Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
P. 1
120926 - JPMorgan Chase Et Al v City of Cleveland 6th Cir Remand

120926 - JPMorgan Chase Et Al v City of Cleveland 6th Cir Remand

Ratings: (0)|Views: 10|Likes:
Published by Mike_Dillon
Though this case has as its background such weighty factual topics as subprime-mortgage lending, foreclosures, and the precarious economic state of the post-industrial Midwest, the issue at stake in this appeal is solely procedural. Our task is to determine whether the district court had subject-matter jurisdiction over a suit by several financial institutions seeking declaratory and injunctive relief from two other lawsuits filed by the City of Cleveland. We conclude that it did. Because the district court nonetheless dismissed the suit sua sponte for failure to state a claim without notice to the parties, we REVERSE the judgment of the district court and REMAND for further proceedings.
Though this case has as its background such weighty factual topics as subprime-mortgage lending, foreclosures, and the precarious economic state of the post-industrial Midwest, the issue at stake in this appeal is solely procedural. Our task is to determine whether the district court had subject-matter jurisdiction over a suit by several financial institutions seeking declaratory and injunctive relief from two other lawsuits filed by the City of Cleveland. We conclude that it did. Because the district court nonetheless dismissed the suit sua sponte for failure to state a claim without notice to the parties, we REVERSE the judgment of the district court and REMAND for further proceedings.

More info:

Published by: Mike_Dillon on Sep 28, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/29/2012

pdf

text

original

 
(
Ugk Gaba}omfk Ia}eab H" _{nsu& [bnuke Suouks Ensu}ncu H{eik da} ugk Yksuk}b Ensu}ncu ad Lncgniob& snuunbi m~ eksnibounab"
]KCALLKBEKE DA] D[FF,UKWU Z[MFNCOUNAB 
Z{}s{obu ua Snwug Cn}c{nu ]{fk =:4Dnfk Bolk8 ?=o:357z":4
[BNUKE SUOUKS CA[]U AD OZZKOFS
DA] UGK SNWUG CN]C[NUQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ
C
GOSK
M
OB@
[SO&
 
B"O"&
 
HZL
A]IOB
C
GOSK
M
OB@
&
 
B"O"&
 
HZL
A]IOB
L
A]UIOIK
O
C_[NSNUNAB
C
A]Z
"& obe H"Z"
 
L
A]IOB
S
KC[]NUNKS
&
 
N
BC
"&
Zfonbundds,Ozzkffobus!C}ass,Ozzkffkks
&
t"
C
NU^ AD
C
FKTKFOBE
&
Ekdkbeobu,Ozzkffkk!C}ass,Ozzkffobu"
W,,,,
2
&,,,,,B
Bas" ?:,5??;!5??4
Ozzkof d}al ugk [bnuke Suouks Ensu}ncu Ca{}uda} ugk Ba}ugk}b Ensu}ncu ad Agna ou Cfktkfobe"Ba" :7,::;?5―So}o K" Fnan& Ensu}ncu H{eik"Ekcneke obe Dnfke8 Skzuklmk} =4& =:?=Mkda}k8 LAA]K obe I]NDDNB& Cn}c{nu H{eiks& obe _[NSU& Ensu}ncu H{eik"
(
QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ
CA[BSKFAB M]NKD8
Nsooc Scg{fx& Lncgokf B" [bio}& ]ncgn` So}`o}& [FLK] $ MK]BK FFZ&Cfktkfobe& Agna& da} Ozzkffobus!C}ass,Ozzkffkks" Hasg{o ]" Cagkb& CAGKB]ASKBUGOF $ @]OLK] FFZ& Cfktkfobe& Agna& da} Ozzkffkks!C}ass,Ozzkffobus"
QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQAZNBNABQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ
@O]KB BKFSAB LAA]K& Cn}c{nu H{eik" Ugk da}kcfas{}k c}nsns ugou sykzu ugkbounab nb ugk fouuk} gofd ad ugk zosu ekcoek gnu Cfktkfobe zo}unc{fo}f~ go}e" Nu ofsa fke uaugns fnuniounab" Uga{ig ugns cosk gos os nus moc`i}a{be s{cg yknigu~ docu{of uazncs oss{mz}nlk,la}uioik fkbenbi& da}kcfas{}ks& obe ugk z}kco}na{s kcabalnc suouk ad ugk zasu,
?
 
Bas" ?:,5??;!5??4
Cgosk Mob`& ku of" t" Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe 
Zoik =
nbe{su}nof Lneyksu& ugk nss{k ou suo`k nb ugns ozzkof ns safkf~ z}acke{}of" A{} uos` ns uaekuk}lnbk ygkugk} ugk ensu}ncu ca{}u goe s{mhkcu,louuk} h{}nsencunab atk} o s{nu m~ sktk}ofdnbobcnof nbsunu{unabs skk`nbi ekcfo}oua}~ obe nbh{bcuntk }kfnkd d}al uya augk} foys{nusdnfke m~ ugk Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe" Yk cabcf{ek ugou nu ene" Mkco{sk ugk ensu}ncu ca{}ubabkugkfkss enslnsske ugk s{nu s{o szabuk da} donf{}k ua suouk o cfonl ynuga{u baunck ua ugkzo}unks& yk ]KTK]SK ugk h{eilkbu ad ugk ensu}ncu ca{}u obe ]KLOBE da} d{}ugk}z}ackkenbis"
N" MOC@I]A[BE
Ugk Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe gos skkb o }kca}e b{lmk} ad galk da}kcfas{}ks nb ugk zosuekcoek" Mkuykkb =::: obe =::7& C{~ogaio Ca{bu~& Agna& ygk}k Cfktkfobe ns facouke&}kca}eke ozz}awnloukf~ 7:&::: da}kcfas{}ks" Scauu Snlab&
 Nb Cfktkfobe& Da}kcfas{}ks Ekcnlouk Bknigma}gaaes
& Bou„f Z{m" ]oena& Lo~ =5& =::7" Nb =::9& Ca{bu~ U}kos{}k}Hnl ]a`o`ns eksc}nmke ugk cnu~ os ‖ugk kznckbuk} ad ugk la}uioik lkfueayb nb Olk}nco"“Ugalos Auu $ S{sob Tnbkffo&
 Galk Faob Da}kcfas{}ks ab ugk ]nsk nb C{~ogaio
& UgkZfonb Ekofk}& H{f~ 5& =::9& ou M?" Oionbsu ugns moc`e}az colk ugk ug}kk foys{nus }kfktobuua ugns cosk"
O"
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe t" Olk}nq{ksu La}uioik Skc{}nunks& Nbc"
'
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe N 
.
Nb Hob{o}~ =::7& Cfktkfobe m}a{igu s{nu oionbsu uykbu~,abk dnbobcnof nbsunu{unabsnb Agna suouk ca{}u& offkinbi ugou ugk ekdkbeobus„ ocunabs nb ugk s{mz}nlk,la}uioiknbe{su}~ cabsunu{uke o z{mfnc b{nsobck {bek} Agna callab foy" M~ skc{}nunxnbis{mz}nlk la}uioiks obe fouk} da}kcfasnbi ab ugk ga{sks z{}cgoske ug}a{ig s{cgla}uioiks& ugk ekdkbeobus offkikef~ cabu}nm{uke ua o dnbobcnof c}nsns nb ugk cnu~ ugounbcf{eke snibndncobu ekcfnbks nb z}azk}u~ tof{ks& o sg}nb`nbi uow mosk& obe ob nbc}kosk nbc}nlnbof ocuntnu~" Cfktkfobe sa{igu ua }kcatk} da} ugk casus nu nbc{}}ke nb labnua}nbi&lonbuonbnbi& a} eklafnsgnbi da}kcfaske z}azk}unks obe da} ekc}koske uow }ktkb{ks" Ugkekdkbeobus }klatke ugk cosk ua dkek}of ca{}u ab entk}snu~ i}a{bes" Oduk} ekb~nbiCfktkfobe„s launabs ua }klobe obe ua olkbe nus calzfonbu m~ oeenbi HZLa}iob CgoskMob`& B"O"& o bab,entk}sk zo}u~& ugk ensu}ncu ca{}u i}obuke ugk ekdkbeobus„ launab ua
 
Bas" ?:,5??;!5??4
Cgosk Mob`& ku of" t" Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe 
Zoik 3
?
Da} ugk so`k ad cfo}nu~& yk zo{sk ua }ktnky ugk fnbk{z nb ugksk ug}kk foys{nus" Ugk zfonbundds nb
Cgosk Mob` 
& ygncg ns ugk s{nu c{}}kbuf~ mkda}k {s& o}k Cgosk Mob`& [SO& B"O"& HZLa}iob Cgosk Mob`&B"O"& HZLa}iob La}uioik Ocq{nsnunab Ca}z"& obe H"Z" La}iob Skc{}nunks& Nbc" Ad ugksk zfonbundds& Cgosk
enslnss ab ugk i}a{bes ugou ugk cnu~„s s{nu yos z}kklzuke m~ suouk foy obe yos mo}}kem~ ugk kcabalnc,fass eacu}nbk& obe& ofuk}bountkf~& ugou ugk calzfonbu donfke uaeklabsu}ouk ugou ugk ekdkbeobus„ ocunabs {b}kosabomf~ nbuk}dk}ke ynug o z{mfnc }nigu a}yk}k ugk z}awnlouk co{sk ad ugk offkike go}l"
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe t" Olk}nq{ksu  La}uioik Skc"& Nbc"
& 4=? D" S{zz" =e ;?3& ;?4–?9 'B"E" Agna =::>." Yk oddn}lke abz}awnlouk,co{sk i}a{bes" 4?; D"3e 5>4& ;:=–:4 '4ug Cn}" =:?:.&
ck}u" ekbnke 
& ?3? S" Cu"?47; '=:??."
M"
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe t" HZ La}iob Cgosk Mob`& B"O"
'
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe NN 
.
Nb O{i{su =::7& sga}uf~ oduk} ugk ensu}ncu ca{}u ekbnke Cfktkfobe„s launab ua}klobe nb
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe N 
& Cfktkfobe dnfke o skcabe s{nu nb Agna suouk ca{}u oionbsuuykbu~,knigu dnbobcnof nbsunu{unabs& nbcf{enbi ugk bab,entk}sk HZLa}iob Cgosk Mob`&B"O" Nb oeenunab ua zfkoenbi obaugk} z{mfnc,b{nsobck cfonl& Cfktkfobe offkike ugou ugkekdkbeobus goe tnafouke ugk Agna Ca}}{zu Ocuntnunks Ocu '‖ACOO“.& ugk suouk ]NCAobofai{k& m~ nbocc{}oukf~ cfonlnbi unufk ua la}uioiks obe z}alnssa}~ bauks nbda}kcfas{}k z}ackkenbis nb tnafounab ad Agna ]ktnske Caek © =>=?"?='O."
Skk
Agna ]kt"Caek © =>=3"3=" Cfktkfobe ofsa sa{igu ua }kcatk} {bek} Agna ]ktnske Caek © 9?;"=4?da} casus nbc{}}ke lonbuonbnbi a} eklafnsgnbi da}kcfaske ga{sks"
C"
Cgosk Mob`& [SO& B"O" t" Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe 
'
Cgosk Mob`
.
Nb Dkm}{o}~ =::7& ygnfk
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe N 
yos zkbenbi& Zfonbundds,OzzkffobusCgosk Mob`& [SO& B"O"& HZLa}iob Cgosk Mob`& B"O"& HZLa}iob La}uioik Ocq{nsnunabCa}z"& obe H"Z" La}iob Skc{}nunks& Nbc" 'caffkcuntkf~& ‖Cgosk Mob`“. m}a{igu ugk s{nu ugouns c{}}kbuf~ mkda}k {s" Cgosk Mob` s{ke Cfktkfobe nb dkek}of ensu}ncu ca{}u& skk`nbi oekcfo}oua}~ h{eilkbu ugou Cfktkfobe„s z{mfnc,b{nsobck cfonl nb
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe N 
yosz}kklzuke m~ ugk Bounabof Mob` Ocu obe }kq{ksunbi ob nbh{bcunab oionbsu ugou s{nu" Oduk}Cfktkfobe dnfke
Cnu~ ad Cfktkfobe NN 
& Cgosk Mob` olkbeke nus calzfonbu ua }kq{ksuekcfo}oua}~ }kfnkd obe ob nbh{bcunab oionbsu maug ad Cfktkfobe„s foys{nus"
?
Cfktkfobe

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->