Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword or section
Like this
P. 1
Christian Responses to Muslim Questions

Christian Responses to Muslim Questions

Ratings: (0)|Views: 56|Likes:
Published by 1way

More info:

Published by: 1way on Apr 20, 2009
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





Translated by David Marshall
Meetings between individual Muslims and Christians and also between church and mosquecongregations are taking place today in more and more parts of the world. Joint projects ineducation and relief; visits to mosques and churches; dialogues in Muslim-Christian societies;lectures; discussions about local politics, and so on: these all provide opportunities for Christians and Muslims to ask questions about each other’s faith and practice.But are we Christians in fact prepared to give an adequate, sensitive and respectful accountof our own faith? Do we have at our disposal the necessary background knowledge of thespecific faith perspective and religious sensibility of Muslims?This short book is primarily addressed to Christians; it seeks both to provide them withinformation and also to prompt them to engage in further reflection and learning. It might offer a basis and a reference
point for Christian groups seeking to understand more accurately thequestions put to them by Muslims about the Christian faith and way of life, and also wishing toprepare themselves to respond to such questions as honestly and sympathetically aspossible.It cannot be emphasized too strongly that Islam contains at its very core a questioning of central Christian claims and of the concepts which arise from them. Muslims, with the Qur’anand the whole Islamic tradition as their starting point, will therefore continually articulate thisquestioning. This is an essential part of the mission with which all believing Muslims knowthemselves to have been entrusted. The Qur’an challenges Muslims to call others to Islamand also sets forth the way in which an appropriate dialogue should proceed: ‘Invite to theway of your Lord with wisdom and beautiful preaching; and argue with them in ways that arebest and most gracious: for your Lord knows best who have strayed from his path, and whoreceive guidance.’ (16:125)From 1974 onwards a group of Christians in Tunisia in North Africa met regularly withProfessor Robert Caspar M. Afr. for joint discussion of a sequence of questions aboutChristian faith and practice regularly raised by Muslims. The work carried out by this groupissued in 13 little chapters, each consisting of four stages: (I) formulation of the questions onone of the main themes, as Muslims express these questions; (II) the perspectives underlyingthese questions, first in general terms and then in greater detail; (III) Christian theologicalperspectives on the relevant question; and finally (IV) suggestions for the formulation of actualChristian responses to the Muslim questions. A small book consisting of these 13 chaptersappeared first in French and shortly afterwards, lightly revised, in English, under the title
Trying to Answer Questions
(Rome, Pontifical Institute for Arabic and Islamic Studies [PISAI],1989).On my return to Germany in 1999, after many years of experience and study of Muslimcivilizations and of work with Muslims in different parts of the Christian-Islamic world, it verysoon became clear to me that a thorough revision of this book was called for. At the CatholicAcademy in Berlin a circle of Catholic and Protestant Christians met more or less monthly for more than two years from 1999-2002; the members were all living in contact with Muslimsand therefore the subject of the book was of great practical interest to them. We deliberatelypreserved the book’s basic structure but left out a chapter dealing with questions about thepresence of Christians in an almost exclusively Muslim country such as Tunisia. The materialwas critically revised, adapted and in parts substantially re-written.My thanks go particularly to the Revd Dr Ulrich Schröter, who played a key editorial andtheological role in the whole process; and also to my colleague Erhard Kunz SJ, Professor of Dogmatic Theology here at Hochschule Sankt Georgen in Frankfurt, who made somesubstantial improvements to the Christian theological responses, in some places completelyre-writing them. Two years ago Robert Kaya prepared a Turkish translation of this book,which has been published in Istanbul (San Antuan, 2003), but which has attracted particular attention through the homepage http://www.islamacevaplar.com. Together with the Germanversion http://www.antwortenanmuslime.com, this offers the opportunity for further questionsto be raised and responses to be suggested. It is to be hoped that the English version
http://www.answers-to-muslims.com will have an even wider impact than its German andTurkish counterparts. Finally, I am indebted to my old friend the Revd Dr David Marshall, whohas not only translated the book accurately from German into English but has also enhancedthe text at many points in terms both of style and content. The English version should thus inmany respects improve on the German original. I record here my heartfelt thanks to all thosewho, in groups or as individuals, have shared in this project.May this material contribute to the enrichment of religious dialogue between Muslim andChristian believers based on better and more objective information; may it encourage thediscovery of shared foundations for living together in solidarity and peace; and may it alsoprompt each one of us to persist in the faithful search for the light of ever greater truth.Christian W Troll SJHochschule Sankt Georgen, Frankfurt a. M.28 June 2005

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
peeters liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->