Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T HE
2012
NUMBER
A conference that would focus on the problem of avoidable care was the vehicle we chose to start a dialog about the problem and to propose possible solutions. We invited some of the countrys leading thinkers on health care issues. The result was an intellectually rich, lively, and productive two days.
INSIDE
2 3 4
Lown Award to John Bogle Into the re Lessons learned Development in action 2012 Donor recognition Avoidable Care Conference (cont.)
5 6 8
Into the re Lessons learned (cont.) Is it true that chocolate is good for me? Patient prole: Being part of the family Statins and the risk of diabetes What not to say to your doctor
LOW N
FO RUM Us Sicker and Poorer, and who co-directed our recent Conference on Avoiding Avoidable Care, continues as a partner in the Foundations work in the arena of appropriate care. Jeremy Grantham, Co- LCRF Board Members: Nassib Chamoun, Dr. Joseph Brain, & emcee Jonathan Elias Founder and Chief Investment Strategist of Grantham Mayo Van Otterloo (GMO), echoed the call for better stewardship of resources, especially regarding the environment. The dinner was cochaired by Grantham, LCRF Board Member Patricia Aslanis, and James Joslin, CEO, TFC Financial Management. A silent auction featuring vacations, works of art, and unique experiences added to the festivities, Dr. Tom & Vicki Graboys with a live auction providing a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to throw out the rst pitch at a home Red Sox game. Funds raised will support the Lown Foundations initiatives aimed at advancing a more humane, cost-eective and rational approach to caring for patients locally and globally.
LOW N
FO RUM
DEVELOPMENT
Mr. & Mrs. Gary Hatton Mr. & Mrs. William C.S. Hicks Mrs. Carol A. Jarvis Mrs. Janet Johnson Bullard Mr. & Mrs. Edwin M. Kania, Jr. Mr. & Mrs. Bruce Leeds Dr. & Mrs. Bernard Lown Mr. & Mrs. Milton Lown Dr. & Mrs. Charles Magraw Mr. & Mrs. James Mahoney, Jr. Mr. & Mrs. Jay Marvin Mr. & Mrs. John R. Monsky, Jr. Mr. Albert F. Nagel Mr. John J. O'Connor Dr. & Mrs. John O. Pastore Mr. Morris Raker Prof. & Mrs. V. Kasturi Rangan Mr. & Mrs. Ira J. Rosenberg Dr. Arno A. Schneberger Mr. & Mrs. Milton Schwartzberg Mr. & Mrs. Joseph L. Serani Mr. & Mrs. Ronald M. Shaich Mr. & Mrs. Jerey M. Shaw Mr. & Mrs. John Simon Mr. & Mrs. W. Mason Smith, III Mr. & Mrs. Luke T. Sotir Mr. John D. Spooner Mr. & Mrs. Kenneth L. Sullivan Mr. & Mrs. Bernard Taradash Mr. Charles Thomas Tenney, Jr. Mr. W. Nicholas Thorndike Mrs. Elizabeth P. Vining Patrons Anonymous Mr. & Mrs. Christopher Arnold Mr. John J. Barry Mr. & Mrs. Joerg Braun Dr. & Mrs. Norman M. Bress Mr. Robert Bullard Mr. & Mrs. James E. Clawson Mr. Joel M. Cohen Mr. Christopher H. Covington Mr. & Mrs. Philip Devlin Ms. Michelle Duarte-Anderson Mr. Michael A. Esposito Mr. & Mrs. Louis L. Farber Mr. & Mrs. David I. Feingold Mr. Richard S. Forte Mr. & Mrs. Lawrence Fruman Mr. Eric Geller Mr. & Mrs. George Graboys Dr. & Mrs. David S. Greer Mr. & Mrs. Jay I. Grossman Mr. & Mrs. Thomas S. Grossman Dr. David M. Hodges Mr. Harold G. Jacklin, Jr. Mr. & Mrs. Ted King Mr. & Mrs. Yoseph L. Linde
Dr. & Mrs. Robert M. Lurie Mr. William D. Mahoney Mr. Vincent Megna Mr. David G. Mugar Dr. & Mrs. Silvio J. Onesti Dr. & Mrs. Rolf F. Poser Mr. Samuel S. Pratt Mr. James Rakowski Mr. Eugene E. Record, Jr. Mrs. Susan Rocca Mr. & Mrs. Mark A. Ross Mr. Louis Rudolph Mr. & Mrs. Nathaniel Saltonstall Mr. John Schneider Dr. Michael Sheehy Mr. & Mrs. Chester F. Sidell Mr. & Mrs. Francis Spellman, Jr. Mrs. Irene M. Stare Mr. & Mrs. Jerey I. Sussman Corporations & Foundations Daniel Neidich/Brooke Garber Fdn Enable Hope Foundation Foley Hoag, LLP The Glaser Family Charitable Fdn Grimshaw-Gudewicz Foundation The Haenreer Family Fund The Krauss Charitable Foundation The Lunder Foundation Max Kagan Family Foundation Nissie & Ethel Grossman Fdn PERSONAL MDS, LLC The Print House Reuben & Lizzie Grossman Fdn The Rhode Island Foundation Saracen Properties, LLC Temple Emanuel TFC Financial Management The Tilles Family Foundation Wellington Management Co., LLP Workable Alternatives Foundation
Special Thanks to our 2012 Conference Funders Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality California HealthCare Foundation Fannie E. Rippel Foundation Kaiser Permanente The Mattina R. Proctor Foundation Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
LOW N
FO RUM procedures must be eliminated, and payment needs to be aligned to support desired outcomes. In other words, unnecessary treatment must no longer carry a nancial incentive for individuals or institutions delivering health care. But there is substantial unnecessary care even in health systems with various payment models, so payment-reform is not going to be a silver bullet. Other key solutions proposed were: Changing the malpractice system to a nofault one Engaging patients in shared decision-making Having medical residents ask why the need for tests and procedures during rounds Changing communication between physicians and patients: solving the time crunch problem Developing a robust research agenda that denes when not to do things as much as when to do them
Staying positive
In remarks on Day Two of the conference, Shannon Brownlee reminded everyone of the power of ideas. We need to recapture the soul of medicine, she said. Dr. Lown pointed out that overtreatment had been a trickle at the start of his career, but now its a ood. Yet the more time the doctor invests, the more cost eective the encounter and the more satised the patient. If time is given short shrift, the doctor treats only the chief complaint, not the person. "And medicine is a calling, Dr. Lown said. At its core, it's a moral enterprise, grounded in trust. We have a challenge before us. And any challenge is doable. Those who see the invisible can do the impossible.
What next?
In conversations after the event, it has become clear that many are looking to the Lown Foundation to continue to engage the national medical community on this issue. The growing national focus on cost needs to be leavened with a genuine concern for patients. We bring enormous credibility to such an eort and have an opportunity to have the kind of impact that matters. We have recently received a planning grant from the Markle Foundation of New York City to develop a strategy for building a coalition of organizations and individuals dedicated to changing the health care system to one that provides the Right Care. The Lown Foundation looks forward to leading the charge on right-sizing health care, creating a system in which costs are reasonable, physicians spend time communicating, and patients come rst. For more information visit: www.avoidablecare.org.
Some Solutions
Payment reform is clearly one answer to the overtreatment problem. The volume imperative do more
LOW N
FO RUM
He described the machismo that pervaded the rehouse, the denial if only we had made changes sooner.
Cardiovascular disease is largely preventable it requires knowledge and action, and importantly, consistency in lifestyle modication. The Lown physicians have embraced a model of prevention, a model of a proactive, inclusive approach to wellness. We encourage evaluations before trouble nds our patients. We are convinced that longevity is possible if chronic disease and risk factors are well managed in a motivated individual. We are hopeful that we will help foster change in our local rehouses, working collaboratively with the re chiefs, reghters, the unions, and our towns, we are proposing wellness and prevention programs helping to protect those who protect us.
Is it true that chocolate is good for me? Or is it all just white noise?
Fred Mamuya, MD, PhD
Dark chocolate has been in the news lately everywhere I turn, yet another benet is ascribed to this delicacy. Dark chocolate may help reduce high blood pressure is the headline in a prestigious medical journal. Dark chocolate has also been reported to substantially reduce the risk of coronary disease and strokes, lower bad cholesterol (LDL), and lower markers of inammation due to its powerful anti-oxidant eects. It turns out that it is even good for your teeth when compared to uoride according to researchers from Tulane University. I could go on and on, but a headline from this spring really took the cake Chocolate: melts in your mouth and melts o your waistline! The New York Times actually headlined the same story The chocolate diet?. Never mind that the title of the scientic paper published in the Archives of Internal Medicine actually read Association between more frequent chocolate consumption and lower body mass index, and that the ne print went on to say, Causality in the observed association cannot be presumed. The problem usually lies with the supercial approach of how health information is presented to the public. Titillating
headlines sell and the caveats are usually mentioned casually and usually buried deep in the article or ne print.
It is unclear if dark chocolate consumed regularly can indeed deliver on all of its touted benets.
Almost all of the studies cited have looked at an association between people who regularly indulge in dark chocolate, and health outcomes. However, an association does not imply causality since the people who regularly consume dark chocolate may indeed have other qualities and attributes that promote a healthier lifestyle, with subsequent better outcomes. A 2010 review of all published studies looking at the association of chocolate and high blood pressure reduction noted that other factors such as local dietary habits or genetic/ethnic disparities may have been responsible for the results. A subsequent 2011 review, which concluded that chocolate consumption is associated with a substantial reduction in the risk of cardiometabolic disorders, admitted that none of the studies cited was a randomized trial! It should also be noted that many of the short-term trials, and some of the review articles have been funded by the chocolate industry. If you were to believe the headlines and consumed 40 grams of dark chocolate daily (~ 4 squares), you would be consuming about 227 extra-calories; and may gain about a pound of weight per week. At the next social gathering when someone comes up to you and begins to regale you with the latest news headline touting the health benets of substance X smile its probably just white noise.
LOW N
FO RUM
PATIENT PROFILE
When I had my LVAD put in, I spent 78 days in the hospital, and someone from the Lown Center came and sat with me almost every day.
Mr. Barnstein has worked hard to keep up his general health, and he gives much of the credit to the Lown Center. The practice exemplies not only caring for their patients, but also their personal lives. Its not Arthur, his wife, Dr. Bilchik, Lown sta just about the symptoms, but how are things going at home? They care for you as a person, not a sick organ. Its a cardiology oce, but the doctors are also like psychologists. They deal with all the issues in our life, and they give us time to talk about all our issues. You dont have to go in and say your piece quickly and then get out of there. That feeling of family that I rst had with Dr. Lown continues to this day. Even our own psychologist was enthralled by the Lown Center, Mr. Barnstein chuckled.
LOW N
FO RUM
NewsBeat
Dr. Charles M. Blatt was interviewed by Reuters Health on February 28th regarding a recent study on statin use and depression risk. Dr. Blatt and colleagues at the LCRF had published one of the earliest reports on this novel nding. On March 26th, Dr. Vikas Saini presented the Lown Foundations research Long-Term All-Cause Mortality in Second Opinion Coronary Patients Managed with Optimal Medical Therapy at the 61st Annual Scientic Sessions of the American College of Cardiology held in Chicago, IL. The research abstract was co-authored by Dr. Deepa Aggarwal, Padraig Carolan, Dr. Fred Mamuya, Dr. Brian Bilchik, Dr. Shmuel Ravid, and Dr. Charles M. Blatt. Dr. Fred Mamuya presented on the topic of End of Life Care on April 3rd at the Brookline Council on Aging. Dr. Vikas Saini attended the National Press Club event: U.S. Medical Specialty Societies to Identify Overused or Unnecessary Tests, Procedures on April 4th. On April 5th, Dr. Brian Bilchik addressed the Brookline Rotary Club on the topic of heart disease, family involvement, and decision making. Dr. Vikas Saini and Padraig Carolan presented the Lown Foundations research abstract Long Term Outcomes with Optimal Medical Therapy in Patients Seeking a Second Opinion Regarding Invasive Coronary Angiography at the American Heart Associations Quality of Care and Outcomes Research in Cardiovascular Disease and Stroke: 2012 Scientic Sessions in Atlanta, GA on May 9th. The abstract was co-authored by Dr. Deepa Aggarwal, Padraig Carolan, Dr. Fred Mamuya, Dr. Brian Bilchik, Dr. Shmuel Ravid, and Dr. Charles M. Blatt. Dr. Selwyn O. Rogers, Jr. and Dr. Bruce B. Feinberg were awarded the 2012 Bernard Lown Award for Excellence in Teaching at Brigham and Women's Hospital. Dr. Rogers serves as the Division Chief of Trauma, Burn, and Surgical Critical Care for the Department of Surgery. Dr. Feinberg is the Research Director of the Complement Research Unit in the Division of Maternal Fetal Medicine. Dr. Bernard Lown was the recipient of the 2012 British Medical Journal Group Lifetime Achievement Award in recognition of his exceptional contribution to international health and healthcare. The Lifetime Achievement Award is the journals top annual award and was awarded last year to Sir Richard Peto. On June 12th, LCRF Board Member Dr. Barbara Roberts was a guest commentator on NPRs Diane Rehm Show, joining other national gures in a discussion on the use of statins for prevention. Dr. Roberts was invited in part because of her new book, The Truth About Statins, which has received favorable notice in the media, including a recent Q&A, How to Lower Your Cholesterol in Womens Day magazine.
CONTACT US
Lown Cardiovascular Research Foundation
21 Longwood Avenue Brookline, MA 02446 USA (617) 732-1318 info@lownfoundation.org www.lownfoundation.org www.lowncenter.org www.procor.org
Advisory Board
Martha Crowninshield Herbert Engelhardt Edward Finkelstein William E. Ford Renee Gelman, MD Barbara Greenberg Milton Lown John R. Monsky Jerey I. Sussman David L. Weltman
LOW N
FO RUM
not forget issues of importance and nd yourself calling the oce later to relay other details. This list should include: 1. All current medications and doses 2. A summary of past major medical events by relevance to current visit or listed chronologically 3. An outline of the current complaint (What is the exact complaint? When did it start? How often does it occur? Is it ongoing?) 4. Any other issues of importance
What to avoid
It is important to come prepared for your discussion with your doctor, but at the same time, it is also important to avoid certain statements. For example, it is a mistake to begin the oce visit by telling the doctor that you need a dierent medication to treat angina. This lets the doctor o the hook and presents the busy physician with the opportunity to simply take your word for it, prescribe a new antianginal medication, and be done with the visit. The patient should aim to describe the symptom or complaint in his own words without attaching a medical label or diagnosis. Let the doctor do his own work and gure this out by asking more questions and probing the history for clues. The patient must also avoid perpetuating possible errors of past doctors. This is especially important when meeting a new doctor for a consultation. A new symptom and/or consultation requires an open mind. With this approach, you engage the doctor to evaluate your unique complaints and circumstances and thereby help assure that you will receive better medical care.
Preparing in advance
For both patient and doctor, it is important to come to the meeting prepared in advance. For the doctor, this means reading the past medical record and becoming familiar with information that may have been forwarded from other physicians. For the patient being prepared means coming to the appointment with a clear understanding of the following: 1. Purpose of the visit 2. What information you want to convey 3. What you want to learn For the oce visit to achieve your goals, preparing an organized written list in advance is useful. An organized, written account helps the doctor (and you) so that you do