High Quality
Open the downloaded document, and select print from the file menu (PDF reader required).
- O F F , ( , ( A - ~
-
Page1
IN
THE
UNITEDSTATESDISTRICTCOURT
FORTHE
DISTRICT
OF
OREGONOREGON,INC.,aDelawarecorporation;andOREGONCUTTINGSYSTEMS,adivision
of
Oregon,Inc.,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
TRILINKSAWCHAIN,LLC,aGeorgialimitedliability
c ~ m p a n y ;
TRILINK
GLOBAL,LLC,aGeorgialimitedliabilitycompany;JINHUATRILINKHUIHUANGCO.,LTD,aChinesecompany;
and
.TINHUA
HUIHUANGHARDWARECO.,LTD,aChinesecompany,
Defendants.
We,
the
jury,
unanimously
find
as
follows:SPECIAL
VERDICT
No.
CV
06
..
00767-BRSPECIALVERDICT
Case 3:06-cv-00767-BR Document 220 Filed 03/05/2009 Page 1 of 7
INFRINGEMENT
OFTHE
'783PATENT
1.
DidPlaintiffsprovebyapreponderance
of
theevidencethat
any
of
theAccusedProductsliterallyinfringeclaim1
of
the'783patentduringnormaloperation?Answer:Yes
X
No_
If
yes,identifyalltheproductsyoufindtobeinfringing(seeattachedexhibit):
L14B
~ 1 6 C
L16E
Ll8A
~ 2 0 A
"Yes"isafindingforPlaintiffs.
''No''
is
a
findingfortheDefendants.Pleaseproceedtoquestion
2.
2.
DidPlaintiffsproveby
a
preponderance
of
theevidencethattheAccusedProductsinfringeclaim1
of
the'783patentunderthedoctrine
of
equivalentsduringnormaloperation?Answer:Yes
A
No
_
If
yes>
identifyalltheproductsyoufindtobeinfringing:
X.
14B
_ ~ J 6 C
'/...
16E
X.
18A
:b...20A
Page2SPECIALVERDICT
Case 3:06-cv-00767-BR Document 220 Filed 03/05/2009 Page 2 of 7
"Yes"isafindingforPlaintiffs.
"No"
isafindingfortheDefendants.Pleaseproceedtoquestion
3.
3.DidPlaintiffsprovebyapreponderance
of
theevidencethatoneormoreDefendantsinducedusers
of
theAccusedProductstoinfringeclaim1
of
the'783patent?Answer:YesNo
~ X ~ -
If
yes,identifyalltheproductsyoufindtobeinfringing:14B16C16E18A20A"Yes"isafindingforPlaintiffs.''No''isafindingfortheDefendants.Pleaseproceedtoquestion4.
4.
DidPlaintiffsprovebyapreponderance
of
theevidencethatone
or
moreDefendantscontributedtodirectinfring.ement
of
claim
1
of
the'783patentbyusers
of
theAccusedProducts?Answer:Yes
---
No
X
Page3
If
yes,identifyalltheproductsyoufindtobeinfringing:
__
ItemNumber15016MK57TR(16-inchrentalbar)
__
ItemNumber35018MK64TR(18-:inchrentalbar)
__
ItemNumber35020MK72TR(20-inchrental
bar)
SPECIALVERDICT
Case 3:06-cv-00767-BR Document 220 Filed 03/05/2009 Page 3 of 7
Add a Comment