Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
8Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
MUFTI TAHA KHAN VS KHIDR AMARI DEBATE ABOUT QURAN AND SUNNAH

MUFTI TAHA KHAN VS KHIDR AMARI DEBATE ABOUT QURAN AND SUNNAH

Ratings: (0)|Views: 321 |Likes:
Published by Dr. Momin Sohil
Sammy HossainWhy should Muslims return to the Qur'an Alone without the Sunnah

October 30 at 3:33am ·
 Lol are you guys serious? O man you fools are just hilarious. Jump on the band wagon with the retarded atheists. You wanna return to Islam alone without the sunnah whereas in the Quran it clearly mentions that it is Nabi (saw) who will explain the Quran to us. Honestly, if you don't like Islam then feel free to leave cuz Islam isn't great due to your presence.

Like ·
o

Khidr Amari, Tajudeen
Sammy HossainWhy should Muslims return to the Qur'an Alone without the Sunnah

October 30 at 3:33am ·
 Lol are you guys serious? O man you fools are just hilarious. Jump on the band wagon with the retarded atheists. You wanna return to Islam alone without the sunnah whereas in the Quran it clearly mentions that it is Nabi (saw) who will explain the Quran to us. Honestly, if you don't like Islam then feel free to leave cuz Islam isn't great due to your presence.

Like ·
o

Khidr Amari, Tajudeen

More info:

Published by: Dr. Momin Sohil on Nov 09, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

11/05/2013

pdf

text

original

 
 
Lol are you guys serious? O man you fools are just hilarious. Jump on the band wagon with theretarded atheists. You wanna return to Islam alone without the sunnah whereas in the Quran itclearly mentions that it is Nabi (saw) who will explain the Quran to us. Honestly, if you don't likeIslam then feel free to leave cuz Islam isn't great due to your presence.
o
 
o
 
Khidr Amari PRODUCE ONE VERSE IN AL QUR'AAN THAT SAYS EITHERONE OF THE FOLLOWING:(1) We are suppose to follow Nataq-un-
 Nabi” (Speech of Nabi)/ SunnatuRasoolullah (Sunnah of Messenger) by ‘NAME’
or...(2) We will get guidance from Nataq-un-
 Nabi” (Speech of Nabi) / SunnatuRasoolullah (Sunnah of Messenger) by ‘NAME’ or 
 (3) We are suppose to believe in Nataq-un-
 Nabi” (Speech of Nabi) / SunnatuRasoolullah (Sunnah of Messenger) by ‘NAME’ ? or 
 (4) Nataq-un-
 Nabi” (Speech of Nabi) / Sunnatu Rasoolullah (Sunnah oMessenger) was revealed or sent down (nazala) to Muhammad by ‘NAME’?
o
 
Khidr Amari Put your proof where your mouth isOctober 30 at 3:34am · Like · 2 
o
 
Khidr Amari Its obvious you don't like the Qur'an.
 
o
 
Khidr Amari I see you study so it shouldn't take you no time to validate theoutside books called Hadith and Sunnah right?October 30 at 3:35am · Like · 1 
o
 
Sammy Hossain Unlike you buddy I don't have everything ready to be copy andpasted so please do allow me to my time. Thank you. (Can't say jazakAllahuKhairan cuz its not in the Quran)October 30 at 3:38am via mobile · Like · 3 
o
 
Khidr Amari Sammy Hossain don't be mad because I do what Allah ask of us to verify Surah 17/36October 30 at 3:47am · Like · 2 
o
 
Sammy Hossain 1) Obey Allah and obey the Messenger. (Not sure which ayahbut its there, believe me I'm a Haafizul Quran Alhamdulillah)2) Surah Baqarah ayah 151. Clearly mentions that the Messenger will teach you(which will lead to guidance)3)/4) last ayah of surah Fath juz 26Don't tell me I don't love the Quran. I've got the whole thing memorized anddevoted 3 yrs to it and for the past 6 yrs I been studying it Alhamdulillah.First off, apparently, you're denying the whole concept of a Rasool. A Rasool issent so that he can show us the way and so we can follow him.Second, your english grammar sucks! You really expect me to or anyone for thatmatter to listen to your illogical arguments?"so it shouldn't take you no time" 2 negatives equal a positive.Now my turn
 
Surah Nahl ayah 44, surah Baqarah ayah 151, surah Aale Imraan ayah 164, surah jumah ayah 2All mention that the messenger will explain and teach the Quran to you. Howexactly do you expect that to happen with out hadith? These ayahs are alsoindirectly indicating that Allah will protect hadith so that the correct meaning of the Quran remains.How exactly do you intend on following the Quran when you have no explanationfor it?I think what the problem here is that you've misunderstood the contrast betweenthe compilation of hadith and the actual writing of it.The writing of hadith was found within the very lifetime of Nabi (saw). Thecompilation of Hadith only initiated 3 centuries later.Just in case you were unaware but the people back then had brains better andmuch more advanced then any computer you can find today. Do really think thatAllah will not protect His Deen and on top of that just leave us with the Quranwithout any sort of explanation or example?October 30 at 4:00am via mobile · Like · 7 
o
 
Sammy Hossain Surah 17/36? "Do not pursue in such matters which you have noknowledge of. Verily your hearing and sight and heart, all of it will bequestioned"Honestly, I have no clue what you mean by that. Plz elaborate. Thank you againOctober 30 at 4:03am via mobile · Like · 1 
o
 
Khidr Amari I love it when you Sunnis or Shites say obey the messenger means intranslation to follow or believe in Hadith. You are so predictable. You remind meof Christians who say 'I and the Father are one' when they try to defend their Jesusis God doctrine.Obey the messenger only means to obey the message how do we get the messagethat was revealed to the Messenger through the message which was nothing butthe Qur'an.Specifially in Surah 33/1-3 Allah addresses Muhammad as "Prophet' whichdifferentiated between hims as a 'Messenger' because even Muhammad/theProphet had to follow again what was revealed to him which was the Message/the

Activity (8)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
Dr. Momin Sohil liked this
Dr. Momin Sohil liked this
Dhanish Truman liked this
Dr. Momin Sohil liked this
Dr. Momin Sohil liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->