• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
 
Calculating Submerged Weight
© 2008 Douglas GouldToss a solid brick of steel into the water and it sinks, but pound that steel brick into theshape of a salad bowl, and it will float. That is because a steel salad bowl will displace anamount of water that is equal to the actual weight of the bowl itself. By changing the steelbrick to a steel bowl, we didn’t make it buoyant, all we did was take advantage of thebuoyant force of water to make the steel float. The buoyant force was always there,acting on brick and bowl alike. Archimedes of Syracuse became so famous for his enduring ideas that today he needsonly one name: Archimedes (like Cher, I guess). If he were alive today, he would bemuch to smart to become a marine salvor. But almost two-thousand five-hundred yearsago he did discover an interesting phenonemon when he descibed what happens when asolid gets immersed in a fluid. Expressed mathimatically, Archimedes’ Principal lookslike someone spilled a Scrabble board:
m
b
=
m
object
 
*
 
(
1 –
 
 p
fluid
 
 / 
 
 p
object
)
 
Expressed in plain English, it says:
‘a body immersed in a fluid is buoyed up by a forceequal to the weight of the displaced fluid’.
Notice that the buoyant force pushing theobject ‘up’ is not based on the weight of the object, but rather the weight of the fluid. Thebuoyant force is created because the object has pushed, or
displaced 
, some of the fluid.This makes the fluid really angry, and it tries with all its might to push that object back up to the surface. And it is simple to measure the force; just weigh the fluid that getsdisplaced. Think about this for a minute….liquids create a force that pushes solid objectsback toward the surface. That could come in handy, huh?A cubic foot of sea water weighs 64 lbs. According to Archimedes’ Principal, for everycubic foot of sea water that a solid displaces, it will be
buoyed up
by 64 lbs of force. Acubic foot is a measurement of volume, not weight. A cubic foot of cast iron weighs morethan a cubic foot of aluminum, but they both displace the exact same volume of water,and each would receive the same 64 lbs of buoyancy if submerged. This is where the plotthickens.On the surface, a cubic foot of cast iron weighs 442 lbs. But underwater, it is beingpushed to the surface by 64 lbs of force. The practical effect of the buoyant force createsa
submerged weight 
of 378 lbs. With one cubic foot, it is simple math: 442 lbs
down
, 64lbs
up
equals 378 lbs left over. That means that we can make 442 lbs of cast ironneutrally buoyant by adding only 378 lbs of lift.A cubic foot of aluminum, on the other hand, weighs 170lbs, and it displaces the exactsame amount of water, so the
submerged weight 
of the aluminum is 170 – 64 = 106lbs.(think 170 lbs.
down
, 64 lbs.
up
).
 
Finally, a cubic foot of balsa wood only weighs 10 lbs, and yet again displaces the samecubic foot of water. This time, 10 lbs
down
, and 64 lbs.
up
, equals -54. Minus 54 lbs of submerged weight is 54 lbs. of lift!But boats aren’t built in tidy shapes like cubes, and figuring out exactly how many cubicfeet of each submerged material would be impractical. Fortunately, its easy to establish aratio of dry weight to submerged weight by dividing one into the other – i.e. a cubic footof aluminum retains 62% of its dry weight when submerged (106
  ⁄  
170 = .62), and a cubicfoot of iron retains 85% of its dry weight (378 / 442 = .85).Remember, even stuff that floats receives that same 64 lbs/cu.ft of buoyant force when itis submerged. A cubic foot of balsa wood weighs 10 lbs dry. Submerge that balsa andwhat do you get? 10 lbs
down
, 64 lbs
up
, which leaves us with a
 minus 54 lbs
of submerged weight, or
54 lbs of lift
. The formula to solve the ratio is the same, but wehave to deal with negative dry weight number. (– 54
  ⁄  
10 = – 5.4)I don’t know about you, but my head hurts already, and I haven’t put on my wet suit yet.Figure 1 illustrates how this all works.
Figure 1. All solids are buoyed up by the same force, and the resultant 
submerged weight
 depends on the density of the material. The ability to calculate submerged weight helpssalvors know how much lift will be needed to raise a sunken vessel.
1 cu.ft. of Cast IronDry = 442lbs 
1 cu.ft ofBuoyant Force= 64 lbs
 
Submergedweight =378 lbs
1 cu.ft. of AluminumDry = 170lbs
1 cu.ft ofBuoyant Force= 64lbs
 
Submergedweight =106 lbs
1 cu.ft. of Balsa WoodDry = 10lbs
1 cu.ft ofBuoyant Force= 64 lbs
 
Submergedweight =- 54 lbs
.62 .85
-5.4
Conversionratio
 
 Rather than waste you time figuring the conversion factor for each material, the nicefolks over at the USCG publish a table called “Factors for Converting Various BoatMaterials from Dry Weight to Submerged Weight.” [you can find a copy on the webhere:http://www.uscgboating.org/safety/boatbuilder/flotation/table4-1.htm]. I havereprinted a portion of the chart here.
Chart 1. Factors for Converting Various Boat Materials from Dry Weight toSubmerged Weight in Fresh Water. Other sources may refer to conversionnumber as the “K Factor”.
To calculate the submerged weight of a material, just multiply the known dry weight bythe Conversion Factor. With the minus factors, remember that your answer will be aminus number, which means that the material is creating lift when it is submerged.Does all this have a practical application? Well, Ham Gale and I had a perfectopportunity to prove out the theory last October up in Annapolis. A Soling sailboat sank in about 30 feet of water. Solings have short cables attached to the keel bolts that aredesigned to allow easy lifting of the boat on to a trailer (how handy for us salvage divers,huh?). So, I was able to access the lifting cables down there in 30 feet of cloudyChesapeake Bay, and attach some lift. According to the spec sheet a Soling displaces2277 lbs. constructed with a solid fiberglass hull, with aluminum spars and cast iron keelweighing 1278 lbs, plus some SS rigging; nothing that would naturally float.Would you be tempted to send your diver down with at least 2500 lbs. of lift bags?Would a 2000 lb. lift bag be enough to bring this 2277 lb. boat to the surface?Material Specific Gravity ConversionFactorPounds Percubic ftLead 11.38 0.91 710Steel 7.85 0.88 490Cast Iron 7.08 0.86 442Aluminum 2.73 0.63 170Ferro cement 2.40 0.58 150Fiberglass laminate 1.50 0.33 94Sea Water 1.03 n/a 64Distilled (fresh) Water 1.00 0.00 62.4Teak 0.99 -0.01 62Oak (White) 0.85 -0.18 53Diesel Fuel 0.85 -0.18 53Gasoline 0.73 -0.37 45Mahogany (Honduras) 0.56 -0.78 35Plywood (Fir) 0.55 -0.81 34Spruce (wood masts) 0.45 -1.22 28
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...