Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
21Activity
P. 1
The EU and Ukraine after the 2012 elections

The EU and Ukraine after the 2012 elections

Ratings: (0)|Views: 149 |Likes:
Europe needs to realise that the political situation in Ukraine is deteriorating. Ukraine has become more authoritarian and corrupt - it is therefore essential for the EU to change its approach and abandon its “business as usual” attitude.

The parliamentary elections in Ukraine were a powerful reminder that democratic principles have been replaced by “political technology” and that the influence of oligarchs has reached new levels. Members of the literal and metaphorical “family” around President Yanukovych are using their power to enrich themselves on an unprecedented scale.

In a new ECFR policy memo,"The EU and Ukraine after the 2012 elections", Andrew Wilson argues that ignoring the problems in Ukraine would simply allow these worrisome trends to get worse.

What the EU should do:

- Smart conditionality: The EU needs to redefine conditionality in three key areas: selective prosecutions, the conduct of elections and sustainable reform.

- Rethink EU-Ukraine trade deals: DCFTA and AA ratification need to be linked to real progress in Ukraine and alternatives to a full implementation should be developed.

- Fight against corruption:The EU should start auditing the activities of corrupt “family” companies in Cyprus, Luxembourg and Austria which are breaking existing EU law.

- Visa bans: The EU should develop a Ukrainian equivalent of the “Magnitsky List” starting with a visa ban on Renat Kuzmin, the deputy prosecutor responsible for the trials of Tymoshenko and former Interior Minister Yuriy Lutsenko.

- Support for SMEs: The EU should help revive lending schemes for SMEs and support businesses that are worried by the rise of corrupt oligarchs.


“The EU should not fear continuing to apply tough standards to Ukraine. But the EU needs leverage and should also work harder to show it is on the side of Ukraine’s beleaguered democratic, liberal and economically constructive forces. - It’s time to show Ukraine some tough love.” - Andrew Wilson
Europe needs to realise that the political situation in Ukraine is deteriorating. Ukraine has become more authoritarian and corrupt - it is therefore essential for the EU to change its approach and abandon its “business as usual” attitude.

The parliamentary elections in Ukraine were a powerful reminder that democratic principles have been replaced by “political technology” and that the influence of oligarchs has reached new levels. Members of the literal and metaphorical “family” around President Yanukovych are using their power to enrich themselves on an unprecedented scale.

In a new ECFR policy memo,"The EU and Ukraine after the 2012 elections", Andrew Wilson argues that ignoring the problems in Ukraine would simply allow these worrisome trends to get worse.

What the EU should do:

- Smart conditionality: The EU needs to redefine conditionality in three key areas: selective prosecutions, the conduct of elections and sustainable reform.

- Rethink EU-Ukraine trade deals: DCFTA and AA ratification need to be linked to real progress in Ukraine and alternatives to a full implementation should be developed.

- Fight against corruption:The EU should start auditing the activities of corrupt “family” companies in Cyprus, Luxembourg and Austria which are breaking existing EU law.

- Visa bans: The EU should develop a Ukrainian equivalent of the “Magnitsky List” starting with a visa ban on Renat Kuzmin, the deputy prosecutor responsible for the trials of Tymoshenko and former Interior Minister Yuriy Lutsenko.

- Support for SMEs: The EU should help revive lending schemes for SMEs and support businesses that are worried by the rise of corrupt oligarchs.


“The EU should not fear continuing to apply tough standards to Ukraine. But the EU needs leverage and should also work harder to show it is on the side of Ukraine’s beleaguered democratic, liberal and economically constructive forces. - It’s time to show Ukraine some tough love.” - Andrew Wilson

More info:

Published by: ECFR, European Council on Foreign Relations on Nov 02, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/08/2013

pdf

text

original

 
 PMK K[ JG@ [FRJCGKJEPKR PMK 2>:2KIKHPCAGX
Jg`rkt Tcixag
 ^  AI   C    H  S   OK   O A X   [  O O J  R  S   X   [  O O J  R  S  
Rkijpcagx bkptkkg pmk K[ jg` [frjcgk jrk jp jg co~jxxk'Pmk ijxp pta skjrx mjuk bkkg `aocgjpk` bs ratx aukr pmkxkikhpcuk ~raxkh{pcag ae rkdcok a~~agkgpx) cg ~jrpch{ijr pmkhaguchpcag ae earokr ^rcok Ocgcxpkr S{icsj Psoaxmkgfacg Ahpabkr 2>::) jg` jg jhhkikrjpcgd prkg` patjr`x j oarkj{pmarcpjrcjg jg` harr{~p xpsik ae r{ik cg [frjcgk' Jppkgpcagmjx gat p{rgk` pa pmk ~jricjokgpjrs kikhpcagx mki` ag 2=Ahpabkr 2>:2 jx j `ceekrkgp pkxp ae [frjcgk–x `koahrjpch bagj ec`kx' Pmk a~~axcpcag rcdmpis ekkix jddrckuk` pmjp pmkj{pmarcpckx mjuk `kgck` pmko j ~axxcbik uchpars' Pmkrk tjx xaok `crkhp erj{`) ~jrpch{ijris cg pmk gkt pkrrcparcjihagxpcp{kghckx'
:
B{p cg dkgkrji pmk j{pmarcpckx xa{dmp parcd pmk kikhpcag bs apmkr okpma`x x{hm jx pmk haukrp {xk ae ’~aicpchji pkhmgaiads‟ jg` j hmjgdk cg pmk uapcgd xsxpkopmjp pmk a~~axcpcag cragchjiis jdrkk` pa bjhf cg 2>::'^jrj`a}chjiis) pmcx okjgp pmjp cg ojgs tjsx pmk kikhpcag tjx oark hao~kpcpcuk pmjg k}~khpk` ‘ b{p agis bkhj{xk pmkj{pmarcpckx tkrk hagec`kgp pmks ta{i` tcg'Pmk rkhkgp eah{x ag pmk kikhpcagx mjx braj`kgk` pmk K{ra~kjg uckt erao pmk Psoaxmkgfa hjxk pa iaaf jp mat pmcgdx mjuk`kpkrcarjpk` jhraxx pmk bajr`' B{p pmkrk cx jixa j `jgdkrpmjp pmk K[ tcii oauk pmk daji~axpx jg` ojfk pmk hag`{hpae pmk kikhpcagx pmk agis hrcpkrcag ear `khc`cgd tmkpmkr argap cp xma{i` rkxpjrp rkijpcagx tcpm [frjcgk) ar l{`dk pmkj{pmarcpckx oark ag ~jxp pmjg ag ~rkxkgp bkmjuca{r jg`{xk j hrcpcz{k ae pmk kikhpcagx pa oauk patjr`x j `k ejhpa
:
Pmk [frjcgcjg ~jricjokgp mjx 0;> O^x' Jepkr pmk ’Arjgdk Rkuai{pcag‟ cg 2>>0) cp tjxpma{dmp bkppkr pmjp jii ae pmko xma{i` bk kikhpk` bs ~ra~arpcagji rk~rkxkgpjpcag' B{p cg2>:: pmk daukrgokgp earhk` pmra{dm j rkp{rg pa pmk kjrickr xsxpko) {g`kr tmchm mjie ae O^x ta{i` bk kikhpk` bs ^R) jg` pmk apmkr mjie cg pkrrcparcji hagxpcp{kghckx) tmkrk xa/hjiik` j`ocgcxprjpcuk rkxa{rhkx -pmjp cx) xpjpk/`crkhpk` erj{`# mj` oark tkcdmp'
Rkijpcagx bkptkkg pmk K[ jg` [frjcgk jrk jp jgco~jxxk jepkr pta skjrx `aocgjpk` bs ratx aukrpmk xkikhpcuk ~raxkh{pcag ae rkdcok a~~agkgpx)cg ~jrpch{ijr pmk haguchpcag ae earokr ^rcokOcgcxpkr S{icsj Psoaxmkgfa cg Ahpabkr 2>::)jg` j{pmarcpjrcjgcxo jg` harr{~pcag cg [frjcgk'Matkukr) pmk rkji `jgdkr eaiiatcgd pmk kikhpcagx ag2= Ahpabkr cx gap kikhparji erj{` b{p pmk tjs pmjppmk j{pmarcpckx jrk gat kgprkghmcgd pmkoxkiukx cg~atkr bs kukrs ~axxcbik okjgx' Okobkrx ae pmkicpkrji jg` okpj~marchji ’ejocis‟ jra{g` ^rkxc`kgp Sjg{faushm jrk {xcgd pmkcr ~atkr pa kgrchmpmkoxkiukx ag jg {g~rkhk`kgpk` xhjik' Pmk K[hjggap jeear` pa xco~is tjcp {gpci pmk gk}p hagpkxpcg 2>:;'Pmk K[ o{xp pmcgf hrkjpcukis pa ecg` j tjs pa
oauk bksag` pmcx co~jxxk' Cp xma{i` bkppkr `kgk
hag`cpcagjicps cg pmk pmrkk fks jrkjx ae xkikhpcuk~raxkh{pcagx) pmk hag`{hp ae kikhpcagx jg` ’rkearo‟'Cp xma{i` j~~is pmk Jxxahcjpcag Jdrkkokgp jg`@kk~ jg` Hao~rkmkgxcuk Erkk Prj`k Jdrkkokgp tcpm [frjcgk pmjp mjuk bkkg ag mai` xcghk ijxp@khkobkr) ce gkhkxxjrs xkikhpcukis ar ~raucxcagjiis) b{p pjfk j pa{dmkr icgk cg apmkr jrkjx) ear k}jo~ik bs 
co~axcgd j ucxj bjg ag ikj`cgd d{rkx cg pmk rkdcok
jg` j{`cpcgd x{x~khp ’ejocis‟ hao~jgckx cg pmk K[' Jp pmk xjok pcok) pmk K[ xma{i` icbkrjicxk ucxjx)kgha{rjdk k`{hjpcagji k}hmjgdkx jg` x{~~arp pmkkokrdkghk ae gkt cg`k~kg`kgp jhparx cg [frjcgk tma jrk tarrck` bs pmk rcxk ae pmk ’ejocis‟'
 
   P   M   K   K   [   J   G   @   [   F   R   J   C   G   K   J   E   P   K   R   P   M   K   2   >   :   2   K   I   K   H   P   C   A   G   X
2
   K   H   E   R   !   5   ;   G  a  u  k  o   b  k  r   2   >   :   2  t  t  t '  k  h   e  r '  k  {
cxaijpcag ~aichs' Cg Gaukobkr pmk Earkcdg Jeejcrx Ha{ghci tcii `khc`k tmkpmkr pa oauk eartjr` tcpm pmk Jxxahcjpcag Jdrkkokgp -JJ# jg` @kk~ jg` Hao~rkmkgxcuk Erkk Prj`k Jdrkkokgp -@HEPJ# tcpm [frjcgk pmjp mjuk bkkg ag mai`xcghk ijxp @khkobkr' Pmk jgg{ji K[/[frjcgk x{oocp cx xpciixhmk`{ik` ear xaok pcok bkeark pmk kg` ae pmcx skjr) pma{dmgkcpmkr xc`k cx ~jrpch{ijris kgpm{xcjxpch' Xaok cg pmk K[ jrkocg`k` pa xcdg pmk jdrkkokgpx) cg ~jrp bkhj{xk pmk ~rahkxxae rjpcechjpcag bs okobkr xpjpkx cx icfkis pa dkp baddk` `atgjgstjs' Apmkrx tjgp pa {xk pmk jdrkkokgpx pa kgearhk rk`icgkx ag ~aicpchji ~raxkh{pcagx ar `koahrjpch `kpkrcarjpcag'Matkukr) gkcpmkr j~~rajhm tcii mki~ prjgxearo [frjcgkcgpa pmk fcg` ae xahckps pmk K[ ta{i` icfk pa xkk' Xcdgcgd pmkjdrkkokgpx ~rkojp{rkis ta{i` {g`krocgk hag`cpcagjicps6ikjucgd pmko ag chk ikjukx pmk K[ tcpma{p ikukrjdk' PmkK[ pmkrkeark gkk`x pa pmcgf ae hrkjpcuk tjsx ae rkdjcgcgdcgei{kghk tmcik ojcgpjcgcgd rk` icgkx ag uji{kx ‘ gap ikjxp bkhj{xk pmk ~aicpchji xcp{jpcag cg [frjcgk ha{i` kjxcis `kpkrcarjpk e{rpmkr' J pcdmpkgcgd ae pmk xhrktx ag cg`k~kg`kgpok`cj jg` ag pmk xpcii xpragd cg`k~kg`kgp GDA xkhpar cx~axxcbik jepkr pmk kikhpcagx' Pmk rat aukr pmk Psoaxmkgfahjxk tjx bj` kga{dm' B{p {gikxx pmk K[ rkdjcgx prjhpcag)pmkrk tcii bk tarxk pa haok' Pmk j{pmarcpckx jrk kgprkghmcgdpmkoxkiukx cg ~atkr bs kukrs ~axxcbik okjgx) jg` okobkrxae pmk icpkrji jg` okpj~marchji ’ejocis‟ jra{g` ^rkxc`kgp Sjg{faushm jrk {xcgd pmjp ~atkr pa kgrchm pmkoxkiukx ag jg{g~rkhk`kgpk` xhjik' Pmk K[ hjggap jeear` pa tjcp {gpci pmkgk}p hagpkxp cg 2>:;'
Pmk rkp{rg ae ’~aicpchji pkhmgaiads‟
Pmkrk tkrk xaok kgha{rjdcgd xcdgx ae `koahrjpch ucpjicps cgpmk Ahpabkr kikhpcagx' Pmk ojxx ok`cj a~kgk` {~ j icppik) ce agis pko~arjrcis' Pmk j{pmarcpckx tkrk {gjbik pa ~rkujci cgxkukrji fks mapis hagpkxpk` hagxpcp{kghs rjhkx' Pmk [gcpk`A~~axcpcag hajicpcag b{cip jra{g` Psoaxmkgfa–x Ejpmkrijg`~jrps hjok xkhag`) kukg pma{dm xmk tjx gap jiiatk` pa xpjg`'B{p tmcik pmk K[ mjx pkg`k` pa eah{x ag kikhpcag erj{` jg`pmk xkikhpcuk ~raxkh{pcag ae ~aicpchji a~~agkgpx) `koahrjhs cg [frjcgk cx gat bkcgd {g`krocgk` cg ojgs apmkr tjsx'Pmk l{`chcji ’rkearo‟ ~{xmk` pmra{dm cg 2>:> gat dcukx pmkxpjpk pmk ~atkr pa ~{p jgsagk cp tjgpx cg ~rcxag' Pmk ikdjixsxpko mjx bkhaok papjiis ~aicpchcxk`6 haguchpcag rjpkx jrkaukr 33 ~krhkgp' Pmk l{`chcjrs cx {xk` pa xcikghk kgkockxjg` pa ikdcpcocxk pmk cghrkjxcgd ~rabiko ae rjc`krpxua) ar pmkpmkep bs aicdjrhmx ae kjhm apmkrx– b{xcgkxxkx' Kukg pmk rkikjxkae Psoaxmkgfa ta{i` gap xaiuk pmcx oark e{g`jokgpji~rabiko' Tmkrk pmk a~~axcpcag `c` tkii) cp tjx `kx~cpk cpx atg tkjfgkxxkx' Ojgs ae cpx ikj`cgd ecd{rkx ~ijsk` xjek jg` xpaa`ag ~jrps icxpx rjpmkr pmjg pjfk ag pmk r{icgd ^jrps ae Rkdcagx`crkhpis cg pmk hagxpcp{kghckx' Pmk pmrkk ojcg a~~axcpcag~jrpckx ‘ Ejpmkrijg`) [@JR -fgatg jx ’^{ghm‟ bkhj{xk cp cxik` bs pmk ba}kr Ucpjics Fichmfa# jg` pmk ejr/rcdmp Erkk`ao^jrps ‘ ha{i` agis rkjhm j ~jrpcji jdrkkokgp ag tcpm`rjtcgdcg kjhm apmkrx– ejua{r cg pmk hagxpcp{kghckx' Kjhm x{x~khpxpmk apmkr ae jhpcgd jx j Praljg marxk jg` xkhrkpis ~ijggcgdpa jiis tcpm pmk ^jrps ae Rkdcagx jepkr pmk kikhpcagx' @cucxcagx tcpmcg pmk ojcg ~jrpckx jrk ojgceai`) jg` tmkrk pmks `a gapk}cxp pmks jrk hrkjpk` bs pmk j{pmarcpckx– ojicdg cgei{kghk'Pmk a~~axcpcag xma{i`g–p kukg bk pmk a~~axcpcag cg pmka{pdacgd ~jricjokgp) jx cp tag pmk ijxp kikhpcagx cg 2>>4'B{p `cx{gcps cg cpx rjgfx mjx rk~kjpk`is ik` pa `kekhpcagxjg` ejci{rk pa biahf ar keekhpcukis rkxcxp fks okjx{rkx icfkpmk kikhpcag ijt cpxkie cg Gaukobkr 2>:: ar pmk gkt Ijt agIjgd{jdkx cg L{is 2>:2'Pmk ~axcpcag ae pmk a~~axcpcag cx bkcgd e{rpmkr tkjfkgk` bs pmk rkucuji ae xa/hjiik` ’~aicpchji pkhmgaiads‟ -pmk iahji bijhf jrpx ae haukrp ojgc~{ijpcag#' Ojgs ae pmk ’a~~axcpcag‟~jrpckx r{ggcgd cg pmk kikhpcag tkrk cg rkjicps haukrp ~ralkhpxae pmk j{pmarcpckx' Eartjr` [frjcgk* jg` cpx ikj`kr GjpjicsjFaraikuxfj jhp icfk rj`chji a~~axcpcag earhkx) b{p jrk cgrkjicps tmjp cx fgatg iahjiis jx ’hiagkx‟ ‘ pmjp cx) ha~ckxae apmkr ~jrpckx ecgjghk` bs ikj`cgd aicdjrhmx pmjp prs papjfk pmk ~ijhk ae pmk ai` a~~axcpcag ‘ mkghk pmk hmachk ae j sa{gd) dijoara{x ekojik ikj`kr pa hao~kpk tcpm S{icsjPsoaxmkgfa' Pmk j{pmarcpckx ~rkukgpk` xaok a~~axcpcag~jrpckx x{hm jx [@JR erao hjo~jcdgcgd cg kjxpkrg [frjcgk) tmkrk pmk ^jrps ae Rkdcagx cx rkijpcukis xjgd{cgk jba{piaxcgd uapkx pa apmkr ~jrpckx x{hm jx pmk Haoo{gcxpx) jx cpfgatx pmk Haoo{gcxpx tcii bk j rkicjbik ~jrp ae jgs e{p{rkx{~kr/ojlarcps'Kukg pmk dkg{cgk a~~axcpcag ~jrpckx jrk gat jii ecgjghcjiis `k~kg`kgp ag aicdjrhmch x~agxarx) aepkg kukg erao pmkj{pmarcpckx– atg rjgfx' [frjcgk–x rchmkxp ojg) Rcgjp Jfmokpau) x{~~axk`is x~kgp $=> ociicag ag Eartjr`[frjcgk* ‘ pma{dm mk jiikdk`is h{p e{g`cgd bkhj{xk pmk~ralkhp tjx pmrkjpkgcgd pa pjfk uapkx aee pmk ^jrps ae Rkdcagx' Pmk Haoo{gcxpx jrk x~agxark` pa pmk p{gk ae $2;ociicag bs Cmar Faikpgcf) pmk mkj` ae pmk H{xpaox Xkruchk'
2
 Pmcx ecgjghcgd cii{xprjpkx mat pmrkjpkgk` xaok [frjcgcjgaicdjrhmx ekki bs pmk rcxk ae Sjg{fauhm–x ’ejocis‟' Jp pmk xjokpcok) matkukr) x{hm e{g`cgd rk`{hkx pmk rkji cg`k~kg`kghkae pmk ’a~~axcpcag‟'Pmk a~~axcpcag ~jrpckx mjuk jixa bkkg xkk`k` tcpm xa/hjiik`
p{xmfc 
‘ cg`cuc`{jix tma jrk fgatg pa bk kjxcis brcbkjbikjg` jrk ~rk/~radrjook` pa `kekhp jepkr pmk kikhpcag
8
' Pmk~rabiko ae brcbkrs jg` pmk `kekhpcag ae O^x mjx bkkgjra{g` ear j iagd pcok' Cg 2>>0) hmjgdkx pa pmk hagxpcp{pcag tkrk jdrkk` pmjp rkz{crk` O^x pa xpjs cg pmk ~jrpckx pmks  tkrk kikhpk` pa xkruk jg` pa kgx{rk pmjp pmk daukrgokgp’ojlarcps‟ tjx oj`k {~ ae ~jrpckx rjpmkr pmjg cg`cuc`{jix'B{p cg j bijpjgpis ~jrpcji r{icgd cg 2>:> pmk hagxpcp{pcagjiha{rp rkukrxk` pmjp `khcxcag' Jp ikjxp => ~krhkgp ae ’cg`k~kg`kgp‟ O^x tcii bk ~krx{j`k` pa lacg pmk j{pmarcpckx–hjo~ bs pmk xjok okjgx' Pm{x kukg pma{dm pmk ^jrps ae Rkdcagx `c` gap tcg pmk mkj`icgk uapk) padkpmkr tcpm pmk ejfka~~axcpcag) ’cg`k~kg`kgpx‟ jg` p{xmfc) cp xpcii mjx j ojlarcps jg` cx tcpmcg rkjhm ae pmk 8>> a{p ae 0;> xkjpx cg pmk gkt ~jricjokgp cp gkk`x pa hmjgdk pmk hagxpcp{pcag' Pmk pmrkk
2
J{pmar cgpkruckt tcpm ikj`cgd iahji ~aicpchji pkhmgaiadcxp Pjrjx Bkrk|aukpx) 2>Xk~pkobkr 2>:2'
8
P{xmfj
okjgx pmk har~xk ae j xojii jgcoji ‘ xaokpmcgd icfk ’raj`fcii‟'
 
8
ojcg a~~axcpcag ~jrpckx tcii mjuk pa xmat jg {ghmjrjhpkrcxpchikuki ae xaic`jrcps pa ~rkukgp pmcx mj~~kgcgd'
Pmk rcxk ae pmk ’ejocis‟
Harr{~pcag mjx jixa cghrkjxk` x{bxpjgpcjiis xcghk pmk 2>:>kikhpcagx' Sjg{faushm mjx cghrkjxcgdis ukxpk` ~atkr jg` tkjipm cg j icpkrji jg` okpj~marchji ’ejocis‟' Pmk ~rkxc`kgp–xai`kxp xag Aikfxjg`r Sjg{faushm jg` mcx jxxahcjpkx mjuk pjfkgaukr pmk hkgprji bjgf jg` pj}) ecgjghk jg` ijt kgearhkokgpjdkghckx) jg` {xk` pmjp ~atkr pa pjfk aukr rcuji b{xcgkxxkx'
0
 Pmcx bkdjg tcpm b{xcgkxxkx atgk` bs x{~~arpkrx ae pmk iaxcgdxc`k cg 2>:> jg` [frjcgk–x u{igkrjbik XOK xkhpar' Gat pmk’ejocis‟ mjx xmcepk` pa pjrdkpcgd ojlar aicdjrhmx' ’Drjbbcgd~ra~krps xpjrpk` tcpm pmk x{~~arpkrx ae pmk arjgdk kicpk) b{pgat cp cx `jgdkr ae x~rkj`cgd pa pmk rkijpcukis iasji d{sx)‟xjsx ikj`cgd [frjcgcjg jgjisxp Osfmjcia Maghmjr'
;
Aukrpmk ijxp skjr) pmk ’ejocis‟ mjx bkd{g oaucgd cgpa pmk haji b{xcgkxx) kikhprchcps) pkikhaoo{gchjpcagx jg` jdrch{ip{rk'Ijg` ~rcujpcxjpcag cx xhmk`{ik` ecgjiis pa oauk eartjr` jepkrpmk kikhpcagx) b{p jokg`okgpx pa pmk ijt rkhkgpis hrkjpk` jgkt xpjpk ijg` bjgf pmjp ta{i` mjuk ecrxp rcdmp ae ~{rhmjxkce ~kjxjgp ejrokrx hmaxk pa xkii pmkcr ijg`) ikj`cgd pa ekjrxpmjp ’ejocis‟ b{xcgkxxkx tcii z{chfis jhh{o{ijpk pmk ijrdkxp~jrhkix ae [frjcgk–x rchm ejro ijg`'[frjcgk–x ha/maxpcgd ae pmk K{ra 2>:2 eaapbjii hmjo~cagxmc~ecgjix tjx ojrrk` bs hagpraukrxckx aukr pmk ~rcucikdk` raikae xmj`ats hagprjhpar hao~jgckx icgfk` pa pmk ’ejocis‟ icfk Jiphao' Rjfk/aeex jg` aukr/~jsokgpx haxp pmk [frjcgcjgpj}~jskr m{g`rk`x ae ociicagx ae `aiijrx' Cg J{d{xp 2>:2) Sjg{faushm xcdgk` j ijt hjghkiicgd pmk abicdjpcag ae xpjpkhao~jgckx pa mai` pkg`krx ear pmk ~{rhmjxk ae daa`x jg`xkruchkx tmkg pmks {xk pmkcr atg e{g`x' S{icsj Oaxpauj)pmk k`cpar ae [frjcgk–x ojcg cg`k~kg`kgp ~j~kr
 Ocrrarae pmk Tkkf
) jrd{kx pmjp Sjg{faushm–x daji cx xco~ik' ’Mk tjgpx pa bk pmk rchmkxp ojg cg Kjxpkrg K{ra~k‟) xmk xjsx'’Sjg{faushm cx pmk ecrxp ~rkxc`kgp ae [frjcgk tma gkk`x jhagpraiicgd xmjrk gap agis ae jii ~atkr cg pmk ha{gprs b{p ae jii cpx b{xcgkxx paa'‟
5
 Pmk ~atkr ae pmk ’ejocis‟ cx icfkis pa drat e{rpmkr jepkr pmkkikhpcagx jx Xkrmcs Jrb{|au) pmk h{rrkgp mkj` ae pmk hkgprji bjgf jg` ’h{rjpar‟ ae pmk ojgs ’ejocis‟ b{xcgkxxkx) oaukx pa bkhaok ecrxp `k~{ps ~rcok ocgcxpkr ar kukg ~rcok ocgcxpkr'Bkhj{xk pmk cgpkrkxpx ae pmk ’ejocis‟ jrk h{rrkgpis jii tcpmcg[frjcgk) cpx okobkrx jrk coo{gk pa pmk jrd{okgp pmjp[frjcgk gkk`x pmk jdrkkokgpx tcpm pmk K[' Matkukr) apmkraicdjrhmx tma prj`k ar cgukxp jbraj` jrk `kk~is tarrck`jba{p pmk pmrkjp pa pmkcr b{xcgkxx cgpkrkxpx'
0
Xkk pmk jgjisxcx ae mcx k}~jg`cgd ko~crk bs Xkudci O{xjkuj) ’Mat pmk B{xcgkxx ae pmk^rkxc`kgp–x Ki`kr Xag Tarfx‟)
 Earbkx [frjcgk
) 8 Xk~pkobkr 2>:2) jp mpp~<!!earbkx'{j!ojdj|cgk!earbkx!:88583=/fjf/rjbapjkp/bc|gkx/xpjrxmkda/xsgj/~rk|c`kgpj
;
J{pmar cgpkruckt) = Gaukobkr 2>::'
5
J{pmar cgpkruckt tcpm S{icsj Oaxpauj) = Gaukobkr 2>::6 S{iccj Oaxpauj) ’Xkoaxpccgsc Sjg{faushm‟)
 @|krfjia ps|mgcj
) : L{gk 2>:2) jujcijbik jp mpp~<!!`p'{j!^AICPCHX!xkoaxpcsgcsQsjg{fauchm/:>8:;2'mpoi'
Erjdcik ~i{rjicxo
Pmk j{pmarcpckx jrk gap ejr xmarp ae j pta/pmcr`x ojlarcps cg pmk gkt ~jricjokgp pmjp ta{i` jiiat pmko pa hmjgdkpmk hagxpcp{pcag' Ear k}jo~ik) pmks ha{i` `khc`k pa jiiat  Sjg{faushm pa bk ’rk/kikhpk`‟ bs ~jricjokgp cg 2>:; rjpmkrpmjg `crkhpis bs pmk ~ka~ik' Jipkrgjpcukis) jx pmk j{pmarcpckxgat hagprai jioaxp jii ~aicpchji brjghmkx ae xpjpk) pmks ha{i`pjrdkp rkojcgcgd cg`k~kg`kgp hkgprkx ae ~atkr bkeark jgs x{hm hmjiikgdkx jrcxk' Xcghk 2>:>) pmk j{pmarcpckx mjuk bkkg drj`{jiis pcdmpkgcgd hagprai aukr cg`k~kg`kgp ok`cj)gap bs rkxparcgd `crkhp hkgxarxmc~) b{p bs hmjiikgdcgdjg` rk`cxprcb{pcgd aicdjrhmch hagprai' Jx Xkrmcs F{`kisj~{px cp) ’hagprai aukr pmk ikj`cgd pkikucxcag hmjggkix bs aicdjrhmch oad{ix hiaxk pa Sjg{faushm mjx ~ra`{hk` joark `khkgprjic|k` xsxpko ae xkie/hkgxarxmc~‟'
4
Pmk gkt ~rkekrkghk cx ear xa/hjiik` {xgsfs) ar ukrbji cgxpr{hpcagxerao pmk ~rkxc`kgpcji j`ocgcxprjpcag pa PU atgkrx cg~krxag' Pm{x pmk ok`cj rkojcgx ~i{rjicxpch b{p cx mcdmis harr{~p' Jhhar`cgd pa agk [@JR j`ucxkr) ’jii ok`cj cx gat ~jc` ear) jg` tk mjuk pa ~ijs pmjp djok‟'
=
 Pmk j{pmarcpckx ojs `ra~ pmkcr rkijpcukis mjg`x/aee j~~rajhmpa pmk ok`cj aghk pmk uapk cx aukr) l{xp jx pmks `c` aghk pmkK{ra 2>:2 ecgji cg Fscu tjx a{p ae pmk tjs) cg ~jrp xa pmjppmk ’ejocis‟ hjg o{xhik cg ag pmk iahji ok`cj ojrfkp' Pmkhjo~jcdg pmjp bkdjg cg pmk x{ookr jdjcgxp [frjcgk–x ijxprkojcgcgd PU hmjggkix icfk PUc jg` cg`k~kg`kgp a{pikpxicfk pmk ~j~kr jg` ~a~{ijr tkb xcpk Ikep Bjgf) jx tkii jxxcpkx oa`kiik` ag Jik}ks Gjujigs–x hjo~jcdgx cg R{xxcj icfk~jrficfkc`cap'hao'{j jg` gjxmcdraxmc'ard -’A{r Oagks‟#) tmchm iaafx jp harr{~pcag cg ~{bich hagprjhpx) ojs tkii bkrkx{ok`'Okjgtmcik [frjcgk–x rkijpcukis erkk GDA xkhpar iaafxicfk jg cghrkjxcgd jgaojis' Pmk g{obkr ae rkdcxpkrk`GDAx mjx jhp{jiis dratg cg rkhkgp skjrx' [frjcgk mjx gap skp eaiiatk` R{xxcj bs earhcgd a{p ’earkcdg‟ GDAx jg`x{bxpcp{pcgd pmko tcpm Frkoicg/erckg`is ’daukrgokgp/ardjgcxk` GDAx‟ ar DAGDAx -R{xxcj–x atg okjx{rkx tkrk cragchjiis j rkjhpcag pa [frjcgk–x Arjgdk Rkuai{pcagcg 2>>0#' B{p pmk [frjcgcjg j{pmarcpckx jrk gat xkppcgd {~’hiagk‟ GDAx x{hm jx Ear Ejcr Kikhpcagx) tmchm ~rk`chpjbis djuk pmk Ahpabkr kikhpcagx j hikjg bcii ae mkjipm'
3
Cragchjiis jg` xj`is ear pmk ha{gprs pmjp xpjdk` ejoa{x ojxx ~rapkxpxjdjcgxp pmk ijxp rcddk` kikhpcagx cg 2>>0) pmk ardjgcxjpcag ae hrat`x jg` `koagxprjpcagx cx gat j ~raekxxcagji b{xcgkxx‘ `koagxprjparx) aepkg xp{`kgpx) jrk ~jc` pa p{rg {~'
:>
 ^rkhcxkis bkhj{xk ojgs GDAx ~ijsk` j fks raik cg kikhpcagoagcparcgd) j ’ecgji eragp‟ jdjcgxp pmkoha{i` bk a~kgk` jepkr pmk kikhpcagx'
Xkrmcs F{`kisj) ’^aicpchx jg` @koahrjhs cg [frjcgk‟) cg Pjrjx F{|ca jg` @jgckiMjocipag -k`x'#)
A~kg [frjcgk< Hmjgdcgd Ha{rxk Patjr`x j K{ra~kjg E{p{rk
 -Tjxmcgdpag) @H< Hkgpkr ear Prjgxjpijgpch Rkijpcagx) 2>::#) ~~' :/2> jg` ~~' :>/::'
=
J{pmar cgpkruckt) :3 Xk~pkobkr 2>:2'
3
’Pmk abxkrukrx erao Ear Ejcr Kikhpcagx xjt ga xkrca{x ucaijpcagx jg` pjif jba{p pmk”gkt `kukia~okgpx– cg pmk {~haocgd kikhpcagx cg [frjcgk‟)
 Faoxaoaixfjsj ^rju`j cg[frjcgk
) 2; Ahpabkr 2>:2) jujcijbik jp mpp~<!!f~'{j!`jcis!2;:>:2!852=0;!
:>
 Skdar Ujxsisku) ’Pmk E{ggs B{xcgkxx ae [frjcgcjg ^aicpchji Rjiickx‟) PrjgxcpcagxAgicgk ) 3 Ekbr{jrs 2>:2) jujcijbik jp ttt'pai'ard!hickgp!jrpchik!223==/pmk/e{ggs/ b{xcgkxx/ae/{frjcgcjg/~aicpchji/rjiickx'mpoi6 Rchmjr` Ba{`rkj{}) ’B{hfx ^a~{ic< Ojfcgd@koahrjhs j Dacgd Haghkrg cg Fcku‟)
Pmk Tjii Xprkkp La{rgji 
) ; Ekbr{jrs 2>:>'

Activity (21)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
soupchange added this note
Superior
felinevietnamese added this note
Its helpful
lewismik added this note
Superior
PaulBlanchard added this note
that's nice
CarmenSBarnes added this note
that's helpful
tightdistressed added this note
Thats helpful...
LaurenBuckner added this note
good
spanishmug added this note
nice
loafstuffy added this note
Neat...!!
soupchange liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->