Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
See Premium Plans
 
 
Vabr`b Lb`cmrm|adk
BZJAOA\ =:
 
Eacbl Rklbr Pbmc
@mpb27==.`u.6=:<5.CJH Ld`rnbk|?6=0.=: Eacbl=6$6?$=? Vmib= de <
 
@dk|makp Akedrnm|adk Pogb`| |d Mvvcb.PmnpkTu KLM
Mvrac 06# ?6=?
OQ AK\B_KM\ADKMC DUB_KAIJ\ % BNMAC
Pbdkiydd Han
Larb`|dr
Ca`bkpaki \bmn# AV @bk|brPmnpki Bcb`|rdka`p
<=5# Nmb|mk 0.Ldki
Qbdki|dki.I# Pydk.Pa
Ibdkiaa.Ld# <<0.9<?# Hdrbm
Lbmr Nr+ Han7
A yra|b ak rbpvdkpb |d qdr Gmkmrq 0=# ?6=? cb||br rbpvdklaki |d nq cb||br de Lb`bnobr ?<# ?6==#
rbimrlaki Mvvcb‑p rb}bp| edr E_MKL ca`bkpaki |brnp edr vm|bk|p |jm| Pmnpki jmp lb`cmrbl
bppbk|amc |d |jb RN\P p|mklmrl..ak`claki |jdpb |jm| Pmnpki jmp mppbr|bl mimakp| Mvvcb+ Ak
|jap cb||br# A mllrbpp Pmnpki‑p vdpa|adkp rbimrlaki a|p lb`cmrbl.bppbk|amc RN\P vm|bk|p# mkl mcpdvrdualb pvb`aea` ca`bkpaki |brnp edr Mvvcb‑p dyk lb`cmrbl.bppbk|amc RN\P vm|bk|p+
Pmnpki‑p Vdpa|adkp _bimrlaki A|p Lb`cmrbl.Bppbk|amc Vm|bk|p
\d obiak# Mvvcb ap vrbpbk|cq ca`bkpbl |d Pmnpki‑p lb`cmrbl.bppbk|amc vm|bk|p oq uar|b dePmnpki‑p E_MKL `dnna|nbk|p |d B\PA mkl Mvvcb‑p m``bv|mk`b de Pmnpki‑p deebr de mE_MKL ca`bkpbp yjbk Mvvcb obimk |d anvcbnbk| |jb R\NP p|mklmrl+ M``drlakicq# |jb dkcqrbnmakaki appb edr Mvvcb mkl Pmnpki |d kbid|am|b ap |jb E_MKL rm|b edr Mvvcb‑p vrbpbk|ca`bkpb+ Mp Mvvcb jmp p|m|bl rbvbm|blcq# a| ap yaccaki |d vmq E_MKL rdqmc|abp |d Pmnpki akpdemrmp Pmnpki‑p lb`cmrbl.bppbk|amc vm|bk|p mrb m`|mccq umcal# akerakibl# mkl bkedr`bmocb mkl Mvvcbap kd| d|jbryapb m|jdrawbl |d vrm`|a`b |jdpb vm|bk|p *b+i+# ompbl dk Pmnpki‑p ca`bkpbp ya|jMvvcb‑p ompbomkl `javpb| pvvcabrp Ak|bc mkl ]mc`dnn!+
Yb mrb prvrapbl |jm| Pmnpki rbepbp |d mirbb ya|j |jb ompa` E_MKL ca`bkpaki ermnbydrh |jm|Mvvcb pb| edr|j ak a|p cb||br |d B\PA lm|bl Kdubnobr ==#?6==# edr vrvdpbp de kbid|am|akica`bkpaki |brnp ya|j Mvvcb+ Pbubrmc vdak|p np| ob nmlb7
Earp|#
Mvvcb ldbp kd| `dk|bkl |jm| m vrdvbr vdr|edcad rm|b edr m vmr|q‑p lb`cmrbl.bppbk|amc vm|bk|pnp| ak
mcc
akp|mk`bp ob ompbl bz`cpaubcq dk |jb vmr|q‑p knobr de bppbk|amc vm|bk|p mp mvrdvdr|adk de mcc vm|bk|p |jm| jmub obbk lb`cmrbl bppbk|amc |d |jb RN\P p|mklmrl# o| rm|jbr |jm||jap `mc`cm|adk pjdcl jbcv ialb |jb kbid|am|adkp+ Pmnpki jmp kbubr deebrbl mkq bzvcmkm|adk
de yjq a| `dcl bubr ob bk|a|cbl |d m ?+<" rdqmc|q rm|b yjbk a| jdclp dkcq m pnmcc vrdvdr|adk de mcc
vm|bk|p lb`cmrbl bppbk|amc |d |jb RN\P p|mklmrl+ Kdr jmp Pmnpki deebrbl mkq bzvcmkm|adk#n`j cbpp bualbk`b# yjq |jb lb`cmrbl bppbk|amc vm|bk|p |jm| Pmnpki jmp mppbr|bl mimakp| Mvvcbpjdcl ob uabybl mp ndrb umcmocb |jmk Pmnpki‑p d|jbr lb`cmrbl bppbk|amc vm|bk|p+ \jb rbpc|ppd emr ak |jb |jrbb Ibrnmk `mpbp dk |jb BV ‑9?5# BV ‑2?:# mkl BV ‑?51 vm|bk|p..ak yja`j bm`jvm|bk| ymp jbcl kd| akerakibl oq Mvvcb...`br|makcq ydcl kd| pvvdr| p`j m vrdvdpa|adk+
M``drlaki |d |jb ?661 Emareabcl _bpdr`bp Ak|brkm|adkmc P|lq# Pmnpki jdclp 2+<2" de |jb |d|mc
knobr de lb`cmrbl.bppbk|amc vm|bk|p edr RN\P+ Bubk |jm| vbr`bk|mib ap dubrp|m|bl7 |jb
MVVCB @DKEALBK\AMC ORPAKBPPAKED_NM\ADK# PROGB@\ \D V_D\B@\AUB D_LB_
MVC91<K.66666=29:1
VCMAK\AEE‑P BZJAOA\ KD+
Rka|bl P|m|bp Lap|ra`| @dr| Kdr|jbrk Lap|ra`| de @mcaedrkam Kd+ ==.@U.6=:<5.CJH *VPI!Mvvcb Ak`+ u+ Pmnpki Bcb`p+Lm|b Mlna||bl7TTTTTTTTTT Oq7TTTTTTTTT 
91
@mpb27==.`u.6=:<5.CJH Ld`rnbk|?6=0.=: Eacbl=6$6?$=? Vmib? de <
 
@dk|makp Akedrnm|adk Pogb`| |d M{vcb.Pmnpk{ KLM
Emareabcl P|lq edkl |jm| Pmnpki jml kd| dkcq dubr.lb`cmrbl vm|bk|p# o| ldkb pd m| m rm|b
n`j jaijbr |jmk |jb aklp|rq mp m yjdcb+ \jb ca|aim|adk ob|ybbk Mvvcb mkl Pmnpki vrdualbp
er|jbr bualbk`b de |jb Emareabcl P|lq‑p `dk`cpadk rbimrlaki P mnpki‑p vm||brk de dubr.lb`cmrm|adk+ Pmnpki jmp `dk|bklbl |jm| a|p BV ‑9?5# BV ‑2?:# mkl BV ‑?51 vm|bk|p mrb bppbk|amc|d |jb RN\P p|mklmrl# qb| |jb Ibrnmk `dr| rb`bk|cq edkl kdkb de |jbn ap |rcq bppbk|amc mkljbcl |jm| Mvvcb lal kd| akerakib mkq+Bubk v||aki mpalb |jb dubr.lb`cmrm|adk appb# mkl iauaki ecc beeb`| |d Pmnpki‑p dyklb`cmrm|adkp# Pmnpki‑p lbnmkl ydcl anvcq mvvrdzanm|bcq m <<" miirbim|b rdqmc|q orlbk dkRN\P vrdl`|p+ \jap ap emr modub |jb 2.9" rmkib |jm| Pmnpki mribl *ak a|p bmrcabr ca|aim|adkya|j Bra`ppdk mkl Ak|brLaia|mc! ymp |jb mvvrdvram|b rmkib edr miirbim|b rdqmc|abp+
Pb`dkl#
a| ap }a|b prvrapaki |jm| Pmnpki ydcl `dk|bkl |jm| m `dnndk rdqmc|q ompb pjdcl`dkpap| de mkq ndrb |jmk |jb vra`b de |jb ompbomkl `jav |jm| vrdualbp |jb mccbiblcq akerakiakiek`|adkmca|q..rm|jbr |jmk |jb ecc vra`b de mk mlumk`bl lbua`b cahb |jb aVjdkb+ Aklbbl# ak a|pca|aim|adk ya|j Bra`ppdk# Pmnpki# a|pbce# `dnvcmakbl |jm| Bra`ppdk ymp mopaubcq pbbhaki |d/ompb |jb rdqmc|q rm|b dk |jb kb| pbccaki vra`bp de |jb XPmnpki‑p^ ndoacb |bcb`dnnka`m|adkpvrdl`|p# yja`j mrb ak paikaea`mk| vmr|# mkl ak`rbmpakicq# lb|brnakbl oq bz|rmkbdp ebm|rbp |jm|
ld kd| rbcm|b |d |jb ca`bkpbl |bcb`dnnka`m|adkp |b`jkdcdiq# p`j mp vjd|d mkl ualbd `mnbrmp#
imnbp# `dcdr p`rbbkp# nv0 vcmqbrp# mkl rmlad+/ Yb emac |d klbrp|mkl jdy Pmnpki‑p lbnmkl
edr m rdqmc|q dk |jb bk|arb umcb de |jb Mvvcb vrdl`|p `dcl bubr ob `dkpap|bk| ya|j Pmnpki‑p
E_MKL docaim|adkp..aklbbl# Pmnpki‑p dyk vradr p|m|bnbk|p rbimrlaki E_MKL `mkkd| ob
rb`dk`acbl ya|j a|p vrbpbk| vdpa|adk+ M| od||dn# Pmnpki ap lbnmklaki m |mz dk |jbkvrb`blbk|bl akkdum|aub ebm|rbp ak |jb aVjdkb mkl aVml |jm| jmub kd rbcm|adk |d|bcb`dnnka`m|adkp `mvmoaca|q# bzm`|cq yjm| Pmnpki `cmanbl ymp kd| E_MKL yjbk |jb pjdb
ymp dk |jb d|jbr edd|+
\jarl#
qd p|m|b |jm| /yb lapmirbb |jm| m vmr|q uadcm|bp a|p `dnna|nbk| |d E_MKL ca`bkpaki oqpbbhaki mk akgk`|adk+/ Pak`b qd yrd|b qdr cmp| cb||br# |jb Lap|ra`| @dr| ak |jb Jmib jbcl *dkNmr`j =<# ?6=?! |jm| Pmnpki‑p E_MKL `dnna|nbk|p vrb`clb Pmnpki erdn pbbhaki
akgk`|adkp dk a|p lb`cmrbl.bppbk|amc vm|bk|p+ Ndrbdubr# bubk cdki obedrb qd yrd|b qdr cb||br#
ak m ?669 ponappadk |jm| Pmnpki pona||bl ak a|p ca|aim|adk mimakp| Bra`ppdk# Pmnpki |dcl |jb`dr| |jm| Bra`ppdk# /jmuaki `dnna||bl a|pbce |d ca`bkpaki |jb Vm|bk|p vdk emar# rbmpdkmocb mkl
kdk.lap`ranakm|drq |brnp# jmp m``bv|bl |jm| a| `mk ob `dnvbkpm|bl ak ndkb|mrq |brnp edr mkq pb
de |jb Vm|bk|p+++# mkl /pjdcl XBra`ppdk^ ob bk|a|cbl |d mkq rbcabe++# |jb mvvrdvram|b rbcabe ap |jb
irmk| de lmnmibp b}aumcbk| |d m emar# rbmpdkmocb# mkl kdklap`ranakm|drq rdqmc|q+/ Yjm| bzvcmakpPmnpki‑p `dnvcb|b rbubrpmc de vdpa|adk4 Ldbp Pmnpki nmak|mak a|p kby vdpa|adk# bubk ak |jb
em`b de |jb Kb|jbrcmklp `dr|‑p rbvlam|adk de |jm| vdpa|adk4
Ak mlla|adk# mp qdr cb||br rb.`dkearnp# Pmnpki ap `dk|akaki |d uadcm|b a|p E_MKL docaim|adkpoq rbepaki |d vrdualb Mvvcb akedrnm|adk rb}arbl |d klbrp|mkl yjb|jbr Pmnpki‑p lbnmklp`dnvdr| ya|j Pmnpki‑p vradr mirbbnbk|p# ak`claki akedrnm|adk mod| Pmnpki‑p ca`bkpbp ya|jd|jbr vmr|abp edr vm|bk|p |jm| Pmnpki jmp lb`cmrbl bppbk|amc |d |jb RN\P p|mklmrl+ Mvvcb`mkkd| vrdvbrcq bumcm|b yjb|jbr mkq e|rb ca`bkpb deebr |jm| Pmnpki naij| nmhb ap |rcqE_MKL...dr nmhb mk bl`m|bl `dk|brdeebr..ya|jd| mlb}m|b |rmkpvmrbk`q |d |jb |brnp dePmnpki‑p ca`bkpbp ya|j d|jbr RN\P anvcbnbk|brp+
MVVCB @DKEALBK\AMC ORPAKBPPAKED_NM\ADK# PROGB@\ \D V_D\B@\AUB D_LB_
MVC91<K.66666=2916
Vcmak|aee)p Bzjaoa| Kd+ 91+?
@mpb27==.`u.6=:<5.CJH Ld`rnbk|?6=0.=: Eacbl=6$6?$=? Vmib0 de <

More From This User

15 p.
13-05-20 RealTek v. Agere Preliminary Injunction Against ITC Exclus...
Florian_Muelle_439
423 Reads
9 p.
13-05-20 Order Denying Microsoft v. Motorola Bench Trial on Breach-...
Florian_Muelle_439
61 Reads
41 p.
13-05-13 Google (Motorola) Reply Brief in Posner Appeal
Florian_Muelle_439
325 Reads
7 p.
13-05-09 Order Granting Apple Motion to Compel Google to Provide Se...
Florian_Muelle_439
379 Reads
22 p.
BlackBerry Amicus Brief on FRAND Issues (Appeal of J. Posner's Ruling)
Florian_Muelle_439
131 Reads
34 p.
Nokia's Amicus Curiae Brief on FRAND Issues (Appeal of J. Posner's ...
Florian_Muelle_439
238 Reads
7 p.
13-05-07 Apple Opposition to Google Et Al. Amicus Curiae Brief in S...
Florian_Muelle_439
1068 Reads
23 p.
13-05-03 Nokia Amicus Brief in Apple v Samsung Injunction Appeal
Florian_Muelle_439
183 Reads
10 p.
13-05-03 Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter Re. Breach Damages
Florian_Muelle_439
143 Reads
3 p.
13-05-03 Exhibit 6 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
Florian_Muelle_439
124 Reads
4 p.
13-05-03 Exhibit 5 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
Florian_Muelle_439
118 Reads
3 p.
13-05-03 Exhibit 4 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
Florian_Muelle_439
118 Reads
6 p.
13-05-03 Exhibit 3 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
Florian_Muelle_439
140 Reads
5 p.
13-05-03 Exhibit 2 to Microsoft Response to Motorola
Florian_Muelle_439
121 Reads
3 p.
13-05-03 Exhibit 1 to Microsoft Response to Motorola
Florian_Muelle_439
106 Reads
8 p.
13-05-01 Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Damages Theories
Florian_Muelle_439
135 Reads
7 p.
13-05-01 Exhibits J-K to Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Damages Theo...
Florian_Muelle_439
108 Reads
77 p.
13-05-01 Exhibits a-I to Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Damages Theo...
Florian_Muelle_439
130 Reads
4 p.
13-05-01 Declaration in Support of Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Da...
Florian_Muelle_439
143 Reads
74 p.
13-05-01 Apple v. Samsung Permanent Injunction Appeal Responsive Brief
Florian_Muelle_439
243 Reads
3 p.
13-04-29 Apple-Samsung Case Management Order (Limited Retrial Etc.)
Florian_Muelle_439
376 Reads
3 p.
13-04-25 Microsoft v Motorola FRAND Rate FoFaCoL - Unofficial Table...
Florian_Muelle_439
846 Reads
207 p.
13-04-25 Microsoft-Motorola FRAND Rate Determination
Florian_Muelle_439
2338 Reads
10 p.
13-04-16 Apple Declaration Regarding Patent Reexaminations
Florian_Muelle_439
516 Reads
64 p.
13-04-10 Apple v. Samsung Claim Construction Order
Florian_Muelle_439
963 Reads
Notes
Load more