Is state bonus probe partisan?

Sunday, August 03, 2008

BY CHARLES THOMPSON AND BRETT LIEBERMAN

Of The Patriot-News

The situations might sound familiar.Five-figure bonuses were given to state legislative staffers who spent weeks on campaign work.A former legislative staffer said her old boss routinely ran his House campaigns out of his districtoffice.A change in computer systems coincided with word that an investigation was under way.You might guess that these are the latest revelations from Attorney General Tom Corbett's investigationinto the House Democratic caucus.These actually are some of the facts that have surfaced over the last year out of the House and SenateRepublican caucuses -- groups that Corbett, a Republican, has insisted will receive the same scrutiny asDemocrats.For now, no charges have been filed.That wasn't the case with the Democrats. Last month, after an 18-month investigation, Corbett and hispublic-corruption unit announced charges against 12 people who were affiliated with the HouseDemocratic caucus. They included former whip Mike Veon of Beaver County and Michael Manzo, theformer chief of staff to House Democratic leader William DeWeese.The investigation of the Democrats intensified after concerns were raised about possible destruction of evidence, Corbett said. His investigators found an electronic trail of e-mails and other evidence that setthem on their way, he said. That investigation is continuing, and more charges could follow.But to many observers, the onus now is on Corbett and his staff to prove that he has looked just as hardat Republicans in the Legislature -- even those 2004-era decision-makers who supported and steereddollars into his campaign for attorney general."It's not partisan in the sense that the cases look pretty sound," said Chris Borick, a political scienceprofessor at Muhlenberg College. But "if this was going on on the Democratic side, you have to wonder if similar practices were going on somewhere else."Here's a look at some of the questions that have been raised about Republicans at the Capitol during theinvestigation.

Bonuses:

Just like the House Democrats, the Republican caucuses had bonus programs, and some of the largestbonuses in any caucus were awarded to GOP staffers. No publicly documented evidence has surfacedtying their bonuses to campaign work.Legally, staffers can get bonuses. And staffers can do campaign work on their own time. But they can't gettaxpayer-funded bonuses to do campaign work.Staffers can use their own time or take leaves of absence to do campaign work, but they can't usetaxpayer-paid time for campaign work. That is what the Democrats are accused of doing.

Top GOP bonuses in 2006 included $22,500 to Michael Long, a staff administrator to former SenatePresident Pro Tempore Robert Jubelirer. Long took about six weeks of leave that year to work for Jubelirer's re-election effort. Another $22,500 went to Stephen MacNett, the general counsel to theSenate Republicans who also serves as the treasurer of the Senate Republican Campaign Committee.A $19,467 payment was given to J. Andrew Crompton, a Senate Republican staffer who took 14 weeks of leave in 2006 to work on Republican Lynn Swann's gubernatorial campaign.MacNett defended the Senate bonuses last week. He said Crompton and other staffers put in tremendouseffort on the state's property tax cuts that the Legislature approved that year. Long was instrumental inguiding the caucus through a leadership transition after Jubelirer and Senate Majority Leader David"Chip" Brightbill were defeated at the polls, MacNett said.On the House GOP side, a $16,427 bonus was paid in 2006 to Brian Preski, the chief of staff to former Speaker John Perzel. Preski never went on leave from his state job, which paid $164,000. At the sametime, Perzel's campaign committee was paying him a $60,000 salary, plus reimbursements for travel andother expenses.Now working as a lawyer in Philadelphia, Preski made only limited comment about his activity in aninterview with The Patriot-News several months ago, saying the bonus was partly in recognition of hisunpaid service as the chief clerk of the House after a vacancy in that position.As to his simultaneous wearing of campaign and staff hats, Preski said, "We always made sure thelegislative work got done first, before we did any of the campaign work."

Computer changes:

The House GOP replaced computer equipment in 2007, after Corbett would have launched hisinvestigation.Corbett said e-mail trails provided some of the best, real-time evidence about the alleged conspiracyamong the Democrats. Democrats critical of the staging of the probe have argued that Republicans weregiven ample opportunity to clean their records.House Republican spokesman Steve Miskin confirmed last week that all GOP desktop computers werereplaced from July 17 to Sept. 6 last year at the Capitol and from Sept. 24 through Nov. 2 at districtoffices.That was when the probe of House Democrats was intensifying. But Miskin has contended that, becauseall prior records were archived on the Republicans' network servers, no potential evidence of interest toCorbett should have been lost."I can assure you that we have not destroyed any information," Miskin said.

Campaign work:

Lisa Ann Deon is a former staffer to state Rep. Matt Wright of Bucks County and has said that Wright'sstaff routinely did campaign work out of his Langhorne district office.In an affidavit from last year that was provided to Corbett's office, Deon stated that, early on, when shebecame more certain of the firewall that is supposed to exist between campaigns and governing, sheconfronted Wright about his political assignments.

"I would explain to Representative Wright that this was not proper," Deon stated. "Each time,Representative Wright told me not to worry about it, 'everyone does it.'"The practice continued until she reported it to Republican leaders in early 2006, at which point Housestaffers offered her a job in another office, Deon said.Neither Deon nor Wright responded to requests for an interview for this story.Other questions include whether taxpayer-funded resources were used for political material.

Corbett's campaigns:

All of this will play out against the backdrop of Corbett's re-election race this year and his status as acontender for the GOP gubernatorial nomination in 2010.Corbett is under pressure to apply the same level of scrutiny to the Republican caucuses as he did to theHouse Democrats.Some Democrats -- even while conceding the allegations against their former colleagues don't look good-- said they believe politics has already been played, if only in the timing of the investigation.Democrats said Corbett's office has called more than 100 Democratic staffers in for interviews or testimony before grand juries, compared with what they claimed is a handful of Republicans. There's anadvantage there if only in terms of giving people time to get their stories straight, some Democrats said."He's using this lame excuse that [House Democrats] gave the most bonuses," a state Democrat officialsaid. "I don't care if it was $10. If they gave bonuses for campaign work, it's wrong."Like many Democrats, that official would speak only on the condition of anonymity.Republicans in the Legislature have supported Corbett's campaigns.In his 2004 race, Jubelirer, Brightbill and Perzel were among his biggest donors. As recently asSeptember, Corbett's campaign committee received a contribution from a political action committee linkedto Brightbill, the Great Valley Leadership Fund.Corbett's campaign returned money to the Great Valley Leadership Fund this April, "once we realized itwas something Senator Brightbill had created after he left office," said Corbett's campaign manager, BrianNutt.Nutt said the money was returned in keeping with a policy to not take new money from any lawmakerswho were in office during the period under investigation or any committees affiliated with thoselawmakers.In his races, Corbett has drawn lines between taxpayer-funded staff work and campaign work done bystaffers on their time. Nutt, for example, moved from a full-time campaign role in 2004 to serving asCorbett's chief of staff through most of his first term in office. Nutt then returned to the campaign full timein June.As the campaign manager, Nutt is paid from the Friends of Tom Corbett Committee, and he gives up hisstate salary and benefits.