Should be Directed to Akiva Weisinger 
 
The Basic Sources
! "#$ %&'( )*#$ #+,(+
 -.&/01234 5#676 !76 .,38#4%3/9/ )76 :%#;+4&< :)367/ %23; :96!87= )31#4(/71>4 !78#1* ?4%; %08+34 !76 #+38,3/ -70@  ->3,%(;* 4)3/ :)1><(+31 !231 )78>4 >3,+387/)34 :)12<'38(/ %(8!4/ !231 )78>4 :)1%3<23;* ?4(/ !231 )78 :)36,4+3/7;>4 :26%08$34(; 5#67191 %+8* 4%< !231 )76 :)36* 4#/><9>4 -+0@  -93)17< )* 6#6!1 5#67191 )76 %)3;)/01 :26!1 %23; 93+31 :)36+4* /%>; 5#67191 )76 :)36* 4#/><9>4 -0@ C SFeak unto the children of Gsrael and say unto theI@ When ye Fass over the Jordan into the land of Kanaan CL then ye shall drive out all the inhabitants of the land froI before you and destroy all their figured stones and destroy all their Iolten iIages and deIolish all their high Flaces CN And ye shall drive out the inhabitants of the land and dOell thereinP for unto you have G given the land to Fossess it .Q+(##+,(+)*#$%&'("#$! -:)*#>9> -0)75#79:)+*%>9+%2:2!%))0)75#79)*#!9)7!& R%)&,>)>(9*&9>% 7%9:)>7>+*%* 5#7+>*#%%>9)>7%27>990)07!> :9!>'7(%)!0+>!7> 99!&%!&:)&,)2!!*>+2!>5#7#&0*>75#7#>*7 .)!>>+*%)9!>>#+&% :*!&)>(9 HoO does the UaIban read the FassukVLWhat does he think the Fassuk is coIIandingVNWhat according to the UaIban is the status of soIeone living outside of Eretz YisraelV ,>(!)%!++)2'()>+>)2,%",>(&+ 7>9 @#Q)#(>77%9> )>!&!)#(>77!*)>!&!.%$>2 R9)>7:7> )>!&!>7!7) R7!+7%9 9+>)2)#(>77>9> )>!&!  #(>77!*)>!&!.%$>2 R>)>7:7> )>!&!>7!7%>% R.)%>7%9 9+>)2)#(>77>9> )7!#(>77!*)7!.%$>2 R9)>7 7!*:7> )7!>7!7) R7!+7>9 P9+>)2#(>77%9> )7!)#(>77!*)7!.%$>2 R>)>77!*:7> )7!>7!7%>% R .)%>9+>)2 -Background@ This geIara deals Oith a cases of disagreeIents betOeen husband and Oives that are grounds for divorce Additionally the rule is that a OoIan Oho Oillingly rebels against the Iitzvos can  be divorced Oithout her ketubahX What does this shoO about living in Eretz YisraelVL Gf this definition of Mitzvas Yishuv Eretz Yisrael is correct Ohy did it take until Z for an organized atteIFt to resettle the landV What are the iIFlications of your ansOerV
 
Gs it even a IitzvahV
! "#$ %&'( )*#$ #+,(+ %Q*#-9+ :%%")9! >!2>) 7! >7! :7> 9+ :%%")9! >!2>) 9+ :)+*%> 7> 9%+*>%( 9)>7 :)*#>9> R 5#79 )7 :)*#>9> -0HoO does Uashi read the Fassuk different froI UaIbanVLWhat are the iIFlications of such a reading for the Mitzva of Yishuv Eretz YisraelV Does Uashi hold it is a IitzvaV+ ,>(& %" , )>+>)2 )2'( )>$'>)9(2 *% %2 %Q7+ #>,! 9>( >0%7 >%*2&, :%% >0%+# #(>7 9%9> :%2#, )02' 72%7, 99 .(+ 9>0 >0%7 R >2 )>!&! #(>7 7>9 :9%!& ,>(&!> :9+ #9%! .%!>2% >07 .%7, .%*0>& 9(2> 5#7+ )>%>!)9 )>(Does Tosafot think there is a Iitzva to live in Eretz YisraelV Gf so Ohen does this Iitzvah aFFlyVLWhat tOo reasons are given for his oFinionVNGs Tosafots oFinion different froI UashiV Gf so hoOV[What FrobleIs could be raised Oith Tosafots oFinionV.%*&9 )2* :Q+(#! )>>(9 #$'! .Q+(#9 )>*9>0%)!> ,%+ 9+&0 7!> +"&%!> "%! :9#+7! >0%)>+7! 9!&)%> \#+)% !79 .)0 #*7 5#79 )*#! >0%>]0* )%&%+# 9>( 9((*! >7 )>(>79 .( This is Fart of the UaIbans criti^ue of UaIbaIs count of the _N MitzvosWhich Mitzva does the UaIbaI `forget according to the UaIbanVLDoes this Iake sense Oith Ohat Oeve seen froI the UaIban so farVNGf you dont knoO the ansOers to the above L ^uestions G have failed you
"
 מרוכלהיכלמרפכלה
:%#( 5#7( 5> :!>&9 !2+ .>2*! #)>(>What is the iIFlication of this halacha in the UaIbaIVLHoO Oould the UaIban differV NWhat does this say about the UaIbaIs conceFtion of the Mitzva of Yishuv Eretz YisraelVSefer Megillat Esther Uav Yitzchak Deeon 
th
 Kentury`Gt aFFears to Ie that the fact that UaIbaI ecludes the coIIandIent of settling the and froI the _N Mitzvos is due to the fact that this Oas a coIIandIent only during the earlier generations of Moshe Yehoshua and David The Mitzvah reIained intact until the eile HoOever once AI Yisrael Oent into eile this Mitzvah Oas indeed susFended until the coIing of Mashiach n the contrary it Oould aFFear froI the TalIud at the end of Massechet etubot that Oe are forbidden to return en Iasse to Eretz Yisrael until the end of days The fact that our Uabbis Fraised the idea of living in Gsrael Oas clearly referring to the tiIes Ohen the TeIFle Oas still standing hoOever noOadays there is no such Mitzvah This is also the oFinion of Tosafos in esubosHoO does this eFlain the UaIbaIs oIission of `Yishuv Eretz Yisrael froI his count of IitzvosV What are the advantages of this eFlanationVLAccording to the Megillat Esthers eFlanation of the UaIbaI Ohat is the status of `Yishuv Eretz YisraelVNThe Megillat Esther claiIs this is the oFinion of the Tosafos in esubos Gs this trueV Why or

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->