Immiation RvwDcsion of th Board o mmgraton AppalsFa Church,
Fe: A012 043 018 -Batava NY Date:In re: MCHAEL MCARANE a..a Mchael Matn Mcfalae MOVAL PROCEDGSAPPEALO BEHAL O RSPODETPro seON BEAL OF DHS:Mchae G. Dreher Assstt Ce osel
he respondet, an ae who was admed to the Uted States as a aw peanet resdenton Apr 14,960 appeas e decson othe mmaton Judge dated October 31, 201 orderghs remova to Aba ad ateatvely to the Netherlads We w dsmss the respondet'sappeal.We revew mmaton Jdges ndgs o ct r clear error, but qestons olaw dscretonand jdent and a other sses appeas de ovo. 8 C.R. §§ 003. (d)(3)(), ().o the extet that the respondent calenges hs crrent detento on appeal, we note thatremova proceedngs ae sepate and apa om bod proceedngs.
8 CF R. § 10039(d).Ths we ack jisdcto to consder the respondets clams regadg s deteton he corseoconsdeing the appea oa decson remova proceedgsWe arm he mmgraton dges decson to order the respodent removed. On appea, theespodetrases no agment wch dsptes the mmgraton dge's detenaton hat, gto the respondents 2002 convcton r robbery n the trd degree n voaton o NY
§ 16005 (2002), whch rested n an yea term o mprisonmet beng mposed he s sbject toemoval om the Uted Sates as an alen who, at any tme aer admsson has been covcted oan aggravated ony (J. at 17; Ex 1; Exh 2)
sectos 01(a)(43)(G) 237(a)(2)(A)() othe Immaton and atonaty Act 8 S.. §§ 110(a)(43)(G) 227(a)(2)(A)() Whe werecognzethat the respodent as led a motion r postconvcton relewth e ew Yor statecors the pendency o a moto r postconvcto rele does not aect the naty o thehe respodets ctzenshp s ot cea. Te Record o Deportabe
admssbe Aen(orm213) states thatte respondet was bo on the sand oAruba on Agst 3, 1951. Today,Aba s oe ote constet counes that the Kgdom o the Neterlads. We asoobseve tat the resodents mmrant vsa ssed to the espodent n 960 states that therespondent s a Bts natoa and held a passport ssed by the Goveetothe owdssolvedWdward sands
Cite as: Michael McFarlane, A012 043 018 (BIA Jan. 18, 2012)