Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1) Plato
a) Pros Types of Government
i) Aristocracy
(1) Best! – “Philosopher” rules kingdom in the way that is best for all of
civilization see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosopher_king
ii) Oligarchy
(1) Organized
(2) Motivated (Money)
iii) Timocracy
(1) Spirited
iv) Democracy
(1) Equal rights
v) Tyranny
b) Cons Types of Government
i) Oligarchy
(1) Too Material
ii) Timocracy
(1) Too rash
iii) Democracy
(1) Freedom is misconceived
(2) “freedom” really anarchy, “shamelessness” really courage, “good
breeding” really arrogance
iv) Tyranny
(1) Degenerate of Society
c) Soul and Individual
i) A person can also be one or the other of these things
ii) Oligarchy
(1) Out of tyrant
(2) To awful
iii) Timocracy
(1) Will grow out of an Oligarch
(2) Realize his father is too material
iv) Democracy
(1) Out of Timocrat
(2) Too rigid, no freedom
v) Tyranny
(1) Out of Democrat
(2) Too free no rigidity
d) Best would be philosopher.
2) Locke
a) Very different historical context – Locke’s big political agenda is against the
Divine Rights of Kings
b) Still very much juxtaposed to Plato, who severely hated Democracy… see essay
on democracy
c) State of Nature all being are equal, men are generally good
d) Private Property is a problem… sort of socialistic
e) People exchange some of their natural rights to enter into society with other
people, and be protected by common laws and a common executive power to
enforce the laws.
f) Government exists for the people and should be overthrown if it doesn’t work
g) Abiding by the majorities opinion
h) Lacks of Nature
i) Established law
ii) Indifferent Judge
iii) Power to back law and judgment