For more in\ue000ormation or to be placed on our mailing list, visit our website: www.interbranddesign\ue000orum.com and
complete the contact \ue000orm. Reprints o\ue000 articles or excerpts without the express written permission o\ue000 Interbrand Design
Forum is prohibited. Ideations will print 4 times in 2009. Subscriptions: $125 annually in the U.S.; $150 elsewhere.
Chairman\u2019s Commentary
A Retail Publication by
7575 Paragon Road, Dayton, Ohio 45459
P +1 937 439 4400
F +1 937 439 4340
retail@design\ue000orum.com
D. Lee Carpenter, Chairman & CEO
Jill Davis, Editor
Mike England, Design/Production
\u00a9 2009
Ideations
The recovery outlook is slow
with a chance o\ue002 innovation.
The Remaking
of Retail
It\u2019s going to be a tough year. Headlines call-
ing out \u201cthe epochal crisis o\ue003 capitalism on a
global scale\u201d will be served up every morn-
ing with break\ue003ast. Wrenching job layo\ue001s
and business closings will be waiting on the
desk at work, and the actions o\ue003 a new U.S.
president calling \ue003or \u201csacri\ue002ce\u201d will dominate
the conversation over evening drinks.
But even as we dig in \ue003or a prolonged down-
turn, we\u2019re already anxious to know what
awaits us when the dust settles. Will retail
ever be the same again?
That, o\ue003 course, depends on people.
Americans are expected to be hit with 2 mil-
lion more job losses in 2009 along with the
combined loss o\ue003 $10 trillion in household
assets. A con\ue003rontation with our debt culture
and broken health insurance system has had
a sobering e\ue001ect on us.
We\u2019re trading down instead o\ue003 trading up,
repairing instead o\ue003 replacing, dining in
instead o\ue003 out, and all in all revalidating our
brand experiences according to value. While
\ue003rugality is good \ue003or consumers, it\u2019s bad
\ue003or retailers.
Lee Scott, outgoing president and CEO o\ue003
Walmart Stores, believes that people have,
indeed, \ue003undamentally changed and are not
\u201cgoing to have the same immediate desire to
go back to consumption and debt.\u201d
For many consumers, that will be true. But
\ue003or others, this is just a speed bump. They\u2019ll
return to their \ue003avorite luxury brands mixed
with mass purchases as soon as they begin
to see their home and stock equity rebound.
In the meantime, however, as stores
vanish with consumer assets, we\u2019ll see a
recalibration o\ue003 retail happening over the
next several years. Weaker players will
continue to close underper\ue003orming stores or
consolidate. And as usual, private equity will
have its eyes on the real estate.
New store concepts will most likely have
smaller \ue003ootprints, greater energy e\ue000ciency
and reduced inventory that gives shoppers
optimum choice instead o\ue003 endless choice.
A di\ue001erentiated experience with heightened
customer service in more exciting surround-
ings will be one o\ue003 the strategies adopted to
engage shoppers. We\u2019re currently advising
our clients to allocate resources to improve
the shopping experience, with a\ue001ordable
but meaning\ue003ul innovations designed to
encourage an extra cash register ring and
inspire loyalty.
The winning retail brands will be those that
adopt strategies in\ue003ormed by shopper in-
sights to re\ue003resh their brands, invest in store
enhancements in key markets and evolve
the value proposition to meet the changed
behaviors o\ue003 their particular segment.
In all these decisions, it will be vital \ue003or retail-
ers to in\ue003orm themselves with new shopper
insights. Because we might be looking at a
cultural change as \ue002nancial conservatism
dovetails with another macrotrend, conser-
vation and sustainability.
It\u2019s hard to imagine Americans adopting \ue003ru-
gality \ue003or its own sake, but with a larger goal
in mind, a signi\ue002cant segment o\ue003 the popu-
lation may shi\ue003t the paradigm. And since
retailers and shoppers infuence one another
mutually, retail may pro\ue002t \ue003rom the change
by helping shoppers \u201cindulge in thri\ue003t\u201d and be
good stewards o\ue003 what they have.
Thri\ue003t is a means o\ue003 thriving by applying \u201cthe
discipline o\ue003 wisest use\u201d\u2014something we rou-
tinely recommend to our clients. The record
number o\ue003 \ue003reezers sold last year to consum-
ers who\u2019ve switched to buying consumables
in bulk might be an indicator o\ue003 the search
\ue003or a smarter way to live well.
According to behavioral economic theory,
advance purchases like a case o\ue003 wine are
thought o\ue003 as investments rather than
spending. And consumption o\ue003 a good
purchased earlier\u2014a bottle o\ue003 wine served
at dinner\u2014is considered a savings, and even
thought o\ue003 as \ue003ree.
So the good news is, we\u2019ll still be consuming,
just \ue003raming things di\ue001erently.
Meanwhile, resources are limited and ten-
sion is high. The time is ripe \ue003or innovation,
and I\u2019m hoping to see a world-upending
idea or two be\ue003ore it\u2019s over. We\u2019ve got new
media, demographics and ideologies\u2014next
is new retail.
Thought\ue003ully,
D. Lee Carpenter
Leave a Comment