Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
The Beacon Spotlight: Issue 1; Republican Form of Government

The Beacon Spotlight: Issue 1; Republican Form of Government

Ratings: (0)|Views: 11|Likes:
Published by Matt Erickson

More info:

Categories:Types, Research, History
Published by: Matt Erickson on Nov 09, 2012
Copyright:Public Domain


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less




 A quick look to the U.S. Constitution confirmsat least the fundamental basis of the proposition that"Government is power".For example,
 Article III, Section 1
"The judicial
of the United States,shall be vested in one supreme Court, and insuch inferior Courts as the Congress may fromtime to time ordain and establish..."
 Article II, Section 1
likewise proclaims:
"The executive
shall be vested in aPresident of the United States of America..."
 Article I, Section 1
further declares:
"All legislative
herein granted shallbe vested in a Congress of the United States,which shall consist of a Senate and House ofRepresentatives."
 An additional look into a few enumerated powersof Congress helps prove the charge that governmentis all about power.
 Article I, Section 8, Clause 1
, forexample, declares in part that:
"The Congress shall have
To layand collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises,to pay the Debts and provide for the commonDefence and general Welfare of the UnitedStates."
 Article I, Section 8, Clause 3
declares that:
"The Congress shall have
To regulateCommerce with foreign Nations, and among theseveral States, and with the Indian Tribes."
 Article I, Section 8, Clause 11
proclaims that:
"The Congress shall have
Todeclare War, grant Letters of Marque andReprisal, and make Rules concerning Captureson Land and Water."
Government, then, is power
but toward whatpurpose? As acknowledged within our Declaration of Independence, men have unalienable Rights endowedby our Creator, including the Right to Life, Liberty,and the pursuit of Happiness.Governments are specifically instituted among men, as told by our Declaration, "to Secure theserights", and not to trample over them. The purposeof Government is to then protect our rights, not tobe the greatest transgressor of them.Left unchecked, government power is antitheticalto man's rights. As such, one would expect strong limitations on American government to protectagainst destroying its very purpose, so the end is notsacrificed to the means.
A Study of Constitutional Issues by Topic
Public Domain (no copyright). 2010
Distributed by: The Foundation For Liberty
"The Essence of Government is Power"
 James Madison
 While government may be all about power,its explicit purpose is to secure man'sunalienable (inalienable) rights.
Issue 1: Republican Form of Government 
The Beacon SpotLight: Issue 1: Page 2
Though the Constitution grants Power togovernment, Americans with expectations of finding express limitations on government power within theConstitution will not be disappointed.One of the most powerful constitutionalprotections is found in
 Article IV, Section 4
of theU.S. Constitution which declares, in part:
"The United States shall guarantee to everyState in this Union a Republican Form ofGovernment."
Form of Government is representativegovernment, where laws are enacted by legislativemembers operating within their powers as delegated by the very citizens whom they were elected to represent.The Declaration of Independence lists many factsto prove the King of Great Britain was "unfit to be theruler of a free people".Foremost amongthe Declaration's list of abusesand usurpations was of the king pressing the Americancolonists to "relinquish the right of Representation inthe Legislature". The Declaration held Representationin the Legislature to be a "right inestimable to them"and the king's call for relinquishment was "formidableto tyrants only".The 1774 Declaration of Rights (issued by the firstContinental Congress) stated:
“That the foundation of English liberty, and ofall free government, is a right in the people toparticipate in their legislative council”.
From the explicit constitutional guarantee of a Republican form of Government, to the Declaration'sinsistence of this inestimable right of free people, tothe 1774 Declaration that people participating in theirlegislative council is the very foundation of liberty andfree government, one dare not overlook thefundamental importance of legislative representation.In that even a quick glance at our founding documents produced a curtailing effect to the tenetthat government is power, a further look is in order. A simple compare and contrast between Articles I,II and III detailed earlier show a fundamentaldifference between Article I (legislative) and Articles II& III (executive and judicial, respectively). As earlier covered, the Constitution unequivocallvested the
Power in the Courts and vested the
Power in a President of the United States of  America (each of these separate Powers were vestedcompletely in their respective branches).However, conspicuously absent is a similarcomprehensive investment of the
Power withthe Congress. To properly understand the limitednature of our federal government, one mustcomprehend this critical difference.It is important to note that only a 
legislativePowers, individually-enumerated and “herein granted”, were vested with the Congress, rather thanthe wholelegislative “Power”.Notably, Article I does NOTdeclare (in similarfashion to Articles II and III):
"The legislative Power shall be vested in aCongress."
 Article I
actually details:
"All legislative Powers
herein granted 
shallbe vested in a Congress."
To repeat, ONLY the individually-enumeratedlegislative Powers "herein granted" were vested inCongress and NOT the whole legislative Power in any unified and complete sense (note the use of the pluralform of “Powers” used in Article I, rather than “Power”as used in Articles II and III).Though the word All” in Article I appears inclusive, words of limitation (“herein granted”) follow. The neteffect is to
all other powers not therein granted. Another way of stating "
legislative Powers
herein granted 
shall be vested in a Congress" is "
the legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested ina Congress".The express acknowledgement that the enumeratedpowers were "
" to Congress in the first placefurther and explicitly recognizes that there must besome other entity or individual, or a number of otherentities or individuals, who grant(s) this power.This principle is confirmed in the Constitution by 
 Article VII, Clause 1
 which reads:
"The Ratification of the Conventions of nineStates, shall be sufficient for the Establishment ofthis Constitution between the States so ratifyingthe Same."
Republican Form of Government
The separate States, when they individually ratifiedthe Constitution, ceded specified legislative powersover to the Congress of the United States of America.Further, this express limitation of the grant of legislative powers to include only the powers specifically granted therein acknowledges that the legislative power which was
granted to Congress is located elsewhere(as later explicitly detailed in the 10
 Article V 
covers the process of amending theConstitution. It reads, in part:
"The Congress, whenever two thirds of bothHouses shall deem it necessary, shall proposeAmendments to this Constitution, or, on theApplication of the Legislatures of two thirds ofthe several States, shall call a Convention forproposing Amendments, which, in either Case,shall be valid to all Intents and Purposes, asPart of this Constitution, when ratified by theLegislatures of three fourths of the severalStates, or by Conventions in three fourthsthereof."
 Article V shows there are two methods formodifying the Constitution. In the first mechanism,Congress, with sufficient numbers, may (only) proposeamendments. These proposed amendments are thensent to the State legislatures for debate and possibleratification.The second mechanism allows for two-thirds of theState legislatures to call for a convention for proposing amendments. Any proposed amendments of such constitutional convention would be debated and perhapsratified by the individual State ratifying conventions. As one can plainly see, only the States themselveshave the authority to decide the ultimate powersprovided or allowed the United States. Only the Statesratified the Constitution and only the States may ratify  Amendments. It is important to realize therefore thatthe several States are the
to the contract which is the Constitution; the United States’government is but the
. The United States’government is the State's agent for dealing with theissues detailed within the Constitution.The individual States acting together created theUnited States and the individual States acting togetherdetermine the extent of powers allowed the UnitedStates.Of course, that the States ultimately control theUnited States is backwards from common understanding 
that the United States essentially dictate to theStates. Without the States, there are no United States.Since the States ratified the Constitution and ratify all amendments (additional grants or limitations onpower), the States clearly have at least some of theresidual legislative authority.This principle is explicitly confirmed by the
Tenth Amendment 
, which plainly declares:
"The powers not delegated to the UnitedStates by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it tothe States, are reserved to the Statesrespectively, or to the people."
 All legislative powers besides those listed in theConstitution remain with the States or within thepeople at large.In discussing the powers granted to the Congressof the United States, one must thoroughly understandthat phrase, as well as the proper relationship betweenthe separate States and the United States. Article I, Section 1 earlier discussed provides that“All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested ina Congress of the United States”. At first glance, it is perhaps natural to think of Congress as but one of three entities of the federalgovernment (along with the executive and judicialbranches). If one misunderstands Congress as but anentity, however, one may easily misunderstand the very relationship between the States and the United States.Literally and most properly, the Congress of theUnited States of America is NOT an "entity" but firstand foremost a "meeting" or an "event".This is perhaps easiest understood by looking atsome of our country's organic documents forclarification. If one looks at the
Bill of Rights
, forexample, one finds that it commences with thefollowing words:
"Congress of the United States, begun andheld at the City of New-York, on Wednesday theFourth of March, one thousand seven hundredand eighty nine."
The Beacon SpotLight: Issue 1: Page 3
Congress of the United States

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->