• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
I
F i n a l \ue001 r e p o r t , \ue001 p
. \ue0016.
T A X - E X E M P T \ue001
F
O U N D A T I
O N S
1 0 7 7
s t r e n g t h \ue001 a n d \ue001 i n \ue001 m o r a l \ue001 a n d \ue001 i n t e l l e c t u a l \ue001 c a p a c i t y \ue001 o n \ue001 t h e \ue001 b a s i s \ue001 o f \ue001 f r e e
a n d \ue001 r e s p o n s i b l e \ue001 r e s e a r c h \ue001 a n d \ue001 s c h o l a r s h i p
.
W e \ue001 s h a l l \ue001 c o n t i n u e \ue001 t o \ue001 s u p -
p o r t \ue001 v i g o r o u s l y \ue001 t h i s \ue001 c o n c e p t \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 l i e s \ue001 a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 h e a r t \ue001 o f \ue001 f r e e \ue001 i n s t i t u t i o n s
a n d \ue001 w e \ue001 w i l l \ue001 o p p o s e \ue001 a n y \ue001 e f f o r t \ue001 b y \ue001 g o v e r n m e n t \ue001 t o \ue001 u s e \ue001 t h e \ue001 t a x -e x e m p t
s t a t u s \ue001 t o \ue001 a c c o m p l i s h \ue001 i n d i r e c t l y \ue001 w h a t \ue001 c o u l d \ue001 n o t \ue001 b e \ue001 d o n e \ue001 d i r e c t l y \ue001 u n d e r
t h e \ue001 C o n s t i t u t i o n
.
D. \ue001 C ONG R ESSI ONAL \ue001 J UR I SDI C TI ON

W e \ue001 r e s p e c t \ue001 t h e \ue001 h e a v y \ue001 r e s p o n s i b i l i t y \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 r e s t s \ue001 u p o n \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o n g r e s s f o r \ue001 c a r r y i n g \ue001 o u t \ue001 t h e \ue001 o n e r o u s \ue001 t a s k s \ue001 p l a c e d \ue001 u p o n \ue001 i t \ue001 u n d e r \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o n s t i t u - t i o n , \ue001 b u t \ue001 w e \ue001 s u b m i t \ue001 t h a t \ue001 t h e r e \ue001 a r e \ue001 w i d e \ue001 a r e a s \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 l i f e \ue001 o f \ue001 o u r \ue001 p e o p l e w h i c h \ue001 w e r e \ue001 n o t \ue001 i n t e n d e d \ue001 t o \ue001 b e \ue001 s u b j e c t \ue001 t o \ue001 c o n g r e s s i o n a l \ue001 r e g u l a t i o n \ue001 a n d c o n t r o l. \ue001 W e \ue001 h a v e \ue001 w e l c o m e d \ue001 t h e \ue001 s t a t e m e n t s \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 c h a i r m a n \ue001 a n d \ue001 o f

o t h e r \ue001 m e m b e r s \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 c o m m i t t e e \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 i n d i c a t e \ue001 t h a t \ue001 t h i s
. i m p o r t a n t
p r i n c i p l e \ue001 i s \ue001 r e c e i v i n g \ue001 t h e \ue001 c o m m i t t e e ' s \ue001 a t t e n t i o n
.

H o w e v e r , \ue001 t h e \ue001 c o m m i t t e e \ue001 h a s \ue001 h e a r d \ue001 c o n s i d e r a b l e \ue001 t e s t i m o n y \ue001 m a i n t a i n - i n g \ue001 t h a t \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 h a v e \ue001 c o n t r i b u t e d \ue001 t o o \ue001 m u c h \ue001 t o w a r d \ue001 a n \ue001 e m p i r i c a l a p p r o a c h \ue001 a s \ue001 c o n t r a s t e d \ue001 w i t h \ue001 a \ue001 p h i l o s o p h i c a l \ue001 a p p r o a c h \ue001 t o \ue001 c e r t a i n

s t u d i e s. \ue001 W e \ue001 s h a l l \ue001 s p e a k \ue001 o f \ue001 t h i s \ue001 p o i n t \ue001 l a t e r

; \ue001 f o r \ue001 t h e \ue001 m o m e n t , \ue001 w e \ue001 w i s h m e r e l y \ue001 t o \ue001 o b s e r v e \ue001 t h a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e l a t i o n \ue001 b e t w e e n \ue001 e m p i r i c a l \ue001 s t u d i e s \ue001 a n d \ue001 f u n - d a m e n t a l \ue001 o r \ue001 g e n e r a l \ue001 p r i n c i p l e \ue001 i s \ue001 a n \ue001 i n t e l l e c t u a l \ue001 i s s u e \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 i s \ue001 a s \ue001 o l d a s \ue001 m a n \ue001 h i m s e l f , \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 e n t e r e d \ue001 o u r \ue001 l i t e r a t u r e \ue001 a t \ue001 l e a s t \ue001 a s \ue001 e a r l y \ue001 a s \ue001 Pl a t o a n d \ue001 Ar i s t o t l e , \ue001 a n d \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 w i l l \ue001 e n d u r e \ue001 a s \ue001 l o n g \ue001 a s \ue001 t h e r e \ue001 a r e \ue001 m e n \ue001 t o \ue001 t h i n k

.
I t \ue001 i s \ue001 n o t
a
q u e s t i o n \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 a n y \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n , \ue001 o r \ue001 a l l \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s ,
c a n \ue001 o r \ue001 s h o u l d \ue001 r e f e r e e \ue001 o r \ue001 d e c i d e , \ue001 a n d \ue001 o u r \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 h a v e \ue001 n e v e r
a t t e m p t e d \ue001 t o \ue001 d o \ue001 s o
. \ue001 No r \ue001 i s \ue001 i t , \ue001 w e \ue001 s u b m i t , \ue001 a \ue001 m a t t e r \ue001 u n d e r \ue001 t h e \ue001 j u r i s d i c -
t i o n \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o n g r e s s
.
Si m i l a r l y , \ue001 t h e \ue001 c u r r i c u l u m s \ue001 o f \ue001 o u r \ue001 s c h o o l s \ue001 a r e \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 h a n d s \ue001 o f \ue001 t e n s \ue001 o f
t h o u s a n d s \ue001 o f \ue001 a g e n c i e s \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 a r e \ue001 i n d e p e n d e n t \ue001 i n \ue001 c u r r i c u l u m \ue001 m a t t e r s
;
t h e s e \ue001 a r e \ue001 t h e \ue001 St a t e \ue001 a n d \ue001 l o c a l \ue001 e d u c a t i o n a l \ue001 a u t h o r i t i e s , \ue001 t e a c h e r s \ue001 i n \ue001 o u r
s c h o o l s \ue001 a n d \ue001 c o l l e g e s , \ue001 a n d \ue001 t h e \ue001 b o a r d s \ue001 o f \ue001 o u r \ue001 i n d e p e n d e n t \ue001 e d u c a t i o n a l
i n s t i t u t i o n s \ue001 o f \ue001 a l l l \ue001 l e v e l s
.
Th e \ue001 g r e a t \ue001 s t r e n g t h \ue001 o f \ue001 o u r \ue001 e d u c a t i o n a l \ue001 s y s -
t e m
i s
i t s \ue001 v a r i e t y \ue001 o f \ue001 p a t t e r n s \ue001 a n d \ue001 i t s \ue001 d e c e n t r a l i z a t i o n \ue001 o f \ue001 c o n t r o l
.
W e
b e l i e v e \ue001 t h a t \ue001 i t \ue001 i s \ue001 n o t \ue001 f o r \ue001 g o v e r n m e n t , \ue001 n o r \ue001 f o r \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s , \ue001 n o r \ue001 f o r \ue001 a n y
o t h e r \ue001 g r o u p , \ue001 t o \ue001 a t t e m p t \ue001 t o \ue001 i m p o s e \ue001 c o n f o r m i t y \ue001 u p o n \ue001 t h i s \ue001 v a r i e t y
.
I f
a n y o n e \ue001 h a s \ue001 t h e \ue001 i m p r e s s i o n \ue001 t h a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 h a v e \ue001 t h e \ue001 p o w e r \ue001 t o \ue001 d o
s o , \ue001 h e \ue001 i s \ue001 w r o n g \ue001 a s \ue001 a \ue001 m a t t e r \ue001 o f \ue001 f a c t
.
I f \ue001 a n y o n e \ue001 h a s \ue001 t h e \ue001 i m p r e s s i o n
t h a t \ue001 o u r \ue001 p a r t i c u l a r \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 h a v e \ue001 e x e r t e d \ue001 p r e s s u r e \ue001 t o \ue001 p r o d u c e \ue001 s u c h
u n i f o r m i t y , \ue001 h e \ue001 i s \ue001 e q u a l l y \ue001 w r o n g
.
E. \ue001 PER SPEC TI V E\ue001 AND\ue001 DI STOR TI ON
Th e \ue001 C o x \ue001 c o m m i t t e e \ue001 r e p o r t e d \ue001 t o \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o n g r e s s \ue001 t h a t \ue001 i t \ue001 h a d \ue001 b e e n \ue001 " a l l o t -
t e d \ue001 i n s u f f i c i e n t \ue001 t i m e \ue001 f o r \ue001 t h e \ue001 m a g n i t u d e \ue001 o f \ue001 i t s \ue001 t a s k. "
7
W e \ue001 r e s p e c t f u l l y
s u b m i t \ue001 t h a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 p r e s e n t \ue001 c o m m i t t e e \ue001 f a c e s \ue001 e v e n \ue001 g r e a t e r \ue001 l i m i t a t i o n s \ue001 o f
t i m e \ue001 a n d \ue001 s t a f f \ue001 i f , \ue001 e v e n \ue001 t h o u g h \ue001 g i v i n g \ue001 a t t e n t i o n \ue001 t o \ue001 f e w e r \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s
t h a n \ue001 d i d \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o x \ue001 c o m m i t t e e , \ue001 i t \ue001 e x t e n d s \ue001 i t s \ue001 i n q u i r y \ue001 i n t o \ue001 a \ue001 h a l f \ue001 c e n t u r y
o f \ue001 s o c i a l , \ue001 e c o n o m i c , \ue001 a n d \ue001 p o l i t i c a l \ue001 c h a n g e \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 Un i t e d \ue001 St a t e s
.
Th e \ue001 c o m m i t t e e \ue001 h a s \ue001 b e f o r e \ue001 i t \ue001 a \ue001 n u m b e r \ue001 o f \ue001 r e p o r t s \ue001 p r e p a r e d \ue001 b y \ue001 i t s
o w n \ue001 s t a f f \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 p u r p o r t \ue001 t o \ue001 d e a l \ue001 w i t h \ue001 t h e s e \ue001 c o m p l e x \ue001 e v e n t s
.
Th e y
h a v e \ue001 b e e n \ue001 w i d e l y \ue001 r e g a r d e d \ue001 a s \ue001 a \ue001 c o n f u s e d \ue001 a n d \ue001 i n a d e q u a t e \ue001 r e v i e w \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e
d e c a d e s \ue001 t h e y \ue001 p u r p o r t \ue001 t o \ue001 c o v e r \ue001 a n d \ue001 a r e \ue001 p a r t i c u l a r l y \ue001 d e f i c i e n t \ue001 a t \ue001 t h e
TAX-EXEMPT\ue001 F OUNDATI ONS
t \ue001 o f \ue001 g r e a t e s t \ue001 i n t e r e s t \ue001 t o \ue001 t h i s \ue001 c o m m i t t e e , \ue001 n a m e l y , \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e s p o n -
o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 f o r \ue001 t h e \ue001 e v e n t s \ue001 t h e m s e l v e s
.

e l v e s \ue001 d o \ue001 n o t \ue001 f i n d \ue001 t h e m \ue001 t o \ue001 b e \ue001 a \ue001 c o m p e t e n t \ue001 r e v i e w \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 t r e n d s u s s , \ue001 m o r e \ue001 p a r t i c u l a r l y \ue001 a s \ue001 t o \ue001 t h e i r \ue001 s w e e p i n g \ue001 g e n e r a l i z a t i o n s , p o s e d \ue001 d e f i n i t i o n s \ue001 o f \ue001 k e y \ue001 t e r m s , \ue001 t h e \ue001 a c c u r a c y \ue001 a n d \ue001 r e l e v a n c e \ue001 o f r t s \ue001 a n d \ue001 t a b l e s , \ue001 a n d \ue001 t h e \ue001 i m b a l a n c e \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 s e l e c t e d \ue001 q u o t a t i o n s y \ue001 c o n t a i n

.
W e \ue001 a s s u m e \ue001 t h a t \ue001 w e \ue001 a r e \ue001 n o t \ue001 c a l l e d \ue001 u p o n \ue001 t o \ue001 p e r -
a f f \ue001 m e m b e r s \ue001 t h a t \ue001 t h e y \ue001 h a v e \ue001 b e e n \ue001 w r o n g \ue001 a b o u t \ue001 v i e w s \ue001 w h i c h

\ue001 n o w \ue001 p l a c e d \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 p u b l i c \ue001 r e c o r d \ue001 a s \ue001 s w o r n \ue001 t e s t i m o n y \ue001 a n d \ue001 t h a t t t e e \ue001 w i l l \ue001 a d o p t \ue001 p r o c e d u r e s \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 w i l l \ue001 n o t \ue001 p e r m i t \ue001 s t a f f \ue001 t o \ue001 p a r - i n \ue001 b o t h \ue001 a n \ue001 a c c u s a t o r y \ue001 a n d \ue001 a n \ue001 a d j u d i c a t i n g \ue001 r o l e

.
h \ue001 s e v e r a l \ue001 s e c t i o n s \ue001 o f \ue001 t h i s \ue001 s t a t e m e n t \ue001 h a v e \ue001 a \ue001 d i r e c t \ue001 b e a r i n g
e \ue001 s t a f f \ue001 r e p o r t s , \ue001 w e \ue001 o f f e r \ue001 h e r e \ue001 b r i e f \ue001 c o m m e n t s \ue001 o n \ue001 t h r e e \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e m
.
\ue001 t h e \ue001 d i r e c t o r \ue001 o \ue001 f \ue001 r e s e a r c h
s
m i t t e e ' s \ue001 d i r e c t o r \ue001 o f \ue001 r e s e a r c h \ue001 d e s c r i b e d \ue001 t h e \ue001 l o g i c \ue001 u s e d \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e
o n \ue001 o f \ue001 h i s \ue001 i n i t i a l \ue001 r e p o r t \ue001 a s \ue001 " r e a s o n i n g \ue001 f r o m
a
t o t a l \ue001 e f f e c t \ue001 t o \ue001 i t s
o r \ue001 s e c o n d a r y \ue001 c a u s e s
. "
9
I f \ue001 w e \ue001 r e a d \ue001 h i s \ue001 r e p o r t \ue001 f a i r l y \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e
f \ue001 t h i s \ue001 i n v e s t i g a t i o n , \ue001 h i s \ue001 l o g i c \ue001 p r o d u c e s \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o l l o w i n g
:
( 1)
i o n \ue001 o c c u r r e d \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 Un i t e d \ue001 St a t e s \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 y e a r s \ue001 1 9 3 3 -3 6
; \ue001 ( 2 )
l u t i o n \ue001 o c c u r r e d \ue001 w i t h o u t \ue001 v i o l e n c e \ue001 a n d \ue001 w i t h \ue001 t h e \ue001 f u l l \ue001 c o n s e n t \ue001 o f
e l m i n g \ue001 m a j o r i t y \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 e l e c t o r a t e
; \ue001 ( 3 ) \ue001 t h i s \ue001 c o u l d \ue001 n o t \ue001 h a v e
h a d \ue001 n o t \ue001 e d u c a t i o n \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 Un i t e d \ue001 St a t e s \ue001 p r e p a r e d \ue001 i n \ue001 a d v a n c e
\ue001 i t
; \ue001 ( 4 ) \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 c o n t r i b u t e d \ue001 f u n d s \ue001 a n d \ue001 i d e a s \ue001 t o \ue001 e d u -
5 ) \ue001 t h e r e f o r e , \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 a r e \ue001 r e s p o n s i b l e \ue001 f o r \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e v o l u -
o r t \ue001 i n \ue001 q u e s t i o n \ue001 s e e m s \ue001 t o \ue001 g i v e \ue001 l i t t l e \ue001 w e i g h t \ue001 t o \ue001 t h e \ue001 g r e a t \ue001 d e -
o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 e a r l y \ue001 19 3 0' s , \ue001 t o \ue001 W o r l d \ue001 W a r \ue001 I , \ue001 a n d \ue001 t o \ue001 W o r l d \ue001 W a r \ue001 I I
.

\ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 h a v e \ue001 b e e n \ue001 c h a r g e d \ue001 w i t h \ue001 s o m e \ue001 u n d e f i n e d \ue001 r e s p o n - f o r \ue001 a n \ue001 i n c r e a s e \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 p o w e r s \ue001 a n d \ue001 f u n c t i o n s \ue001 o f \ue001 g o v e r n m e n t , t \ue001 i s \ue001 r e l e v a n t \ue001 t h a t \ue001 w a r \ue001 a n d \ue001 d e p r e s s i o n \ue001 b r o u g h t \ue001 a b o u t \ue001 a n \ue001 i n - x e r c i s e \ue001 o f \ue001 p o w e r \ue001 b y \ue001 b o t h \ue001 t h e \ue001 e x e c u t i v e \ue001 a n d \ue001 l e g i s l a t i v e \ue001 a r m s

a t i o n a l \ue001 Go v e r n m e n t \ue001 u n d e r \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o n s t i t u t i o n
.
Su r e l y \ue001 i t \ue001 i s
e v a n t \ue001 t h a t , \ue001 w h i l e \ue001 s o m e \ue001 m e a s u r e s \ue001 a d o p t e d \ue001 b y \ue001 Go v e r n m e n t \ue001 d u r -
e \ue001 d e c a d e s \ue001 w e r e \ue001 a b a n d o n e d , \ue001 o t h e r s \ue001 h a v e \ue001 c o n t i n u e d , \ue001 d e s p i t e
n \ue001 p a r t y \ue001 c o n t r o l , \ue001 a s \ue001 a \ue001 p a r t \ue001 o f \ue001 o n g o i n g \ue001 p u b l i c \ue001 p o l i c y
.
I n \ue001 a n y

n u m b e r \ue001 o f \ue001 a l l e g a t i o n s \ue001 h e a r d \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 c o u r s e \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e s e \ue001 h e a r i n g s \ue001 b e \ue001 d i r e c t e d , \ue001 n o t \ue001 a t \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s , \ue001 b u t \ue001 a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 e x e c u t i v e , \ue001 l e g i s - n d \ue001 j u d i c i a l \ue001 b r a n c h e s \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 Go v e r n m e n t \ue001 a n d \ue001 a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 e l e c t o r a t e

.
t r o n g l y \ue001 p r o t e s t \ue001 a n y \ue001 a t t e m p t \ue001 t o \ue001 i n v o l v e \ue001 o u r \ue001 t w o \ue001 n o n p o l i t i c a l
i o n s \ue001 i n \ue001 q u e s t i o n s \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 a r e \ue001 s o \ue001 b a s i c a l l y \ue001 p o l i t i c a l , \ue001 b o t h \ue001 b e -
e \ue001 c h a r g e s \ue001 a r e \ue001 u n s u p p o r t e d \ue001 a n d \ue001 b e c a u s e \ue001 i t \ue001 w o u l d \ue001 b e \ue001 o u t \ue001 o f
\ue001 f o r \ue001 o u r \ue001 t w o \ue001 p h i l a n t h r o p i e s \ue001 t o \ue001 a t t e m p t \ue001 t o \ue001 r e p l y \ue001 t o \ue001 s u c h \ue001 a t t a c k s
i v e \ue001 p o l i t i c a l \ue001 t e r m s
.
t \ue001 a l s o \ue001 c o m m e n t \ue001 u p o n \ue001 t h e \ue001 u s e \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 w o r d \ue001 " r e v o l u t i o n " \ue001 i n
t \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 d i r e c t o r \ue001 o f \ue001 r e s e a r c h
.
Th e \ue001 w o r d \ue001 h a s \ue001 s t r o n g \ue001 e m o -
s o c i a t i o n s
.
I t \ue001 i s \ue001 f r e q u e n t l y \ue001 u s e d \ue001 i n \ue001 d e b a t e \ue001 b e t w e e n \ue001 p o l i t i c a l
a n d \ue001 b e t w e e n \ue001 f a c t i o n s \ue001 w i t h i n \ue001 a \ue001 p o l i t i c a l \ue001 p a r t y -a n d \ue001 i n \ue001 s u c h
s \ue001 o r d i n a r i l y \ue001 a c c e p t e d \ue001 a s \ue001 a \ue001 f o r e n s i c \ue001 f i g u r e \ue001 o f \ue001 s p e e c h
.
c t , \ue001 h o w e v e r , \ue001 t o \ue001 t h e \ue001 u s e \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 w o r d \ue001 " r e v o l u t i o n " \ue001 i n \ue001 a n \ue001 o f f i c i a l
n g \ue001 w h e r e \ue001 t h e \ue001 i m p l i c a t i o n \ue001 i s \ue001 a \ue001 c h a r g e \ue001 o f \ue001 w r o n g d o i n g
.
Su c h
o f \ue001 s p e e c h \ue001 s h o u l d \ue001 n o t \ue001 b e \ue001 u s e d \ue001 a s \ue001 a \ue001 b a s i s \ue001 f o r \ue001 a l l e g i n g \ue001 i m p r o p e r
o r \ue001 f o r \ue001 i m p u g n i n g \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e p u t a t i o n s \ue001 o f \ue001 r e s p e c t a b l e \ue001 a n d \ue001 l a w -
p t , \ue001 p
. \ue001 12
ff. ,
i b i d
. ,\ue001p. \ue0015.
p t , \ue001 p
. \ue00146 ,\ue001ibid. ,\ue001p. \ue001 2 0.
T A X - E X E M P T
F OUNDATI
O N S
1 0 7 9
a b i d i n g \ue001 c i t i z e n s. \ue001 I t \ue001 d o e s \ue001 n o t \ue001 h e l p \ue001 t o \ue001 p u t \ue001 t h e \ue001 w o r d \ue001 i n \ue001 q u o t a t i o n \ue001 m a r k s -
t h e s e \ue001 b e c o m e \ue001 l o s t . \ue001 I t \ue001 d o e s \ue001 n o t \ue001 h e l p \ue001 t o \ue001 s a y , \ue001 a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 b e g i n n i n g \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e
r e p o r t , \ue001 " I n \ue001 n o \ue001 s e n s e \ue001 s h o u l d \ue001 t h e y \ue001 [ i
. \ue001e. , \ue001 t h e \ue001 s t a t e m e n t s \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e p o r t ]
b e \ue001 c o n s i d e r e d \ue001 a s \ue001 p r o o f "
10
f o r \ue001 s u c h \ue001 s t a t e m e n t s \ue001 a r e \ue001 o v e r l o o k e d
. \ue001 I t \ue001 d o e s
n o t \ue001 e v e n \ue001 h e l p \ue001 t h a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e p o r t \ue001 c a m e \ue001 o n l y \ue001 f r o m \ue001 a \ue001 m e m b e r \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 s t a f f ,
f o r \ue001 i t \ue001 h a s \ue001 a l r e a d y \ue001 b e e n \ue001 a t t r i b u t e d \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 p r e s s \ue001 t o \ue001 t h e \ue001 c o m m i t t e e \ue001 i t s e l f
.
As \ue001 a \ue001 r e c e n t \ue001 s t a t e m e n t \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 Am e r i c a n \ue001 t r a d i t i o n \ue001 o n \ue001 s u c h \ue001 m a t t e r s , \ue001 w e
c i t e \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o l l o w i n g \ue001 p o r t i o n \ue001 o f \ue001 a n \ue001 a d d r e s s \ue001 m a d e \ue001 b y \ue001 Pr e s i d e n t \ue001 Ei s e n h o w e r
o n
M Yo
r k
:
3 1 , \ue001 1 9 5 4 , \ue001 a t \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o l u m b i a \ue001 Un i v e r s i t y \ue001 b i c e n t e n n i a l \ue001 d i n n e r \ue001 i n
Ne w

W h e n e v e r , \ue001 a n d \ue001 f o r \ue001 w h a t e v e r \ue001 a l l e g e d \ue001 r e a s o n , \ue001 p e o p l e \ue001 a t t e m p t \ue001 t o \ue001 c r u s h \ue001 i d e a s , \ue001 t o m a s k \ue001 t h e i r \ue001 c o n v i c t i o n s , \ue001 t o \ue001 v i e w \ue001 e v e r y \ue001 n e i g h b o r \ue001 a s \ue001 a \ue001 p o s s i b l e \ue001 e n e m y , \ue001 t o \ue001 s e e k s o m e \ue001 k i n d \ue001 o f \ue001 d i v i n i n g \ue001 r o d \ue001 b y \ue001 w h i c h \ue001 t o \ue001 t e s t \ue001 f o r \ue001 c o n f o r m i t y , \ue001 a \ue001 f r e e \ue001 s o c i e t y \ue001 i s \ue001 i n

d a n g e r
. \ue001 W h e r e v e r \ue001 m a n ' s \ue001 r i g h t \ue001 t o \ue001 k n o w l e d g e \ue001 a n d \ue001 t h e \ue001 u s e \ue001 t h e r e o f \ue001 i s \ue001 r e s t r i c t e d ,
m a n ' s \ue001 f r e e d o m \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e \ue001 s a m e \ue001 m e a s u r e \ue001 d i s a p p e a r s
.
H e r e \ue001 i n \ue001 Am e r i c a \ue001 w e \ue001 a r e \ue001 d e s c e n d e d
i n
b l o o d \ue001 a n d \ue001 i n \ue001 s p i r i t \ue001 f r o m \ue001 r e v o l u t i o n a r i e s
a n d \ue001 r e b e l s -m e n \ue001 a n d \ue001 w o m e n \ue001 w h o \ue001 d a r e d \ue001 t o \ue001 d i s s e n t \ue001 f r o m \ue001 a c c e p t e d \ue001 d o c t r i n e
. \ue001 As
t h e i r \ue001 h e i r s , \ue001 m a y \ue001 w e \ue001 n e v e r \ue001 c o n f u s e \ue001 h o n e s t \ue001 d i s s e n t \ue001 w i t h \ue001 d i s l o y a l \ue001 s u b v e r s i o n
.
W i t h o u t \ue001 e x h a u s t i v e \ue001 d e b a t e -e v e n \ue001 h e a t e d \ue001 d e b a t e -o f \ue001 i d e a s \ue001 a n d \ue001 p r o g r a m s , \ue001 f r e e
g o v e r n m e n t \ue001 w o u l d \ue001 w e a k e n \ue001 a n d \ue001 w i t h e r

. \ue001 B u t \ue001 i f \ue001 w e \ue001 a l l o w \ue001 o u r s e l v e s \ue001 t o \ue001 b e \ue001 p e r - s u a d e d \ue001 t h a t \ue001 e v e r y \ue001 i n d i v i d u a l -o r \ue001 p a r t y -t h a t \ue001 t a k e s \ue001 i s s u e \ue001 w i t h \ue001 o u r \ue001 o w n \ue001 c o n v i c - t i o n s \ue001 i s \ue001 n e c e s s a r i l y \ue001 w i c k e d \ue001 o r \ue001 t r e a s o n o u s -t h e n \ue001 i n d e e d \ue001 w e \ue001 a r e \ue001 a p p r o a c h i n g \ue001 t h e e n d \ue001 o f \ue001 f r e e d o m ' s \ue001 r o a d

. "
Re p o r t \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e
As s i s t a n t
Di r e c t o r \ue001 o f \ue001 Re s e a r c h
o n \ue001 " Ec o n o m i c s \ue001 a n d
t h e
Pu b l i c \ue001 I n t e r e s t "
1 2
A\ue001 f u r t h e r \ue001 i s s u e \ue001 o f \ue001 m a j o r \ue001 i m p o r t a n c e \ue001 i s \ue001 r a i s e d \ue001 b y \ue001 t h i s \ue001 r e p o r t , \ue001 w h i c h
i s \ue001 e n t i t l e d \ue001 " Ec o n o m i c s \ue001 a n d \ue001 t h e \ue001 Pu b l i c \ue001 I n t e r e s t
. "
I n \ue001 h i s \ue001 i n t r o d u c t i o n , \ue001 t h e \ue001 w r i t e r \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e p o r t \ue001 s a y s
Th i s \ue001 r e p o r t \ue001 i s \ue001 m a d e \ue001 f o r \ue001 t h e \ue001 p u r p o s e \ue001 o f \ue001 s h o w i n g \ue001 t h e \ue001 n a t u r e \ue001 a n d \ue001 i n c r e a s i n g \ue001 c o s t s
o f \ue001 g o v e r n m e n t a l \ue001 p a r t i c i p a t i o n \ue001 i n \ue001 e c o n o m i c \ue001 a n d \ue001 w e l f a r e \ue001 a c t i v i t i e s \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 Na t i o n
.

Th e \ue001 b o d y \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e p o r t \ue001 c o n t a i n s \ue001 a \ue001 n u m b e r \ue001 o f \ue001 t a b l e s \ue001 r e f l e c t i n g \ue001 t h e u p w a r d \ue001 t r e n d \ue001 o f \ue001 F e d e r a l \ue001 Go v e r n m e n t \ue001 e x p e n d i t u r e s \ue001 f o r \ue001 s u c h \ue001 p u r p o s e s a s \ue001 h o u s i n g \ue001 a n d \ue001 s l u m \ue001 c l e a r a n c e , \ue001 s o c i a l \ue001 s e c u r i t y \ue001 a n d \ue001 h e a l t h , \ue001 e d u c a t i o n ( i n c l u d i n g \ue001 t h e \ue001 GI \ue001 b i l l \ue001 o f \ue001 r i g h t s ) , \ue001 p u b l i c \ue001 w o r k s , \ue001 f o o d \ue001 p r o g r a m s , \ue001 e t c

.
Th e \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n s \ue001 a r e \ue001 b r o u g h t \ue001 i n t o \ue001 t h e \ue001 p i c t u r e \ue001 b y \ue001 s t a t e m e n t s \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e
p r e f a c e \ue001 t o \ue001 t h e \ue001 r e p o r t \ue001 t o \ue001 t h e \ue001 e f f e c t \ue001 t h a t \ue001 " Mo s t , \ue001 i f \ue001 n o t \ue001 a l l \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e s e \ue001 n e w e r

a c t i v i t i e s \ue001 o f \ue001 g o v e r n m e n t \ue001 a r e \ue001 r e c o m m e n d e d \ue001 i n \ue001 * \ue001 * \ue001 * \ue001 r e p o r t s \ue001 b y \ue001 v a r i o u s e d u c a t i o n a l \ue001 g r o u p s , \ue001 s o c i a l \ue001 s c i e n c e , \ue001 a n d \ue001 o t h e r s , \ue001 s u p p o r t e d \ue001 b y \ue001 f o u n d a - t i o n \ue001 g r a n t s , "

11

a n d \ue001 t h a t \ue001 " Mu c h \ue001 o f \ue001 t h i s \ue001 p l a n n i n g \ue001 w a s \ue001 d o n e \ue001 w i t h \ue001 t h e a i d \ue001 o f \ue001 s o c i a l \ue001 s c i e n t i s t s \ue001 i n \ue001 g o v e r n m e n t \ue001 e m p l o y \ue001 * \ue001 * \ue001 * \ue001 [ m a n y \ue001 o f \ue001 w h o m ] w e r e \ue001 d i r e c t l y \ue001 o r \ue001 i n d i r e c t l y \ue001 c o n n e c t e d \ue001 w i t h \ue001 e d u c a t i o n a l \ue001 o r g a n i z a t i o n s w h o \ue001 h a v e \ue001 a n d \ue001 s t i l l \ue001 a r e \ue001 r e c e i v i n g \ue001 v e r y \ue001 s u b s t a n t i a l \ue001 a i d \ue001 f r o m \ue001 t h e \ue001 l a r g e f o u n d a t i o n s

. "
1 4

Th e \ue001 i m p l i c a t i o n \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e s e \ue001 s t a t e m e n t s \ue001 i s \ue001 t h a t \ue001 a \ue001 g r a n t \ue001 b y \ue001 a \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n t o \ue001 e d u c a t i o n a l \ue001 g r o u p s \ue001 o r \ue001 i n s t i t u t i o n s , \ue001 o r \ue001 f o r \ue001 t h e \ue001 t r a i n i n g \ue001 o f \ue001 i n d i v i d u a l s t h r o u g h \ue001 f e l l o w s h i p s , \ue001 m a k e s \ue001 t h e \ue001 f o u n d a t i o n \ue001 r e s p o n s i b l e \ue001 f o r \ue001 t h e \ue001 v i e w s \ue001 o f s u c h \ue001 g r o u p s , \ue001 o r g a n i z a t i o n s \ue001 a n d \ue001 i n d i v i d u a l s \ue001 o n \ue001 p u b l i c \ue001 i s s u e s

. \ue001 Th e \ue001 r e -
p o r t \ue001 i n \ue001 q u e s t i o n \ue001 s e e m s \ue001 t o \ue001 a s s i g n \ue001 t h i s \ue001 r e s p o n s i b i l i t y \ue001 t o \ue001 u s \ue001 e v e n \ue001 i n \ue001 t h e
c a s e \ue001 o f \ue001 e m p l o y e e s \ue001 o f \ue001 Go v e r n m e n t \ue001 w h o \ue001 a r e \ue001 k n o w n \ue001 t o \ue001 w o r k \ue001 u n d e r \ue001 t h e
p o l i c y \ue001 d i r e c t i o n \ue001 o f \ue001 t h e \ue001 Pr e s i d e n t , \ue001 C a b i n e t \ue001 o f f i c e r s , \ue001 a n d \ue001 t h e \ue001 C o n g r e s s
.
1 0
Tr a n s c r i p t , \ue001 p
. \ue001 4 2 , \ue001 i b i d. ,\ue001p. \ue001 19
.
1 1
Th e \ue001 De p a r t m e n t \ue001 o f \ue001 St a t e \ue001 B u l l e t i n , \ue001 v o l
. \ue001 XXX, \ue001 No. \ue001 7 8 1 , \ue001 Pu b l i c a t i o n \ue001 5 5 0 3 \ue001 ( W a s h i n g t o n ,
D. \ue001C.
: \ue001U. \ue001S. \ue001 G o v e r n m e n t \ue001 Pr i n t i n g \ue001 Of f i c e , \ue001 J u n e \ue001 1 4 , \ue001 1 9 5 4 ) , \ue001 p
. \ue001 9 02
.
1 2
Tr a n s c r i p t , \ue001 p
. \ue001 14 07, \ue001 i b i d. ,\ue001p. \ue001 6 2 8
.
1 8
Tr a n s c r i p t , \ue001 p
. \ue001 14 03 , \ue001 I b i d. ,\ue001p. \ue001 6 2 7
.
1 4
Tr a n s c r i p t , \ue001 p
. \ue001 14 05 , \ue001 i b i d. ,\ue001p. \ue001 6 2 7
.
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...