Case 2:12-cv-02997-MCE-DAD Document 20 Filed 12/26/12 Page 1 of 3

Ao 88 (Rev 07/10) suhpcna

ro

Apn{rrdd l!{n} drllclniEdrlnd Ln.civllAcion

UNITgo STATES DISTRICT COURT

for ihe

Grinols et al

Obama et al

SUBPOENA TO APPCAR AND TESTIFY AT A HEARING OR TRIAL IN A CIVIL ACTION

To:

lvlichael Astrue, commissioner of Social Securitv adminisltion

YOU ARE COMMANDED !o appear in thc tjnhcd Stares districtcourtar thetime. date, and placeset forth bclow lotestiry at a hearing or trial in this civilaction. Whenyou arrive, you must remain al lhe coun until thejudgeora court
officer allorvs vou to leave-

Morrison

c.

Engtand

You musl also bring wjth you the following documenls. lectronica'ly stored information, or objecls /r/a,t i/,or
1. originalSS-5 appl;cation for CT SocialSecurity number xxx-xx*4425 whjch Earack Obama used on his 2009lax returns, but which was nol assigned to Barack Obama acco.ding to E-Verifyand SSNVS 2. Evidence of any actions taken by your to apprize lhe law enforcmenl and the L,.S- Congress prior to January 6 2013 joint session Presidential confirmation ofObama's use ofa SSN from a state, where he never resided and whjch was never assigned to him

R-

122412012

Dare:

of
('LERK OF COLIRT

The provisions ofFed. R. Civ. P.45(c). relat;ng 1o your protection as a pe6on subjcd lo a subpoena, and Fed. C;v. P.45 (d) and (e), relating to yourduty to respond to this subpoena and the potential consequences ofnol dojng

nd

iign-n*,,ttu,i,

ie

The name. address. e-mail, and lelephone number ofthe attomey represenii

Fr

Law olUces of Orly Tailz 29839 Santa Ma.garita, ste 100 Rancho Sania Margarila, CA 92688 ph. 949{83-541 1 fax 949-766-7688 orly.tailz@gmail.com

Th eF og bo w. co m
Districr ofColumb;a

) )

C;!ilAdionNo.

2:12 02997 USDC EDCA

) )

Date and lirne: 6176372313 2 66 orn

oR
a"p,t,

(1",*
^g
lnoue
oJ

"l:1 ;*.*" il'*l

pdn!)
Plainliffs Ginols t al

, who issue! or rcquests this subpoena, are:

Case 2:12-cv-02997-MCE-DAD Document 20 Filed 12/26/12 Page 2 of 3

Ao 8* (Rd.07l10)

suq4d b

Appe{ rdj T.stify .r

. I lding

or

Trirl

in a

civil Actid

(pgc 2)

Civil Acrion No. 2:12-02997 USDC EDCA

This subpona for

f-*,/itulNid@l

was received by me on a/a,c)

I s"*ed the subpoena by delivering a copy to the named person as

Michael Astrue, commissioner of Social Secudty

c./o U.S. Attorney 555 4thstr. Washington DC

f,

I retumed the subpoena unexecuted because:

Unless the subpoena was issud on bhalfofthe United States. or one ofits officers or agents, I have also lendered to the witness fees forone day's attendance. and the mileage allowed by la\r, in the amount of

$
My
fees ar

7s3.20

$ 7t ) i

I declare under penalty olpedury rhat this information is true.

Date:

1212412012

Additional information regarding attempted seNice, etc:

Fr

ie

nd

of

Th eF og bo w. co m
dtu! title,

PROOFOF SERVICE (This section should not befiled with the coun unless rcquiftd b! Fed- R Civ- P.15.)

ila"y)

MichaelAstue

fbllows:

served through FodEx

20530

on

d.k)

1212412012

; or

for traveland $

lor services, for a total

of$

0.00

4,L

Pinted |onte ond title

29839 Sanla l\rargadta ste 100 Rancho Santa Margarita, Ca 92688

Case 2:12-cv-02997-MCE-DAD Document 20 Filed 12/26/12 Page 3 of 3

O

38 lRev r,6109) SubpocN b

.4openr !nd

Tenili

ar

ltDanns or

Tiat

in u

CivtLA.ri{in toase 3)

Fedcral Rulc ofCivil Procedure 45 (c), (d), and (e) (Eficctivc l2ll/07)

tor a dcposirion. heffirs. or ni l. (B) orl..rn ,r. A pcsotr commmded to poduGd.cuftnrsor langiblc things or to pcrmit inspcction may senc on thc puty or altomel designated in fi. subpcna a rrrn(.D obic.rion to inspcctinS- copving. tesrirg or srmpling dy or clloltl1c matcrialsor b inspocling rhepNrhises orro ptuducints elccrronicallr. skrrcd in lomation in the lbnn or ibnnr rcqLoded. I he obiectim musL bc scrvcd beforc rhe.arlierol the timc\pccilled forcompliancc or dr)sallcr th subpoena is sedcd. Il0n objcctnrn h nrdd.rhe lbllo$ ins rulci appb: (i) Atan) time. on noli to the coDnnndcd pe6on. the scrving p!n) ma) more thc issuinScou( lbrm or.lcr compclling pruduclion

lhe

orlicer lrcnr sien

1A) tt'her lteguipd On tnclr" motion- thc i!$ir-q cotrn nrusl qursh ormodil) a subpocna lhat: (i) liilstoallo\v a reasonablc ri'ne ro q,mpl!: (ii) rcquircs a pcrson sho is rEilhera pany norapany-solficcr lo tmle I morc dlan I 00 miles liom $he thal pc$on rcsids. is cmplotcd. or rcgularly ttunsacls b sincss in person-cxcept rhal, subiecl ro Rule lilc)(l)(llXiii). thepcMn nray bc conrmddd to altcnd otridlby tr rcling l-rcn rny$r.h pln.e \rirhii rhc n!r. rrhdB

ilicei e\pcrs esuking lrom 6) SaNtiiE ot Modifiit'8 nSabpo.aL

(ii) Ihe$.cts ma) b. requircd onll adiectcd in thc order and odcrmusr prot0lLa pcrson $ho h nenhcr a farty nor a pan! s
compliance.

of

no

(iii) requiles d isclo$rc ofprililcged or oth.r prot.cted mauer. exccplior of {ailerapPlie!: or (iv) subjccts a p$son lo lndue burden.

Fr

(A, |l'he, P.trli ul. ptotecl a person \ubjcot to or afl-cctcd bl asubpocna. tlic issuing courl nra). on motion. quash or modilv lhc subpoc a ilil rcquircs: (i) disclosine arad. s.crcro.orhcr con udcnrial rcsca(h. dclelopmenl. or conrmercial inlb nario.: (ii) disclosine!n unrctaincd exnen_soninion or inrbmation rhat does nol describe spccilic occunlccs in dispu$ and rcsuxs liolr rhe erpcn s srud! that {ns nor r.qucslcd b) . pant: or nor a pary's olllcdrto incur {iii) a prson who is 'rcilherapan)_ subshntialexpl'nse Io lRvclmorc lhnn 100 miles lo ancnd rial. \\ aB t -oLJh tor\ /, ln rhe cir. -mjan*r tt dcscrib(d in Rulc 45(cxl )(B), lhe coln md\. insread ofquashing or hdiiying a subpocna ordcr appealunce or prcduction undcr specificd condift,ns ifthc snine pan): (i) sho$s a $'bstdtialncld lorrlt teslimon) rlcriallhar cannol bc othe$ i* net rlitho undoe hardship: and

li

nd

ie

),

Jt,,,,t

(ii) cnsurus thrl the $rbpocnaed lcson will hc rcasonably

Th eF og bo w. co m
(A) Do.deals A pison Fspording to a subpoena to poducc documenls must produce lhed as they are kcfl in the odinary 0ou.se of busincss or nust organirc md labcllhem to corcspond ro rhe caLegorics in lhc dem rd. lB) l:onn

(c) Prote(ting, Pffson Subj.cr ro r Subpoena. n\ at llt Aroidittg Undae Bunlen or E penst; Saactiots. attome) Fsponsiblc fo.issuing and scNing asubpcna^p rake musl rcasonable stcps 10 aloid inposing undue burdcn orerl1lnr on a ru6on subjccr lo ftc subpoena. The issdr8.ourt mun cnforccthis duLr and inposc an approprialc sanctir)n- qhich nay includc losl camir8s Dd rcasonnble afiome) s laes on apiry oranonrc! {l,. ldrl. ro.umrrl!. \2) Connanl to P.ottuce MaknaLs o. Pe.nit lnspectiol (AJ,1ppeatunce Not Req,ircl A peson coimandcd to pruducc documctrls clcclrcnicall) slo.cd inioflnalnD orr{ngiblc lhinrs. or (, Fnnitthe i$speclion olprcnlises. seed nor dtpear in pcN)n aldr place olprcduclion orinspeclion unlcssaho commddcd to appear

(d) Duti.s in Res0ondi.g to a Sobpo.nr. (l) I'ronucittg DoMDp ot Electtu^ico ! Slot.tl LtJbthtlion. These pocedL'esappl) $ ^ prudrcing d@uments or clectronicalh

,s/"crrsd Ila

trt

Pt rlnci'rS Elettturica Sbp.l l fotrt\tion .\:or sLrbpocnadocs nol spccjly a li)nn lbr producing

.lcclronicalll slorcd inlornulio .lhe pc6on rcsponding mun pftrdu$ it in d lorn or ibmrs in $hich it is ordindil! mrnrlanr.d oi i! 1
rcnsonnbl)" usoble

fom or lorms.

The pc$on rcsponding nccd nor pruduccrhc inlbrm lion in norc than one forn1-

lc) Elc.bo icdt0

Stotpti |hjamdrion

Prcdu.alinOtt On. I,orh.

smc electronicalll storcd

ll

lDl kaccessible l:tecttunicd r Stot".t L{bttutio" the pcnlrn rcspordirSrced not providc discovery of clectrunlcall) srorcd infomalion iiom elms thar $c pe.son id.rtiilcsas nol rea$nabl) aeccssiblc becduse olondue buden orcosl. On motion to comp.l dis.olcn or lbr a proleclivc orden the pe6on respondinemun shd$ thal $e inibrnrarion is not Fasonabl) accssible becauseofundue burden dr@sr. Iffal sho\ ina is made. thceurl ina,\ nonethcless ordcrdiscovcry from such lources iithe requcsting pan) shows eood caus- considerine lhc limilations of Rule 26( b)(2 )(C). t he couft rul spccify condilions fo. thc discoverl. (2) CIairtry Priilege ot P te.tion. (Al htf.nhdtion lyithheld A pcrson sithholding subpocnrcd inibmalion ur)dera claim that it is pri!ile8cd orsubjed to protecLio)
(i) e\prcsslr makc rhc.laim:

a\ trial-Preparalion matcrill must:

sd

the nature olrhc wnhhrld docum.irs. or tangiblc thiDSs in a mannerlhat. Nilhodl rcrealiDs

co'nnuniclrbns_ irnbmation ilrclfprivilegcd or prolecrcd. $illcnabl.lhc panicslo assess lhe

(ii) d.s..ibc

iI

lA) laJomdtian Prcduce.l.ll inlomation produced in esponse lo a subpoena is subjecl to aclaim ol pri!ilege orofpRnection as hialpRparalio, lurerial. the pcren mdki.re thcclaim may notirj an) pan) fislreceived llc ir lbrmalion ol lhe cl0im and the basis lor it. Aner bcine nolified. dpanr must pornplly rctum, $quesrcr. or dcslrof lhe spccilied inlomatnD dd uny copies iLbas: nrud rot usc or dis.lo$ lhc infomration unlilthcclaim is resolvcd: mun lakc reasonablc slepsto retriele the inlonlatior iftJrc paJn'discbsed it bcloe hcing nolificd: and may prcnptll prcscnr thc iniormtionlo th6 court under scalfor0 deicnninalion olrhe claim. I}e pcrsn $ho

prcduccd lhe infomalion mu$

pesNe

thc iDlbmralion untiltheclaim

/n/

(c) coninpl.Thc issunrg cou( may hold i'l contcdpr a person *hohaving ben *fted. flih \rilhout adeqoarc crcu$ lo obq lhc subpoena. A nonpa y s hilurc to obcy nusl be cxcused ifthc subpoena purports () rcquire th nonpmr-.. to allcM or producc al a place dLuside the limi$ o I Rule 45(c X3 ){A )( ii).

o.