You are on page 1of 59

:

:

February 15, 2009

2................................................................................................................
3..................................................................................................
5....................................................................................................
6...................................................................................................
7......................................................................................................
8................................................................................... MATLAB
17 ..........................................................................................
27 .................................................................................................
30 ...............................................
31 ..............................................................................................................

plate bending
120 . 1 .

= 2.1 10 / , = 0.3


.

ANSYS .
6.0

x=- 1/8 y^2+3.5

0.6
4.0

t=3 cm

-1

x= 1/8 y^2-3.5

0.6


.
.
.
. .
) ( .
)
( :

-2 4 9


:
: - . -
. .



.
.
. -
.

Shear locking


MATLAB :
(1
.
(2

(3 .
(4 .
(5 .
(6 .
(7 .
(8 .
(9 .
(10 .
(11 .
(12 .

MATLAB
%% PROGRAM2:ANALISYS OF PLATE BENDING USING FINITE ELEMENT METHOD
%
% Solves a linear elastic 2D plate bendig problem
% with several element types.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%%%%%
%% Start Program
clear all
clc
disp('SAHAND University of Technology');
disp('****** plate bending programming with MATLAB project ****');
disp(' ');
disp('WRITEN BY:');
disp('

KHALED TOFIGHI');

disp('

EBRAHIM KOSARI');

disp('

MORTEZA MORADIZADE');

disp(' ');
%% Input Data
disp('..................................');
disp('**********INPUT DATA**********');
disp('..................................');
h=input('Enter THICKNESS of plate: ');
nnode=input('Enter number of nodes: ');
nel=input('Enter number of elements: ');
sdof=nnode*3;
bcn=input('Enter number of nodes that are constrained: ');
for i=1:length(bcn)
bcdof((3*i-2):3*i)=(bcn(i)*3-2):(bcn(i)*3);

end
q=input('Enter size of load: ');
bcval=zeros(1,length(bcdof));
rs=zeros(sdof,1);
kk=zeros(sdof,sdof);
elprop=zeros(nel,2);
ss=zeros(3,nnode);
tt=zeros(2,nnode);
ndof=3;
gcoord=input('Enter coordinate of nodes [x y]: ');
answer=input('Is elements similar? (y/n) ','s');
if answer=='y'
elprop(:,1)=input('Enter modul of elasticity (E): ');
elprop(:,2)=input('Enter poisons ratio (nou): ');
else
for i=1:nel
elprop(i,1)=input('Enter modul of elasticity (E): ');
elprop(i,2)=input('Enter poissons ratio (nou): ');
end
end
nnel=input('Enter number of nodes of the element: ');
elnode=input('Enter nodes number: (ex:[1 2 3 4]) ');
%% Displacement Calculation
for i=1:nel
%fprintf('ELEMENT %1.0f\n',i);
%nnel=input('Enter number of nodes of the element: ');
%elnode=input('Enter nodes number: (ex:[1 2 3 4]) ');
for j=1:nnel
xx=elnode(i,j);

xcoord(j)=gcoord(xx,1);
ycoord(j)=gcoord(xx,2);
end
if nnel==4
pointb=2;
else
pointb=3;
end
points=pointb-1;
edof=nnel*3;
e=elprop(i,1); nou=elprop(i,2);
cbi=e*h^3/(12*(1-nou^2))*[1 nou 0;nou 1 0;0 0 (1-nou)/2];
csi=e*h*5/(12*(1+nou))*[1 0;0 1];
kb=zeros(edof,edof);
ks=zeros(edof,edof);
sigma=zeros(3,edof);
tau=zeros(2,edof);
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%%%%%%%%%%% bendig term %%%%%%
[r1,a]=gaus22(pointb);
for intx=1:(pointb^2)
r=r1(intx,1);
wtx=a(intx,1);
s=r1(intx,2);
wty=a(intx,2);
if nnel==4
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso4(r,s);
elseif nnel==5

10

aa=input('which node is present (as respects BATHE PAGE 453): ');


[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso5(r,s,aa);
elseif nnel==8
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso8(r,s);
elseif nnel==9
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso9(r,s);
end
jacob2=fejacob2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,xcoord,ycoord);
detjacob=det(jacob2);
invjacob=inv(jacob2);
bkapa=kapa2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,invjacob);
kb=kb+bkapa'*cbi*bkapa*wtx*wty*detjacob;
detjs=jacobs(nnel,dhdr,dhds,xcoord,ycoord);
for x=1:nnel
dofz=elnode(i,x)*3-2;
rs(dofz)=rs(dofz)+wtx*wty*shape(x)*q*detjs;
end
end
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%% shear matrix %%%
[r2,a2]=gaus22(points);
for intx=1:(points^2)
r=r2(intx,1);
wtx=a2(intx,1);
s=r2(intx,2);
wty=a2(intx,2);
if nnel==4
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso4(r,s);
elseif nnel==5

11

aa=input('which node is present (as respects BATHE PAGE 453): ');


[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso5(r,s,aa);
elseif nnel==8
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso8(r,s);
elseif nnel==9
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso9(r,s);
end
jacob2=fejacob2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,xcoord,ycoord);
detjacob=det(jacob2);
invjacob=inv(jacob2);
bgama=gama2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,shape,invjacob);
ks=ks+bgama'*csi*bgama*wtx*wty*detjacob;
end
k=kb+ks;
%%%%%%%%%
%%% assemble of stiffness matrix
index=feeldof(elnode(i,:),nnel,ndof);
kk=feasmbl1(kk,k,index);
end
[kk,rs]=feaplyc2(kk,rs,bcdof,bcval);
delta=kk\rs;
num=1:1:nnode;
%% Stress Calculation
sigma=zeros(3,edof);
tau=zeros(2,edof);
for i=1:nel
%fprintf('ELEMENT %1.0f\n',i);
%nnel=input('Enter number of nodes of the element: ');

12

%elnode=input('Enter nodes number: (ex:[1 2 3 4]) ');


for j=1:nnel
xx=elnode(i,j);
xcoord(j)=gcoord(xx,1);
ycoord(j)=gcoord(xx,2);
end
if nnel==4
pointb=2;
else
pointb=3;
end
points=pointb-1;
edof=nnel*3;
e=elprop(i,1); nou=elprop(i,2);
cbi=e*h^3/(12*(1-nou^2))*[1 nou 0;nou 1 0;0 0 (1-nou)/2];
csi=e*h*5/(12*(1+nou))*[1 0;0 1];
kb=zeros(edof,edof);
ks=zeros(edof,edof);

index=feeldof(elnode(i,:),nnel,ndof);
for ii=1:length(index)
dis(ii)=delta(index(ii));
end
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%%%%%%%%%%% bendig term %%%%%%
[r1,a]=gaus22(pointb);
for intx=1:(pointb^2)
r=r1(intx,1);
wtx=a(intx,1);

13

s=r1(intx,2);
wty=a(intx,2);
if nnel==4
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso4(r,s);
elseif nnel==5
aa=input('which node is present (as respects BATHE PAGE 453): ');
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso5(r,s,aa);
elseif nnel==8
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso8(r,s);
elseif nnel==9
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso9(r,s);
end
jacob2=fejacob2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,xcoord,ycoord);
detjacob=det(jacob2);
invjacob=inv(jacob2);
bkapa=kapa2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,invjacob);
end
sigma(:,i)=-h/2*e/(1-nou^2)*[1 nou 0;nou 1 0;0 0 (1-nou)/2]*bkapa*dis';
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
%%% shear matrix %%%
[r2,a2]=gaus22(points);
for intx=1:(points^2)
r=r2(intx,1);
wtx=a2(intx,1);
s=r2(intx,2);
wty=a2(intx,2);
if nnel==4
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso4(r,s);

14

elseif nnel==5
aa=input('which node is present (as respects BATHE PAGE 453): ');
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso5(r,s,aa);
elseif nnel==8
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso8(r,s);
elseif nnel==9
[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso9(r,s);
end
jacob2=fejacob2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,xcoord,ycoord);
detjacob=det(jacob2);
invjacob=inv(jacob2);
bgama=gama2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,shape,invjacob);
ks=ks+bgama'*csi*bgama*wtx*wty*detjacob;

end
tau(:,i)=0.5*e/(1+nou)*bgama*dis';
k=kb+ks;
%%%%%%%%%
%%% assemble of stiffness matrix
ss=feasmbl2(ss,sigma,elnode(i,:));
tt=feasmbl3(tt,tau,elnode(i,:));
end
%% output data
disp(' ');
disp('-------------------------------');
disp('.......... RESULTS ............');
disp('-------------------------------');
%{'Dof','displacement';num',delta}
for i=1:length(delta)/3

15

dz(i)=delta(3*i-2);
tetax(i)=delta(3*i-1);
tetay(i)=delta(3*i);
end
maxdz=max(dz);
mindz=min(dz);
if abs(mindz)>abs(maxdz)
maxdz=mindz;
end
deltaz=dz';
maxdz
sx=ss(1,:)';
sy=ss(2,:)';
sxy=ss(3,:)';
sxz=tt(1,:)';
syz=tt(2,:)';
displacement=[dz' tetax' tetay']
stress=[sx sy sxy sxz syz]

16


.
gauss22 (1

- :
:
%%POINT AND WHIET OF GAUS-LEGANDER METHOD
function[r,alpha]=gaus22(point)
if point==1
r=[0 0];
alpha=[2 2];
elseif point==2
s1=0.57735022692;
r=[s1 s1;s1 -s1;-s1 s1;-s1 -s1];
alpha=[1 1;1 1;1 1;1 1;1 1];
elseif point==3
s1=0.7745966692;
s2=0;
r=[s1 s1;s1 s2;s1 -s1;s2 s1;s2 s2;s2 -s1;-s1 s1;-s1 s2;-s1 -s1];
a1=0.5555556; a2=0.8888889;
alpha=[a1 a1;a1 a2;a1 a1;a2 a1;a2 a2;a2 a1;a1 a1;a1 a2;a1 a1];
end

iso4 (2

4 :
:
%% SHAPE FUNCTIONS AND THEIR DERIVATIONS FOR 4 NODE ELEMENT
function[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso4(r,s)
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s);

17

%%%%derivations
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s);
dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s);
%%
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r);
dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r);
dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r);

iso5 (3

5 :
:
%% SHAPE FUNCTIONS AND THEIR DERIVATIONS FOR 5 NODE ELEMENT
function[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso5(r,s,aa)
if aa==5
shape(5)=0.5*(1-r^2)*(1+s);
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s);
%%%%derivations
dhdr(5)=-r*(1+s);
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s);
dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s);
%%
dhds(5)=0.5*(1-r^2);
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r)-0.5*dhds(5);
dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r);

18

dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r);
elseif aa==6
shape(5)=0.5*(1-s^2)*(1-r);
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(5);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s);
%%%%derivations
dhdr(5)=-0.5*(1-s^2);
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s);
%%
dhds(5)=-s*(1-r);
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r);
dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5);
dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r);
elseif aa==7
shape(5)=0.5*(1-r^2)*(1-s);
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(5);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(5);
%%%%derivations
dhdr(5)=-r*(1-s);
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
%%
dhds(5)=-0.5*(1-r^2);
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r);

19

dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5);
dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r)-0.5*dhds(5);
elseif aa==8
shape(5)=0.5*(1-s^2)*(1+r);
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(5);
%%%%derivations
dhdr(5)=0.5*(1-s^2);
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s);
dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(5);
%%
dhds(5)=-s*(1+r);
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r);
dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5);
dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r);
elseif aa==9
shape(5)=(1-s^2)*(1-r^2);
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s)-0.25*shape(5);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s)-0.25*shape(5);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s)-0.25*shape(5);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s)-0.25*shape(5);
%%%%derivations
dhdr(5)=-2*r*(1-s^2);
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s)-0.25*dhdr(5);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s)-0.25*dhdr(5);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s)-0.25*dhdr(5);
dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s)-0.25*dhdr(5);

20

%%
dhds(5)=-2*s*(1-r^2);
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r)-0.25*dhds(5);
dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r)-0.25*dhds(5);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r)-0.25*dhds(5);
dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r)-0.25*dhds(5);
end

iso8 (4

8 :
:
%% SHAPE FUNCTIONS AND THEIR DERIVATIONS FOR 9 NODE ELEMENT
function[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso8(r,s)
%% shape function
shape(8)=0.5*(1+r)*(1-s^2);
shape(7)=0.5*(1-r^2)*(1-s);
shape(6)=0.5*(1-r)*(1-s^2);
shape(5)=0.5*(1-r^2)*(1+s);
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5)-0.5*shape(8);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5)-0.5*shape(6);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(6)-0.5*shape(7);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(7)-0.5*shape(8);
%% derivations dhdr
dhdr(8)=0.5*(1-s^2);
dhdr(7)=-r*(1-s);
dhdr(6)=-0.5*(1-s^2);
dhdr(5)=-r*(1+s);
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5)-0.5*dhdr(8);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5)-0.5*dhdr(6);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(6)-0.5*dhdr(7);
dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(7)-0.5*dhdr(8);
%% derivations dhds

21

dhds(8)=-s*(1+r);
dhds(7)=-0.5*(1-r^2);
dhds(6)=-s*(1-r);
dhds(5)=0.5*(1-r^2);
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r)-0.5*dhds(5)-0.5*dhds(8);
dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5)-0.5*dhds(6);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(6)-0.5*dhds(7);
dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r)-0.5*dhds(7)-0.5*dhds(8);

iso9 (5

9 :
:
%% SHAPE FUNCTIONS AND THEIR DERIVATIONS FOR 9 NODE ELEMENT
function[shape,dhdr,dhds]=iso9(r,s)
%% shape function
shape(9)=(1-r^2)*(1-s^2);
shape(8)=0.5*(1+r)*(1-s^2)-0.5*shape(9);
shape(7)=0.5*(1-r^2)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(9);
shape(6)=0.5*(1-r)*(1-s^2)-0.5*shape(9);
shape(5)=0.5*(1-r^2)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(9);
shape(1)=0.25*(1+r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5)-0.5*shape(8)-0.25*shape(9);
shape(2)=0.25*(1-r)*(1+s)-0.5*shape(5)-0.5*shape(6)-0.25*shape(9);
shape(3)=0.25*(1-r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(6)-0.5*shape(7)-0.25*shape(9);
shape(4)=0.25*(1+r)*(1-s)-0.5*shape(7)-0.5*shape(8)-0.25*shape(9);
%% derivations dhdr
dhdr(9)=-2*r*(1-s^2);
dhdr(8)=0.5*(1-s^2)-0.5*dhdr(9);
dhdr(7)=-r*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(9);
dhdr(6)=-0.5*(1-s^2)-0.5*dhdr(9);
dhdr(5)=-r*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(9);
dhdr(1)=0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5)-0.5*dhdr(8)-0.25*dhdr(9);
dhdr(2)=-0.25*(1+s)-0.5*dhdr(5)-0.5*dhdr(6)-0.25*dhdr(9);
dhdr(3)=-0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(6)-0.5*dhdr(7)-0.25*dhdr(9);

22

dhdr(4)=0.25*(1-s)-0.5*dhdr(7)-0.5*dhdr(8)-0.25*dhdr(9);
%% derivations dhds
dhds(9)=-2*s*(1-r^2);
dhds(8)=-s*(1+r)-0.5*dhds(9);
dhds(7)=-0.5*(1-r^2)-0.5*dhds(9);
dhds(6)=-s*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(9);
dhds(5)=0.5*(1-r^2)-0.5*dhds(9);
dhds(1)=0.25*(1+r)-0.5*dhds(5)-0.5*dhds(8)-0.25*dhds(9);
dhds(2)=0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(5)-0.5*dhds(6)-0.25*dhds(9);
dhds(3)=-0.25*(1-r)-0.5*dhds(6)-0.5*dhds(7)-0.25*dhds(9);
dhds(4)=-0.25*(1+r)-0.5*dhds(7)-0.5*dhds(8)-0.25*dhds(9);

fejacob2 (6

:
:
%% jacobian function
function[jacob2]=fejacob2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,xcoord,ycoord)
jacob2=zeros(2);
for i=1:nnel
jacob2(1,1)=jacob2(1,1)+dhdr(i)*xcoord(i);
jacob2(1,2)=jacob2(1,2)+dhdr(i)*ycoord(i);
jacob2(2,1)=jacob2(2,1)+dhds(i)*xcoord(i);
jacob2(2,2)=jacob2(2,2)+dhds(i)*ycoord(i);
end

kapa2 (7
:

:
%% Bkapa matrix
function[bkapa]=kapa2(nnel,dhdr,dhds,invjacob)
bkapa=zeros(3,3*nnel);
for i=1:nnel

23

h(1,:)=dhdr;
h(2,:)=dhds;
kapa=invjacob*h;
bkapa(:,3*i-2)=0;
bkapa(1,(3*i-1))=0;
bkapa(2,(3*i-1))=kapa(2,i);
bkapa(3,(3*i-1))=kapa(1,i);
bkapa(1,3*i)=-kapa(1,i);
bkapa(2,3*i)=0;
bkapa(3,3*i)=-kapa(2,i);
end

jacobs (8
:

:
%% jacobians function
function[detjs]=jacobs(nnel,dhdr,dhds,xcoord,ycoord)
dxdr=0;
dydr=0;
dxds=0;
dyds=0;
for i=1:nnel
dxdr=dxdr+dhdr(i)*xcoord(i);
dydr=dydr+dhdr(i)*ycoord(i);
dxds=dxds+dhds(i)*xcoord(i);
dyds=dyds+dhds(i)*ycoord(i);
end
detjs=sqrt(dxdr^2+dydr^2)*sqrt(dxds^2+dyds^2);

feeldof (9

(LM ) :
:

24

function [index]=feeldof(nd,nnel,ndof)
%purpose:
%dof
%
edof=nnel*ndof;
k=0;
for i=1:nnel
start=(nd(i)-1)*ndof;
for j=1:ndof
k=k+1;
index(k)=start+j;
end
end

feasmbl1 (10

. :
:
function [kk]=feasmbl1(kk,k,index)
%purpose:
%Assembly of element matrices into the system matrix
%
edof=length(index);
for i=1:edof
ii=index(i);
for j=1:edof
jj=index(j);
kk(ii,jj)=kk(ii,jj)+k(i,j);
end
end

feaplyc2 (11

. :

25

:
function [kk,ff]=feaplyc2(kk,ff,bcdof,bcval)
%purpose:
%aplly constraints to matrix equation [kk]x=ff
n=length(bcdof);
sdof=size(kk);
%
for i=1:n
c=bcdof(i);
for j=1:sdof
kk(c,j)=0;
end
%
kk(c,c)=1;
ff(c)=bcval(i);
end

26


ANSYS
ANSYS . Z

.
) .
(.

27

MATLAB

ANSYS

NODE

-0.0660

-0.0798

-0.0734

-0.0854

-0.0662

-0.0777

-0.0689

-0.0814

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

10

0.0000

0.0000

11

0.0000

0.0000

12

0.0000

0.0000

13

0.0000

0.0000

14

0.0000

0.0000

15

0.0000

0.0000

16

0.0000

0.0000

17

0.0000

0.0000

18

-0.0147

-0.0225

19

-0.0446

-0.0622

20

-0.0627

-0.0800

21

-0.0641

-0.0798

22

-0.0453

-0.0614

23

-0.0229

-0.0353

24

-0.0075

-0.0115

25

-0.0136

-0.0219

26

-0.0364

-0.0509

27

28

-0.0691

-0.0517

29

-0.0733

-0.0547

30

-0.0599

-0.0428

31

-0.0365

-0.0254

32

-0.0115

-0.0088

33

-0.0847

-0.0746

34

-0.0846

-0.0719

35

-0.0850

-0.0718

36

-0.0828

-0.0718

37

-0.0473

-0.0365

38

-0.0718

-0.0572

39

-0.0459

-0.0336

40

-0.0476

-0.0359

41

-0.0535

-0.0390

42

-0.0816

-0.0678

43

-0.0574

-0.0449

44

-0.0277

-0.0195

45

-0.0157

-0.0113

46

-0.0422

-0.0305

47

-0.0723

-0.0561

48

-0.0702

-0.0548

49

-0.0325

-0.0227

50

-0.0156

-0.0126

51

-0.0150

-0.0110

52

-0.0624

-0.0504

53

-0.0719

-0.0570

54

-0.0632

-0.0503

55

-0.0771

-0.0636

56

-0.0470

-0.0356

57

-0.0612

-0.0479

max

0.0000

0.0000

min

-0.0854

-0.0746

28

0.0200
0.0000
60

50

40

20

30

10

0
-0.0200
dz

ANSYS

-0.0400

MATLAB
-0.0600
-0.0800
-0.1000

node number

3 MATLAB ANSYS 8 ) 13 (

0.0200
0.0000
250

200

150

100

50

0
-0.0200
-0.0400
dz

ANSYS
-0.0600

MATLAB

-0.0800
-0.1000
node number

-0.1200

4 MATLAB ANSYS 8 ) 52 (

ANSYS
. .
.

29


4

ANSYS . 5 .
0.0200
0.0000
25

15

20

10

0
-0.0200

-0.0600

dz

ansys

-0.0400


-0.0800
-0.1000
node number

-0.1200

5 .
.

ANSYS .

30

0.0200
0.0000
60

50

40

30

20

10

0
-0.0200
-0.0400
dz

ANSYS
-0.0600

MATLAB

-0.0800
-0.1000
node number

-0.1200

7 MATLAB ANSYS

(1 ) ( :
2) The Finite Element Method Using MATLAB , By: young W. Kwon & Hyochoong Bang

31

1
8 ) 12(
coordinate

UZ
MATLAB

ANSYS

NODE

0.0000

-3

0.0000

-2

-3

0.0000

0.0000

-2

0.0000

1.344015

-3.27233

0.0000

0.655087

-3.44459

0.0000

-2.63E-02

-3.49991

0.0000

-0.70701

-3.43561

0.0000

-1.36898

-3.26393

0.0000

1.344015

3.27233

10

0.0000

0.655087

3.444594

11

0.0000

-2.63E-02

3.499907

12

0.0000

-0.70701

3.435613

13

0.0000

-1.36898

3.263932

14

-0.0154

-0.0168

-2.31548

15

-0.0475

-0.0506

-1.63096

16

-0.0839

-0.0875

-0.68452

17

-0.0934

-0.0969

0.261927

18

-0.0772

-0.0806

0.946445

19

-0.0476

-0.0508

1.630964

20

-0.0152

-0.0168

2.315482

21

-0.0155

-0.0169

-2

-2.31548

22

-0.0477

-0.0506

-2

-1.63096

23

-0.0842

-0.0874

-2

-0.68452

24

-0.0937

-0.0969

-2

0.261927

25

-0.0776

-0.0806

-2

0.946445

26

-0.048

-0.0508

-2

1.630964

27

-0.0154

-0.0168

-2

2.315482

28

-0.0498

-0.0513

0.629146

1.695791

29

-0.0905

-0.0930

-0.66326

0.152359

30

32

31

-1.60132

-0.66973

-0.0551

-0.054

32

1.691561

-0.67517

-0.0514

-0.05

33

0.176746

0.664458

-0.0929

-0.0905

34

-1.61451

0.661052

-0.0546

-0.0535

35

2.570193

0.642112

-0.0166

-0.0162

36

2.563586

-0.69109

-0.0166

-0.0163

37

1.66127

-1.33759

-0.0510

-0.0493

38

0.207129

-1.33163

-0.0934

-0.0911

39

-1.61615

-1.33486

-0.0527

-0.0513

40

-2.51846

-0.68837

-0.0181

-0.0177

41

-2.52955

0.658064

-0.0179

-0.0175

42

-1.62274

1.330526

-0.0525

-0.051

43

0.219323

1.332229

-0.0933

-0.0909

44

1.663385

1.314573

-0.0510

-0.0492

45

1.693676

-2.30E-02

-0.0519

-0.0504

46

0.936269

0.646802

-0.0787

-0.0765

47

0.164553

5.98E-04

-0.0926

-0.0897

48

0.92196

-0.66922

-0.0792

-0.0768

49

-0.72448

-0.6665

-0.0840

-0.0819

50

-1.60791

-4.34E-03

-0.0553

-0.0541

51

-0.71888

0.662755

-0.0841

-0.0821

33

2
8 ) 192(
UZ

34

coordinate

MATLAB

ANSYS

NODE

0.0000

-3

0.0000

-2

-3

0.0000

0.0000

-2

0.0000

1.839702

-3.07671

0.0000

1.676829

-3.14779

0.0000

1.511543

-3.21306

0.0000

1.34401

-3.27233

0.0000

1.174403

-3.32537

0.0000

1.839702

3.076713

10

0.0000

1.676829

3.147793

11

0.0000

1.511543

3.213065

12

0.0000

1.34401

3.272331

13

0.0000

1.174403

3.325372

14

-0.0015

-0.0015

-2.82888

15

-0.0055

-0.0055

-2.65776

16

-0.0113

-0.0113

-2.48663

17

-0.0183

-0.0183

-2.31549

18

-0.0261

-0.0261

-2.14437

19

-0.0344

-0.0344

-1.97325

20

-0.0429

-0.0429

-1.80211

21

-0.0015

-0.0015

-2

-2.82888

22

-0.0055

-0.0055

-2

-2.65776

23

-0.0113

-0.0113

-2

-2.48663

24

-0.0183

-0.0183

-2

-2.31549

25

-0.0261

-0.0261

-2

-2.14437

26

-0.0344

-0.0344

-2

-1.97325

27

-0.0429

-0.0429

-2

-1.80211

28

-0.0494

-0.0494

0.642166

1.756016

29

-0.0938

-0.0938

-0.66326

0.152359

30

31

-1.60958

-0.66837

-0.0555

-0.0555

32

1.749033

-0.66352

-0.0496

-0.0497

33

0.176746

0.664458

-0.0937

-0.0937

34

-1.61134

0.657363

-0.0554

-0.0554

35

2.580476

0.64326

-0.0163

-0.0162

36

2.575112

-0.67455

-0.0163

-0.0163

37

1.701624

-1.3212

-0.0498

-0.0498

38

0.207143

-1.33163

-0.0942

-0.0942

39

-1.61614

-1.33486

-0.0535

-0.0535

40

-2.51601

-0.6692

-0.0184

-0.0184

41

-2.51939

0.647827

-0.0184

-0.0183

42

-1.59577

1.32549

-0.0544

-0.0545

43

0.219337

1.332229

-0.0941

-0.0941

44

1.708327

1.311089

-0.0495

-0.0496

45

1.759751

-1.30E-02

-0.0500

-0.0501

46

0.962643

0.649802

-0.0791

-0.0791

47

0.164553

5.98E-04

-0.0937

-0.0937

48

0.951196

-0.66131

-0.0794

-0.0795

49

-0.72448

-0.6665

-0.0855

-0.0855

50

-1.62096

-4.90E-03

-0.0557

-0.0557

51

-0.71888

0.662755

-0.0856

-0.0856

52

2.469822

-1.33234

-0.0167

-0.0167

53

-2.43358

-1.32546

-0.0181

-0.0181

54

-2.43743

1.311947

-0.0180

-0.018

55

-2.52498

-1.11E-02

-0.0194

-0.0194

56

-0.69668

1.332239

-0.0864

-0.0864

57

0.949514

-1.32263

-0.0793

-0.0794

58

-0.7045

-1.33325

-0.0862

-0.0862

59

-0.72168

-1.87E-03

-0.0857

-0.0857

60

0.959473

1.317852

-0.0790

-0.079

61

2.477293

1.311104

-0.0165

-0.0165

62

2.606697

-1.80E-02

-0.0166

-0.0166

63

0.956623

-7.03E-03

-0.0795

-0.0796

64

0.95134

-0.33497

-0.0796

-0.0796

65

1.355617

-1.08E-02

-0.0661

-0.0662

66

0.558019

-4.02E-03

-0.0890

-0.0891

35

67

0.957064

0.320586

-0.0794

-0.0795

68

1.754392

-0.33827

-0.0500

-0.05

69

2.598593

-0.34747

-0.0165

-0.0165

70

3.04392

-2.22E-02

-0.0047

-0.0047

71

2.180301

-1.52E-02

-0.0326

-0.0326

72

2.594253

0.312251

-0.0167

-0.0167

73

1.765735

0.314049

-0.0496

-0.0496

74

2.401067

1.651112

-0.0173

-0.0173

75

2.088466

1.310921

-0.0325

-0.0325

76

2.161816

0.643252

-0.0322

-0.0322

77

2.871241

1.322493

-0.0046

-0.0046

78

2.538689

0.976194

-0.0162

-0.0162

79

3.007708

0.648874

-0.0045

-0.0045

80

0.569695

0.65713

-0.0888

-0.0888

81

1.35933

0.645984

-0.0655

-0.0655

82

1.737745

0.974734

-0.0493

-0.0493

83

0.959424

0.982544

-0.0790

-0.0791

84

1.33294

1.311242

-0.0655

-0.0656

85

1.670319

1.653599

-0.0503

-0.0503

86

0.587771

1.323758

-0.0888

-0.0888

87

0.954255

1.655226

-0.0795

-0.0796

88

0.17065

0.332528

-0.0937

-0.0937

89

-0.72028

0.330442

-0.0857

-0.0857

90

-1.17132

-3.39E-03

-0.0727

-0.0727

91

-0.27856

-6.36E-04

-0.0929

-0.0929

92

-0.72308

-0.33418

-0.0856

-0.0856

93

0.158456

-0.33133

-0.0937

-0.0938

94

-0.69452

-1.66662

-0.0871

-0.0872

95

-0.24868

-1.33244

-0.0938

-0.0939

96

-0.28039

-0.66633

-0.0929

-0.0929

97

-1.16032

-1.33406

-0.0721

-0.0721

98

-0.71449

-0.99987

-0.0857

-0.0857

99

-1.1629

-0.66811

-0.0726

-0.0726

100

1.350115

-0.66241

-0.0658

-0.0659

101

1.323646

-1.32168

-0.0659

-0.0659

102

0.948432

-0.99173

-0.0794

-0.0794

36

103

0.551778

-0.66228

-0.0891

-0.0891

104

0.179751

-0.99745

-0.0938

-0.0939

105

0.948584

-1.65789

-0.0797

-0.0798

106

0.576405

-1.3269

-0.0890

-0.0891

107

0.234535

-1.66582

-0.0950

-0.0951

108

0.240632

1.666115

-0.0950

-0.095

109

-0.69312

1.665689

-0.0872

-0.0872

110

-1.14874

1.328434

-0.0726

-0.0726

111

-1.1667

0.661903

-0.0725

-0.0725

112

-0.24118

1.331803

-0.0939

-0.0939

113

-0.71029

0.997066

-0.0858

-0.0858

114

-0.27107

0.663607

-0.0930

-0.093

115

0.198042

0.998344

-0.0937

-0.0938

116

-1.61773

0.328074

-0.0557

-0.0557

117

-2.52465

0.317511

-0.0191

-0.0191

118

-3.01245

-1.87E-02

-0.0054

-0.0054

119

-2.07297

-8.02E-03

-0.0370

-0.0369

120

-2.52616

-0.34077

-0.0190

-0.019

121

-1.6162

-0.33667

-0.0557

-0.0557

122

-1.61337

1.662745

-0.0529

-0.0529

123

-2.378

1.649592

-0.0182

-0.0182

124

-2.85256

1.322633

-0.0050

-0.005

125

-2.97923

0.650679

-0.0051

-0.0051

126

-2.01745

1.313649

-0.0356

-0.0356

127

-2.48087

0.97905

-0.0183

-0.0183

128

-2.06137

0.652832

-0.0364

-0.0364

129

-1.60025

0.990357

-0.0551

-0.0551

130

-1.62355

-1.66743

-0.0524

-0.0524

131

-2.37794

-1.65731

-0.0182

-0.0182

132

-2.02316

-1.32528

-0.0353

-0.0353

133

-1.60873

-1.0023

-0.0547

-0.0547

134

-2.05866

-0.66947

-0.0365

-0.0364

135

-2.84629

-1.34067

-0.0051

-0.0051

136

-2.47589

-0.99546

-0.0184

-0.0184

137

-2.97145

-0.68263

-0.0052

-0.0052

138

1.667633

-1.65688

-0.0504

-0.0504

37

139

2.396613

-1.66167

-0.0174

-0.0174

140

2.863124

-1.34589

-0.0047

-0.0047

141

3.000822

-0.68775

-0.0046

-0.0046

142

2.081555

-1.32562

-0.0327

-0.0328

143

2.530989

-1.00338

-0.0164

-0.0164

144

2.156636

-0.66937

-0.0324

-0.0324

145

1.73041

-0.99086

-0.0495

-0.0496

146

3.371941

1.002908

0.0000

147

3.411777

0.829725

0.0000

148

-1.63096

-2

-0.0514

-0.0514

149

-1.39436

-2

-0.0626

-0.0626

150

-3.37194

1.002908

0.0000

151

-1.15776

-2

-0.0729

-0.0729

152

-3.41178

0.829725

0.0000

153

-0.92115

-2

-0.0817

-0.0817

154

-3.44459

0.655087

0.0000

155

-3.46929

0.485756

0.0000

156

-1.63096

-0.0514

-0.0514

157

-1.39436

-0.0626

-0.0626

158

-3.48692

0.315557

0.0000

159

-3.49722

0.144757

0.0000

160

-1.15776

-0.0729

-0.0729

161

-0.92115

-0.0817

-0.0818

162

-0.68454

-2

-0.0889

-0.0889

163

-0.44793

-2

-0.0941

-0.0941

164

-0.21132

-2

-0.0972

-0.0972

165

2.53E-02

-2

-0.0981

-0.0981

166

-0.68454

-0.0889

-0.0889

167

-0.44793

-0.0941

-0.0941

168

3.444594

0.655087

0.0000

169

-0.21132

-0.0972

-0.0973

170

3.469287

0.485756

0.0000

171

2.53E-02

-0.0981

-0.0981

172

3.486922

0.315557

0.0000

173

3.49722

0.144757

0.0000

174

2.943915

-1.01866

-0.0045

-0.0045

38

175

2.767128

-1.66856

-0.0050

-0.005

176

2.030336

-1.65844

-0.0334

-0.0334

177

-2.04244

-0.99418

-0.0360

-0.0359

178

-2.00096

-1.65643

-0.0348

-0.0348

179

-2.75821

-1.66408

-0.0053

-0.0053

180

-2.9287

0.985223

-0.0050

-0.005

181

-2.76211

1.655007

-0.0052

-0.0052

182

-1.99647

1.650628

-0.0350

-0.035

183

-3.00224

-0.3507

-0.0053

-0.0053

184

-3.0066

0.313652

-0.0053

-0.0053

185

-2.07119

0.322792

-0.0368

-0.0368

186

-1.15772

0.995168

-0.0725

-0.0725

187

-1.15325

1.664217

-0.0724

-0.0725

188

-0.22625

1.665902

-0.0951

-0.0951

189

0.564091

-0.99459

-0.0889

-0.089

190

1.33688

-0.99204

-0.0658

-0.0659

191

1.307324

-1.65663

-0.0663

-0.0663

192

-0.26737

-0.99866

-0.0932

-0.0932

193

-0.23

-1.66622

-0.0951

-0.0951

194

-1.15904

-1.66703

-0.0722

-0.0722

195

-1.16711

-0.33575

-0.0728

-0.0728

196

-1.16901

0.329258

-0.0727

-0.0727

197

-0.27482

0.331485

-0.0929

-0.0929

198

1.310823

1.655621

-0.0662

-0.0662

199

1.346135

0.978613

-0.0655

-0.0655

200

0.578733

0.990444

-0.0886

-0.0887

201

2.132086

0.975933

-0.0322

-0.0322

202

2.034826

1.650066

-0.0332

-0.0333

203

2.770969

1.65737

-0.0050

-0.005

204

3.0374

0.311105

-0.0046

-0.0046

205

3.033632

-0.35463

-0.0047

-0.0047

206

2.175119

-0.34133

-0.0325

-0.0325

207

1.357474

0.317578

-0.0659

-0.066

208

1.352866

-0.33662

-0.0661

-0.0661

209

0.554898

-0.33315

-0.0891

-0.0891

210

2.127905

-0.99512

-0.0323

-0.0323

39

211

-2.92003

-1.01253

-0.0050

-0.005

212

-2.04136

0.981923

-0.0361

-0.036

213

-2.06582

-0.33874

-0.0370

-0.037

214

-0.25613

0.997705

-0.0933

-0.0933

215

0.591851

-1.66007

-0.0895

-0.0896

216

-1.16161

-1.00108

-0.0723

-0.0723

217

-0.28231

-0.33276

-0.0928

-0.0928

218

0.597943

1.658864

-0.0894

-0.0894

219

2.952989

0.985155

-0.0045

-0.0045

220

2.176396

0.3127

-0.0325

-0.0325

221

0.563857

0.326557

-0.0889

-0.0889

222

0.560938

0.161271

-0.0890

-0.089

223

0.76046

0.323571

-0.0847

-0.0847

224

0.367253

0.329543

-0.0919

-0.0919

225

0.566776

0.491843

-0.0888

-0.0889

226

2.178348

0.148733

-0.0326

-0.0326

227

2.385324

0.312476

-0.0242

-0.0242

228

1.971065

0.313375

-0.0410

-0.041

229

2.169106

0.477976

-0.0324

-0.0324

230

2.912115

1.153824

-0.0046

-0.0046

231

2.745839

0.980675

-0.0096

-0.0096

232

3.162465

0.994031

-0.0012

-0.0012

233

2.980349

0.817014

-0.0045

-0.0045

234

0.592857

1.491311

-0.0890

-0.089

235

0.776099

1.657045

-0.0849

-0.085

236

0.419287

1.662489

-0.0927

-0.0928

237

0.601056

1.829432

-0.0900

-0.0901

238

-0.28044

-0.1667

-0.0928

-0.0929

239

-0.5027

-0.33347

-0.0900

-0.09

240

-6.19E-02

-0.33204

-0.0941

-0.0941

241

-0.28135

-0.49954

-0.0928

-0.0929

242

-1.16097

-1.16757

-0.0722

-0.0722

243

-0.93805

-1.00048

-0.0797

-0.0797

244

-1.38517

-1.00169

-0.0639

-0.0639

245

-1.16225

-0.8346

-0.0725

-0.0725

246

0.770217

-1.65898

-0.0851

-0.0852

40

247

0.584128

-1.49348

-0.0892

-0.0892

248

0.598011

-1.83003

-0.0901

-0.0901

249

0.413193

-1.66294

-0.0928

-0.0929

250

-0.24866

1.164754

-0.0935

-0.0936

251

-0.48321

0.997386

-0.0904

-0.0904

252

-2.90E-02

0.998024

-0.0944

-0.0944

253

-0.2636

0.830656

-0.0931

-0.0931

254

-2.06939

-0.17338

-0.0370

-0.037

255

-2.29599

-0.33975

-0.0276

-0.0276

256

-1.84101

-0.3377

-0.0464

-0.0464

257

-2.06224

-0.5041

-0.0368

-0.0368

258

-2.02941

1.147786

-0.0359

-0.0359

259

-2.26112

0.980487

-0.0268

-0.0268

260

-1.8208

0.98614

-0.0456

-0.0456

261

-2.05136

0.817378

-0.0363

-0.0363

262

-2.88316

-1.1766

-0.0051

-0.0051

263

-2.69796

-1.004

-0.0109

-0.0109

264

-3.14109

-1.02687

-0.0013

-0.0013

265

-2.94574

-0.84758

-0.0052

-0.0051

266

2.10473

-1.16037

-0.0325

-0.0325

267

2.329447

-0.99925

-0.0240

-0.024

268

1.929157

-0.99299

-0.0409

-0.0409

269

2.14227

-0.83225

-0.0324

-0.0324

270

0.155407

-0.4973

-0.0938

-0.0938

271

0.553338

-0.49772

-0.0891

-0.0891

272

0.753119

-0.33406

-0.0849

-0.0849

273

0.757321

-5.52E-03

-0.0848

-0.0849

274

0.356677

-0.33224

-0.0920

-0.0921

275

0.556458

-0.16858

-0.0890

-0.0891

276

0.361286

-1.71E-03

-0.0920

-0.092

277

0.161504

-0.16537

-0.0937

-0.0937

278

0.951268

-0.49814

-0.0795

-0.0796

279

1.35149

-0.49952

-0.0660

-0.066

280

1.553629

-0.33745

-0.0583

-0.0583

281

1.152103

-0.33579

-0.0733

-0.0733

282

1.354242

-0.17372

-0.0662

-0.0662

41

283

0.953982

-0.171

-0.0796

-0.0796

284

1.15612

-8.93E-03

-0.0732

-0.0733

285

0.956843

0.156779

-0.0795

-0.0795

286

1.557684

-1.19E-02

-0.0583

-0.0583

287

1.762743

0.150512

-0.0499

-0.0499

288

1.356545

0.153375

-0.0661

-0.0661

289

1.561604

0.315814

-0.0580

-0.058

290

1.760876

0.478108

-0.0495

-0.0496

291

1.157269

0.319082

-0.0731

-0.0731

292

1.358402

0.481781

-0.0657

-0.0658

293

0.959853

0.485194

-0.0793

-0.0793

294

1.952835

-0.66644

-0.0410

-0.041

295

1.751712

-0.50089

-0.0499

-0.0499

296

2.365874

-0.67196

-0.0240

-0.024

297

2.165877

-0.50535

-0.0325

-0.0325

298

2.386856

-0.3444

-0.0241

-0.0241

299

2.393499

-1.66E-02

-0.0242

-0.0242

300

1.964755

-0.3398

-0.0412

-0.0412

301

2.17771

-0.17828

-0.0326

-0.0326

302

1.970026

-1.41E-02

-0.0413

-0.0413

303

1.757071

-0.17565

-0.0501

-0.0501

304

2.586852

-0.51101

-0.0165

-0.0165

305

3.017227

-0.52119

-0.0047

-0.0047

306

3.257946

-0.36133

-0.0012

-0.0012

307

2.816112

-0.35105

-0.0098

-0.0098

308

3.038776

-0.18843

-0.0047

-0.0047

309

2.602645

-0.18273

-0.0166

-0.0166

310

2.825309

-2.01E-02

-0.0099

-0.0099

311

2.600475

0.147128

-0.0167

-0.0167

312

3.271913

-2.43E-02

-0.0012

-0.0012

313

3.04066

0.144443

-0.0047

-0.0047

314

3.262161

0.313331

-0.0012

-0.0012

315

3.226151

0.651981

-0.0012

-0.0012

316

2.815827

0.311678

-0.0099

-0.0099

317

3.022554

0.47999

-0.0046

-0.0046

318

2.794092

0.646067

-0.0096

-0.0096

42

319

2.587364

0.477755

-0.0166

-0.0165

320

2.71435

1.828685

-0.0053

-0.0053

321

2.586018

1.654241

-0.0105

-0.0105

322

2.674267

1.316798

-0.0098

-0.0098

323

2.959381

1.667099

-0.0013

-0.0013

324

2.821105

1.489931

-0.0048

-0.0048

325

3.071786

1.333251

-0.0012

-0.0012

326

2.358278

1.825556

-0.0178

-0.0178

327

2.004023

1.825033

-0.0338

-0.0338

328

1.852573

1.651832

-0.0417

-0.0418

329

2.217947

1.650589

-0.0250

-0.025

330

2.061646

1.480493

-0.0329

-0.0329

331

2.43918

1.481108

-0.0169

-0.0169

332

2.282879

1.311012

-0.0242

-0.0242

333

2.507991

1.143649

-0.0164

-0.0164

334

1.898396

1.311005

-0.0410

-0.041

335

2.110276

1.143427

-0.0324

-0.0324

336

1.934916

0.975334

-0.0407

-0.0407

337

1.958916

0.642709

-0.0408

-0.0408

338

2.335388

0.976064

-0.0238

-0.0238

339

2.146951

0.809593

-0.0323

-0.0323

340

2.371146

0.643256

-0.0239

-0.0239

341

2.559583

0.809727

-0.0163

-0.0163

342

0.373221

0.660794

-0.0918

-0.0919

343

0.187394

0.831401

-0.0937

-0.0937

344

0.766169

0.653466

-0.0845

-0.0845

345

0.574214

0.823787

-0.0887

-0.0887

346

0.769079

0.986494

-0.0844

-0.0844

347

0.773622

1.320805

-0.0844

-0.0844

348

0.388387

0.994394

-0.0918

-0.0918

349

0.583252

1.157101

-0.0887

-0.0887

350

0.403554

1.327993

-0.0920

-0.092

351

0.208689

1.165286

-0.0938

-0.0939

352

1.160986

0.647893

-0.0727

-0.0727

353

0.961034

0.816173

-0.0791

-0.0791

354

1.557673

0.644075

-0.0577

-0.0577

43

355

1.746881

0.80845

-0.0494

-0.0494

356

1.352732

0.812298

-0.0655

-0.0655

357

1.54194

0.976674

-0.0576

-0.0576

358

1.723036

1.142912

-0.0494

-0.0494

359

1.15278

0.980578

-0.0727

-0.0727

360

1.339538

1.144928

-0.0655

-0.0655

361

0.959449

1.150198

-0.0790

-0.079

362

1.146207

1.314547

-0.0727

-0.0727

363

0.956864

1.486539

-0.0792

-0.0792

364

1.520633

1.311166

-0.0577

-0.0578

365

1.689323

1.482344

-0.0499

-0.0499

366

1.321882

1.483432

-0.0658

-0.0658

367

1.490571

1.65461

-0.0584

-0.0585

368

1.650641

1.8268

-0.0508

-0.0508

369

1.132539

1.655424

-0.0732

-0.0733

370

1.299767

1.827811

-0.0667

-0.0667

371

0.950347

1.827613

-0.0801

-0.0801

372

-4.72E-02

0.664032

-0.0942

-0.0942

373

0.173698

0.498493

-0.0937

-0.0937

374

-0.49497

0.663181

-0.0901

-0.0901

375

-0.27294

0.497546

-0.0929

-0.0929

376

-0.49755

0.330964

-0.0900

-0.0901

377

-0.50012

-1.25E-03

-0.0900

-0.09

378

-5.21E-02

0.332007

-0.0941

-0.0941

379

-0.27669

0.165425

-0.0929

-0.0929

380

-5.70E-02

-1.89E-05

-0.0941

-0.0941

381

0.167601

0.166563

-0.0937

-0.0937

382

-0.71958

0.496599

-0.0856

-0.0856

383

-1.16785

0.495581

-0.0726

-0.0726

384

-1.39337

0.328666

-0.0646

-0.0646

385

-0.94464

0.32985

-0.0798

-0.0798

386

-1.17016

0.162936

-0.0727

-0.0727

387

-0.72098

0.164286

-0.0857

-0.0857

388

-0.9465

-2.63E-03

-0.0798

-0.0798

389

-0.72238

-0.16803

-0.0856

-0.0856

390

-1.39614

-4.15E-03

-0.0646

-0.0646

44

391

-1.61858

-0.17079

-0.0558

-0.0558

392

-1.16921

-0.16957

-0.0728

-0.0728

393

-1.39165

-0.33621

-0.0646

-0.0646

394

-1.61289

-0.50252

-0.0556

-0.0556

395

-1.38624

-0.66824

-0.0644

-0.0644

396

-0.94509

-0.33497

-0.0798

-0.0798

397

-1.165

-0.50193

-0.0727

-0.0727

398

-0.94369

-0.6673

-0.0797

-0.0797

399

-0.72378

-0.50034

-0.0855

-0.0855

400

-1.1584

-1.83351

-0.0725

-0.0725

401

-0.92678

-1.66683

-0.0804

-0.0805

402

-0.93241

-1.33365

-0.0799

-0.0799

403

-1.3913

-1.66723

-0.0627

-0.0628

404

-1.15968

-1.50054

-0.0721

-0.0721

405

-1.38823

-1.33446

-0.0632

-0.0633

406

-0.68953

-1.83331

-0.0879

-0.0879

407

0.248231

-1.83291

-0.0957

-0.0958

408

-0.22066

-1.83311

-0.0960

-0.096

409

2.27E-03

-1.66602

-0.0961

-0.0961

410

0.220839

-1.49872

-0.0945

-0.0945

411

-0.46226

-1.66642

-0.0921

-0.0921

412

-0.23934

-1.49933

-0.0944

-0.0944

413

-0.69951

-1.49994

-0.0866

-0.0866

414

-0.47659

-1.33284

-0.0909

-0.0909

415

-0.7095

-1.16656

-0.0859

-0.0859

416

-2.08E-02

-1.33204

-0.0949

-0.095

417

-0.25803

-1.16555

-0.0934

-0.0935

418

-4.38E-02

-0.99805

-0.0944

-0.0944

419

-6.40E-02

-0.66479

-0.0941

-0.0942

420

-0.49093

-0.99927

-0.0902

-0.0903

421

-0.27388

-0.83249

-0.0930

-0.093

422

-0.50243

-0.66641

-0.0899

-0.09

423

-0.71949

-0.83318

-0.0856

-0.0856

424

1.487478

-1.65676

-0.0586

-0.0586

425

1.315485

-1.48916

-0.0660

-0.0661

426

0.949049

-1.49026

-0.0795

-0.0795

45

427

1.298017

-1.82832

-0.0667

-0.0668

428

1.127954

-1.65726

-0.0734

-0.0734

429

0.947512

-1.82895

-0.0802

-0.0802

430

1.716017

-1.15603

-0.0497

-0.0497

431

1.512635

-1.32144

-0.0581

-0.0581

432

1.739721

-0.82719

-0.0496

-0.0496

433

1.549574

-0.66296

-0.0580

-0.058

434

1.533645

-0.99145

-0.0579

-0.0579

435

1.343497

-0.82723

-0.0658

-0.0659

436

1.150655

-0.66186

-0.0731

-0.0731

437

1.330263

-1.15686

-0.0658

-0.0659

438

1.142656

-0.99189

-0.0730

-0.073

439

1.13658

-1.32216

-0.0730

-0.073

440

0.948973

-1.15718

-0.0793

-0.0793

441

0.762959

-1.32476

-0.0847

-0.0847

442

0.949814

-0.82652

-0.0794

-0.0794

443

0.751487

-0.66179

-0.0848

-0.0849

444

0.756262

-0.99316

-0.0847

-0.0847

445

0.557934

-0.82844

-0.0890

-0.089

446

0.352068

-0.66277

-0.0921

-0.0921

447

0.166055

-0.83035

-0.0938

-0.0938

448

0.570248

-1.16074

-0.0889

-0.089

449

0.371921

-0.99602

-0.0920

-0.092

450

0.193447

-1.16454

-0.0940

-0.094

451

0.391774

-1.32926

-0.0922

-0.0922

452

0.25128

1.833057

-0.0957

-0.0958

453

-0.21878

1.832951

-0.0960

-0.096

454

-0.45969

1.665795

-0.0921

-0.0921

455

-0.46893

1.332021

-0.0910

-0.091

456

7.19E-03

1.666008

-0.0961

-0.0961

457

-0.23372

1.498852

-0.0944

-0.0944

458

-1.09E-02

1.332016

-0.0949

-0.095

459

0.229984

1.499172

-0.0944

-0.0945

460

-0.68883

1.832844

-0.0879

-0.0879

461

-1.1555

1.832108

-0.0726

-0.0726

462

-1.38331

1.663481

-0.0631

-0.0631

46

463

-0.92318

1.664953

-0.0806

-0.0806

464

-1.15099

1.496325

-0.0724

-0.0725

465

-0.6949

1.498964

-0.0867

-0.0867

466

-0.92271

1.330337

-0.0801

-0.0802

467

-0.70349

1.164653

-0.0860

-0.0861

468

-1.37225

1.326962

-0.0639

-0.0639

469

-1.59801

1.157924

-0.0548

-0.0548

470

-1.15323

1.161801

-0.0725

-0.0725

471

-1.37898

0.992763

-0.0642

-0.0642

472

-1.60579

0.82386

-0.0553

-0.0553

473

-1.38902

0.659633

-0.0643

-0.0643

474

-0.934

0.996117

-0.0798

-0.0798

475

-1.16221

0.828536

-0.0725

-0.0725

476

-0.94279

0.662329

-0.0797

-0.0797

477

-0.71459

0.829911

-0.0857

-0.0857

478

-1.83635

0.655097

-0.0460

-0.0459

479

-1.61454

0.492718

-0.0556

-0.0556

480

-2.29038

0.65033

-0.0270

-0.027

481

-2.06628

0.487812

-0.0366

-0.0366

482

-2.29792

0.320152

-0.0276

-0.0276

483

-2.29898

-9.57E-03

-0.0278

-0.0278

484

-1.84446

0.325433

-0.0463

-0.0463

485

-2.07208

0.157387

-0.0369

-0.0369

486

-1.84696

-6.46E-03

-0.0464

-0.0464

487

-1.61935

0.161585

-0.0558

-0.0558

488

-2.52202

0.482669

-0.0188

-0.0188

489

-2.99291

0.482166

-0.0052

-0.0052

490

-3.24676

0.314604

-0.0014

-0.0014

491

-2.76562

0.315582

-0.0113

-0.0113

492

-3.00952

0.147455

-0.0054

-0.0054

493

-2.52482

0.153189

-0.0193

-0.0193

494

-2.76871

-1.49E-02

-0.0115

-0.0115

495

-2.52557

-0.17595

-0.0193

-0.0192

496

-3.25618

-2.25E-02

-0.0014

-0.0014

497

-3.00734

-0.18472

-0.0054

-0.0054

498

-3.24225

-0.35937

-0.0014

-0.0014

47

499

-3.20353

-0.69482

-0.0013

-0.0013

500

-2.7642

-0.34573

-0.0113

-0.0113

501

-2.98685

-0.51666

-0.0053

-0.0053

502

-2.74373

-0.67591

-0.0110

-0.011

503

-2.52108

-0.50498

-0.0188

-0.0187

504

-1.62216

1.831372

-0.0521

-0.0521

505

-1.98486

1.825314

-0.0347

-0.0347

506

-2.18724

1.65011

-0.0263

-0.0263

507

-2.22744

1.312798

-0.0265

-0.0265

508

-1.80492

1.656686

-0.0440

-0.044

509

-2.00696

1.482138

-0.0353

-0.0353

510

-1.80661

1.319569

-0.0451

-0.0451

511

-1.60457

1.494117

-0.0536

-0.0536

512

-2.34675

1.824796

-0.0183

-0.0183

513

-2.70994

1.827504

-0.0055

-0.0055

514

-2.95495

1.665918

-0.0014

-0.0014

515

-2.57006

1.6523

-0.0110

-0.011

516

-2.80734

1.48882

-0.0051

-0.0051

517

-2.40771

1.480769

-0.0181

-0.0181

518

-2.64499

1.31729

-0.0107

-0.0107

519

-2.45915

1.145499

-0.0182

-0.0182

520

-3.06245

1.333322

-0.0013

-0.0013

521

-2.89063

1.153928

-0.0050

-0.005

522

-3.15032

0.994066

-0.0013

-0.0013

523

-3.21191

0.652883

-0.0013

-0.0013

524

-2.70478

0.982137

-0.0108

-0.0108

525

-2.95396

0.817951

-0.0051

-0.0051

526

-2.74931

0.649253

-0.0109

-0.0109

527

-2.50013

0.813439

-0.0184

-0.0184

528

-2.70798

-1.83204

-0.0055

-0.0055

529

-2.56807

-1.66069

-0.0110

-0.011

530

-2.63993

-1.33306

-0.0108

-0.0108

531

-2.95046

-1.67653

-0.0014

-0.0014

532

-2.80225

-1.50238

-0.0052

-0.0052

533

-3.05511

-1.35483

-0.0013

-0.0013

534

-2.34672

-1.82865

-0.0183

-0.0183

48

535

-1.62726

-1.83372

-0.0519

-0.0519

536

-1.9871

-1.82822

-0.0346

-0.0346

537

-1.81225

-1.66193

-0.0436

-0.0436

538

-1.61985

-1.50115

-0.0529

-0.0529

539

-2.18945

-1.65687

-0.0262

-0.0262

540

-2.01206

-1.49085

-0.0351

-0.0351

541

-2.40576

-1.49138

-0.0181

-0.0181

542

-2.22837

-1.32537

-0.0264

-0.0264

543

-2.45474

-1.16046

-0.0183

-0.0183

544

-1.81965

-1.33007

-0.0445

-0.0445

545

-1.61243

-1.16858

-0.0541

-0.0541

546

-2.0328

-1.15973

-0.0357

-0.0357

547

-1.82559

-0.99824

-0.0454

-0.0454

548

-1.60915

-0.83533

-0.0551

-0.0551

549

-1.83412

-0.66892

-0.0460

-0.046

550

-2.25917

-0.99482

-0.0268

-0.0268

551

-2.05055

-0.83182

-0.0362

-0.0362

552

-2.28734

-0.66933

-0.0270

-0.027

553

-2.49595

-0.83233

-0.0184

-0.0184

554

1.649298

-1.82844

-0.0508

-0.0509

555

2.001778

-1.82922

-0.0339

-0.0339

556

2.213475

-1.66006

-0.0251

-0.0251

557

2.275689

-1.32898

-0.0244

-0.0244

558

1.848984

-1.65766

-0.0419

-0.0419

559

2.055946

-1.49203

-0.0331

-0.0331

560

1.891589

-1.32341

-0.0413

-0.0413

561

1.684628

-1.48904

-0.0501

-0.0501

562

2.356051

-1.83084

-0.0179

-0.0179

563

2.712429

-1.83428

-0.0054

-0.0054

564

2.954926

-1.67877

-0.0013

-0.0013

565

2.581871

-1.66512

-0.0105

-0.0105

566

2.815126

-1.50722

-0.0048

-0.0048

567

2.433217

-1.49701

-0.0170

-0.017

568

2.666473

-1.33912

-0.0099

-0.0099

569

2.500405

-1.16786

-0.0165

-0.0165

570

3.063527

-1.35744

-0.0012

-0.0012

49

571

2.903519

-1.18228

-0.0046

-0.0046

572

3.153037

-1.02993

-0.0012

-0.0012

573

3.218218

-0.69738

-0.0012

-0.0012

574

2.737452

-1.01102

-0.0097

-0.0097

575

2.972369

-0.85321

-0.0046

-0.0046

576

2.787967

-0.68115

-0.0097

-0.0097

577

2.55305

-0.83897

-0.0164

-0.0164

578

3.499907

-2.64E-02

0.0000

579

3.494849

-0.19738

0.0000

580

3.482261

-0.36803

0.0000

581

3.462423

-0.538

0.0000

582

0.261927

-2

-0.0967

-0.0968

583

0.433049

-2

-0.0944

-0.0944

584

0.60417

-2

-0.0909

-0.0909

585

0.775305

-2

-0.0864

-0.0864

586

0.94644

-2

-0.0809

-0.0809

587

1.117575

-2

-0.0745

-0.0745

588

-3.49991

-2.64E-02

0.0000

589

1.28871

-2

-0.0673

-0.0674

590

-3.49485

-0.19738

0.0000

591

1.459837

-2

-0.0596

-0.0596

592

-3.48226

-0.36803

0.0000

593

-3.46242

-0.538

0.0000

594

-3.43561

-0.70701

0.0000

595

-3.4021

-0.87481

0.0000

596

0.261927

-0.0967

-0.0968

597

0.433049

-0.0944

-0.0944

598

0.60417

-0.0909

-0.0909

599

0.775305

-0.0864

-0.0864

600

-3.36216

-1.0412

0.0000

601

-3.31603

-1.20597

0.0000

602

-3.26393

-1.36899

0.0000

603

-3.2061

-1.53002

0.0000

604

0.94644

-0.0809

-0.0809

605

1.117575

-0.0745

-0.0745

606

1.28871

-0.0673

-0.0674

50

607

1.459837

-0.0596

-0.0596

608

1.630964

-2

-0.0514

-0.0514

609

1.802092

-2

-0.0429

-0.043

610

1.97322

-2

-0.0344

-0.0345

611

2.144355

-2

-0.0261

-0.0261

612

2.31549

-2

-0.0183

-0.0183

613

2.48661

-2

-0.0113

-0.0113

614

1.630964

-0.0514

-0.0514

615

1.802092

-0.0429

-0.043

616

1.97322

-0.0344

-0.0345

617

2.144355

-0.0261

-0.0262

618

3.435613

-0.70701

0.0000

619

2.31549

-0.0183

-0.0183

620

3.402103

-0.87481

0.0000

621

2.48661

-0.0113

-0.0113

622

3.362159

-1.0412

0.0000

623

3.316026

-1.20597

0.0000

624

3.263931

-1.36899

0.0000

625

3.206104

-1.53002

0.0000

626

-3.14272

-1.68898

0.0000

627

-3.07397

-1.84569

0.0000

628

2.65773

-2

-0.0055

-0.0056

629

2.828865

-2

-0.0015

-0.0015

630

2.65773

-0.0055

-0.0056

631

2.828865

-0.0015

-0.0015

632

3.142724

-1.68898

0.0000

633

3.073971

-1.84569

0.0000

51

3
8 ) 52(
UZ

52

coordinate

MATLAB

ANSYS

NODE

-0.0900

-0.0888

-0.6

-0.0991

-0.0969

0.6

-0.0903

-0.0892

0.6

-0.0951

-0.0950

-0.6

0.0000

0.0000

-3

0.0000

0.0000

-2

-3

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

0.0000

-2

0.0000

0.0000

1.668231

-3.15136

0.0000

0.0000

1.326339

-3.27818

10

0.0000

0.0000

0.975804

-3.37865

11

0.0000

0.0000

0.618337

-3.45055

12

0.0000

0.0000

0.283074

-3.48946

13

0.0000

0.0000

1.668231

3.151357

14

0.0000

0.0000

1.326339

3.278183

15

0.0000

0.0000

0.975804

3.378653

16

0.0000

0.0000

0.618337

3.450552

17

0.0000

0.0000

0.283074

3.489456

18

-0.0095

-0.0095

-2.51282

19

-0.0315

-0.0307

-2.02563

20

-0.0558

-0.0540

-1.53845

21

-0.0773

-0.0749

-1.05126

22

-0.0890

-0.0860

-0.71366

23

-0.0966

-0.0932

-0.37605

24

-0.0993

-0.0958

-3.84E-02

25

-0.0066

-0.0082

-2

-2.51282

26

-0.0202

-0.0238

-2

-2.02563

27

-0.0407

-0.0459

-2

-1.53845

28

29

-1.05126

-2

-0.0668

-0.0612

30

-0.71366

-2

-0.0787

-0.0734

31

-0.37605

-2

-0.0868

-0.0822

32

-3.84E-02

-2

-0.0904

-0.0867

33

0.15

0.45

-0.0972

-0.0992

34

-0.45

0.15

-0.0930

-0.0946

35

-0.15

-0.45

-0.0951

-0.0955

36

0.45

-0.15

-0.0927

-0.0936

37

-1.59314

0.317093

-0.0537

-0.0534

38

0.557049

-1.2446

-0.0858

-0.0849

39

-1.62587

0.984914

-0.0521

-0.0528

40

1.409196

-1.12008

-0.0598

-0.0593

41

-1.43632

1.460388

-0.0593

-0.0608

42

0.149579

1.3

-0.0937

-0.0963

43

1.12479

-0.0717

-0.0729

44

2.101295

0.373015

-0.0339

-0.0337

45

2.388422

-0.84855

-0.0212

-0.0210

46

1.529387

-1.56004

-0.0536

-0.0528

47

0.421972

-1.6088

-0.0875

-0.0858

48

-0.68994

-1.31796

-0.0809

-0.0780

49

-1.806

-0.98309

-0.0412

-0.0380

50

-2.50283

-0.23935

-0.0182

-0.0173

51

-2.54164

0.821006

-0.0159

-0.0158

52

1.004598

-0.56004

-0.0758

-0.0759

53

-0.76359

0.937115

-0.0835

-0.0853

54

-1.09657

0.158547

-0.0728

-0.0730

55

0.278524

-0.9223

-0.0911

-0.0907

56

-1.69377

0.587982

-0.0497

-0.0497

57

0.947828

-1.17121

-0.0760

-0.0754

58

2.416742

-1.43315

-0.0170

-0.0167

59

-0.14149

-1.45764

-0.0897

-0.0875

60

-0.57521

1.409053

-0.0879

-0.0904

61

0.683471

1.191588

-0.0854

-0.0874

62

-0.93924

0.528752

-0.0788

-0.0798

53

63

0.656127

-0.71966

-0.0854

-0.0854

64

0.988962

-1.61033

-0.0740

-0.0729

65

-2.33615

1.409582

-0.0205

-0.0208

66

-2.61069

0.272515

-0.0151

-0.0145

67

2.221641

-0.26254

-0.0294

-0.0291

68

2.152671

1.104553

-0.0291

-0.0289

69

-2.16755

-0.60584

-0.0290

-0.0272

70

-1.25827

-1.18774

-0.0620

-0.0583

71

-0.9741

-1.25285

-0.0724

-0.0691

72

-0.77913

-0.74387

-0.0811

-0.0799

73

-1.64195

-1.59387

-0.0437

-0.0390

74

-1.53213

-1.08542

-0.0520

-0.0481

75

-2.403

-1.49155

-0.0144

-0.0125

76

-2.71424

-0.99181

-0.0089

-0.0082

77

-1.98678

-0.79446

-0.0349

-0.0326

78

-1.203

-0.49155

-0.0674

-0.0658

79

-2.33519

-0.42259

-0.0234

-0.0221

80

-1.63206

-0.22365

-0.0512

-0.0498

81

2.23873

1.552276

-0.0230

-0.0227

82

1.63873

1.052276

-0.0513

-0.0519

83

2.715427

1.215446

-0.0085

-0.0080

84

2.126983

0.738784

-0.0317

-0.0315

85

1.350647

0.186508

-0.0644

-0.0649

86

1.61312

-0.41129

-0.0537

-0.0537

87

2.305032

-0.55554

-0.0254

-0.0252

88

2.161468

5.52E-02

-0.0319

-0.0316

89

2.860624

-0.1584

-0.0083

-0.0081

90

2.775924

0.495676

-0.0099

-0.0095

91

-2.96756

-0.48234

-0.0050

-0.0048

92

-3.05515

0.109126

-0.0041

-0.0039

93

-2.55676

1.66E-02

-0.0168

-0.0160

94

-2.04798

3.89E-02

-0.0353

-0.0341

95

-2.57616

0.546761

-0.0156

-0.0153

54

96

-2.15223

0.430249

-0.0311

-0.0305

97

-2.9961

0.719671

-0.0043

-0.0042

98

-2.80717

1.36796

-0.0057

-0.0057

99

-2.4389

1.115294

-0.0181

-0.0182

100

-2.08375

0.90296

-0.0329

-0.0330

101

-2.18089

1.704791

-0.0252

-0.0258

102

-1.88623

1.434985

-0.0395

-0.0404

103

0.981666

-1.80517

-0.0742

-0.0728

104

1.259175

-1.58519

-0.0645

-0.0635

105

0.705467

-1.60956

-0.0820

-0.0806

106

0.968395

-1.39077

-0.0750

-0.0741

107

0.752438

-1.2079

-0.0814

-0.0807

108

1.178512

-1.14565

-0.0684

-0.0678

109

1.206897

-0.84006

-0.0682

-0.0679

110

0.801978

-0.94544

-0.0808

-0.0805

111

0.830363

-0.63985

-0.0810

-0.0811

112

0.802299

-0.28002

-0.0828

-0.0834

113

0.467326

-0.82098

-0.0889

-0.0887

114

0.478064

-0.50983

-0.0902

-0.0906

115

-1.65982

0.786448

-0.0510

-0.0514

116

-1.64345

0.452538

-0.0518

-0.0516

117

-1.34485

0.23782

-0.0635

-0.0633

118

-1.3165

0.558367

-0.0650

-0.0655

119

-1.0179

0.343649

-0.0760

-0.0766

120

-0.84828

7.93E-02

-0.0813

-0.0818

121

-0.85141

0.732933

-0.0813

-0.0827

122

-0.61962

0.414376

-0.0882

-0.0897

123

0.862395

0.5

-0.0812

-0.0825

124

1.387184

1.5

-0.0608

-0.0619

125

0.90413

1.095794

-0.0791

-0.0808

126

0.82892

1.595794

-0.0811

-0.0832

127

0.491735

0.745794

-0.0904

-0.0924

128

0.416525

1.245794

-0.0907

-0.0932

129

7.48E-02

0.95

-0.0949

-0.0974

55

130

-0.38179

0.768557

-0.0925

-0.0945

131

0.224369

1.65

-0.0934

-0.0963

132

-0.21282

1.354527

-0.0933

-0.0959

133

-0.47563

1.704527

-0.0904

-0.0933

134

-1.24379

1.730194

-0.0670

-0.0689

135

-0.6694

1.173084

-0.0858

-0.0879

136

-1.00577

1.434721

-0.0759

-0.0779

137

-1.53109

1.222651

-0.0557

-0.0568

138

-1.19473

0.961015

-0.0695

-0.0708

139

0.417786

-1.08345

-0.0886

-0.0879

140

0.48951

-1.4267

-0.0866

-0.0854

141

0.139262

-0.76115

-0.0932

-0.0930

142

-0.34497

-0.95898

-0.0894

-0.0884

143

6.85E-02

-1.18997

-0.0910

-0.0899

144

-0.41571

-1.3878

-0.0866

-0.0841

145

-0.8706

-1.65898

-0.0744

-0.0699

146

0.140242

-1.53322

-0.0900

-0.0881

147

-0.25877

-1.72882

-0.0883

-0.0851

148

0.360565

-1.8044

-0.0883

-0.0862

149

1.589483

-1.78002

-0.0503

-0.0493

150

2.370766

-1.71658

-0.0169

-0.0166

151

2.838838

-1.40547

-0.0046

-0.0046

152

2.910355

-0.78694

-0.0058

-0.0057

153

1.973065

-1.4966

-0.0346

-0.0341

154

2.402582

-1.14085

-0.0192

-0.0190

155

1.898809

-0.98432

-0.0402

-0.0400

156

1.469292

-1.34006

-0.0567

-0.0561

157

3.499607

-5.43E-02

0.0000

0.0000

158

3.479984

-0.39119

0.0000

0.0000

159

0.299158

-2

-0.0895

-0.0868

160

0.636764

-2

-0.0840

-0.0819

161

0.97437

-2

-0.0746

-0.0730

162

1.311975

-2

-0.0619

-0.0607

56

163

0.299158

-0.0939

-0.0971

164

0.636764

-0.0875

-0.0901

165

0.3

0.3

-0.0960

-0.0977

166

0.97437

-0.0774

-0.0795

167

1.311975

-0.0638

-0.0652

168

0.45

0.15

-0.0931

-0.0945

169

-0.3

0.3

-0.0959

-0.0977

170

-0.15

0.45

-0.0971

-0.0991

171

0.3

-0.3

-0.0951

-0.0958

172

0.15

-0.45

-0.0959

-0.0963

173

1.649579

-2

-0.0469

-0.0459

174

1.987185

-2

-0.0313

-0.0306

175

1.649579

-0.0480

-0.0489

176

-3.49961

-5.43E-02

0.0000

0.0000

177

1.987185

-0.0316

-0.0320

178

-3.47998

-0.39119

0.0000

0.0000

179

-3.43229

-0.72532

0.0000

0.0000

180

-3.35862

-1.0547

0.0000

0.0000

181

3.432287

-0.72532

0.0000

0.0000

182

3.358625

-1.0547

0.0000

0.0000

183

3.260935

-1.37779

0.0000

0.0000

184

2.32479

-0.0161

-0.0159

185

3.140922

-1.69328

0.0000

0.0000

186

2.662395

-0.0045

-0.0041

187

-3.26093

-1.37779

0.0000

0.0000

188

-3.14092

-1.69328

0.0000

0.0000

189

2.32479

-2

-0.0165

-0.0161

190

-0.3

-0.3

-0.0938

-0.0946

191

-0.45

-0.15

-0.0919

-0.0932

192

2.662395

-2

-0.0048

-0.0045

57

58

You might also like