STATE OF WISCONSIN - VS -.Antonio D Barbeau and Nathan J PaapeCRIMINAL COMPLAINTPage 3
Nathan stated they got a ride to the Sheboygan Falls residence by
her and that they hid their weapons from her in theirclothing.Once dropped off, they both entered the residence through anunlocked side door to the attached garage. When they met Ms. Olson,she told Antonio she was going to call his mother, at which pointshe turned away from the pair and Antonio struck her in the headwith the blunt end of the hatchet knocking her down and struck herwith the blunt end several more times as she tried to cover herhead, groaning and telling them to stop. Nathan stated he hit hertwice with the hammer and then Antonio, using the blade end of thehatchet, struck her in the head and the hatchet stuck there and thatboth of them had to pull the hatchet loose. Nathan stated theyrealized she was dead and they attempted to load her in her car todispose of the body, but were
able to.Nathan stated they went through the house, taking a purse, loosequarters, jewelry including rings, earrings and a watch. Nathan
stated he and Antonio took Ms. Olson’s car and sped away from
thehouse, eventually leaving the car in the parking lot of a bowlingalley in Sheboygan and walked a short distance to a pizza parlorwhere they had a pizza. They returned to the car after buying somecleaning wipes from a nearby store and wiped the car down, leavingthe car unlocked with the keys in it and most of the jewelry exposedin the rear seat, hoping someone would steal the car and get blamedfor the death. Nathan stated the hatchet and hammer were left in the
car’s trunk. He also stated the pair
discarded some wipes and glovesin the bushes adjacent to the bowling parking lot and the purse wasthrown into a storm drain near his house.Officer Nicole Schmelter of the Sheboygan Falls Police Departmentwas assigned as the lead officer in executing a number of searchwarrants. She reports a purse was fished out of a storm drain three
houses down from Nathan’s residence containing identifiers for
Barbara Olson. Quarters and a gold watch with blood-splatteredclothing including jeans, shoes and a T-shirt was also located in
Nathan’s house.In the vehicle’s trunk, the hatchet and hammer were located
, alongwith bloodied blanket-like material, including a crocheted throwwith what appeared to be bits of human flesh on it. In the frontseat floor area, some type of school paper was found with the name
“Nate” written on it. A bag of jewelry was found on the back seat.
Officer Schmelter also found a small coin purse which matched, inpattern and color, the purse fished from the storm drain.