Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
4Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
CDCA ECF 593-2 2013-04-02 - Liberi v Taitz - Exhibit 2 to Response to OSC

CDCA ECF 593-2 2013-04-02 - Liberi v Taitz - Exhibit 2 to Response to OSC

Ratings: (0)|Views: 31|Likes:
Published by Jack Ryan
CDCA ECF 593-2 2013-04-02 - Liberi v Taitz - Exhibit 2 to Response to OSC
CDCA ECF 593-2 2013-04-02 - Liberi v Taitz - Exhibit 2 to Response to OSC

More info:

Categories:Types, Research
Published by: Jack Ryan on Feb 05, 2013
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

02/06/2013

pdf

text

original

 
I
a
L
s
4
5
6
I
I
9
10
1l
t2
13
t4
15
I6
I7
l8l9
20
2Ln')
LL
11
24
?5262728
D.
JAY
RITT,
State
Bar
No.
138661
RITT,
TAI,
THVEDT
&
HODGES
A
Limited
Liabilitv
Partnershin65
Norttr RaymondAvenue,Silite
320Pasadena,
Califomia
91103
Tel:
(626)68s-2s50
Fax:
(626)685-2562
-:-*FfilrbiEffi+:r,,^
Noy
02
20t2
Case
No.
30-2012-005
82135
lAssignedto:Hon.
Charles
Marginis
-
Dept.
C-191
NOTICE
OB
RULING
Date:
Novernber
1,2012
Time:
1:30 o,m.
Dept;
C-19^
Attorneys
for
Third-Party
Respondent
OCCIDENTAL
COLLEGE
SUPERIOR
COI]RT
OF
THE
STATE
OT'CALIFORNIA
COUNTY
OF
ORANGE
-
CENTBAL DIVISION
ORLY
TAITZ,Plaintiff,
v,
BARACKOBAMA, DIANE
FEiNSTEIN,
ELIZABETHEMKEN,DAN
HUGHES,
RICK
MLLIAMS,
iN
their capaciil
as
candidatesonthe
ballot,
JOFIN
DOE;
JANE
DoE
l-100,
Defendants.
TO
ALL
PARTIESANDTO
TI{EIR
ATTORNEYSOF RECORD
HEREIN:
PLEASE
TAKE NOTICE
that on
November Lr}frLz,at
1:30p.m.n
inDepartment
"C19"
of
the
above-entitled
court,
Plaintiff's
Ex
Parte
Motion
for Production
ofDocuments
from
Third
Party OccidentaiCollege
was
held
in
the
above-oaptioned
action
beforethe
Honorable
Charles
Marginis.Attomey
D.
JAY
RITT
ofRitt,
Tai, Thvedt
&
Hodges
specially
appearedon
behalf
of
Third
Parlry
Respondent
OCCIDENTAL
COLLbGE;
and
plaintiff
ORLY
TAI'IZ
appeared
ir-pro
per.
CARL
BOTTERIID,
GeneralCounsel
of
OcoidentalCollege,
wasalsopresent
in
the
courtroom.
There
werenoothcr
appearances
by
anydefendantor
respondingparty,
NOTICE
OF
RULING
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG-AJW Document 593-2 Filed 02/04/13 Page 1 of 3 Page ID#:15723
 
1
2
1
4
5
6
7
I
I
l0
ll
12
i3
t4
15
l6
t7
r8
19
20
2t
')')
23
24?5
2627
28
The Court having
read
the
pepsrs
and
pleadings
filed
by
Plaintiff
Orly Taitz
and
Third
PartyRespondent
Occidental College,
and
having
consideredthe
oral
argumcnt
of
counsel
at
thehearingon
this
m&tter, made
the
following
findings:
(a)
Ms.
Taitz'"ex
parte"motion
to compel
production
ofrecordsfrom
third-partyOccidentalCollcge
wasprepared,
frled
and
servedbefore
Ms.'l'aitz
even
prepared,
frled
and
served
an
underlying
subpoenaduces
tecum
itself;
(b)
The"ex
palte"
motion
refers
to
a
request
for
documents pursuant
to
California
Code
of Civil
Procedure
Section 2031.3I0
which
applies
by
itsterms
only to
parties
and
OccidentalCollege
is
not
a
partyinthis action;
(c)
The
subpoena
which
Ms.
Taitz
didultimately
prepareand serye
(after
her
ex
parte
"motion")
does
not
meetnumerous requirernents
of California
Code
of
Civil
Procedure
Section
2020.510, in
thaL amongother
things;
(d)
The
proofof
service
provided
by
Plaintiff
reflects
that the
subpoena
was
served
upon
OccidentalCollegeonOctober31,2A72,grvingOccidentalpurportedly
less
than
twenty-four
hours
notice
to
comply indirect
conflictwith
the
noticeprovisions
of
Section
2020.510;
(e)
The
proof of
service
provided
by
Plaintiffreflects
that
the
subpoena
wasimproperly
seryed
bye-mail;
(f)
The
subpoena
was
not
accompaniedby any
Notice of
Consumer
Privacy Rights
pursuant
toCalifornia
Code
of
Civil
Procedure Section
1985,3,
which
by its
terms applics
to
con$umerrecords sought
from
a
school
such
as
OccidentalCollege;
(g)
The
documents
and
records sought
are
plainly
confidential
and
protected
as
private
and
are
not reievantto
the
claims
atissue
inthis matter;
and
(h)
Even
had
the subpoena
been
properly
and
timely
prepared
and
served,
and
cven
if
the
subpoenasoughtrecords otherwise
properly
discoverable,the
relief
sought
caffrot
be
obtained
viaexparte
applicationpet CaliforniaRule of
Court
3.1200.
NOTICE
OFRULINC
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG-AJW Document 593-2 Filed 02/04/13 Page 2 of 3 Page ID#:15724

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->