• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
NEWSLETTER no.11
Friday 24th February 2006
eLISU

In December I went down to York to a meeting on Open Source VLEs organised by the JISC Regional Support Centre for Yorkshire and H umber. The aim of the meeting was to look at how Open Source platforms and tools can be developed and used to support and enrich student learning.

Although the focus of the day was supposed to be
about Open Source VLEs, much of the discussion was
about the success and future of VLEs in general \u2013
whether Open Source or proprietary. It proved to be
a very interesting meeting with a lot of thought
provoking ideas presented and questions asked.
\u201cVLEs are just giant photocopiers\u201d
The day was introduced by Derek Morrison:Head

of e-Learning of Higher Education Academy, and writer of the excellent Auricle Blog (http:/ / www.bath.ac.uk / dacs/ cdntl/ pMachine / morriblog.php).

He started off by putting forward a number of questions:
\u201cIs there any evidence that VLEs provide a better
Student learning experience?\u201d
\u201cIs Moodle really student centred?\u201d
\u201cIs Open Source Software disruptive technology?\u201d
His view is that VLEs are a non-disruptive innovation
that universities have been able to absorb without
making any radical changes to how they teach. However,
with more than 100,000 Open Source projects on
Sourceforge (http:/ / sourceforge.net/) alone, students
\u201cIt wasn\u2019t until quite late in life
that I discovered how easy it is to say,
\u2018I don\u2019t know\u2019.\u201d
- S omerset M aughm
now have access to technologies that only a few years
ago would not have been available to them. By

increasingly using tools sourced from outwith their
institution such as blogs and flickr, students are
disrupting the status quo and potentially could change
how technology is used for learning.

Derek suggested that in the future Universities will have to choose between continuing to provide a VLE based on the current model \u2013 a single closed entity (\u201cwalled garden\u201d) or a Learning Management System that pulls together a multitude of elements and tools.

\u201cIt doesn\u2019t matter if your VLE is

proprietary or Open Source, if it isn\u2019t managed properly its take up will be limited and it

won\u2019t be used effectively\u201d
The first Keynote was by Randy Metcalfefrom the
O SS Watch (http:/ / www.oss-watch.ac.uk/ ). The main
points of the talk were:

\u00b7 Open Source Software is a viable and cost-effective option. It is developed by salaried professionals, not as is commonly believed by unpaid hobbyists, and the support provided is usually as professional (and

expensive) as that offered by proprietary products.
Despite the huge number of OS projects, there are in
fact only 58 software products that have received an
OSI certified licence.

\u00b7 Open Source Software is NOT a panacea and doesn\u2019t solve all problems any more than proprietary software does.

Open Source VLEs:
The Next Generation
Mary Cuttle
eLISU Coordinator
OPEN SOURCE VLE\u2019S
\u00b7 Always choose the best solution for your needs

There are three key considerations an institution should take into account before rolling out any VLE, whether it is Open Source or not:

\u00b7 Procurement \u2013 it is difficult to compare OS with
propriety software.
\u00b7 Deployment \u2013 the roll-out of any software needs to
be properly planned and managed.
\u00b7 Support \u2013 many OS developers use their support
packages to fund product development.

\u201cWhen discussing the very
expensive improvements made
when re-engineering a VLE, none
of those improvements were to
develop or add to the student tools,

they were all made to the teacher
and admin tools\u201d.
The second Keynote was by Oleg Liberand was on
Personal Learning Environments. (see page 6 for details
of the PLE Project at Bolton University).
Oleg\u2019s talk picked up and expanded on the theme of

Derek Morrison\u2019s introduction. The world and education is changing, with the focus moving away from traditional lecture/ tutorial based teaching towards distance and electronic learning. VLEs have been a crucial part of this change, both as a product of it and a catalyst for it.

Universities have been able to implement VLEs relatively
easily because traditionally they have experience of

managing big systems, and VLEs have been successful because they have enabled and widened access to learning materials. They have proved to be a non-disruptive

innovation, being used to support existing learning
methods rather than replacing them.

Oleg believes that with the plethora of new technologies available to both students and academics, institutions should be shifting from VLEs to PLEs (Personal

Learning Environments) so as to give students control over the tools used in their learning. Currently, a student registered with more than one institution has to use the different tools and systems provided by each institution. A PLE would enable a student to choose the tools they want to use for their learning and to use them in

whichever institution is providing the learning.
The vast majority of students carry mobile telephones
with access to the internet and often with integrated
cameras. Those of us who regularly travel by bus and
train will be used to being surrounded by students
plugged into their iPods (their thumbs busy txtng).

Institutions should be engaging with these technologies, exploiting the creativity of their students by allowing them to use the technologies they are comfortable and skilled in using.

The concept of PLE is based on a free market \u2013 giving students access to the right tools for their own learning. The institution provides teaching, support and any

specialist knowledge and tools the student needs, whilst a commercial ISP provides core services such as email. The PLE project (http:/ / www.cetis.ac.uk/ members

/ ple/ ) is developing the definition, scope and a reference model for PLEs. It will also be developing desktop and portal based prototypes.

In the afternoon, I attended a workshop on Moodle

(http:/ / moodle.org/ ) and one on StudyNet - a portal developed locally at the University of Hertfordshire. I didn\u2019t feel that either VLE offered much more than our own VLE does, but they did seem to be much better integrated with other support and information webpages.

The conference report and presentations from the day
are now available to view on the RSC YH website:
http:/ / www.rsc-yh.ac.uk/ conference/ ossconf.asp
DIYe-Learning
Five ideas on how free and low-cost tools
can be used to introduce e-learning

elements into your learning and teaching for minimal effort and cost. For help and advice on any of these approaches contact eLISU (elisu@gcal.ac.uk).

BLOGS
Why?

O nline journals that give instant access to expert knowledge and updates. They are increasingly at the core of online communities as they can be commented on, and are usually linked into other blogs and content. Blogs are excellent for capturing individual knowledge and views. However, they are by nature highly personal and depend entirely on the contribution of the author(s).

H ow?
\u00b7 Direct students to blogs related to their subject area

\u00b7 Create a community blog that groups of students can use to keep each other updated on a topic or progress with a project.

\u00b7 Ask students to keep individual blogs to reflect on their
learning.
Getting started

Blog software is largely open source, but needs to be set up on a webhost. A good example of Blogging software is WordPress - http:/ / wordpress.org/

If you aren\u2019t lucky enough to have a webserver to install WordPress onto, you can get a free blog at a number of sites including blogger.com, WordPress.com and

livejournal.com
WI KI S
Why?
Wikis are community website which can be edited and
added to by any member \u2013 ideal for problem solving,
collaboration and knowledge management. However, as
with blogs, they are by nature unstructured and as the

content can be edited by any member of the community, are vulnerable to misuse. Probably the best known Wiki is Wikipedia (http:/ / www.wikipedia.org/ ), a surprisingly useful online encyclopedia to which anybody can contribute. Wikipedia is said to be the world's largest wiki website.

H ow?

\u00b7 Set up pages for students to develop a knowledge base
or micro encyclopedia on a topic.
\u00b7 Create separate pages for small group projects so that

groups can put up the latest drafts of reports they're
working on, brainstorm new ideas, keep track of useful
websites etc.
\u00b7 Use it for lecture notes \u2013 create a page for each lecture,
add any PowerPoint files from the lecture as an attachment.

Let students add their own notes taken during class, or
add follow up questions and comments.
\u00b7 Q&A - Start a page for questions and answers. Let
students post any questions they have - and get answers
(and opinions!) from yourself, other teaching staff and

other students.
Getting Started
Most wiki software is free but needs to be set up on a
webserver. Good examples are: MediaWiki
(http:/ / www.mediawiki.org/ wiki/ MediaWiki) and

DokuWiki (http:/ / www.splitbrain.org/ projects/ dokuwiki). However, for a small sum JotSpot (http:/ / www.jot.com/ ) will host one for you and Seedwiki

(http:/ / www.seedwiki.com/ ) is a free Wiki creation site.
Mary Cuttle
eLISU Coordinator
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...