Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
AT Hynix

AT Hynix

Ratings: (0)|Views: 89|Likes:
Published by sabatino

More info:

Published by: sabatino on Feb 27, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

01/29/2013

pdf

text

original

 
I
2
l456789101112
IJ
t4
t)
to
t718
r9
202l
))
L)al
25262728
JOSEPHW. COTCHETT#36324)PHTLIP . GREGORY#95217)COTCHETT,PITRE&MCCARTHY840MalcolmRoad,Suite200Burlinsame,alifomia94010Tel:(650)697-6000.Fax:(650)697-0577GREGORYP.sToNE(#78329)STEVENM.PERRY#106154)MUNGER,TOLLES& OLSONLLP355SouthGrandAvenue,35thFloorLosAngeles, alilomia90071-1560Tel:(213)683-9100'Fax:(213)687-3702ByJEFFREY. BLEICH(#144340)susANT. BOYD(#229664)LEE S. TAYLoR(#243863)MI.]NGER,OLLES&OLSONLLP560MissionStreet,7thFloorSanFrancisco,alifomia94105-2907Tel:(415)12-4000'ax:415)12-4077Attomeysor PlaintiffRAMBUSNC.SUPERIOROURTOF THE STATEOF CALIFORNIACITY ANDCOUNTYOF SANFRANCISCORAMBUSNC.,Plaintiff,MICRONTECHNOLOGY,NC.,etal.,Defendants.cAsENO.04-43105RAMBUS'SMEMORANDUMOFPOINTSAND AUTHORITIESINOPPOSITIONTOHYNIX'SMOTIONFORSUMMARYJUDGMENTBASEDONFAILUREOFPROOtrASTO ALLEGEDILLEGALAGREEMENTDate:February3, 2009Time:l:30p.m.Deot:304Judge:Hon.uchardA.KramerComplaintiled:May 5,2004TrialDate:March16,2009
lPUBLIC
OPPOSITIONO HYNIX'SMSJREFAILUREOFPROOFASTO ALLEGED LLEGALAGREEMENT
 
t
TABLEOFCONTENTSil.il.
l9202l?2232425262728
PrgcINTRODUCTIONT'IDSI.JMMARYFARGUMENT"""""""""'"'I
STATIMENTOFACTS
ARGlJMENT.......,Miuon'sPurportedrsinessStrategyOf"AdopingNew13TechnologYate
A.HynixHasNotMeteInitialBudenUnderAguilar"""""""""51.Hvnix'sCursoryDescriptionfT-hePefe$3gts'Conductgnorcs
'IHH*ffie#"H$fii"*r#Hamnffi:
2.Hvnix'sConclusoryDenialsOfWrongdoingDoNotShiffTheR
iiiiai'-or-p.aucdon"""""-""'"""""""""""""""""'o
3.Mr.Tabrizi'stat€NnentboutP|ofit.lvqdqi4tignDoesNotofalG-it"etii**OfCollusionrPrallelConduct""""""""""""tB.Evenf HynixHasMettsThr€sholdr'rderu.Rambus"t-{tdtTlttI nfri"*$['Sno"ti"gunfregttil-ro Precludeunrmsryudpent""""""""'tul.Rarnbus'sirectEviriencefConspiracysSufficieotoDefeatr ^
"ffi1g"ifu-ttaotioo"""""""'"""""""'ru
2.ManyOfThessuesOf FactThatHynixDcsignatedsMaerial
ToTheExisten6&"Anrrregarg&m*tefttlesubSectf'
C*"i""-Oitp"t""""""""""""""""""LL
J.
b.CraigBarrctt'sPurportedtat€m€ntegadinghtcl'sRelationshipith*il;il:':"'--:"::""""':"" """"""""""""'14RambusHasAboProfr€redSubgtantialvidence-Of.WhatddinsCalls
.plusFactors,,,ncludingEvri&Etprviiilrt"aitionaton"pita"y."........5
Hynix'sArgumcntRegardingntitustInjuryProvidesNoBasisForTheDismissalXAnyClaim.-'-....""""'"""""""'l8SummaryudpentSbouldB€DqdedAsTo Rtmbus'sOdrerClaimsAgainstHynixro
Iv,
coNCLUSlON............
:::::ECEDLLEGALAGREEMENTOPPO$NONTOI{YNIX'SMSJBEFAILUREOFPROOFASTOALL
 
ttI
trl
lll
l516t7l8l9202lT223242526272t
t
TABLEOF AUTIIORITIES
STATECAsEs
Apztilsv. AtlanticRichfreldCo-,-25 Cal.4th26,24 P.3d5102001)E&lnsv. Redstone,134Cal.App.4th902006)................Amarclv. Connell,102F.3d4949thCir.1996).....'.."......passrm15,7,8
FEDER^LCASES
AtlantlcRIchfuIdCo.v.USAPetroletmtCo-,I o495U.S.281990).........
BroadcomCorp.v.QnlcommInc.,
s43F.3d83Fd.CL.2oo8)...
BrunswickCorp.v.PuebloBo"'tl-O'Ma,
42e .s.7tnT.........
ChamnameMetalsv. Ken'MrcMetals,nc.,458F.3d107310thir.2000..................""""""""'t t' t7InrcCitricAcidLitig.,r <l9l F3d10909thcir. 1999)...............-.Inre CitricAcALiliT,996F.Sum.95f(l.I.D.Cal.1998)..................Inre CoordinaedPretrlalProceedingsnPetroleumodttctsAntitrustLitig''96F.2d4329thCir. I990).."......7,16nreFlatGlassArrtitntsaitig.,385F.3d3503dCir.2004)Inre High FructoseCorn SytqAntitrustLitig.,295F.3d6517thCir.2002)...
InReYitaminsAntittttstLitig.,320F.Supp.2d(D.D.C.2004)
KnevelboodDatrtes. KrafiFoods,te-'r .'232F.3d79glhCir'2000)...........NCAAv.BoardofRegents,.,.1468U.S.51984)...........Rossi . StandodRoofingInc',r ,r ,.r r o156F.3d452(3dCtu.998)....'...'..'v'"''oTotedokck fules& &nice,htc.v. MackTrucks,rc-,530F.3d 043dCir'Tunicaleb Adver.v. TtmicaCasinoOperatorsAss'4te',
- -4e63d4btfstlcir.20oa..........:..............'....."l0'll'12
UnitedStatxv.Alston,..r9?4F.2d12069thCir.19v2).................-MackTracks,rc.,
oPPostnoNTo}IYND('SMs'REFAILUREoFPRooFAsToALLEGED|LLEGALAGREEMENT

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->