Jacob ShamsianChaucerian IronyIrony is not an uncommon element found in wring, and it is certainlynot uncommon in the works of Geoffrey Chaucer. So much has Chaucer usedirony in his works, that the term “Chaucerian Irony” was coined. Many peoplesee Chaucerian Irony as resulting from a view of human beings asfundamentally flawed and complex creations that developed from earlyHumanism. The Pardoner is perhaps the most intricate example of irony; his verycharacter is riddled with the subject. Found in The Canterbury Tales, he is aperson who, if someone were to be asked to give a paradigm of an ironicperson, would be the first to be thought of. He can be characterized as an"honest liar," a phrase both ironic and oxymoronic. To fit into this category,he succeeds in being scrupulously honest when asked a direct question, andfurther representing a moral value that can be derived by the answer hegives. Such is can be manifested through various situations that he putshimself through. Perhaps the most significant example of this is shown rightbefore he begins his tale. He begins by saying that the ultimate moral of histale will be that "Radix malorum est Cupiditas,"
greed (or gluttony) is theroot of all evil
. Yet he refuses to begin his tale until he has a bottle of wineand some food in his hands; transparent about the fact that he's gluttonous.His religious affiliation encompasses spectrum of being hypocritical,ironic, a paradox. As a Pardoner, his job is directly related to religious belief and the purity of oneself before G-d. Aside from his religious occupation of being a Pardoner, he is also a merchant! He is both a religious figure and anoutright swindler! He even goes so far in his arrogance - another sin - to tellhis customers that the "ancient" relics that he is selling them are fake. Andyet, he is so sly and cunning that he is able to sell the items in his inventoryanyway. Clearly this behavior is most disrespectful to G-d, who he issupposedly doing a service to. He thus renders any religious affiliation of hisnull and most likely does not believe in any of it. The Pardoner provides various examples of his hypocrisy throughoutthe telling of his tale. During it, he does not hesitate to pause and insert a bitof commentary that clearly contradicts what he had just said in the previoussentence. It almost seems like his tale is a back-and-forth argument betweenthe morals presented in it and his replies rebutting those morals with eitherdisagreement or sarcasm.For instance, before he begins the tale he is asked to tell a story with amoral, and complies. However, throughout the tale he references himself doing sinful and immoral acts. Among the fact that he is a swindler asmentioned above, he paints himself as a glutton, a gambler, and a liar. In histale, he supports the virtues of honesty, and modesty (in the sense of
Add a Comment
Reader93left a comment