Professional Documents
Culture Documents
บทที่ 4
บทที่ 4
681 165
3 5 1
1 6 1
3 1 6
1 686 135
571 83.24
4
1
2
3
1
5
6
3 6
135 571
135 135
6 135 3 111
6 55 571
(frequency) (percentage) 1
81
1.
2.
6
3
6
3.
4.
(n = 571)
94
477
571
16.46
83.54
100.00
135
135
135
111
55
571
23.64
23.64
23.64
19.44
9.64
100.00
378
178
15
571
66.20
31.17
2.63
100.00
329
172
70
571
57.62
30.12
12.26
100.00
1
477 83.54 94 16.46
6 135 23.64
6 55 9.64
378 66.20 15
82
( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
2
83
2 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 571)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
1261.58 271.010
11.341
0.2148
66.40
1117.73 227.035
9.501
0.2031
69.86
297.45
82.784
3.464
0.2783
74.36
743.68
113.857
4.765
0.1531
82.63
3420.33 622.330
26.044
0.1820
73.31
335.76
103.885
4.347
0.3094
67.15
369.87
85.733
3.588
0.2318
73.97
281.87
136.562
5.715
0.4845
56.37
252.58
89.547
3.747
0.3545
63.15
1240.08 366.251
15.327
0.2953
65.16
84
(C.V.) 0.2318 1
(C.V.) 0.3094 4
(C.V.) 0.3545 3
(C.V.) 0.4845
2.1
1 (Q = 19)
2.1 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 1 ( n = 571)
1
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
2
(
1 )
7.
8.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
18
55.14
19.321
.809
0.3504
55.14
17
56.04
19.190
.803
0.3424
56.04
15
58.27
18.785
.786
0.3224
58.27
14
59.36
19.276
.807
0.3247
59.36
19
50.14
20.463
.856
0.4081
50.14
16
56.38
23.187
.970
0.4113
56.38
13
61.89
19.985
.836
0.3229
61.89
73.61
17.020
.712
0.3504
73.61
86
( n = 571)
1
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
72.43
16.584
.694
0.2312
72.43
74.39
16.377
.685
0.2290
74.39
69.59
17.393
.728
0.2202
69.59
12
64.53
17.543
.734
0.2499
64.53
69.67
16.516
.691
0.2719
69.67
78.69
14.155
.592
0.2371
78.69
73.86
14.248
.596
0.1799
73.86
10
69.01
18.632
.780
0.1929
69.01
76.73
17.418
.729
0.2700
76.73
11
66.28
19.472
.815
0.2270
66.28
75.59
16.050
.672
0.2938
75.59
11.341
0.2148
66.40
1261.58 271.010
87
2.1 1
66.40
14.
78.69 17.
76.73
5.
50.14
2.2
2 (Q = 16)
2.2 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 2
( n = 571)
2
(Q = 15)
1.
2.
3.
4. (ICT)
(Online)
(Offline)
5.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
11
63.66
21.550
.902
0.3385
63.66
13
60.67
18.596
.778
0.3065
60.67
15
57.85
23.392
.979
0.4044
57.85
12
61.87
21.675
.907
0.3503
61.87
74.24
15.825
.662
0.2132
74.24
88
( n = 571)
2
(Q = 15)
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
1 2 .
ICT
13.
14.
15.
16.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
16
57.22
23.899
1.000
0.4177
57.22
70.15
19.575
.819
0.2790
70.15
14
59.54
21.789
.912
0.3660
59.54
80.39
16.290
.682
0.2026
80.39
83.48
15.054
.630
0.1803
83.48
74.53
11.863
.496
0.1592
74.53
82.69
16.965
.701
0.2052
82.69
71.73
17.703
.741
0.2468
71.73
10
67.46
21.725
.909
0.3220
67.46
74.26
16.319
.683
0.2198
74.26
79.05
15.930
.667
0.2015
79.05
1044.25 223.411
9.349
0.2139
69.86
89
90
2.3 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 3
( n = 571)
3
(Q = 4)
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
1.
2.
3.
4.
76.05
39.418
1.650
0.5183
76.05
76.39
18.104
.758
0.2370
76.39
75.20
20.207
.846
0.2687
75.20
73.10
18.627
.780
0.2548
73.10
297.45
82.784
3.464
0.2783
74.36
73.10
2.4
4 (Q = 9)
2.4 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 4
( n = 571)
4
(Q = 9)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
82.36
14.815
.620
0.1799
82.36
81.23
14.058
.588
0.1731
81.23
82.24
14.502
.607
0.1763
82.24
83.36
13.546
.567
0.1625
83.36
82.31
15.221
.637
0.1849
82.31
92
( n = 571)
4
(Q = 9)
6.
7.
8.
9.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
85.99
13.036
.546
0.1516
85.99
79.97
05.882
.665
0.0736
79.97
82.71
14.716
.616
0.1779
82.71
83.50
14.055
.588
0.1683
83.50
743.68
113.857
4.765
0.1531
82.63
93
2.5
1 (Q = 5)
2.5 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 1
( n = 571)
1
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
73.66
24.438
1.023
0.3318
73.66
76.17
19.647
.822
0.2579
76.17
62.92
28.719
1.202
0.4564
62.92
56.90
30.485
1.276
0.5358
56.90
67.47
23.752
.994
0.3520
67.47
335.76
103.885
4.347
0.3094
67.15
76.17 1.
73.66
4.
56.90
2.6
2
(Q = 5)
95
2.6 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 2
( n = 571)
2
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D. Error
Mean
C.V.
75.85
18.937
.792
0.2497
75.85
73.53
18.816
.787
0.2559
73.53
74.88
18.013
.754
0.2406
74.88
78.58
17.277
.723
0.2199
78.58
67.59
24.503
1.025
0.3625
67.59
369.87
85.733
3.588
0.2318
73.97
96
2.6 2
73.97
4.
78.58 1.
75.85
5.
67.59
2.7
3 (Q = 5)
97
2.7 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 3
( n = 571)
3
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
63.39
51.143
2.140
0.8068
63.39
59.22
27.060
1.132
0.4569
59.22
54.12
30.193
1.264
0.5579
54.12
56.45
28.678
1.200
0.5080
56.45
49.17
30.837
1.290
0.6272
49.17
281.87
136.562
5.715
0.4845
56.37
5.
49.17
2.8
4 (Q = 4)
2.8 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%) 4
( n = 571)
4
1.
2.
3.
4.
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
60.91
26.513
1.110
0.4353
60.91
65.50
23.207
.971
0.3543
65.50
67.21
22.023
.922
0.3277
67.21
58.97
26.421
1.106
0.4480
58.97
252.58
89.547
3.747
0.3545
63.15
99
2.8 4
63.15
3.
67.21 2.
65.50 4.
58.97
3
100
3 (%)
1
66.39
(Q = 19)
2
70.18
(Q = 16)
3
73.23
(Q = 4)
4
83.24
(Q = 9)
71.41
( n = 571)
69.69
70.91
68.87
64.00
65.16
63.71
64.33
57.68
66.98
72.02
75.10
68.74
68.50
68.13
67.32
65.72
60.75
70.32
78.42
80.20
77.99
76.54
66.35
69.93
77.38
63.31
76.75
85.29
85.43
84.29
82.29
78.50
82.44
77.69
75.39
84.37
74.16
75.82
72.56
70.00
68.76
68.98
68.44
62.53
72.21
( n = 571)
1
72.38
75.72
70.48
67.12
57.15
67.55
(Q = 5)
2
74.18
81.93
79.45
71.00
69.96
74.51
(Q = 5)
3
53.47
53.32
63.99
62.27
57.58
53.71
(Q = 5)
4
67.88
68.07
69.20
66.15
58.02
62.24
(Q = 4)
64.71
67.17
72.81
70.42
65.51
59.42
65.16
64.17
57.23
66.89
76.36
67.23
62.40
72.07
53.78
61.83
49.60
62.93
59.51
59.59
54.38
64.00
63.99
63.43
56.04
66.12
3.1
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.1
103
3.1 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 211)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
1261.47 274.291
18.883
0.2174
66.39
1123.93 233.324
16.063
0.2076
70.18
292.91
79.845
5.497
0.2726
73.23
749.50
109.420
7.533
0.1460
83.24
3427.82 620.309
42.704
0.1810
71.41
334.82
111.366
7.667
0.3326
67.55
372.54
85.909
5.914
0.2306
74.51
267.35
139.072
9.574
0.5202
53.47
248.96
92.716
6.383
0.3724
62.24
1223.72 383.028
26.369
0.3130
64.71
3.1
71.41
4
83.24 3
73.23 2 70.18
1 66.39
64.71
2
74.51 1 67.55
4 62.24 3
53.47
3.2
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
3.2
105
3.2 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 56)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
1324.02 229.504
30.669
0.1733
69.69
1158.30 214.894
28.716
0.1855
72.02
313.66
64.642
8.638
0.2061
78.42
767.59
99.590
13.308
0.1297
85.29
3563.57 531.149
70.978
0.1490
74.16
360.71
81.967
10.953
0.2272
72.38
370.89
85.579
11.436
0.2307
74.18
266.61
131.575
17.582
0.4935
53.32
271.52
76.408
10.210
0.2814
67.88
1269.73 333.994
44.632
0.2630
67.17
3.2
74.16
4
85.29 3
78.42 2 72.02
1 69.69
67.17
2
74.18 1 72.38
4 67.88 3
53.32
3.3
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.3
107
3.3 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 75)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Mean
Basic Statistics
Std.
S.D.
Error
Mean
C.V.
1347.27 197.098
22.759
0.1463
70.91
1202.00 167.158
19.302
0.1391
75.10
320.80
54.834
6.332
0.1709
80.20
768.87
97.802
11.293
0.1272
85.43
3638.93 462.407
53.394
0.1271
75.82
375.93
72.786
8.405
0.1936
75.72
409.67
62.700
7.240
0.1531
81.93
319.93
100.362
11.589
0.3137
63.99
272.27
73.440
8.480
0.2697
68.07
1377.80 256.323
29.598
0.1860
72.81
3.3
75.82
4
85.43 3
80.20 2 75.10
1 70.91
72.81
2
81.93 1 75.72
4 68.07 3
63.99
3.4
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.4
109
3.4 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 33)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Basic Statistics
Mean
S.D.
Std. Error
Mean
C.V.
1308.48 335.087
58.331
0.2561
68.87
1103.79 230.750
40.168
0.2091
68.74
311.97
71.872
12.511
0.2304
77.99
758.64
132.384
23.045
0.1745
84.29
3482.88 687.199
119.626
0.1973
72.56
354.09
102.297
17.808
0.2889
70.48
397.27
83.872
14.600
0.2111
79.45
311.36
107.553
18.723
0.3454
62.27
276.82
83.533
14.541
0.3018
69.20
1339.55 304.837
53.065
0.2276
70.42
3.4
72.56
4
84.29 3
77.99 1 68.87 2
68.74
70.42
2
79.45 1 70.48
4 69.20 3
62.27
3.5
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.5
111
3.5 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 26)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
(Q = 5)
Basic Statistics
Mean
S.D.
Std. Error
Mean
C.V.
1215.96 233.791
45.850
0.1923
64.00
1100.96 180.865
35.470
0.1643
68.50
306.15
65.868
12.918
0.2151
76.54
740.58
111.214
21.811
0.1502
82.29
3363.65 513.686
100.742
0.1527
70.00
331.15
91.393
17.924
0.2760
67.12
355.00
71.568
14.036
0.2016
71.00
287.88
112.785
22.119
0.3918
57.58
264.62
68.307
13.396
0.2581
66.15
1238.65 297.108
58.268
0.2399
65.51
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
112
3.5
70.00
4
82.29 3
76.54 2
68.50 1 64.00
65.51
2
71.00 1
67.12 4 66.15
3 57.58
3.6
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.6
113
3.6 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 24)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Basic Statistics
Mean
S.D.
Std. Error
Mean
C.V.
1238.13 292.225
59.650
0.2360
65.16
1095.63 215.817
44.053
0.1970
68.13
265.42
88.905
18.148
0.3350
66.35
706.46
118.574
24.204
0.1678
78.50
3305.63 671.072
136.982
0.2030
68.76
279.38
90.305
18.433
0.3232
57.15
344.79
77.747
15.870
0.2255
69.96
268.54
129.165
26.366
0.4810
53.71
232.08
84.698
17.289
0.3650
58.02
1124.79 334.945
68.370
0.2978
59.42
3.6
68.76
4
78.50 2
68.13 3 66.35
1 65.16
59.42
2
69.96 4 58.02
1 57.15
3 53.71
3.7
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.7
115
3.7 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 36)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Basic Statistics
Mean
S.D.
Std. Error
Mean
C.V.
1210.56 237.868
39.645
0.1965
63.71
1091.39 218.356
36.393
0.2001
67.32
279.72
75.450
12.575
0.2697
69.93
741.94
65.871
10.978
0.0888
82.44
3323.61 539.773
89.962
0.1624
68.98
321.67
105.992
17.665
0.3295
65.16
381.81
78.122
13.020
0.2046
76.36
268.89
137.400
22.900
0.5110
53.78
238.06
103.643
17.274
0.4354
59.51
1210.42 394.719
65.787
0.3261
63.99
3.7
68.98
4
82.44 3
69.93 2 67.32
1 63.71
63.99
2
76.36 1 65.16
4 59.51 3
53.78
3.8
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.8
117
3.8 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 40)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Basic Statistics
Mean
S.D.
Std. Error
Mean
C.V.
1222.25 278.443
44.026
0.2278
64.33
1058.00 243.684
38.530
0.2303
65.72
309.50
150.208
23.750
0.4853
77.38
699.25
125.005
19.765
0.1788
77.69
3289.00 700.202
110.712
0.2129
68.44
320.00
106.139
16.782
0.3317
64.17
336.13
89.725
14.187
0.2669
67.23
309.13
224.990
35.574
0.7278
61.83
238.38
101.744
16.087
0.4268
59.59
1203.62 463.628
73.306
0.3852
63.43
3.8
68.44
4
77.69 3
77.38 2 65.72
1 64.33
63.43
2
67.23 1 64.17
3 61.83 4
59.59
3.9
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.9
119
3.9 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 40)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Basic Statistics
Mean
S.D.
Std. Error
Mean
C.V.
1096.00 296.542
46.887
0.2706
57.68
979.00
265.345
41.955
0.2710
60.75
253.25
79.118
12.510
0.3124
63.31
678.50
151.392
23.937
0.2231
75.39
3006.75 736.136
116.393
0.2448
62.53
282.87
104.513
16.525
0.3695
57.23
312.00
97.749
15.455
0.3133
62.40
248.00
114.134
18.046
0.4602
49.60
217.50
93.931
14.852
0.4319
54.38
1060.38 379.688
60.034
0.3581
56.04
3.9
62.53
4
75.39 3
63.31 2 60.75
1 57.68
56.04
2
62.40 1 57.23
4 54.38 3
49.60
3.10
( X )
(S.D.) Coefficient of variation (C.V.)
(%)
3.10
121
3.10 ( X ) (S.D.)
Coefficient of variation (C.V.) (%)
( n = 30)
1
(Q = 19)
2
(Q = 16)
3
(Q = 4)
4
(Q = 9)
1
(Q = 5)
2
(Q = 5)
3
(Q = 5)
4
(Q = 4)
Basic Statistics
Mean
S.D.
Std. Error
Mean
C.V.
1272.67 309.128
56.439
0.2429
66.98
1131.50 220.927
40.336
0.1953
70.32
307.00
70.669
12.902
0.2302
76.75
759.33
115.823
21.146
0.1525
84.37
3468.50 666.534
121.692
0.1922
72.21
332.33
120.671
22.031
0.3631
66.89
360.33
83.097
15.171
0.2306
72.07
314.67
108.596
19.827
0.3451
62.93
256.00
95.794
17.490
0.3742
64.00
1263.33 365.174
66.671
0.2891
66.12
3.10
72.21
4
84.37 3
76.75 2 70.32
1 66.98
66.12
2
72.07 1 66.89
4 64.00 3
62.93
123