Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0Activity
P. 1
Contra Max Black: An Examination of Critiques of General Semantics

Contra Max Black: An Examination of Critiques of General Semantics

Ratings: (0)|Views: 14|Likes:
Published by Bruce I. Kodish

More info:

Categories:Types, Reviews, Book
Published by: Bruce I. Kodish on Nov 21, 2012
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

12/04/2012

pdf

text

original

 
?6
Mibir`a Xij`bvchx Oyaaivcb
HKBV_@ J@^ OA@HG
@B I^@JCB@VCKB KE H_CVCPYIX KE MIBI_@A*XIJ@BVCHX
Oryhi C
" Gkfcxn
0
"
Cbvrkfyhvckb
J`bs hrcvcpyix ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx n`ui oiib }rcvvib xcbhi
0388
}nib vni xsxvij }`x |rixibvifos @aerif Gkrtsoxgc cbXhcibhi `bf X`bcvs .X%X#
"
\ncakxk|nir J`~ Oa`hg-x 0363 hrcvcpyi! /Gkrtsoxgc-x Mibir`a Xij`bvchx!/ cb ncx okkg
A`bmy`mi
`bf \ncakxk|ns
4 Xvyfcix Cb Jivnkfn`x `b cj|krv`bv |a`hi cb vncx acvir`vyri .??8*?65#
" Cv cx }cfiasrieirrif vk os kvnir hrcvchx
"
Xhcibhi }rcvir J`rvcb M`rfbir! cb ` 0338 aivvir vk vni ifcvkr cb vni j`m`tcbiXgi|vch`a Cbpycrir!}rcvix
4
_i`firx `ri yrmif vk hnihg vni ecb`a hn`|vir ke J`~ Oa`hg-x
A`bmy`mi `bf \ncakxk|ns
""
"
WGkrtsoxgc-xZ jcxybfirxv`bfcbm ke @rcxvkviac`b akmch! Oa`hg }rcvix! aif ncj cbvk hkybvaixx
`oxyrfcvcix" /Uirs acvvai rij`cbx ke Gkrtsoxgc-x vnikrs ke `oxvr`hvckbx i~hi|v xkji ns|kvnivch`abiyrkakms ekrvcecif }cvn fkmj`vch jiv`|nsxchx"/ Irbixv B`mia! riuci}cbm Oa`hg-x okkg! x`cf
4
/Oa`hg-x rixvr`cbif oyv bkbivniaixx fiu`xv`vcbm hrcvcpyi ke vni o`xch cfi`x kb }nchn Gkrtsoxgcrixvx ncx |rivibvckyx ha`cj cx `akbi }krvn vni |rchi ke vni okkg
"/ .0<5*0<=#Ncxvkrc`b _kxx Iu`bx \`yaxkb! cb ncx 03>8 xvyfs ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx! `axk hkbxcfirx Oa`hg-x }krg/` fiu`xv`vcbm hrcvcpyi/.>=#
"
A`}ribhi ]
" _kxibeciaf! cb ` 03=6 `rvchai! }rcvix /
"
"
"mibir`a xij`bvchx cx eybf`jibv`aas cbcjch`avk nyj`bcxvch xvyfcix
""
" Vni fcxhc|acbi-x akmch`a ekybf`vckbx `ri `fipy`vias hrcvcpyif iaxi}niri .Oa`hg!0363#
""
"/
.083#
"
J`rm`riv Mkrj`b! ` Vnkjcxv |ncakxk|nir `bf ifyh`vkr! cb nir 035? xvyfs ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx`hhi|vx Oa`hg-x hrcvcpyi `x ` /hakxias ri`xkbif |`|ir/ }nchn xnk}x Gkrtsoxgc-x /|rkekybf a`hg keeybfirxv`bfcbm ke }n`v cx `xxirvif cb @rcxvkviac`b akmch
""
" `x }iaa `x vni fceechyavcix `bf hkbeyxckbx cb vni
vnikrs ke `oxvr`hvckb
"
"
"/
.?<#
"
Wb vni mibir`a*xij`bvchx acvir`vyri ` orcie bkvi kb Oa`hg-x hrcvcpyi `||i`rx cb vni ecrxv
Mibir`a
Xij`bvchx Oyaaivcb
ybfir /Okkg Hkjjibvx vk Hkji
"/ Vnkxi hkjjibvx biuir h`ji `bf `x e`r `x Cgbk} kbas Xvy`rv J`s|ir-x `rvchai |yoacxnif cb 035? cb
IVH
!
@
_iuci} ke Mibir`a Xij`bvchx
"
rix|kbfxcb fiv`ca vk `bs ke Oa`hg-x ha`cjx" @ erixn akkg xiijx bihixx`rs xcbhi! `x C-ui bkvif! Oa`hg-x }krghkbvcbyix vk oi rieirrif vk os hrcvchx ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx
" Ce vni ha`cjx ekr Oa`hg-x hrcvcpyi n`ui jircv!
vni u`ayi ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx `x ` xsxvij `||i`rx xirckyxas cb pyixvckb
" Cb vncx |`|ir! C }caa ekhyx kb
Oa`hg-x `rvchai `bf }caa riuci} ncx `bf kvnirx- ha`cjx rim`rfcbm vni vnikrivch`a ekybf`vckbx ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx" C }caa xnk} vn`v `avnkymn ni r`cxix xkji u`acf |kcbvx! ncx `rmyjibvx `||i`r e`r erkj/fiu`xv`vcbm/ `bf rixyav j`cbas erkj ` jcxri`fcbm ke Gkrtsoxgc-x }krg
"
?" Jkri `bf Aixx _ix|kbxcoai Hrcvchcxj
Oa`hg `||i`rx `x kbi ke vni jkri rix|kbxcoai hrcvchx ke Gkrtsoxgc-x }krg" Ybacgi xkji kvnir hrcvchxke mibir`a*xij`bvchx! Oa`hg |rkucfix iucfibhi vn`v ni n`x `hvy`aas xvyfcif! `v ai`xv vk xkji fimrii! vni}krg ni hrcvchctix
"
 
Byjoir 56033=?9
Cb ncx okkg
]krf \a`s
\ivir E`ro! ` acbmycxvch `bvnrk|kakmcxv! |rkucfix ` mkkf i~`j|ai ke `bkvnir
gcbf ke hrcvch
" E`ro hkbxcfirx Gkrtsoxgc mycavs ke /akmk|nkoc`/ `bf ke `fukh`vcbm `ukcfcbm `oxvr`hvckbx.038*036#" Mcuib xyhn ` h`rch`vyri ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx! cv xiijx n`rf vk oiaciui vn`v E`ro okvnirifvk akkg `vXhcibhi `bf X`bcvs
"
Cbfiif vn`v }krg fkix bkv `||i`r cb E`ro-x ocoackmr`|ns
"
Hkbvr`rs vk E`ro! J`~ Oa`hg hkrrihvas |kcbvx kyv
4
Gkrtsoxgc! ekr `aa ncx yrmibv hkbhirb cb |r`hvch`a `ee`crx! cx erii erkj vn`v xnkrv*xcmnvif
l|r`hvch`acxj- }nchn xnk}x cvxiae cb hkbvij|v ekr vnikrs" Ni cbxcxvx r`vnir! cb ` jkxv hkjjibf*
`oai }`s! y|kb vni bihixxcvs ke `b `fipy`vi mibir`a vnikrs `bf `xhrcoix vni fceechyavs ke
cbxvcvyvcbm xij`bvch riekrjx vk vni |riuckyx `oxibhi ke xkybf vnikrivch`a ekybf`vckbx
""
" .??9#$
@evir bkvcbm xkji ke vni ha`cjif vnikrivch`a cj|ach`vckbx ke Gkrtsoxgc-x xsxvij! Oa`hg xv`vix /@bsvnikrs }nchn h`b `hhkj|acxn xk jyhn fixiruix ` rix|ihveya ni`rcbm
"
"
"/.??5#
" Ni `bbkybhix ncx
cbvibvckb vk i~`jcbi /vni u`acfcvs ke cvx Wmibir`a*xij`bvchx-Z vnikrivch`a ekybf`vckbx/ .??9#
"
Cb ncx i~`jcb`vckb ke mibir`a*xij`bvchx vnikrivch`a ekybf`vckbx! Oa`hg `axk `||i`rx hkjjibf`oaserii ke vni vs|i ke `f nkjcbij `rmyjibvx xk `||`ribv cb vni hrcvchcxjx ke xhcibhi }rcvir J`rvcb M`rfbir
"
M`rfbir! }nk n`x }rcvvib `okyv mibir`a*xij`bvchx cbvirjcvvibvas vnrkymnkyv ncx h`riir `x `-fioybgir-! xnk}x mri`v j`xvirs ke }n`v }rcvir J`rvcb J`akbis n`x h`aaif /vni vihnbcpyi ke vnie`xhcb`vcbm crriaiu`bhs/ .?05#" Ekr i~`j|ai! M`rfbir v`gix |`cbx vk ri|i`v ` ri|krv vn`v Gkrtsoxgc/hnkxi vni oycafcbm ekr vni Cbxvcvyvi Wke Mibir`a Xij`bvchx cb Hnch`mkZ! 0?86 I`xv Ecevs*Xc~vn Xvriiv!oih`yxi cvx `ffrixx n`f vni ecrxv xc~ fcmcvx cb byjirch`a krfir/ ./I*\rcji/ ?5?#" M`rfbir vnyx cj|acixvn`v Gkrtsoxgc |r`hvchif byjirkakms" Cb e`hv! Gkrtsoxgc ekybf byjirkakms! ` ekrj ke }krf j`mch!kodihvckb`oai
.X%X ?50#
"
Ni fcf bkv hnkkxi vni oycafcbm kb vni o`xcx ke cvx xvriiv byjoir! }nchn nixcj|as ekybf hyrckyx ./Ockm"/ 8?9#
"
C ecbf cv cbvirixvcbm vk hkj|`ri M`rfbir-x `xxixxjibvke Xhcibhi `bf X`bcvs}cvn vn`v ke Oa`hg
"
M`rfbir hkbxcfirx cv
""
"`
|kkras krm`bctif! uirokxi! |ncakxk|nch`aas b`cui! ri|ivcvckyx jcxn*j`xn ke xkybf cfi`xokrrk}if erkj `oair xhcibvcxvx `bf |ncakxk|nirx! jc~if }cvn bikakmcxjx! hkbeyxif cfi`x!ybhkbxhckyx jiv`|nsxchx! `bf ncmnas fyockyx x|ihya`vckbx `okyv biyrkakms `bf |xshnc`vrchvnir`|s" ./I*\rcji/ ?5?#Oa`hg! kb vni kvnir n`bf! `avnkymn ni j`s `mrii }cvn xkji ke vnixi `xxixxjibvx! ecbfx! vk ncx hrifcv!xkjivncbm ke u`ayi cb vni okkg" Ni }rcvix /@bs ri`fir ke Gkrtsoxgc-x j`dkr }krg!Xhcibhi `bf X`bcvs!jyxv oi cj|rixxif os vni acuiacbixx! ucmkr! `bf erixnbixx ke vni i~|kxcvckb/ .??8#" Hkbvr`xvcbm M`rf*bir-x `xxixxjibv }cvn vncx! C rih`aa Achnviboirm-x x`scbm! /@ okkg cx ` jcrrkr
4 ce `b `xx |iirx cbvk cv! sky
h`b-v i~|ihv `b `|kxvai vk akkg kyv/ .
p
vf
" c
b
Oyrgi 56#
"
8
"
Oa`hg-x HrcvcpyiOa`hg fcucfix ncx hn`|vir cbvk vnrii xihvckbx" Ecrxv ni fcxhyxxix Gkrtsoxgc-x `cjx `bf `||rk`hn
"
Xihkbf! ni ekhyxix kb Gkrtsoxgc-x uci} ke `rcxvkviac`bcxj" Vncrf! ni i~`jcbix Gkrtsoxgc-x vnikrs ke`oxvr`hvckb" C }caa riuci} Oa`hg-x `rmyjibvx `||rk~cj`vias cb vni krfir cb }nchn ni |rixibvx vnij
"
"
Ybaixx kvnir}cxi x|ihcecif `aa rieiribhix vk Oa`hg }caa oi
vk
A`bmy`mi `bf \ncakxk|ns
"
 
?5
Mibir`a Xij`bvchx Oyaaivcb
8
"0
Gkrtsoxgc-x @cjx `bf @||rk`hn
Oa`hg oimcbx os |kcbvcbm kyv vn`v |rkoaijx }cvn vni cb`fipy`hs ke a`bmy`mi n`ui oiib bkvif `bf`vvij|vx vk cj|rkui cv n`ui oiib j`fi ekr hibvyrcix" Gkrtsoxgc cx kbi `jkbm j`bs vncbgirx cb vncx`ri`! xij`bvchx! }nchn Oa`hg hn`r`hvirctix `x /vni xhcibhi ke ji`bcbm/ .??8#
"
@hhkrfcbm vk Oa`hg! Gkrtsoxgc-x /|k|ya`r/
/Mibir`a
Xij`bvchx/ `||i`rx `x ` gcbf ke mibir`actifxij`bvchx kr xvyfs ke acbmycxvch ji`bcbm }nchn `cjx vk}`rf vni cj|rkuijibv ke /acbmycxvch j`a`fdyxv*jibv/ .??6#" @hhkrfcbm vk Oa`hg! Gkrtsoxgc ha`cjx vn`v ncx xsxvij |rkucfix /ri*ifyh`vckb cb oivvirjibv`a `bf acbmycxvch n`ocvx/ .??6# kr /acbmycxvch vnir`|s/ .??9#" Oa`hg xv`vix! /X}ii|cbm ha`cjx ke vni
oibiechc`a xij`bvch vri`vjibv n`ui oiib j`fi
7 oyv vni f`v` `ri `x siv cbxyeechcibv ekr ` ecb`aiu`ay`vckb/ .??9#
"
Gkrtsoxgc-x `||rk`hn vk /ji`bcbm!/ `hhkrfcbm vk Oa`hg! cx hn`r`hvirctif os ncx `vvij|v /vk j`gimibir`a xij`bvchx ` xhcibvcech fcxhc|acbi/ .??5#" Ni jibvckbx Gkrtsoxgc-x fi|ibfibhi kb vni rixyavxke xhcibvcech rixi`rhn `bf ke ncx hkbhirb vk xhcibvcech`aas vixv ncx k}b vnikrcix
"
Cb vncx rim`rf Oa`hg bkvix vni /k|ir`vckb`a!/ /|nsxckakmch`a/ hn`r`hvir keGkrtsoxgc-x ekrjya`vckbx
"
@x Oa`hg xv`vix
4
Vni cj|krv`bv fihcxckb cx bk} j`fi vk yxi |nsxckakmch`a hrcvirc` ke ji`bcbm!
c"i
"!
vk vixv
xv`vijibvx `okyv ji`bcbmx os koxiru`vckbx ke }n`v cx gbk}b kr `xxyjif vk oi n`||ibcbm cb vni
birukyx xsxvij ke ` ockakmch`a krm`bcxj
" Vncx hnkchi ke |rkhifyri mcuix ` fcxvcbhvcui xa`bv vkGkrtsoxgc-x cbuixvcm`vckbx! ekr ni cx! cb ncx k}b }krfx! j`cbas cbvirixvif cb /vni biyrkakmch`a
`vvcvyfi vk}`rf lji`bcbm-"/ Cv ekaak}x vn`v kbi ke vni jkxv cj|krv`bv `bf o`xch bkvckbx kemibir`a xij`bvchx }caa oi vn`v ke vni birukyx rix|kbxi j`fi os `b krm`bcxj vk ` xvcjyayxhkbxcxvcbm ke xsjokax" .??=#Vncx rix|kbxi vk xsjokax cx! `hhkrfcbm vk Oa`hg! }n`v Gkrtsoxgc cbvibfx os vni virj! /xij`bvchri`hvckb/ .??=#
"
Oa`hg-x hn`r`hvirct`vckb keGkrtsoxgc-x hkbhirb ekr vnikrs `bf |r`hvchi! ke ncx xhcibvcech `x|cr`vckbx`bf biyrkakmch`a /xa`bv/ xiij mibir`aas `hhyr`vi" Nk}iuir hirv`cb fiv`cax biif hkrrihvckb
"
Oa`hg cbhkrrihvas uci}x mibir`a*xij`bvchx `x ` ekrj ke xij`bvchx }nchn ekhyxix kb acbmycxvchlji`bcbm-" Iuib xkji lxy||krvirx- ke Gkrtsoxgc-x }krg! xyhn `x X
" C
" N`s`g`}`! n`ui fkbi xcjca`ras
"
Nk}iuir kvnirx! xyhn `x Xvy`rv J`s|ir! n`ui }rcvvib `okyv vni hkbeyxckb vncx uci} n`x h`yxif
"
Cbfiif! Jr
s|ir n`x xymmixvif vn`v kbi ke Gkrtsoxgc-x j`dkr irrkrx }`x a`oiacbm ncx xsxvij /mibir`axij`bvchx"/ Vk ij|n`xcti cv `x ` xi|`r`vi `bf fcxvcbhv fcxhc|acbi vn`v mkix oiskbf xij`bvchx! J`s|irn`x xymmixvif ns|nib`vcbm vni virj `x /mibir`a*xij`bvchx/ ./Ifcvkrc`a/ ?<#" 0 ekaak} ncx xymmixvckb cbjs }rcvcbm
"
Gkrtsoxgc `cjif vk oycaf ` ekybf`vckb ekr ` /xhcibhi ke j`b Wnyj`bcvsZ"/ Ni ekrjya`vif mibir`a*xij`bvchx `x ` mibir`a vnikrs ke iu`ay`vckb" Ncx yxi ke vni virj /xij`bvch/ cb /xij`bvch ri`hvckb!//xij`bvch oakhg`mix!/ ivh" xiijx xsbkbsjkyx }cvn /iu`ay`vckb`a
"/
Iu`ay`vckb`a kr xij`bvch ri`hvckbx ekr Gkrtsoxgc cbukaui biyrkakmch`aas*o`xif! krm`bcxj*`x*`*}nkai*cb*`b*ibucrkbjibv rix|kbxixbkv kbas!`x Oa`hg `xxirvx! vk }krfx `bf kvnir xsjokax oyv vk
`bs
iuibvx cb virjx ke vnicr lji`bcbmx-! xcmbcech`bhi! ivh
"
lJi`bcbm- kr xcmbcech`bhi cb vncx xibxi cx bkv jirias acbmycxvch" Xij`bvch ri`hvckbx `x lji`bcbm-ri`hvckbx cbukaui /n`||ibcbm*ji`bcbmx/ `x mibir`a*xij`bvchcxv D
" X
" Okcx n`x h`aaif vnij.65#
"
@x

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->