Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
2Activity
P. 1
A review of the experience of hospital autonomy in Pakistan

A review of the experience of hospital autonomy in Pakistan

Ratings: (0)|Views: 91 |Likes:
Published by Aamir Shehzad
This paper examines the recent trends in public hospital autonomy as an integral part of health
systems reforms. It reviews literature produced on the subject across a range of developing
countries and explores varying viewpoints, arguments, and rationale for hospital autonomy
developed over the past two decades. It then leads onto a discussion of two experiences of
autonomy reforms in Pakistan: the provinces of Punjab and NWFP. Derived from the lessons
learned from these initiatives, a set of guidelines is suggested as sustainable frameworks for
reviewing the current measures and for designing future autonomy initiatives in Pakistan.
This paper examines the recent trends in public hospital autonomy as an integral part of health
systems reforms. It reviews literature produced on the subject across a range of developing
countries and explores varying viewpoints, arguments, and rationale for hospital autonomy
developed over the past two decades. It then leads onto a discussion of two experiences of
autonomy reforms in Pakistan: the provinces of Punjab and NWFP. Derived from the lessons
learned from these initiatives, a set of guidelines is suggested as sustainable frameworks for
reviewing the current measures and for designing future autonomy initiatives in Pakistan.

More info:

Published by: Aamir Shehzad on Nov 09, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See more
See less

07/19/2013

 
C tfqgf~ ia pof fxzftgfelf ia oi|zgpchcvpieimw ge Zcbg|pce
M% Pce~fft Cd`vhhco+
(
w
ce` Kcef \oc~
 Evaffifh` Lfeptf ait Gepftecpgiech Ofchpo ! @fqfhizmfep( Hff`| Vegqft|gpw( Hff`|( VB 
\VMMCTW
Pog| zczft fxcmgef| pof tflfep ptfe`| ge zvdhgl oi|zgpch cvpieimw c| ce gepfntch zctp ia ofchpo|w|pfm| tfaitm|% Gp tfqgf~| hgpftcpvtf zti`vlf` ie pof |vdkflp clti|| c tcenf ia `fqfhizgenliveptgf| ce` fxzhitf| qctwgen qgf~zigep|( ctnvmfep|( ce` tcpgiechf ait oi|zgpch cvpieimw`fqfhizf` iqft pof zc|p p~i `flc`f|% Gp pofe hfc`| iepi c `g|lv||gie ia p~i fxzftgfelf| ia cvpieimw tfaitm| ge Zcbg|pce; pof ztiqgelf| ia Zvekcd ce` E^AZ% @ftgqf` atim pof hf||ie|hfctef` atim pof|f gegpgcpgqf|( c |fp ia nvg`fhgef| g| |vnnf|pf` c| |v|pcgecdhf atcmf~itb| aittfqgf~gen pof lvttfep mfc|vtf| ce` ait `f|gnegen avpvtf cvpieimw gegpgcpgqf| ge Zcbg|pce%Lizwtgnop
,
4::1 Kioe ^ghfw ! \ie|( Hp`%
bfw ~it`|
; oi|zgpch cvpieimw2 `fqfhizgen liveptgf|2 ofchpo |ftqglf| `flfeptchg{cpgie2limzctcpgqf ofchpo |w|pfm| tfaitm|2 Zcbg|pce
DCLBNTIVE@
Pof g||vf
Zvdhgl |flpit oi|zgpch| ge pof `fqfhizgen liveptgf| ctf nfeftchhw loctclpftg{f` dwgefaffilgfep tf|ivtlf mcecnfmfep( hi~ zti`vlpgqgpw( veatgfe`hw it veztiaf||giechzcpgfep lctf( tgng` ogftctloglch |ptvlpvtf|( gefaaflpgqf c`mgeg|ptcpgqf ce` ffiecelgchlieptih|( ce` ce cd|felf ia zftaitmcelf-dc|f` gelfepgqf|% Pofw ctf iapfe limzctf`(pi pofgt `fptgmfep( ~gpo tfhcpgqfhw faffilgfep ce` li|p-faaflpgqf ENI oi|zgpch|( it ~gpomitf fflfxgdhf ce` zcpgfep-atgfe`hw ztgqcpf oi|zgpch|%Capftmcewwfct|ge~ogloofchpozihglwlielfeptcpf`ieZtgmctwOfchpoLctf(ce`oi|zgpch| ~ftf |ffe c| fxzfe|gqf ce` gttfhfqcep hfqfh ia lctf( tflfep zihglw ptfe`| geofchpo |w|pfm tfaitm| ocqf c`qilcpf` ait ntcepgen cvpieimw pi zvdhgl oi|zgpch| c| c|ihvpgie pi pofgt ztidhfm|% Gp g| lhcgmf` pocp ~gpo cvpieimw( oi|zgpch| lce zhce pofgt|ftqglf| faaflpgqfhw( mcecnf |pcaa ce` ipoft tf|ivtlf| faffilgfephw( tf|zie` fflfxgdhw
+Littf|zie`felf pi; @t M% P% Cd`vhhco( Ztintcmmf Liit`gecpit( Ofchpo Zhceegen ce` Mcecnfmfep(Ge|pgpvpf ia Mcecnfmfep \pv`gf|( Vegqft|gpw ia Zf|oc~ct( Zcbg|pce% F-mcgh; mpcd`vhhcoJoipmcgh%lim
w
Cp pof pgmf ia ~tgpgen pog| zczft( pof li-cvpoit ~c| ch|i zhclf` c| Qg|gpgen \lgfepg|p cp pof Pcqg|pilb Ge|pgpvpf ia Ovmce Tfhcpgie|( Hie`ie( ce` ie zftmcefephw dc|g| c| pof C||ilgcpf Ztiaf||it ia OfchpoZhceegen ce` Mcecnfmfep cp pof Ge|pgpvpf ia Mcecnfmfep \pv`gf|( Vegqft|gpw ia Zf|oc~ct( Zcbg|pce%
%
 
ce` |fe|gpgqfhw pi zcpgfep|‗ eff`|( ce` ztiqg`f czztiztgcpf ce` li|p-faaflpgqf|flie`ctw it pftpgctwlctf c| ce gepfntch zctp ia pof ofchpo |w|pfm% Pog| ctpglhf |fp| ivppi tfqgf~ ce` fxcmgef |imf tflfep fxzftgfelf| ia oi|zgpch cvpieimw ge Zcbg|pce(`tc~|ivppofztfhgmgectwhf||ie|pocpmv|pdfhfctef`atimpof|f(ce`(iepofgtdc|g|(ztizi|f| c atcmf~itb ait avtpoft ~itb%
Lvttfep zvdhg|of` qgf~| ie cvpieimw
Limmfepcpit| ocqf eip dffe |hi~ pi ltgpglg{f pof mcecnfmfep zftaitmcelf ce`svchgpw ia mf`glch lctf ia zvdhgl oi|zgpch| ge `fqfhizgen liveptgf|% ^ofelimzctg|ie g| mc`f~gpo pof ztgqcpf |flpit it pof eie-niqftemfep |flpit oi|zgpch|( gpg| chmi|p ch~cw| pi pof `fptgmfep ia pof zvdhgl oi|zgpch /Ntffe( 37?>2 \|feniidc
fp ch
%( 4::42 Ztfbft ce` Oct`gen( 4::<'% Pofw ctf ch|i li|phw; ge c |pv`w ia 47 liveptgf| /Dctevm ce` Bvp{ge( 3774'( gp ~c| tfzitpf` pocp niqftemfep oi|zgpch|lie|vmf cdivp 1:& ia pof pipch |pcpf fxzfe`gpvtf ie ofchpo( ~oglo( ge pof hgnop ia pofgt acghgen|( ivphgef` cdiqf( dflimf| c |ftgiv| lielfte ait |ilgch tf|fctloft|(zihglw mcbft|( ce` mcecnft|% Ofelf gp g| iapfe ztizi|f` pocp chhi~gen cvpieimw pipof|f oi|zgpch| livh` ztiqg`f |ihvpgie| pi mcew ztidhfm|% Ge mcbgenpocp1 ztf|vmzpgie( ge pof lc|f ia |fqftch `fqfhizgen liveptgf|(
3
pof |lizf ia ce`pof tcpgiechf ait cvpieimw ocqf dffe `tc~e ivp atim( cmien ipoft|( lhfct |ogap| gepof gepftecpgiech zihgpglch-flieimw ia ofchpo ce` `fqfhizmfep /^ith` Dceb( 37?>2Mi|hfw
fp ch
%( 37732 Ef~dtce`ft
fp ch
%( 37742 ^ith` Dceb( 377<2 [cg`g( 37702 Ztfbftce` Oct`gen( 4::<'( pof mclti- it mf|i-hfqfh zihglw izpgie| ce` |ptcpfngl gegpgcpgqf|/Ogh`fdtce`
fp ch
%( 377<2 Mghh|( 37762 Niqge`tck
fp ch
%( 37712 Lihhge|
fp ch
%( 3771'(ge|pgpvpgiech tfaitm| /Lc||fh|( 37762 MlZcbf( 37712 Niqge`tck ce` Loc~hc( 3771'(pof `ilptgef| ia pof ‟Ef~ Zvdhgl Mcecnfmfep(it zvdhgl“ztgqcpf mgx ce`zctpeft|ogz| /MlZcbf( 377<2 Loc~hc ce` Nfitnf( 3771'( ce` pof |lizf aititnceg{cpgiech locenf /Di||ftp
fp ch
%( 37712 Lihhge| ce` Ntffe( 3777'%\fqftch lielfte| mcw df tcg|f` cp pog| zigep; Oi~ pi `fffief ge|pgpvpgiech cvpieimwce` mcbf |vtf pocp gp g| liepfxpvchhw czztiztgcpf9 Oi~ pi `f|gne pof cvpieimw-ntcepgen ztilf|| ce` fe|vtf pof qgcdghgpw ia gp| |pcnf|9 Oi~ pi ltfcpf lie`vlgqffeqgtiemfep| ait ce faaflpgqf gmzhfmfepcpgie ztilf|| ait ptce|hcpgen ce cmdgpgiv|zihglw cnfe`c pi faaflpgqf izftcpgiech ztilf`vtf|9 Oi~ pi acgthw fqchvcpf pof gmzclpia pof ntcepf` cvpieimw ~gpo tfnct` pi |vllf||avh it `f|gtcdhf ivplimf|9 Ce`( oi~pi |v|pcge |vlo gepftqfepgie| ge pof ofchpo |w|pfm| ia pof `fqfhizgen liveptgf| pocpatfsvfephw izftcpf ge gmzftmcefep( gelie|g|pfep( ce` pvtdvhfep feqgtiemfep|9/Cd`vhhco( 4:::' \imf ltgpglch ge|gnop| gepi pof ce|~ft| ait pof|f svf|pgie| lce df`tc~e atim pof hgpftcpvtf pocp oc| dffe zti`vlf` ie pog| |vdkflp iqft pof zc|p cdivp3: wfct|% Oi~fqft( tf|fctloft| ce` ltgpgl| ocqf ch|i dffe lie|lgiv| ia pof aclp pocppof fxzftgfelf| ia gmzhfmfepcpgie ce` fqchvcpgie ia cvpieimw oc| zti`vlf`tfhcpgqfhw hgpphf clc`fmgl `ilvmfepcpgie( ge pftm| ia pof tcenf ia hgmgpcpgie| ce`lochhfenf| fxzftgfelf` ge pof mcge|ptfcm ztclpglf( it ge `fffiegen pof |lizf ia 
3
Ge c``tf||gen pi pof mcge pofmf|( pog| ctpglhf ailv|f| iehw ie pof `fqfhizgen liveptgf|% C evmdft ia pof`fqfhizf` ecpgie|( ~oglo oc` |gmghct it `gaaftfep fxzftgfelf| ce` czzticlof| pi oi|zgpch cvpieimw( ce`ctf fxpfe|gqfhw tfzitpf` ge pof hgpftcpvtf zti`vlf` |gelf pof mg`-377:|( ocqf eip dffe liqftf`%Lizwtgnop
,
4::1 Kioe ^ghfw ! \ie|( Hp`%
Gep K Ofchpo Zhcee Mnmp 
4::>2
44
; 06“14%@IG; 3:%3::4)ozm
01
M% P% CD@VHHCO CE@ K% \OC^
 
faaflpgqfef|| ge pof clpvch gmztiqfmfep ia zftaitmcelf /Niqge`tck ce` Loc~hc(3771'%Chpoivno gp g| nfeftchhw c||vmf` pocp cvpieimw hfc`| pi geltfc|f` zti`vlpgqgpw( gpg| afctf` pocp feocelgen pof svchgpw ia lctf pocp oc| dffe ief iagp| hfc`gen ctnvmfep|mcwpcbfc|flie`ztgitgpwpigmztiqf`flieimglfaffilgfelw`fffief`c|;‟chhilcpgieia tf|ivtlf| cmien chpftecpgqf clpgqgpgf| ge |vlo c ~cw pocp ~ghh zti`vlf pof |cmfivpzvp cp pof hi~ft li|p‗ /Niqge`tck ce` Loc~hc( 3771( z% 6'% Pof ^ith` Dceb tcg|f|ceipoft lielfte dw svf|pgiegen ~ofpoft cvpieimw mcw tf|vhp ge c limztimg|f iefsvgpw ge pof ffiecelgen ce` `fhgqftw ia ofchpo lctf /Loc~hc ce` Dftmce( 3776'%Poftfaitf( cew cppfmzp| pi fxcmgef pof gepfe`f` cgm| ce` idkflpgqf| ia niqftemfepge ntcepgen cvpieimw pi oi|zgpch| mv|p gepftztfp ‟faffilgfelw‗ acgthw |vaffilgfep pi chhi~ait svchgpw lie|g`ftcpgie( ce` ait fsvgpw‐c mckit limziefep ia Ztgmctw OfchpoLctf ce` c vegqft|ch ge`glcpit ia cllf|| pi dc|gl ofchpo lctf ztiqg|gie ge pof`fqfhizgen liveptgf| /Lihhge| ce` Ntffe( 3770'%Faaitp| ocqf dffe mc`f ge pof zc|p `flc`f pi `fqfhiz nfeftch atcmf~itb| aitc||f||mfep ia oi|zgpch cvpieimw% Ge zctpglvhct( Niqge`tck ce` Loc~hc /3771' cp pofOctqct` \loiih ia Zvdhgl Ofchpo( ztizi|f` c ztiqg|giech lielfzpvch atcmf~itb pifxcmgef pof fxzftgfelf| ia oi|zgpch cvpieimw ge ffiqf liveptgf|; Nocec( Bfewc(Ge`gc( Ge`ief|gc( ce` [gmdcd~f% Fclo lc|f |pv`w ~c| nvg`f` dw qf mcgeidkflpgqf|;/3' Cechw|g| ia tfc|ie| ~ow cvpieimw ~c| ngqfe pi pof |fhflpf` oi|zgpch|2/4' @f|ltgzpgie ia pof czzticlo ce` ztilf|| ia ngqgen cvpieimw2/<' @f|ltgzpgie ia pof ecpvtf ce` fxpfep ia cvpieimw2/0' C||f||mfep ia pof gmzclp ia cvpieimw ie tf|ivtlf midghg{cpgie( faffilgfelw(cllivepcdghgpw( fsvgpw ce` svchgpw ia lctf2 ce`/6' \vnnf|pgie| ait |vllf||avh gmzhfmfepcpgie ia cvpieimw%Pof ffie`gen| ia Niqge`tck ce` Loc~hc /3771' ctf dc|f` ie dipo svchgpcpgqf ce`svcepgpcpgqfcechw|f|(ofelf(svgpfv|favh%Dvp(|gelfpofwctfdfgen`ftgqf`atimlc|f|pv`gf|( poftf tfmcge| pof svf|pgie ia lie|g|pfelw ce` nfeftchg{cpgie% Ait ge|pcelf(pof hfqfh| ia oi|zgpch aclghgpgf| |fhflpf` qctw atim pftpgctw pi |flie`ctw ce` ztgmctw(ce` pof pgmgen ia pofgt cvpieimiv| |pcpv| qctgf` dfp~ffe 37>6 ce` 377<‐c pgmfncz ia 3? wfct|% Ztf|vmcdhw( chh pof oi|zgpch| oc` `gaaftfep tfc|ie|( mipgqcpgie| ce`tcpgiechf( feivno ait limztg|gen qftw `gqft|f ce` dtic` zctcmfpft|2 gepftech ce`fxpftech( ~gpo tfnct` pi pofgt |g{f( |ptvlpvtf|( |pcnf| ia pof ptce|aitmcpgie ce` locenfztilf||f|( ce` pof fxpfep ia zihgpglg{cpgie ia pof gepftqfepgie% Pof cvpoit| ch|ilielhv`f` pocp pof g||vf ia fsvgpwoc` ‟~it|fef`‗ ge nfeftch(f|zflgchhw ge pof lc|f ia c loctnf it ce geltfc|f ge pof v|ft aff|2 ce` pocp cew lhfct fqg`felf ia gmztiqfmfep|~c| aive` iehw ge pof `fqfhizmfep ia |w|pfm| ait zow|glgce zcwmfep|%Fe|vtgen c acgt cmivep ia faaflpgqfef|| ce` qgcdghgpw gepi pof ztilf||f| ia ge|pgpvpgiech ptce|aitmcpgie g| ch|i c bfw lie|g`ftcpgie ge `f|gnegen cvpieimw%Lihhge| ce` Ntffe /3777' ztizi|f c lhc||gffilcpgie ia oi|zgpch itnceg{cpgiech locenfpi fxcmgef pof lvhpvtch ce` |ilgch feqgtiemfep ge ~oglo pof ztilf||f| ia ptce|gpgiece` locenf livh` df |v|pcgef`% Pof bfw ctfc| pofw g`fepgaw ctf /c' ovmce tf|ivtlfmcecnfmfep‐|pcaa f|pcdhg|omfep( tfltvgpmfep( lie`gpgie| ia |ftqglf( tf~ct`|( ce``g|lgzhgef2 /d' Agecelf‐|vdmg||gie ia i~e dv`nfp( idpcgegen ntcep| ce` hice|(
Lizwtgnop
,
4::1 Kioe ^ghfw ! \ie|( Hp`%
Gep K Ofchpo Zhcee Mnmp 
4::>2
44
; 06“14%@IG; 3:%3::4)ozmOI\ZGPCH CVPIEIMW GE ZCBG\PCE
0>

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->