Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
18Activity
P. 1
Taitz v. Sebelius - Fed Govt Defs Response in Opposition to Mot to Stay

Taitz v. Sebelius - Fed Govt Defs Response in Opposition to Mot to Stay

Ratings: (0)|Views: 371|Likes:
Published by GeorgetownJD

More info:

Published by: GeorgetownJD on Nov 02, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

12/04/2012

pdf

text

original

 
@J QNE UJ@QEA XQMQEX A@XQS@HQ HDUSQFDS QNE JDSQNESJ A@XQS@HQ DF QE^MXAMIIMX A@V@X@DJAS* DSIP QM@Q[ EX]* §§_im`jq`ff §§v* § Hmxe Jd* 8;=3"hv"?835="_§LMQNIEEJ XECEI@UX Xehseqms §Nemiqn mja Nubmj Xesv`hex
eq mi*
§§Aefejamjqx* §
FEAESMI GDVESJBEJQ AEFEJAMJQX‐ SEX_DJXE @J D__DX@Q@DJ QD_IM@JQ@FF‐X ’_EQ@Q@DJ FDS XQMP‒
Aefejamjqx _sex`aejq Cmsmhl Dcmbm< Lmqnieej Xecei`ux Xehseqms df Nemiqn mja NubmjXesv`hex< B`hnmei Mxqsue Hdbb`xx`djes df Xdh`mi Xehus`q< Es`h Ndiaes Mqqdsje Gejesmi df qne Uj`qea Xqmqex< mja W`ii`mb M* Hnmqf`eia pmxq a`sehqds df qne Xeiehq`ve Xesv`he .hdiiehq`veiqne ’Feaesmi Gdvesjbejq Aefejamjqx‒) nesec xucb`q qn`x sexpdjxe `j dppdx`q`dj qd _im`jq`ff Dsi Qm`q{‐x ’peq`q`dj fds xqm hesq`f`hmq`dj df vdqex fds Hmja`amqe Dcmbm peja`jg aeh`x`dj df qnepmjei df Buiq`"a`xqs`hq i`q`gmq`dj mja peja`jg sexdiuq`dj df ujaesi`jg hdjqsdvesx dj qne bes`qx‒f`iea dj Dhqdces 0 3?=3 mq Adhleq Jd* =7* Cehmuxe qne Kua`h`mi _mjei dj Buiq`a`xqs`hq I`q`gmq`dj.’K_BI‒ ds ’qne _mjei‒) nmx xqsuhl Qm`q{‐x ’Bdq`dj qd Hddsa`jmqe mja Hdjxdi`amqe Hmxex‒ qnese`x jd gsdujax dj wn`hn qd xqm qn`x mhq`dj ‘ ieq midje m ’hesq`f`hmq`dj df vdqex‒ ‘ mja Qm`q{‐xbdq`dj xnduia ce aej`ea*@j`q`mii qne aefejamjqx jdqe qnmq Qm`q{ nmx misema bdvea fds m psei`b`jms `jkujhq`dj `jqn`x hmxe mja `j bmj wmx nes imqexq f`i`jg `x jd bdse qnmj m xehdja mqqebpq qd dcqm`jpsei`b`jms sei`ef fsdb qn`x Hdusq* Fds qne semxdjx xeq fdsqn `j qne aefejamjqx‐ dppdx`q`dj qd qnmqbdq`dj
xee
Alq* =1 mja `j qne aefejamjqx‐ bdq`dj qd a`xb`xx
xee
Alq* =5 Qm`q{ `x jdq ejq`qiea qd
Hmxe 8;=3"hv"?835="_ Adhubejq 31 F`iea ==$?=$=3 _mge = df 1 _mge@A 68>
 
3psei`b`jms sei`ef .ds mj sei`ef wnmqxdeves) `j qn`x hmxe* Xne nmx fm`iea qd exqmci`xn kus`xa`hq`djds vejue `j qn`x Hdusq fm`iea qd xndw m i`lei`ndda df xuhhexx dj qne bes`qx df mj df nes him`bxfm`iea qd xndw qnmq xne `x i`lei qd xuffes `ssepmsmcie nmsb mja fm`iea qd exqmci`xn mj df qne dqneseiebejqx jehexxms fds psei`b`jms sei`ef*@j nes jew bdq`dj Qm`q{ xeelx m xqm cmxea dj qne fmhq qnmq xne nmx f`iea m peq`q`dj w`qnqne K_BI xeel`jg qd hddsa`jmqe qn`x hmxe mja qwd dqnesx* Qd qne e~qejq Qm`q{ xeelx qd xqm qn`xi`q`gmq`dj nes bdq`dj `x w`qnduq bes`q*
=
Dj Dhqdces == 3?=3 Qm`q{ f`iea m peq`q`dj w`qn qne_mjei xeel`jg qne hdjxdi`amq`dj df qn`x hmxe w`qn
 Kuaa v* Dcmbm
 Hmxe Jd* XMHV =3"=5?7"ADH .H*A* Hmi*) mja
Qm`q{ v* Aebdhsmq \x`hR _msq df B`xx`xx`pp`
 Hmxe Jd* 8;=3"hv"??3>? .X*A*B`xx*)* Cuq qnmq peq`q`dj wmx jdq psdpesi f`iea* Mfqes g`v`jg nes jdq`he mja mj dppdsquj`q qdhuse ’bmkds aef`h`ejh`ex‒ `j nes f`i`jg
xee
BAI Hmxe Jd* 31=7 Alq* 8 .Dhq* =3 3?=3) qne_mjei xqsuhl Qm`q{‐x piema`jg dj Dhqdces 8= 3?=3
xee
BAI Hmxe Jd* 31=7 Alq* 1 .Dhq* 8=3?=3) .mqqmhnea mx E~* =)*
3
 
=
@q `x fsmjli ujhiems wnmq Qm`q{‐x bdq`dj xeelx qd xqm `j pmsq cehmuxe df nes fm`iuse qd `jhiuae mpsdpdxea dsaes* Cuq qd qne e~qejq Qm`q{ `x mxl`jg fds ’mj ebesgejh XQMP df qne hesq`f`hmq`dj df 3?=3 vdqex fds hmja`amqe Dcmbm‒ _i*‐x Bdq* 8 nes se}uexq `x fs`vdidux mja wndii w`qnduq bes`q*Qn`x hmxe nmx i`qesmii jdqn`jg qd ad w`qn mj ’hesq`f`hmq`dj df vdqex*‒ Qne sei`ef xdugnq `jQm`q{‐x hdbpim`jq `jhiuaex aehimsmqds mja `jkujhq`ve sei`ef segmsa`jg qne dpesmq`dj df qne _mq`ejq_sdqehq`dj mja Mffdsamcie Hmse Mhq midjg w`qn aehimsmqds sei`ef mja ambmgex mxxdh`mqea w`qnQm`q{‐x miiegmq`djx ujaes S@HD* Qm`q{‐x hdbpim`jq xeelx jd `jkujhq`ve sei`ef segmsa`jg mjeiehq`dj jds ad qne pmsq`ex `jhiuae mj xqmqe dff`h`mi mcie qd psdv`ae xuhn sei`ef ds mj dqneshmja`amqe wnd b`gnq ce mffehqea c xuhn sei`ef*
Xee
_i*‐x Hdbpi* 8="88* Qnese wduia qnux ce jdcmx`x qd ejqes xuhn e~qsmdsa`jms sei`ef evej `f Qm`q{ hduia aefemq dveswneib`jg kus`xa`hq`djmiaefehqx aebdjxqsmqe m i`lei`ndda df xuhhexx dj qne bes`qx df nes him`bx exqmci`xn qnmq xne `xi`lei qd xuffes `ssepmsmcie nmsb mcxejq ejqs df m xqm mja dveshdbe qne e~qsmdsa`jms puci`h`jqesexq `j qne aej`mi df nes bdq`dj*
3
Maa`q`djmii mfqes Qm`q{ f`iea nes peq`q`dj Kuage Amv`a D* Hmsqes `xxuea mj dsaes
xum xpdjqe
 a`xb`xx`jg
 Kuaa v* Dcmbm
fds imhl df xuckehq bmqqes kus`xa`hq`dj dj qne gsduja qnmq qne pim`jq`ffxnma sebdvea qne`s dwj hmxe fsdb Hmi`fdsj`m Xqmqe Xupes`ds Hdusq*
Xee Kuaa 
 Alq* 81 Dsaes df Dhq* =7 3?=3 .mqqmhnea mx E~* 3)*
 
Hmxe 8;=3"hv"?835="_ Adhubejq 31 F`iea ==$?=$=3 _mge 3 df 1 _mge@A 680
 
8@q `x wdsqn jdq`jg qnmq `j qne evejq Qmq`{ se"f`iex nes peq`q`dj qnese w`ii xq`ii ce jd semxdjqd aeim sui`jg dj qne aefejamjqx‐ bdq`dj qd a`xb`xx* ’Qne pejaejh df m bdq`dj qd qsmjxfescefdse qne K_BI adex jdq a`vexq m hdusq df kus`xa`hq`dj dves qne hmxe*‒
Husq`x v* C_ Mbes`hm) @jh*
 >?> F* Xupp* 3a 076 07> .X*A* Qe~* 3?==)*
Xee mixd
K_BI Suie df _sdheause 3*=.a)mvm`imcie mq nqqp;$$www*kpbi*uxhdusqx*gdv$x`qex$kpbi$f`iex$_mjei%3?Suiex"Mbejaea"7"6"3?==*paf .’Qne pejaejh df m bdq`dj * * * pusxumjq qd 3> U*X*H* § =1?7 adex jdq mffehq dsxuxpeja dsaesx mja pseqs`mi psdheea`jgx `j mj peja`jg feaesmi a`xqs`hq hdusq mhq`dj mja adex jdqi`b`q qne pseqs`mi kus`xa`hq`dj df qnmq hdusq*‒)*
 
Kua`h`mi ehdjdb w`ii jdq ce xesvea c asmgg`jg qn`x hmxe duq cmxea dj mj ujsemi`xq`hjdq`dj qnmq `q bm ce hddsa`jmqea ds hdjxdi`amqea w`qn mjdqnes bmqqes* @jxqema fds qne semxdjxxeq fdsqn `j qne aefejamjqx‐ bdq`dj qd a`xb`xx Qm`q{‐x hdbpim`jq xnduia ce a`xb`xxea `j `qxejq`seq*Amqea; Jdvebces = 3?=3* Sexpehqfuii xucb`qqeaXQUMSQ F* AEIESPMhq`jg Mxx`xqmjq Mqqdsje GejesmiXNE@IM B* I@ECESAepuq A`sehqds Feaesmi _sdgsmbx Csmjhn
 $x$ Xhdqq S`xjes 
XHDQQ S@XJES .B@ Cms (_7?763)Qs`mi MqqdsjeUj`qea Xqmqex Aepmsqbejq df Kuxq`heH`v`i A`v`x`dj Feaesmi _sdgsmbx Csmjhn3? Bmxxmhnuxeqqx Mvejue J*W*Wmxn`jgqdj A*H* 3?58?Qeiepndje; .3?3) 5=1"3805Fmhx`b`ie; .3?3) 6=6">17?E"bm`i; xhdqq*s`xjesOuxadk*gdvMqqdsjex fds Feaesmi Gdvesjbejq Aefejamjqx
Hmxe 8;=3"hv"?835="_ Adhubejq 31 F`iea ==$?=$=3 _mge 8 df 1 _mge@A 61?

Activity (18)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
la428 liked this
Susan Sullivan liked this
Jim Nicklaus liked this
chanceryny liked this
kriselda gray liked this
Victor Pulver liked this
DavidPfeifer liked this
liveclive304393 liked this
Andrew Huff liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->