Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ah
cyf yha j
k
hj
j
RM 3.00
3.00 December
December 2012
2012
RM
jafj thJf!
myh TWwh:
... nkY, mtnd j moikf
ghtk nfhifia VW
bfhwh. nkY, mtf
Fwfis bghWjUSwh.
D cf braf midij
eF mwh
(UFM 42 : 25)
Yayasan Ubaidi
org 2012
jiyaf
w fLiu
br
Kf fLiu
28 tjh a mjhJ
34 FwrhL
Kf gafuthfsh?
37 xL
kid fhj!
ujk jhL br
FHij ts
10 v igaid V bfhwhf?
38 mR taR R
12 dbt
dbt bfhifF nua
42 ntL bgUbrt!
brhd fij!
jid
kf Mju!
Mnuha
ciuR
13 jtwhd v!
trj
17 trjK m eruK!
j
22 bdhU K ehLl
nghuh? jf ntL xghkh!
25 ey mgt ah?
tha 15
47 ujij RfF
mUf!
48 brf
#dh[h g!
51 Wfij
nrhW fzF!
jid 23
56 cuj
oF thR!
ahghuF ah?
mikaw cy...
j khj tKiw vjHhf totikJnsh. mik
HJ jF cy jyhj, ril, rruyhj fhthf ekJ
mika ntLbkgnj e xbthUt vz. JUia ML
tU jp vnlhfid gjh Kf fLiu ngRwJ.
flj U khjfshf j jhkjkhf ilUF. mr
Jiwd bjhEg nkghL gdh mr nahf jhkjkh
tUwJ. j khjK mgojh UF vW mryf caufh
bjJsh. thrff bghWjUSkhW nfhUnwh.
mf
et Ukzf kiwJLnkh...!
mHa yha Ukzf W mtyrzfsh tUwd. mF
R F R W eik ekJ khfij nf bghUsh tU
ekJ Ukz ffis ghJ kd ntjid milwJ. jiyaf TW
et Ukzf kiwJL ngh bjwJ.
cJkh f,
bkj#h.
nkhnuh Kf nghuhl!
nkhnuh Kf l fhy nghuhlF ey gy isJsJ.
knyah KaF iwt eT tHFth. UtUilna rkhjh
d brJ itgJ vgJ vyh mwfY wjJ vW ef ehaf ([)
mtf Tshf. mj eik knyah eLtfSF ilFkhf.
Ah mJ AJ
nfhyhy.
jfhUF jf UJ!
j j f wghf UjJ. mP lnjh$ ghYF UJ iljJ
kia jjJ. jfhUF jf UJ vd vz njhaJ. mPf
n mfh KAkJ, & fLiu ey g. D gy fhukhd
fUJfis bjhlJ ju. uh#& A[ ngr brhwh. ng ngna
W r_f ndh ngh bfhoUwJ. mt ngr brhd il
ntW. W e isa r_f miyng mstsh bfhoUgJ ntW
gh. ik Rjh 9 tf ebrW kd gjJ. D gy
tfisfhodh r_fF gydF. b#ankhf, fij
bjhlia fhz Mt. bjhluL eif a g.
#~gUyh ukh,
f.
nkhuh Kf nghuhl!
nkhnuh Kf gy MLfshf nghuho tUwhf. mtfsJ nghuhl
nghfiy. ig muR mtfSFa kahijia bfhLJ
Rah tHf tjjF ghuhl ntL. njnghw iyik yif
jH thlfY ah fhZ kyUjh vgo UUF.
ahU Twhj gy afis eif jJ tUwJ.
guf m dh
Ftjh.
2 eif org 2 0 1 2
mf
iweifahsf bt bgWld
ky : 16
j : 12/185
w fLiu
(brw j bjhl)
W gik r_f vD
fUbghU FJ gutyhf
ngrgLwJ. gy dfis rhj
xU r_f vthW jkF L
bfhLgJl Jz mogil
elJbfhs ntL vW
fyJiuahlgLwJ. jF f wj
KDjhuzkhf kdh r_f saJ.
kdh thj jfSl eatf
clgoif xiw brJ mtf gugu
flikf, cikfis tiuaWw xU
rhrdij cUthFwhf. mJjh kdh
rhrd.
Jnt Kf tuyh
Kjyhtjhf vGjgl mua rhrd.
KAhf, m[hfilyhd cw,
Fghf jfSldhd cw vthW mika
ntL. mtf kj Rju, jJt
vthW ghJfhfgl ntL nghw midJ
cikfis ng kdh rhrd
cUthfglJ.
tuyhW jtW
.. 1789M ML eilbgw buR
uF djh kj cikf ga
jid wjjhf mjdoahfnt 1948M
rnfhjuJt fLkhd
{uF eilbgw ffis
nehFwnghJ e ([) mtf jh fo
vGg Ua <kha r_fJF f
6 eif org 2 0 1 2
w fLiu
ww
J
J
z
z
c
c
F
ff
eekkF
_
u
r
u
r
{
h
{
h
d
d
F..
MF
gghhll kk nffhh M
J
ahhJ
ffLLn F
yya
d
d
i
i
h
h
F
a
a
W
W
cW
c
cW
Jc
m
llnnjjhh
mJ
g
g
z
z
U
iuu nngg kkhhbbggU
ti
Wt
W
vv
h
h
yy
yy
uu
c
c
i
i
f
t
f
t
h
h
W
W
a
a
m
m
rr
J..
wwJ
U
U
J
J
y
y
i
jji
bjhF: b# m
eif org 2 0 1 2 7
br
vI '
' .
e G .
vL
A H p
. J
OJ
. v
A
J O
M
.
' Ux
F 'vLO
F'
. J
J P
M.
'K K J
H ' '
M.
vLO
'F'
G MJA
P. O
HO
P
A P
H, HLdC vI
O H
PH.
IK G
C J C
A.
A A
M AA. Ux
IP G H
P H, CM G
F F
.
A
F
W
. M vb
F E OJ
CM ,
vI P MJ
.
UxF vI
p, F
yM W C A
.
eif org 2 0 1 2 9
ghTuh
... ..?
.. .
M
H vb
H, M i
J
Q
H
G H PM
.
J
FA. C,
E O
A v
A A . F
LA.
' M
A K iC?'
M F A
a. ' .. M
10 eif org 2 0 1 2
...'
K
J vL K
A .
JK. O F 83
I .
JK A
.
' P I
A' vL
FK .
J L
O v
vI T .
M F bM
A O .
Q i
AM vL
v, L FK
. O
O G
A M FK
. FA (19-11-12)
i FJ Hv
LJ .
M
KM 16
M
A. .
M, , , K,
H L
M.
CP a
F A. 'vL
A. A,
J'
C FK
F M. G
M
A .
Lv i, K L
A A .
'
, H
, ,
, ,
H
M'
A . F
?
eif org 2 0 1 2 11
dbt
KAkJ bes~g eh
C vL
H
, P
vb F
K.
F
O
KM.
P A
K
PH. 47M
O K
F P,vb
KF
P. 23
vL Haartez FK F
H O
P OF.
vL J
A 20M K
vL vb
.
PCJ
O Q
I F M
I.
503K
59M O
F
F , M
A. O
F O
KM
CK o A.
12 eif org 2 0 1 2
IH M
,
O M H
K G
A. F
H vL
Q K F
KM . ,
F, KJ G O
vL ,
.
vL
P P
M KM, F AA I
C
P A. O
P
A.
H
K 70M
J 25 vb
MM
vb H M
A. vLO
OA 'v'
FK A M,
O
vL
J I
P O
M A.
M
M K v
A 'F '
FK.
ciuR
fnfh mJ ukh
CJ
E CA
' ! ?
c AF
F J
CA A
C M
C M
Q '
a
M A
KO H,
H
?
F M Q
?
E
i O FK
A?
H F
J I
Q F
M?
O c A?
..
c
c
c
c
c
c
?
F P ?
?
C ?
?
O ?
K i b?
?
H?
? ?
?
b FK
K ?
M ?
?
A?
HJ
H
A?
A !
! i
i !
E
FJ L
P I
M?
F c A?
F c A?
C A
c U? vL?
? q ?
K A?
H?
' ' F
A.
eif org 2 0 1 2 13
trj
ugr
ugr
trj
ef ehaf
ehaf ([)
([)
ef
mtf foa
foa ehff
ehff
mtf
nfhilia,
nfhilia,
Ugnahuh
Ugnahuh
whoY
whoY
Inuha, Ma
Ma ehLf
ehLf
Inuha,
oJ jiukl
jiukl
oJ
Mfnt KaW
KaW
Mfnt
bfhoUwd.
bfhoUwd.
nguhir, j muRikF jil VgLw
Niy, muRik f, khd Fiw
VgLgo w elJ bfhSj, mur bg
bfhLf kWw nghJ - vW y fhuzfis
fhLwh mP ahdj. (jH rh,
gh iya) giHa (J) rKjha nghf
eilbgwjfhd y csa fhuzfis
mP uhkru j (War in Ancient India,
Madras University) RLwh. 1. rh r_f
f nghiu bjhyhf bgwtf
kdiy 2. nghbjh yhk, Rkh Uf
Koahj kdiy. 3. u braf ehl. 4.
cl . 5. jfh vz. 6. nfhgK bghwhik. 7. w nk MSif brYJ nehf.
gHj nghKiw, khL og
bjhlaJ. ngh bra U mur, v
ehL mur khL kijifis ifg
bfhL tUt ngh bjhlF. kijfis
L tUtJ j flik uK vW N
ciuJ sth. jHfSF ngh f
Ujd. cyf kw nghKiw mit.
mw mogilahf, kj mogilahf sa mwbef mit.
M Ma ghgd khfY
bgoU, ilpU, ng
bjy the fUfl DF
bghngh jt bgwhU...
ghJfhghd lJF brW
nrJLf vW mJ nl nghiu
bjhldhf jHf. ngh vW mJ
yf Koahj gRf, ghtJFa ghgh,
bgf, nehahf, FHij yhj Mf
MnahUF rYif tHaJ muR.
ghJfh f mHfhfjh Ujd.
vD it gygldth vwh iy.
rfy ehfffS, KiwfS brj
wFjhnd, ngh bjhlFwJ. ngh xU
fl, Ciu bfhSJ mehffK,
18 eif org 2 0 1 2
trj
eif org 2 0 1 2 19
RAhdh
K F L
e PM .
O I Q
K MF
P. MO
10 I Q 'F'
HA. F
P M F N
O
A.
F F
vL F
AM H
.
A K
AM .
K 3 vL
F .
J KL
N G
K K
M .
(Global Affairs)e C C
J F M 67M
K F G
22 eif org 2 0 1 2
P.
K F F
A M 69%
A.
Q K
MF K
71% K
LA.
F F
A. K
Q
A
J AA v.
v
G G K.
M A. KM
M G .
G
M .
GF O
P G v, vb
MA. w, Y O
F OA.
A. v
A.
j
F A.
F M
A. I
L AC E
G A. C
P
G A.
F M
EM.
M
F K
F
AOH A .
M
A H vbL F
K H
K
A KM.
vL
F FAA
, A A
KM ,
C
F A G.
F F
A A. v-vb
L
FK
.
.
F M
K FK
MA.
O F
C .
C F I
A. ' ,
, '
gFJ
. F
GQ E Y K M.
E
KM.
Q
J.
M. K O
iF, E
, Q
GI, y F
.
K J
A
M. H
HKM . F
.
OI
? C F
FM. 20%Q
.Q K
FO. v F
G. v
UvM , CK
e H,
K
? F
? .
H P
F .
N
N.
OH bM
,
N,
Q
gFJ FA F .
e K E
M.
eif org 2 0 1 2 23
tha 15
uh#] A[
tha 15
nflh.
mjF eh, ntjidia jh
bfhnw. bghWikia nkbfhnw
vW g mnj. clnd, mz e ([)
mtf, j tia jh bfhL f
bghWikahf Ugjh myh cfSF
Rtdij mwh vW Tdhf.
mJkLky, t myJ neh Jg
mfkhf UF l jkJ tyifia
itJ tUkhW uhghf:
iwth@ j tia nghFthahf.
kjfSila mgna! tUF cl eyij
tHFthahf. na ey tHFgtdhf
Uwh. cid ju ntW vtU ey
mghf vD eif iy. tUF
neh mFna yhJ nghF tif ey
mghahf!
nehahia ey rhgjhf brh
bfhL tstsbtd ng bfhoUgijnah,
mtUila XF mikF ilW
VwgLJtijnah mzyh jLJshf.
nehahl mf neu mkuhk
UgJ, rjK TrY nghlhk UgJ
etahF vd mJyh D mgh
(u) vD e njhH TWwh.
K myhj xUt
nehthgoUjh mtiu brW rJ
MWj Tw ntL vgJ yh fW jU
ca gghlhF.
j Wt xUt mz e ([)
mtfl g J bfhoUjh. xUeh
mt nehthgL lh. ntiyfhu
Wtjhnd vW mzyh
myagLjiy. mj Wt L
njo brW, mtid ey rhJ, mtDila
Kf fLiu
v. v
J PJ
A e K
v
P P P.
vL J W
C F
GH
i P MM,
F C K
H A A,
A .
H
G
J P, , i
E v
HK N EA
OL AM
1500 vI H
28 eif org 2 0 1 2
A. J
A M
A I
M A.
Q LHM
H
vL
K A.
KJ
A. K f
AJ H
Q
L F P
A.
AKP 'F
vI cF ' CJ
Av P E
Q.
Kf fLiu
2002 C
G A,
,
A .
F
FA,
G GM .
CK , ,
Fw H b
A
PHA.
C A Q
I,
M. vL
F
i C F,
vL
FA. L
50M H C
KM .
A
A .
FK
A A CJ
(CHP) A K.
A
IP A
. 'QQ N
AA'
'IL' FK
bM M K ,
A, CJ Av
QQ F , AJ
GA A.
H
H Q
eif org 2 0 1 2 29
Kf fLiu
, '
FK A,
OK, I C GA
A. F H
E, L K
M EA
A.
C F
,
A, A
FA,
A.
F A H
FF , i
AJ F
M. H
Q C, Q M
A F.
M M
8 A IP
A.
F
A M. H K
M GJ
H
C A.
C AH F
A
.
30 eif org 2 0 1 2
A
F AA
P
CO.
A
mC
'q'
A.
CK
F A.
Y F
-
GK Q
.
M M
M Y .
MJ c
FHA v
G . CK
H F I.
M, CK c c
.
I vL HEJL
I C P
'C' v
. M
vI OJ M
. N
, H bM C
1994 v
.F vI
CJ H,
P M
CP C .
2001 C
H C
A. , C ,
AJ -A O
Kf fLiu
H H C
. 2002 IK
C C F P
2003 H
MJ .
M FF
J A.
H eF
. F
I K
c . ,
MF P
C A
vI A P
H QQ AJ
H M GK
.
i
AN
MJ c.
A, AJ
O
.
C O F
MJ F. HJ
FC CH.
F cF
AM FK
A.
FK
PM
AM C FK
A. IP A
O C
C F H G AJ
G FAM. Q
J
M M F 2014
F FA
M F
A.
F
F M
M .
F , wM
G . FI
H IK F
F MI b
G .
F
HA.
A.
A FA.
AJ F F
F P pM
'L'v K C
F H
K
Q F I O.
C G
A.
'
F MP
H '
FK , H,
A F EM,
H
... C
O
F MJ F.
HJ
FC CH.
eif org 2 0 1 2 31
Kf fLiu
F F
CO
MK
Q A.
A.
F P
C
QI
A.
F A. AJ
F
K H
P
P,
vI G
PM
C F
A .
fkh mjhJ
A.
Q F M ,
A
F, F H
M
G .
F A.
M
H
GK H.
A
I H MK
.
.
J
Q F H
MA,
iC F. 2002
MM A
H K Q
. FK F
FK. ,
NM MA.
i, O, C
L HKO h C
iA O
Q
. J F
H K M.
CA .
MM A
58 M
. '
F A
iC PM'
A.
EA .
A O
A H Fw
.
. bA
IF
F P G
CF K
A A.
A A K .
I
A M F N
PH '' FK,
CJ O
HK H, H
KA. P
I, C
A A
E K MA,
F
M Q
M.
H CF.
Q F
HE .
F K, F
F .
CF, FK,
H
M, E i
A A.
C O, M
eif org 2 0 1 2 33
FwrhL
lhl #h eha
Kf gy mogilthfshf
gauthfshf UgJ V?
yf af g thF
bghGJ, kjfis g thF
bghGJ neuoahfnth kiwKfkhf
nth Kf mogilthf
vW uthf vW RofhlgL
whf. yh vf cyf cs
vyh Clff thyhf Kf mo
gilthf vW uthf vW mil
ahs fhLt cWahf Uwhf. j
jtwhd jftfS bghahd urhuK K
f jhfgLtjF kfgLtjF
fhuzfshf mikJLwd. cjhuzF
mbkfh xyfhkh ef elj btoFL
g d ka HF ehLf
iftir UwJ vd mbkfh midJ
ClffS ngho nghL bfhL m
brjd. Mdh, mj btoFL btof
fhuzkhUj Fwth mbkfh
Mjgilia nrj xUtjh vW d
fLofglJ. cikahd Fwth
ahbuW bjj , mtiw mf
nkfl Clff ngho nghliy.
mlna thjd.
1. mogilthjfhd sf:
jh rhUF bfhifia kd
cWl goJ, mj bfhifia j
thif f rahf eilKiw
gLJgtDF mogilth vW bga.
cjhuzF kUJt xUt wj kUJt
vd bga vLf ntLkhdh, - mt
34 eif org 2 0 1 2
2. eh xU yha mogilth
vg bgUik bfhnw.
FwrhL
4. mogilthjF My mfuh jU
sf
mogilthjF btl od
jU sf vdbtwh, ghJfhF
bfhifia (Rotestanism) mogilahf
bfhL Ugjh who Mug
mbkfh njha af vgjhF. ed
ehffij vJ ig bfhiffshd
eif kW xGff kLkyhJ
tuyhiw cikfis ig csgona
iyWj nto njha afkhF.
flsh vGJ to mUsgl flisfns
ig vw bfhifF KaJt bfhLJ
a tU afkhF. vdnt Mug
fhyf mogilthj vwh nkFl
bfhiffis mogilahf bfhL a
tj af vW bghU bfhsglJ.
mogilthjF MnghL mfuh
jU sf vdbt, kjf
bjhikahd myJ mogilahd
nfhghLfis be wHhJ eilKiwgLJtJ
-Fghf yha kj nfhghLf vgjhF.
iwF xU kj mogilthj vw
thijia cgnahFnghJ clnd mtdJ
vz K - xU gafuthahf
njhLwh.
5. xbthU KK xU gafuthahf
Uf ntL
xbthU KK xU gafuthahf
Uf ntL. gaJF fhuzkhdt
xL
bjh
C M. C
L. d. ...? ??
i C Al. OJ
C Al.
M C Al.
A C PAl.
C O () C CAl.
C MAl.
C . C .
M .
C K A. C
L
A.
C I. CJ F
F.
, C N .
. C . c MAl
.
GM . CJ v
AI A. CJ AI .
d K...?
- ep
eif org 2 0 1 2 37
FHij ts
Kidt thtuR
38 eif org 2 0 1 2
FHij ts
m fgid fdfSF wFf
lgLwd. mtf tzJ fshf
fgid th njhl wfoJ gwghf.
fij to Mkd g mj
fUJf, ca neu mit FHijf
wj brh, bra totf btgL.
ku bto iHf brhYf... vw v
kf tUik thrf btghL
fijah wjnj!
W FHijfSfhfnt gy
bjhiyfh ff tJsd. fij ntW
brhy ntLkh vd nffyh.
d iuf fhL fhf,
brhY brhf it kLnk FHijf
kd g.
J mtf thd MHkhd
fgia fd wFfis itoL.
e isfis ehjh efnth.
ehnk mtfSF fij brhYnghJ m
fijf mtf m ts, xGf
nkghL, mtf cs czf
nghwtiw e kd bfhL fij
brhnth.
fijf ilna isf
IafSF sf jUnth. mtf
nffSF giy jUnth.
it midij xU d iuah
ju ayhJ.
nkY d iuf brhdij
brhY isf! mt X mkh
mgh czUfhJ.
xU jhjh gho ghrK g mwnt
UfhJ.
jdhjh My d
iuia Idiot Box Klh bgo vwd.
nrJ cz cL, To ng kG
FLgf vW j nghfhJ vgJ mDgt
bkh.
Mdh, MQ bgQ rghf
btna brY fhy it
rhakhfhJ.
Mfnt, Xj u neu j Klh
bgofis rW neu mizJL,
FHijfSF fij brhY nghJ, FHijf
kLky FLgnk To Ffy mila j
fij neuf gagL myth?
xUKiw mj mR taJ R, (v
kfisjh brhnw). ey ghfhu
fijia brhYgh vwJ.
xW ahJ v kidia
ghnj.
fnz! na mj fijia
brhny! vwh v kid.
xU ghfhu ghny jna
fyfkhlh. gh J blr gzny khL
thf nghdh. ty xU kujony bfhr
neu lh.
kuUJ xU FuF w tJ.
jiy khony Uj gz igny if
btR...
clnd myh mj FuF fhJny,
mt ey ghfhu; ghny jna fyf
khlh. mt gzij vLfhnj..D
brhlh. FuF gzij vLfhk kuy
VLR.
Kr ghfhu rijF
nghdh. beiwa khL thdh. beiwa gh,
beiwa gz ilR... buhg rnjhkh
Ujh.
g vdF fK tJo...
go xU fijia fgid brJ,
trd, afnjhL brh KojJ m R.
fij j gh w ghfhu
gh gzij jny, gzij
mtlK FuF nghlJ. j ilj
gz jUnf nghdJ vw fij
kbwhU tot vgJ ekF bjjnj.
mllh! vjid mHfhd gil wid
m FHijFns tsJsd mj u
neu fijf!
cy wF xbthU FHij X
a ebrljh wwJ.
mtfis fd fhz Lfns.
fd vgJ F nghJ njhW
xwy. cfis f lhk, f,
bragl itgJjh fd.
lhl V..n#. mJ fyh j
thrfgo e isf fd fhz fijf gy
brhYnth.
mt _y mtf IQ Mwiy
tsngh.
eif org 2 0 1 2 39
jid
yt g. K. mt
br
t njLtJ thif
aikahj njhahf
csJ. thif vyh
mirfS brtijj
bfhnl iw bgWwd.
brt iybawh thif Xl
iyF WL. miy kj
gfthj nehdh Klfgltngh
MLth. Mjyh, thif Xl aghf
aFtjF brt ntlh. flhakhf
ntL. mjfhf Kay ntL. ciHf
ntL. fLikahf KaW, ciHJ bga
ms brtij nrJl ntL.
myJ frkhd tUth ilawhJ
ilFkhW VghL brJ bfhs ntL.
j Ka jsnah rngh Vgl
ljUj TlhJ.
vyh rjh! Mdh brt
nrgijna thif yakhf
bfhsyhkh?
iwa isa jiyKiw
nghif nehFnghJ thW nff
njhWwJ.
flj fhy tWik dil
iwa Knah kd tLthf gJsJ.
ML bfhoUj may v#khdf
Mzt bfhLnfhikF m T FW
wij mj may v#khdf mF
catfsh fj cehL gzfhuf
mlhtofSF MwhJ mf G iejij
42 eif org 2 0 1 2
jid
eif org 2 0 1 2 43
Mnuha
ah
brf
<
sh Jol
brayh tU j~
kju[h m uh
ML Hh f wghf
eilbgwJ. UFM kdd
gahf brayhtU m
uh kju[h 120F
nkgl isf goJ
tUwhf. lnjh$ Ah
KAkJ gh w
Uduhf fyJbfhL
wiu ManjhL kju[h
khzt khzfSF
gRfis tHdh.
Kdjhf kju[h brayhs
rnfhju AJ Rjh
midtiu tuntwh.
bgnwh khztf vW
ushndh f fyJ
bfhlhf.
48 eif org 2 0 1 2
brf
dhF a K ngh s rh
.v.M khztfSF mnlhg khj
f g Kfh xW VghL
bragoUjJ. dhF tlhuij
nrj 125 khztf fyJ bfhlhf.
Kdjhf x.v.v.. jiyt Ah
Kdt rh jiyiknaf, Ma uh
h tuntiuahdh. vfhy eho
jiywj Fokfshf, bjhygfshf,
fkhfshf ekJ khztf fH
ntL vW jdJ jiyikiu Ah
Kdt Flh. j Kfh g njit
vbfhS tKiwfis g
EQffis g vLJiufglJ
vwh f FG Jiz jiyt #h~g rh.
mLjjhf v..v khztfSF Jnghw
g mf csjhf Ah Kdt rh
Flh.
sh ef J Fk JF
shdh a K gthr
etg 10M eh, g isP
d Joghd Vgho xU kUJt
Kfh VghL braglJ. kWky
af Mjul knya uj t,
sh Rfhjhu fHf, krh kUJt
f Mnah xJiHl kUJt
z KfhK bghJkfSF ytr
kUJt nrhjid tHfglJ. Kdjhf
g jiyt Ah KAkJ R~,
krh kUJt gfiy fHf jiyt
lnjh Ah A~gh Kiy j
Kfh JtaJ.
j Kfh nrhjidf,
uj mGj nrhjidf, cl gnrhjid
f, nahbju~, khgf Wneh nrhjid
f vW gntW nrhjidf bghJkfSF
braglJ. MnyhridfS tHfgld.
nkY, bghJkf zfhf gntW
ffhfS itfgoUjd. j
f aFeU telJduhd
isP [h h Kdjhf tuntwh.
eif org 2 0 1 2 49
Wfij
b#a nkhf
(brw j bjhl)
vneuK kd XoaJ.
ehiyJ Kiw XlYF btna brW
W ghJL ngrhk tnj. mj eWkz
vid WfhaJ. eh bghj id
thifnyna UKiwjh rhoUnw.
UKiw brhj xU gizah
ojh. xU thufJ _W %gh ul
mj gzJl bfnj rh XlYF
brnw. rh Xliy wgJ tiu vdF cl
eL bfhnl UjJ. Vnjh ULjd bra
tjtid ngh cznj. FgnyhL cns
ngh Xukhf ahUnk ftfhjJ nghy mkJ
bfhnl. xnu rj. rh a ntf nrhW
gkh bfhoUjh.
ffgl jhkiu iy jh
rhghL. M gwF t rgh nrhiw bga
gyh m bfho mj nk tj fia
Cdh. yUF nfh FH. yUF
tWjnfh FH. mt vijnk
ftfiy vWjh glJ. mj wF
ftnj. mtUF vnyhiunk bj.
gyl mt vijnk nfgiy. mtnu id
fia itjh. Mdh, ahlK cgrhukhf
VJ brhyiy. mtnu, gkhdh. ulh
Kiw FH gkhw kL xU iga Ujh.
vdUnf tjt vid VL
ghjh. vjh nsrh. jdh tejh?
vwh. vid btshs vW vgo
ftjh vW aJ ngrhk Unj.
nrhiwbfho mjnk FHig Cdh. xU
bga bghj f fh. uL JL bghj
. D vW cWa Ulh. mjF
vgo _W %ghF nk ML. v
iffhf gjw Mujd. nrhW bjhil
miljJ. rblW Ua rh mnl
vJ vLQ? nsrh vW xU
eif org 2 0 1 2 51
Wfij
gafu mjl nghlh. m m
vid liy.mehf v
rhnl. mj U v clbgyh
fdfTl bfnj rh Xl
miukhj
guaJ. U! flns, mgo xW
FH nfh bghaYjh tJ
rgha
cy Ugijna kwJnlnd.
bfhoUjd. V, nehL jf
mgona
v ff UJ f
gf xU fijTl vG
nghlJ.
bfho th tiuF tjJ.
itUnj. cfhJ
vjid ghf,
xU d o
rhL vGJ brwnghJ
f ~ fl
cUa benghw xWl
gz nghlhlh vw vz
vL ehfjh
bfnj rh vdUnf tjh. v
tjJ.
nrh mij bfho D bfhr
mj idng tiw mu
Ujd...
FH L bfhGR neh Anf... d
brjJ. nkbfhL rhlnt
bfhGghQ... vwh. MW bfhG
Koaiy. gij j KFtJnghy
mJ. mj br gF UJ krshf
nrhiw bjhil mGj ntoUjJ.
bto btna vLghf. fF mJ j
ff Uo bfhL tjd. vGJ iffG
Uia bfhLjJ. mfkhf rhL gHfyL fdj Fj fhfis itJ
hjjdh xU fl v tW milJ
elnj. W KLwjh, jiy RHwjh, kh
bfhlJ. rblW D U g nrhiw
milwjh xW aiy. ngrhk gzij
v iy bfhodh rh. mnah
nghL lyh vW njhaJ. bky elJ
ntlh vW jLfnghd v if mj
coa mUnf tnj. mij jho bry
jlhnyna f vW miwJ nrhW trh
Koaiy. fhJf X iur. rblW VG
jLFneh? vugh... Dil n[
%ghia mgona cns nghLL
vwh. ciknyna if t bjjJ.
btna tnj. btfhW glJjh vd
vGUjh rh moJLth vW mtuJ
brUnw vW jJ. miukhj rgha
uj ffis flnghJ njhaJ. nrhiw
mgona nghlJ. vjid ghf, f
r itgJ rhF ofhJ vW, cL
~ fl vL ehf jh Ujd. vd
KojnghJ vdh vH Koaiy. bgir
brJnl! Klhjd cr.
g bfhL elJ iyia nghL if
kd cU f tJ bfhnl
fGnd.
UjJ. f beUa xU kuz nghy. f bga
mj bgoia beWa nghJ v
Vkhw nghy. filF brW mknj. u
fhf eLd. vnfh Vnjh xU nfhz
tiu clig kdij KGf L
bfnj rh ghJbfhLjh Ugh vW
bfhS ntiy Ujjdh jnj.
njhaJ. Mdh, mt ntW Mfis
yhlh mj bt VjhtJ
ftJ bfhoUjh. gy gz nghlhk
jlthsTl jiy itUng. mu
nghdhf vgij ftnj. y nghlnghJ
njhaJ. V mH ntL? mj gz tJ
rhjhuzkhfjh Ujhf. eh if eLf
tiu bfnj rh Xl rhlh nghW.
_W %ghia vLJ cns nghnl. Vnjh xU
mid mj MWjYl nl.
Fu nfF v KJbfyh fhjhf, fzhf
kWeh ka tiujh f. neuhf
Unj. bky btna tjnghJ v clny
tJ bfnj rh Xl mkJ jhdkhf
fdHf MujJ. rhiy vF Fj fhW
UJ rhnl. mt bfhLtJ itJ
RtJngh UjJ. v cl yJ
bfhnl Ujh. bfhr ilbt
bfhnl Uf vtiu vij czuhk
lhTl vH nghnw vd idJ nl,
uik elJ bfhoUnj.
thDlh, khnu vwh. rhLL
ehiyJ eh eh m gFnf
iffG ngrhk eljnghJ cns bfnj rh
bryiy. L uL %gh nrj nghJ
nflh brhy ntoa fhuzfis
J bgW bfnj rh filF brnw.
brhfsh itJ bfhoUnj. mt
mt vid milahs fLbfhlh vgJ
ftfnt iy. btna tjnghJ Vkhwkhf
mnjnghy clbtoF msF rhghL.
UjJ. rblW mt nk vr tjJ. bga
Kiw gzij jhdkhfnt nghnl. L
L vw id. jkJF fLgL
_W ehf fJ brwnghJ v if VG
vyhU gz nghLtjdh t bga
%gh UjJ. mW khiy eh mij khF
jkthdhf njhwkwh. ukyhDF rfhJ
bfhL bfhLf ntL. m uL
bfhLgtf gzij bfhL tJ
%ghF rhlyh vd idnj.
coany nghLtjdh iHwh. Rkhth
uldhF nk rhLtbjgJ vid
bfhLwh? go ilj gz jhnd L
bghWjtiu Cjhjd cr. Mdh, U
brhJkhf MUwJ? nghlhlh vJtiu
52 eif org 2 0 1 2
Wfij
bghWgh, ghngh. mj vr,
vjdh vW bjaiy. Mdh,
cl KGf xU d nghy mJ
UJbfhnl UjJ.
mj vrYl kWeh brW
mknj. rh nffkhlh vd eh
mnt. Mdh, mt ghit
elij xU a khw
bjjhTl mWl brtij
Wl ntL vd idJ
bfhnl. bfhr mfkhf
cgrjhTl mtUF fzF
UwJ. ftwh vWjhnd
mj. Mdh, bfnj rh mtuJ
tHfkhd mnj ntfJl gkh
bfhoUjh. bfhG Cdh.
nfh D nsrh vW xU
miu nfhia itjh. d
itjh. mt j cyjh
Uwhuh? ciknyna J xU
khisjhdh iy VjhtJ dh?
gakhTl UjJ. filahf nrhW nghL
rhlnghdnghJ bfnj rh f bghj
sfh fhu is bfhr fUa nfh
fhiy bfhL itjh. eh mij U
rhLtij btna fho bfhsTlhJ vd
vnghJ Kant. Mdh, mtUF
bjUjJ Mrakfiy.
mj fhuij nrh nghL
irjnghJ rblW kd jJlJ.
fiu mlfnt Koaiy v theh
vtUnk vdF J nrhliy. MHhF
mia f itF mkhF mj
fLfL tirfS rhgfS yhlh
vyhUF gF itfnt KoahJ. eh iwJ
rhl ntL vd vQ Kj kj. vdF
fzF ghfhk rhghL nghL Kj if.
mdl if vwhfns, mk fz tiu
be F mid if vwhfns,
jhaJ foa kfL, joj fhj
ufS, kulj KHif bfhl j
fuo fukyth v jh if? mj eh
bfnj rhF gznk bfhLjiy. brybtd
idJ bfhLfhkUfiy vW v
beir bjhL brhy Ko. mJ v
mkh nrhW vgjhjh bfhLfiy.
xuly KGrhf IJ tUl xU igrh Tl
bfhLjiy.
dK xU ntis mnf rhLnt.
khiy myJ ka. mJnt vdF nghJkhdjhf
UjJ. nkbfhL xU ehF nghJ. v
iffhf cu itjd. fd gsgsjJ. ir
jojJ. Fu fdjJ. eil LF ng
fo jdif tjd.
fil v l ljl
khnd#UF fuhdjhf MaJ.
ruFfis tu itJ njitF Vg
vLJ bfhLgJ KGf v
bghWjh. go bry nghf,
CUF khj njhW gz
mDnd. V .V.it Kj
tF Kjl btw
to fnyna v.V gof
nrnj. rhiy mUzhry
ehlh filnk xU miwia
thlifF vLJ bfhnl. xU
ey ir th bfhnl.
xbthU ehS bfnj
rh ifah rhnl. bkJthf
ngR FiwJ mt vid
ghwhuh vw rnjf Tl
MujJ. Mdh v iy nk
mtuJ fdj iff czl
SnghJ bj mJ mng cUthd
mkh if vW. eh mt ko wJ
mtl Kiylt vW. j ru
gbdhW KoJL oiu iyr vLJ
muR nghFtuJ fHf nrjnghJ L
fZl FiwjJ. eh mtnghJ LF
nghnt. mkh ey m th FH
itJ mtns gkhWth. Mdh, vjidnah
fhykhf L w tWik mtSF gkhw
bjahJ. xU f vnghJ ghid UF
nrhiw ro UF FHig fzF
nghLtij jf KoahJ. mfig mt
nrhnwh FHngh mdh miuth Ug
bfhoLth. D bfhr FH vwh
mtSila mfig y brhLfjh mS.
ifnah kdnkh FWlJ. rhisKsK
rgh m nrhW mt m itif eh
ehyhtJ cUil nrh tW milj
czit milnt. mj nrhiw m th
nghLtnj rghf bj. gydkhf rhLlh
vgh mkh. jiyairJ Kf fG
bfhnt.
v.V. gfiy fHf
ulhl tnj. clnd mnj gfiy
fHf f iuahsuhf ntiy
iljJ. Miz ifF tj mW ka neuhf
bfnj rh filFjh nghnd. fil
wfiy. eh gf brnw. rhF
gLjhit y ghnj. bga cU
bfnj rh FHig o bfhoUjh.
KfK iffS jid vyh FH
Ujd. mJ xU bjhGif nghy. mtiu
TLtJ ray vW njhaJ. U
nl. ka bfnj rh v iyF nrhW
nghLnghJ J mt Kfij ghnj. m
eif org 2 0 1 2 53
Wfij
vdfhd vj ghit iy. brhy
ntlh vW njhaJ. mj brF
mtlK vj mjK iy.
rafhy CUF brnw. mkh
k miljhsh vW bjaiy. vij
ftiyahfnt fhL Kf mik mtSF. mgh
kL vdlh FLgh? vwh. mJ
bfilF vnw rhjhuzkhf. vd vuW
bfhLghdh? vwh. eh mj nf
Uj mgjd f Fkhjhit fL
bfhL lgnl. mytn[hL nrJ
vGW %gh... vnw. mgh ff xU
fz kiwj tkij Wfz tiu
kwf KoahJ. khj UgJ %ghF nk rgsnk
thfhk Xbgwt mt.
jjh cikahd crhfJl
Jdh. ny jhnd sh
vLfQ. cdF mgodh eyh Z ngr
bj ny? Jiu kh ngRt iy? vW
jJ bfhnl Ujh. mkh nfhgJl,
JswJ r, cs gzij nrJ H cs
bfhkUfis fiunaJw ta ghUf vwh.
jhfkhd xU fhuzij fL bfhl
mtSila Mfhu mtahf bttu
MujJ. Jdtyh vf bflfhD
fnly? jhHFofha midF rKt
fahzny ghnj. ror fUthL
fzfhLyh Ujh... vd Ml Modh
gh... rh D FLFyh? vwh.
Vo, vd ngRnf? eh fhd
cdf kt, mt nghl nrhyh goR
Mshdh? e ntQghJf... e
ntQ... vwh mgh. vd e? L
nrhW bfhs nghlh. mJF csj fzF
nghL mt _y blrh nghUnk...
nyzh ehisF d ntw fznfhL
tj gh thrny. vsbtLj W mkh
brhdh. mgh, Cj tha _Lo vW
vH ril vGjJ.
54 eif org 2 0 1 2
Wfij
m i fah .
fhyrfu ny.
bfhoUnj. jid
gz i iy .
ghah
gzij v ifah eh
v jJ
fltDF
rghng vd vnghJ
l
eh jh khd it L
beYF FLJ
vaiy. mij
b j r h j
f Fonwh. jL
itJ Utdju
T bf
U
fnydh m
wef xU a
m a
x s
i
J
n
gF grjilahF
ilTl
f w
s
wJ kfh... Mdh ey
thl
Ko.
if mi it fi
..
.
J
fhyny eh cdF
bfhr
neu
t ehL hJ nj
nghoUnf. v ifahny
mjgz v ifF
n
g U
f gW FoRjjh
kdJF
gH nghd
o
h
Mshnd. vL khr d buL
ijia
idJ
difJ
bf
ntisdhTl mrhW ntis eh
bfhnl.
cdF nrhW f btsUnf.
ka neu bfnj rh filF
ghJnfh. mbjyh c mikF g
nghnd. fil wjJ cns brW
bjahJ. mj e mtSnyzhY
coa gzij nghl Munj. bgo
cdUF. kfh uhkbyRF cid lh
iwjJ bfnj rhl ntW bgo nfnl.
MUny. rtJF uh gfY c
lh mnj bgo khbwlh vwh. iga
idghF. mtSF xU j FL uhrh...
bgoia kh itjJ L nghnl.
z nrhJF e fhlnyzh
bkhj gzij nghl iffGL tJ
mJFlhd fzF brkbrkhjukh
mknj. bfnj rh iy nghL vdF
fQ ghJnfh...
akhd bfhr bghaiy itjh. nrhW nghL
mtl ilbgW g VanghJ
FH Cdh. mtl vj khWjY
ntgfh cjo gLJ nghy frjJ. thna
UfhbjW vdF ewhf bjUjJ. xU
frgJ nghy g UJ J bfhnl
brh iy. mgh U igaf xoaJ
tnj. neuhf tdju tnj. ntiyF
ngh mkUjhf. bta eha igaf.
nrj xU a bghW guguY jY
rjw rz j rUk. btSj ff.
_fhk UUjh mj frig clbgF
bfnj rh m itj fia Ko Ko
iwJ itUng. Kj khj rgs
W bfhoUjhf. bfjh rh bdhU
thaJ mkhF gz mDUnj.
JL fia xUtDFitjf mt mnah
mkh g foj, Rgkh tJ c
ntlh vW vGJlh. bfnj rh,
mghnl ngUwh. cf mghF
Dlh vughnl nkhnd vW mt
miukdRjh. mJ ekF ntlh. nfoah?
kil X mo nghlh. gykhd mo. mt
mtf brjJF nwh Munkh mj Fo
gaJ mgona mkJlh. f fhu
fahzJF FLUnth. ehk ahUF
Gjnjh vdnth, mGJ bfhnl rhlh.
nrhJfl tr kh ntlh. g ey
bfnj rh kh kh nfh FH
vlfny nfwhf. eyh brthf.
D bfhRkhf gkh bfhoUjh. eh
jghoUJ xU tu tUF.
vghjJ mtuJ ff xU ghitia.
ghfLkh vW nfoUjh. ubtyh
ehD xU Mshnl vW v jhF bja
nahJ bfhoUnj. rJ ngh
ntlhkh iyah? Mdh, mtuJ ff
nl. fhiy kd bjthf UjJ.
tHfngh vid rfntiy. L
mkhF, ghU... bghQ bfhr gortsh
bfhL itFnghJ fdj fuo fufis
UfQ vW vG nghnl.
ghnj. mit kLjh vdFait nghy.
Kj khjnk nfO rhehj ma
mit v tiw kLnk msbtLF nghy.
ela Ugjhu %gh L x
mW CUF s brnw.
nrUnj. khj IW %gh jtiz tU.
uhkbyRia mLj Mt Ukz brJ
mij ehyhu %gh j Vy vLnj.
To tnj.
gdhuhu %gh bkhjkhf khU
eif org 2 0 1 2 55
cuj jid 25
lnjh$ Ah KAkJ gh
ahghu Kid
fhLgtf vif
nghJ To tUtJ ghuhLFa
tuntfjf jhf. J D
Tl ntL. bgUghY jeg jDila
RaKadh ahghu <LgLwh.
aJ bgaJkhf yiu fil Kj
mfho ahghu tiu Jj tsia
vLwd. jdif, lhKa,
tjf Egf, tu bry fzF, go
ahghu gy TWfis ifafgL
myJ fW L eilnghLwhf. ahghu
XnAh vW tsU. gf, thf
vW gyngiu ntiyF mk, ahghuij
gLjyh; bdhU bjhYFTl
jhtyh.
kj thif xU fhy viyF
fLglJ. vdnt, eh iybawh
j ahghu vgo aF vw jid
Uf ntL. fhy fhykhf bjhluyh;
eh Ungh vw eif ntfkhdjy.
kid kf ghJ bfhthf
vW edh mtfis <LghoF
bfhL tJ, MugUnj g
bfhLf ntL; mDgtij tsf
ntL. mJl, isf
ciknyna ahghu Mt
cstfsh? mtfSF wik csjh?
vgij myr ntL. ntlh btWghf
tWj cns tUgtfdh
ahghuij af KoahJ. mgo
afgL Wtd bjhlJ iyJ