BennieR.Click
P.O.Box17186
MundsPark,Arizona86017
Tel(928)286-9750
FAX(928)286-9750
Cell(928)600-1622
November29,2011Mr.BradleyJ.Biggs,Esq.TheDoyleFirm,P.C.1313E.OsbornRoad,Suite100Phoenix,Arizona85014
Re:Huminskiv.CityofSurpriseet
al,
U.S.DistrictCourtNo.2:11-cv-00896-DGC
DearMr.Biggs,Informulatingmyopinionsinthiscase,Ihavereviewedthefollowingmaterials:1.AudiorecordingoftheinterviewofMr.NelsonbyOfficerHectorHerediaonApril13,2011;2.E-mailfromOfficerHerediatoMr.ScottHuminski,thePlaintiff,datedApril13,2011;3.RecordedvoicemailmessageleftbybyMr.HuminskitoOfficerHeredia,
SecondrecordedvoicemailmessageleftbyMr.HuminskiforOfficerHeredia;bothmessagesleftonApril13,2011;4.RecordedtelephonecallmadebyOfficerHerediatoMr.Huminski,datedApril13,2011;5.E-mailfromOfficerHerediatoMr.HuminskidatedApril14,2011;6.CivilComplaintfiledbyMr.HuminskiintheMaricopaCountyHighlandJusticeCourtallegingdamagescausedbyOfficerHerediaandtheSurprisePoliceDepartment,datedApril14,2011;7.PleadingbyPlaintiffinMesaMunicipalCourtrequestingcontinuanceinaHarassmentactionagainstJustinNelsonandrequestingtheCourttoholdOfficerHerediaincriminalcontemptforobstructionofjusticeandwitnesstampering;datedApril14,2011;8.E-mailfromMr.HuminskitoMr.BradleyBiggs,Defendants'counsel,
datedMay6,2011;
SURP000037
•Page2
November30,2011
9.E-mailfromMr.BiggstoMr.Huminski,datedMay6,2011;10.E-mailfromMr.HuminskitoMr.Biggs,datedMay9,2011;11.Defendants'ResponseToPlaintiffsMotionForPreliminaryInjunctionAndEmergencyMotionForATemporaryrestrainingOrderdatedMay27,2011;12.AffidavitsofOfficerHectorHeredia,Lt.JohnBaconandLt.HaroldBrady,datedMay26,2011;13.CityofSurprisetelephoneextensionlogsforApril13,2011;14.Variousinternetarticles/blogs,etc.regardingMichaelNelsonandScottHuminski.
PersonalBackground
Ihavethirty-five(35)yearsofexperienceworkinginlawenforcement.Ihaveanadditionaleleven(11)yearsoflawenforcementrelatedexperience.IhaveservedinnumerousassignmentsfromPoliceOfficertoPoliceChiefinboththePhoenix,ArizonaandDallas,TexasPoliceDepartments.WhileservingastheDallasPoliceChief,IalsoservedastheAssistantCityManagerforPublicSafetyfromAugust1998toFebruary1999.Ihavebeeninvolvedinapproximatelyfivethousand(5,000)
internalinvestigationsthatexaminedpoliceemployees'conductandperformance.Ihaveinterviewedandtrainedhundredsofpoliceofficers,supervisorsandcommandpersonnel.Ihaveparticipatedintheresearch,developmentandimplementationofpolicies,proceduresandtraininggoverninghowpoliceofficersperformtheirjobs.Ihavebeeninvolvedintakingdisciplinaryandcorrectiveactionsinthoseincidentswhereitwasdeterminedthedepartments'policiesandprocedureswereviolated.Thereisabodyofknowledgeregardinglawenforcementpracticesandstandardsthathasevolvedintheinterestsoffosteringprofessionalismandeffectiveness.ThroughtheprofessionalassociationstowhichIbelong,mydiscussionswithcolleagues,mytrainingandpersonalexperiences,Iamfamiliarwiththegenerallyacceptedpolicies,proceduresandtrainingthatgoverntheperformanceandconductoflawenforcementofficers.
BackgroundInformation
OnthemorningofApril13,2011,Mr.MichaelNelsoncontactedOfficerHectorHerediaoftheSurprisePoliceDepartmentallegingthatheandhisattorneywere.beingthreatenedandharassedbythePlaintiff,ScottHuminski.Mr.NelsonreportedthattheharassmentwastheresultofacivildisputebetweenhimandMr.Huminski
(RecordedinterviewofMr.NelsonbyOfficerHeredia).
SURP000038
•Page3November30,2011
AfterreceivingtheinformationprovidedbyMr.Nelson,OfficerHerediasentane-mailtoMr.HuminskilaterthatmorningadvisinghimofMr.Nelson'sharassmentallegation.OfficerHerediasentane-mailbecausehedidnothaveanyothercontactinformationforMr.Huminski.Inthee-mail,OfficerHerediarequestedaninterviewwithMr.Huminskitogethissideofthestory.OfficerHerediastatedinthee-mail"PleasedonothaveanytypeofcontactwitheitherMichaelNelsonorAnthonyTsontakislaw(Nelson'sattorney)untilIspeakwithyouandhearyourside."OfficerHerediarequestedaninterviewwithMr.HuminskiandincludedhisPoliceDepartmenttelephonenumberinthee-mail
(Heredia'sApril
13,
2011e-mail).
DuringthenextseveralhoursMr.Huminskirespondedtothee-mailbyleavingseveralvoicemailsforOfficerHeredia.Inthevoicemails,Mr.HuminskiaccusesOfficerHerediaofinterferingwithcivillitigationandHuminskiindicatedhewouldpursuecriminalcharges.Mr.HuminskidemandedthattheordertonothavecontactwithMr.
NelsonandhisattorneyberescindedimmediatelyorhewillfilealawsuitagainstthePoliceDepartment.Mr.HuminskilefthistelephonenumberandOfficerHerediawasabletomaketelephonecontactwithMr.HuminskilaterintheafternoonofApril13,2011(Recordedvoicemailmessages).DuringOfficerHeredia'stelephoneconversationwithMr.HuminskionApril13,2011,
Mr.HuminskiaccusedOfficerHerediaofobstructionofjustice,ofviolatingstateandfederallaw,ofthreateninghimandconspiringtoevadestateandfederaltaxlaws.Mr.HuminskialsostatedthathehasbeenharassedandthreatenedbyMr.Nelson.OfficerHerediainformedMr.Huminskithathewantedtobefairtohimbygettinghissideofthestoryforthepolicereport.OfficerHerediatoldMr.HuminskithatallhecoulddowasrequestthatMr.HuminskihavenocontactwithMr.NelsonandNelson'sattorney.OfficerHerediainformedMr.HuminskithathecouldnotorderhimorpreventhimfromcontactingthemanditwashischoicewhetherornottocontactMr.Nelsonandhisattorney.
(Recordedphoneconversation,April
13,
2011,HerediaAffidavit).
Thenextday,April14,2011,Mr.HuminskifiledsuitagainsttheCityofSurprise,OfficerHerediaandtwootherCityemployeesintheMaricopaCountyHighlandJusticeCourtinGilbert.Mr.Huminskiclaimedthathehadsuffereddamagesduetothedefendants'disregardforhisrights,harassment,negligenceandthedefendants'coercivemanipulationofacivilcourtmatter.Heaskedthecourttoawardhim
$9999.99(HighlandJusticeCourtComplaint).
OnApril14,2011,OfficerHerediasentane-mailtoMr.Huminski.OfficerHerediaaskedMr.Huminskitocomeintothestationforidentificationpurposesbecauseitisnotpossibletoconfirmaperson'sidentitythroughphonecallsande-mails.OfficerHerediatoldMr.HuminskihehaduntilApril16,2011tocomeinandgivehissideofthestoryandifhedidnot,thereportwouldbeforwardedtotheprosecutor'sofficeonlycontainingtheinformationprovidedbyMr.Nelson
(Herediae-mail,April14,
2011).
ThereisnoindicationMr.Huminskicametothestationtobeinterviewed.Lt.JohnBaconoftheSurprisePoliceDepartmentstatedthathecontactedMr.HuminskibytelephoneonApril19,2011,andtoldhimthatatnotimewasheordered
SURP000039
Search History:
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
p.
Arpaio Expert Witness, Bennie R. Click, Allegedly engages in felony impersonation of an attorney and unauthorized practice of law in Federal Court
Arpaio's police state comrade opines on the constitutionality of police conduct in alleged criminal contempt of the rules of the AZ Supreme Court forbidding unauthorized practice of law and allegedly constituting felony criminal impersonation of an attorney in violation of 13 ARS 2006. Bad cop!
487
Reads
0
Readcasts
232
Embed Views
More From This User
Notes
Load more
