The Greenland Investigation

Sergeant Joseph M. Ebert New Hampshire State Police Major Crime Unit

Law Enforcement at 517 Post Road (Initial Response)

Drug Task Force

Detective Detective Detective Detective Detective Detective

Scott Kukesh (Newmarket) Jeremiah Murphy (Rochester) Eric Kulberg (UNH) Greg Turner (Dover) Dev Atma Khalsa (Dover) Christopher Thurlow (Newton)

Law Enforcement at 517 Post Road (Initial Response)

Greenland Police Department

Chief Michael Maloney Officer Wayne Young Officer David LoConte

In the immediate area: Officer Theodore Hartmann

Timeline (Approx.)

1822: 1822: 1825: 1832: 1837: 1857: 1906: 2008: 0429:

260 signs off with DTF Shots fired officers down Two officers en route to PRH 260 hit and unresponsive Subject barricaded in basement Atty. Jeffco advises he can arrange surrender 260 loaded into Bearcat Text from Tibbetts intended for her mother All non-state police units clear

DTF Evacuation

1st Evac: Kukesh and Turner by Hartmann 2nd Evac: Murphy and Kulberg by Law

Firearms

.357 and 9mm only firearms in residence .357 purchased by Tibbetts at Manchester Gun Show (Purchased with .380, not recovered) 9mm purchased by Mutries father, Charles, in 1989

Shots Fired

4 Rounds expended from .357 (1 live round recovered)

JME-1 (Murphy) & MGB-76 (Volks) .357 rounds

Numerous rounds returned from Law Enforcement 4 Rounds from 9 mm

1 Round hit Tibbetts consistent with 9 mm 2 Rounds out basement window (1 Struck Chief Maloney) 1 Round used in Mutrie suicide

Who Shot Who and How Do We Know

DTF: statements that Mutrie in doorway shooting at Detectives Chief Maloney: statement by Mutrie that hed shot 2 officers, height of shot from basement window & Mutrie is in possession of 9mm at the time of his death Tibbetts: shot left to right at a downward angle

Dog leash on left hand, left hand braced on floor

Mutrie: left to right, contact wound and 9 mm in lap

Mutrie scuff mark inside right forearm, consistent with bullet

Residence Security

Camera on porch

No evidence of recordings and or surveillance software on computers

Narcotics/Money in Residence

Cocaine (27.46 grams) Anabolic steroids (3 vials) Marijuana (5.78 grams) Mushrooms (7.79 grams) No narcotics in vehicles Approx. $14,000 cash found on Tibbetts

Majority in bra

Last Known Contact

Phone call by Mutrie to Shane Bateman:

Shane said that he had spoken to Mutrie after the shooting and Mutrie admitted that he shot two cops and that he may have killed them. Mutrie also made statements indicating that he was not going to come out of the residence.
I love u too so much. More than Ill ever know we didnt do anything wrong!! I love u and dad and Linds and gram and gramps soooo much!!! Diesel will need you!!! Ok take care of him!!!!! Im so sorry!!! Good bye!!! 517 post rd Greenland. Take Whiskey too bye mom I love you soooo much!!!!!!!

Text sent from Tibbetts phone:

Mutrie/Tibbetts Toxicology
Mutrie
Mutrie had evidence of narcotics, opiates, marijuana and anabolic steroids in his system at the time of autopsy

Tibbetts
Tibbetts had evidence of narcotics, opiates and marijuana in her system at the time of autopsy