- 157 -
Uncreative Destruction: The
Misguided War on Vertical Integration
in the
Information Economy
Brent Skorup
&
Adam Thierer
*
T
ABLE OF
C
ONTENTS
I.
!
I
NTRODUCTION
................................................................................ 159
!
II.
!
T
HE
S
EPARATIONS
P
RINCIPLE
......................................................... 160
!
A. The Proposal ............................................................................
160
B. A New Spin on an Old Debate ..................................................
161
III. C
OMPETITION AND
V
ERTICAL
I
NTEGRATION
................................. 165
A. Benefits of Complements and Tying .........................................
167
!
B.
!
Efficiency Benefits ....................................................................
170
!
C.
!
Competition in the Information Economy: Case Studies .........
174
!
1. AOL-Time Warner ............................................................. 1742.
!
News Corp.-DirecTV ......................................................... 176
!
3.
!
Smartphone Sector ............................................................. 176
!
D.
!
Dynamic, Schumpeterian Change vs. Static Equilibrium Analysis ....................................................................................
179
!
E.
!
Openness Concerns ..................................................................
183
!
IV.
!
R
EAL
-W
ORLD
A
PPLICATION OF THE
S
EPARATIONS
P
RINCIPLE
..... 186
!
* Brent Skorup is research director for the Information Economy Project at theGeorge Mason University School of Law. Adam Thierer is a senior research fellowat the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. The authors wish to thank thefollowing individuals for helpful comments on various drafts of the paper: JerryBrito, Geoff Manne, Richard Williams, Ted Bolema, and two anonymousreviewers.