Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Health,Nature’s
Wealth
Accounts of
First Nations’
economic
development
initiatives
w w w
Table of Contents
Hupacasath First Nation
China Creek Micro Hydro 4
Tsleil-Waututh Nation
Planning Sustainable Forestry 22
Uqqurmiut Inuit
Uqqurmiut Centre for Arts and Crafts 28
Acknowledgements 34
On the Path to Conservation
The ecological diversity found within our traditional territories helps
to define and enrich our quality of life. Yet there are startling trends
that threaten this. Industrial resource extraction is consuming
resources and our territories at an increasingly rapid rate. Within the
lifetime of our children, our territories and our resources could be
damaged beyond repair.
Protecting British Columbia’s ecological diversity is the driving force
behind the work of many of our First Nations. Our conservation ethic
is deeply rooted in protecting our territories’ most important
landscapes while promoting the wise use of our renewable natural
resources. Maintaining this balance will move First Nations towards a
conservation-based economy and lead to economic self-sufficiency.
As First Nations communities we must encourage activities that
identify new resources and technologies, and that enhance our
current resource base to maximize lasting benefits for our quality of
life and the environment. Low-impact resource developments offer
First Nations one way to create a sustainable economy. We hope the
examples in Community Health, Nature’s Wealth provide communities
with incentives to move in this direction.
It is clear that low-impact resource development could be of great
benefit to coastal First Nations. And it is clear that we now have a
unique window of opportunity to create this kind of development.
But it is also clear that our time is short. The decisions we make today
about how to use our lands and resources will determine whether our
next generation will have access to and be sustained by them in the
future.
We must act now.
Art Sterrit
Executive Director
Coastal First Nations – Turning Point Initiative
1
Introduction
Long before the term “conservation-based
economy” was coined, First Nations
communities across Canada were
pursuing economic opportunities aligned
with the traditions and values of their
ancestors. These economic initiatives
provide for the needs of communities,
maintain healthy ecosystems and natural
resources, and restore First Nations’
stewardship of lands and waters.
In the North and Central Coast of British Columbia, First Nations have negotiated
Land Use Agreements that help to create the conditions that make this kind of economy
possible. Coastal First Nations are now poised to embark on new economic ventures,
guided by indigenous aspirations and wisdom. This booklet was inspired by our work
with the coastal communities. We believe that the stories featured here – a small sample
of the many community initiatives under way in Canada – offer useful information,
ideas, and lessons from other First Nations who are pursuing conservation-based
economies.
These stories show how communities have sought to unite traditions and customs with
today’s economic needs, and to develop opportunities within their traditional territories,
so their people do not have to choose between their homes and their careers. They
highlight some lessons these communities and their leaders have learned about decision-
making, planning, funding, and other issues involved in developing new businesses.
They describe the challenges that communities have overcome, and the benefits
communities have experienced.
Five different sectors are represented here: forestry, shellfish aquaculture, non-timber
forest products, renewable energy, and art. This diversity reflects some of the
opportunities Coastal First Nations have already identified for their own communities.
It also points to the importance of cultivating a variety of initiatives and enterprises in
order to build strong and resilient conservation economies.
2
Experience shows that community ventures are most
likely to be successful if they draw on a combination of
attributes: a spirit of innovation; careful planning;
perseverance and determination; faith in the project; the
courage to take risks; a willingness to seek and accept
help; and a firm grounding in the values and aspirations
Successful nations of the community itself. Each of these attributes is
evident in the stories presented here.
think strategically,
make informed While each of the stories gathered here is as unique as
the community that inspired it, there are some common
decisions, assume themes. Many of these communities faced the challenges
responsibility of remote locations; distance from markets; and lack of
for their own internal capacity, capital and infrastructure. Their strategies for
success also share many elements: careful planning;
affairs, and spend the engaging partners; establishing independent companies
time, energy, and that have community direction (for example, through
resources laying boards with community membership); creating a market
niche based on the identity of the community; and
sound institutional adapting traditions to contemporary times.
foundations for
Many of the benefits of low-impact economic
political, social, development are obvious. These communities have
economic and found ways to offer employment and income to people
living close to the land. They have created new
cultural progress.
opportunities for skills development and training, and
– Amy Besaw, Director, they have generated capital for re-investment.
Honoring Nations
Other benefits are less tangible, but just as important.
Program,
Harvard University
Diversified economies celebrate and honour First
Nations values, traditions, and vision for their territories.
They build a sense of pride and accomplishment. They
provide a foundation for self-governance, self-sufficiency
and self-determination.
Coastal First Nations are entering a new era. They are re-
asserting their rights and title to their lands, and are re-
establishing strong economies based on stewardship of
their territories. We congratulate their vision and their
determination, and we offer this booklet with our hope
that coastal communities will find these stories useful as
they carve their own path to success.
3
Hupacasath
Micro-hydro Power
w w w
© All photos within this section are the property of Hupacasath First Nation and are not to be reproduced without their written permission.
Council. She urged the council to
vote against a proposal to develop a
gas-fired power generation plant in
the Alberni Valley. Instead, Sayers
said, the city should work with local
First Nations towards a shared
economy and a shared energy plan –
both based on respect for the earth
and all living beings.
6
From Plan to Reality FUNDING SOURCES
Project development
Like First Nations everywhere in Canada, the
Hupacasath faced significant barriers in their effort to
funding (approximate)
find financing for this development project. From 2002 to Hupacasath First Nation
2004, the Hupacasath First Nation worked hard to put equity Aboriginal Business
together a sound business partnership and to attract Canada: $250,000
investors for the China Creek Project. The Hupacasath
partnership with Synex Energy (the parent of Sigma Indian and Northern
Engineering) established the engineering and financial Affairs Canada: $100,000
management expertise required to secure federal equity Federation of Canadian
matching capital for the project. Municipalities (Green
The Hupacasath researched and successfully applied for Municipal Enabling fund):
a broad range of funds to support their project planning, $90,000
development and negotiations. The Nation also
identified a few key champions, including supportive Nuu-chah-nulth
federal politicians, who could help bring in investment Economic Development
capital. As a result of this work, the Department of Corp: $90,000
Indian and Northern Affairs invested $2 million through Aboriginal Northern
an Indian and Northern Affairs economic development Climate Change Action
fund, and the Nation received another $900,000 from
Program: $250,000
another federal loan program. The Nuu-chah-nulth
Economic Development Corporation also contributed
some loan and equity financing. Capital Investment
However, conventional financing was still hard to find. Partners’ equity:
Even the Hupacasath’s own bankers thought the project $1,800,000
too risky. The struggle required perseverance and
INAC Equity Matching
creativity – and both of these came together when the
Hupacasath Nation teamed up with the VanCity Capital, Program: $2,000,000
the venture capital arm of Vancity Savings and Credit Western Economic
Union. VanCity helped the Hupacasath Nation to Diversification (Softwood
establish an innovative financing structure for this Industry Community
project: a nine-member debt syndicate that provided Economic Adjustment
more than $9 million in debt financing for the project.
Initiative): $900,000
In October 2004, as soon as the province issued a water
VanCity-led debt
licence for the project, the Hupacasath Nation began
construction. Thirteen months later, the project was syndicate: $9,000,000
complete: on time and under budget.
7
Corporate Structure and Governance
As part of the work to establish Upnit Power Corporation, the Hupacasath Nation
researched a variety of possible corporate structures. The Nation wanted a business
model that would be familiar to potential partners and investors, but also wanted to
protect the tax-exempt status of the development. After considering many options, the
Hupacasath Nation decided on a limited partnership model.
Upnit Power Corporation Limited owns and operates the China Creek power plant, and
has the ability to expand in order to take on additional projects. Upnit Power is
governed by a Board of Directors with representation from each business partner.
w w w
Revenue from Upnit Power Corporation is paid out annually in Upnit Power
the form of pro-rated dividends to each business partner. Corporation
Revenues are forecast at $1.2 to $1.4 million annually, of which a
portion will go to paying down the debt. Upnit Power expects to
Limited
be fully debt-free by 2013. Ownership
The China Creek micro-hydro development project employs
Structure and
Board of
two Hupacasath community members full-time. The project
also provides an important source of funds that will help to
Directors
finance future business ventures, and work is already under way Hupacasath
to create another micro-hydro project on a nearby creek. With an First Nation
established track record of success in planning, building, and 72.5% ownership
managing a significant green energy project, the Hupacasath 4 Board members
Nation is well-positioned to turn new community development
ideas into reality. Synex Energy
12.5% ownership
1 Board member
Ucluelet First
Nation
10% Ownership
1 Board member
Even before the power plant was
officially open, the outstanding
work of the Hupacasath First
City of
Port Alberni
Nation was recognized by the Port
Alberni Chamber of Commerce. 5% Ownership
Upnit Power Corporation won the 1 Board member
Chamber’s 2005 Business
Excellence award in the Valley
Environmental Award category.
9
Huu-ay-aht First Nation
© All photos within this section are by Stefan Ochman unless otherwise noted. The photos are not to be reproduced without written permission from Huu-ay-aht First Nation.
Shellfish Aquaculture
w w w
w w w
Learning by Doing
The decision to explore opportunities in shellfish aquaculture was relatively easy. However,
the decision to go into debt in order to launch the new venture was not. After carefully
examining the options, however, the community decided to take the chance.
In 2000, the Huu-ay-aht Nation decided to direct revenues from its forest
operations to establish the foundation for the new business. Within the year,
the Nation had acquired two shellfish aquaculture leases, invested in
infrastructure, hired a local shellfish grower as the operations manager and
trainer, and begun culturing clams and oysters for market.
By 2005, it became clear that the Nation’s initial assumptions about sales
were not being met, and the market prices for shellfish products had fallen.
The business was not breaking even. However, several people were now
employed by the operation, and they were excited about their new skills and
opportunities. The community was determined not to let them down. So
rather than give up on the operation, the community asked for help.
12
Seeding New Opportunities
In 2004, as part of its effort to strengthen its shellfish
operations, the Huu-ay-aht First Nation invested in a The FLUPSY system uses a
promising economic niche. The Nation developed a paddlewheel to upwell
business plan to establish the first commercial scale seawater through
nursery operation on the West Coast of Vancouver Island. containment tanks,
bringing a continual supply
The plan became a reality in 2006, when the Nation began of plankton and other
nutrients to the juvenile
operating its new Floating Upwelling System (FLUPSY), a
shellfish. Such systems offer
state-of-the-art shellfish nursery. The Nation is now able improved operating
to grow its own shellfish from seed, and can also sell efficiency as well as better-
juveniles to other communities and businesses for quality seed.
outplanting. Over time, the Nation plans to become a key
supplier of oyster and clam seed for shellfish aquaculture
operations on the West Coast of Vancouver Island.
The Nation is mindful of the need to separate business from politics. The shellfish leases
and the nursery project are operated by the Huu-ay-aht First Nation Fisheries
Department. Economic benefits from the project flow directly back to the community.
The oyster operation employs two to three people year-round, and the nursery provides
an additional 1.5 seasonal jobs. Another four to six people work through most of the year
harvesting clams. The clam harvest is managed on a contract basis, with the Nation
taking a 30 percent share of the revenue from sales. The nation seeds the beaches with
approximately 5 million juvenile clams each year.
For now, the shellfish are sent away to be processed before they reach urban markets.
However, the Huu-ay-aht Nation plans to establish a processing plant in order to keep
this activity in the community. The Nation also plans to diversify its operation into other
species including scallops, sea cucumbers, urchins, geoducks, and abalone.
13
Bamfield-Huu-ay-aht Abalone Program:
Uniting Economy and Ecology
Along with its other shellfish operations,
the Huu-ay-aht Nation takes a leadership
role in efforts to protect and rebuild
abalone stocks within its territory. The
Nation hopes that it will soon be able to
include farmed abalone among its
commercial shellfish products. However, its
investment in an abalone recovery
program is about much more than just
economic returns.
Ha-Shilth-Sa photo
w w w
Abalone was a highly-prized shellfish in traditional Huu-ay-aht society. The meat was
considered a delicacy, and the shells were used in jewellery, artwork, and ceremonial
regalia. In recent years, over-harvesting and poaching have done more than threaten the
populations of wild abalone on the west coast. They have also threatened an important
connection between Huu-ay-aht culture and the ocean ecosystem. This intersection of
ecology, economy, and culture brought the Huu-ay-aht Nation to a key role in the
Bamfield Huu-ay-aht Community Abalone Project.
The Abalone Project includes a “coastwatch” program aimed at reducing poaching, along
with research, stock enhancement, and commercial aquaculture. Through the program,
Huu-ay-aht members have been trained to conduct surveys, collect brood stock, and care
for juvenile abalone in a hatchery setting. The Nation is also working with the federal
government, through the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, to develop a streamlined
permit system to support and manage the sale of abalone products.
Juvenile
abalone
The preferred habitat of abalone
is in the lowest intertidal zone.
This means that the shellfish are
only exposed to beach
harvesting at a few exceptionally
low tides each year. In the past,
Huu-ay-aht women would
gather the shellfish for their
families. Today, abalone are a
rare sight along the west coast.
15
Lac La Ronge First Nation
A Lesson in Economic Diversity
w w w
The Lac La Ronge Band, with a population of just under
8000, is the largest First Nation in Saskatchewan and among
the ten largest in Canada. It is located on the shores of Lac
La Ronge, one of a series of giant lakes in the arc of the
Canadian Shield. In this landscape, fresh water is everywhere
– from some of the world’s largest lakes and rivers, down
to small ponds, streams and marshes.
© All photos within this section are the property of Lac La Ronge First Nation and are not to be reproduced without their written permission.
In the 1970s, the Lac La Ronge First Nation had just one source of income:
financial transfers from the Canadian government. The community was located
far from established markets, had no share in the resource development that
was taking place on its doorstep, and could offer few jobs to its members.
Clearly, something needed to change.
And change it did. Today, the Lac La Ronge First Nation owns Kitsaki
Management, which has become known as one of the best examples of
community-based economic development in Saskatchewan. The
community is the full or part owner of more than a dozen diverse
businesses that bring in over $70 million annually. These include a golf
course, a catering company, a trucking company, a sawmill,
a hotel, an environmental assessment company, an
insurance broker, and an organic food company specializing
in wild rice and mushrooms.
This food company, Northern Lights Foods, is now the
world’s largest exporter of organic wild rice. The story of
Northern Lights is an example of how the emerging
non-timber forest products sector can draw on
natural environmental assets to create
exceptional business opportunities.
18
Growing a Wilderness Advantage
The American farmed “wild” rice harvest depends Wild rice may only be the
heavily on fertilizers and pesticides. Because it uses
beginning for Northern Lights
neither, Northern Lights Foods was able to secure QAI
(Quality Assurance International) organic certification Foods. In 2001 the company
in 1992. This gave the company an important added certified organic wild
advantage at a time when organic foods were beginning
mushrooms to its product list.
to claim a growing market share.
With its established client base
European buyers continue to place a premium on
organic certification. To appeal to this market, and distribution system, the
Northern Lights’ marketing strategy emphasizes that its company is poised for
products come from a wild and isolated countryside continued success.
with a pristine environment, including pure waters and
clean air. Using these assets, the marketing program has
built a strong demand for Northern Lights products –
and also earned the company a 2001 Canada Export
Award.
Along with smart marketing, Northern Lights has been
very active in setting up wholesale and retail
distribution systems for its products. The company sells
in bulk to other companies that repackage the product
in their own retail brand for distribution. This
wholesale business includes warehouses in Europe, so
the company can provide next-day delivery to its “We process perhaps 25,000
international clients. At the same time, the company pounds of chanterelles a year.
ships retail products, packaged under its own Northern Morels are less predictable
Lights brand, all over the world.
because productivity is tied to
forest fires. The year after a
heavy fire season we might
take in over 100,000 pounds
of morels.”
ASSUR
TY
LI
A
QUA
NC
AL
R
company distributing a traditional Aboriginal product. NATIO
E
19
Northern Lights Foods is just one of the family of Kitsaki-owned
enterprises. Kitsaki Management Limited Partnership consistently
ranks in the Saskatoon Star-Phoenix’ Top 100 Saskatchewan
Companies. The corporation has also won many provincial,
national and international awards for its business success.
21
Tsleil-Waututh Nation
Planning Sustainable Forestry
Coastal First Nations know from experience
that it can be difficult to launch new economic
ventures in communities that are located a
long way from urban centres. The Tsleil-
Waututh Nation, however, has the opposite
problem. This Nation’s traditional territory
encompasses Burrard Inlet and Indian Arm
© All images within this section are the property of the Tsleil-Waututh Nation and can not be reproduced without written permission.
and includes much of Greater Vancouver.
w w w
Tseil-Waututh means “the people of In just a few generations, the Tsleil-Waututh
the Inlet.” The traditional territory of people witnessed enormous changes as heavy
the Tsleil-Waututh Nation is some of urban and industrial development displaced the
the most intensively exploited land
in BC. Along with intensive urban
resources of the land and sea. The Nation’s
development, these lands management role also changed. As industries,
support active logging stakeholders, and government agencies competed
operations, utility corridors, for development rights around the fast-growing
highways, water reservoirs, city, the Tsleil-Waututh people were excluded from
recreation developments,
and parks.
decision-making. From the perspective of the
outside economy, the Nation became more and
more invisible within its own lands.
Development in Greater Vancouver has not slowed
down. However, the Tsleil-Waututh Nation has
found new and powerful ways to take part in this
development – and to do so on its own terms.
Using a broad-based and integrated planning
process, and supported by carefully-negotiated
protocols and partnerships, the Nation is
instilling its own goals and values in
management practices throughout
its traditional territories.
In 2004, the Tsleil-Waututh Nation In 2004, the Nation negotiated a Forest and Range
Agreement for an additional 11,600 cubic meters per
received Forest Stewardship Council
year of wood. And in 2006, the Tsleil-Waututh began
(or FSC) certification for its woodlot negotiations to acquire the two remaining forest
and private land holdings. tenures in the Indian River watershed.
The certification gives international In just a few years, the Nation laid the groundwork
recognition to the Nation’s sound to establish a long-term, area-based community
forest tenure for the entire watershed. From the
stewardship practices. It also gives outside, it looks like things happened quickly – but
access to a growing market for the ability of the Nation to move quickly on new
sustainable wood products. opportunities is the result of more than a decade of
careful planning. By investing time and effort in a
long-term planning process, the Nation is able to
make the best use of all available tools and
partnerships to pursue its vision.
Territorial planning
identifies the overall vision, values, and goals for the
territory. Traditional use and occupancy maps connect
traditional stewardship responsibilities with current
resource management goals.
Watershed planning
translates the overall vision to watershed units that
comprise the territory. Watershed plans refine TWN
vision and goals by setting specific objectives and
w w w
actions to guide management direction.
The Tsleil-Waututh Nation
combines geographic information, Community and site planning
images, and text to map the establishes social, cultural, and economic indicators
physical and cultural resources of that are used to set management goals. Site plans
the traditional territory. For
define harvest techniques, regeneration strategies,
sensitive information, such as
cultural sites, the maps use measures to protect cultural and ecological values, and
approximations so specific sites safety requirements.
are not identifiable.
24
Planning Sustainable Forestry
Soon after purchasing the Inlailawatash lands, the Tsleil-Waututh Nation began a forest
management planning process to integrate economic, cultural, and ecological objectives.
This planning process highlights six key goals: 1 To practice a high level of
stewardship and conservation of
the forest ecosystem
Based on these goals, the Nation articulated a set
of forest stewardship objectives. Each objective is 2 To maintain and, where necessary,
clearly linked to the overall vision of the Nation. restore resources and
The Tsleil-Waututh forest management plan also
includes specific strategies to achieve each opportunities for Tsleil-Waututh
objective, along with indicators that can be used Nation activities and sustenance
as tools to measure progress. uses associated with the forest
This comprehensive plan provides a framework
that the Nation uses to pursue a wide range of 3 To create economic opportunities
forest-related initiatives. The forest management (revenue and/or employment) for
planning process is also an important part of the
Nation’s broader planning efforts for the whole of
members of the Tsleil-Waututh
the Indian River watershed. Nation
4 To strengthen the skills and
knowledge base for members of
the Tsleil-Waututh Nation in forest
ecosystem management
and the forestry sector
5 To provide a positive example of
sustainable forest resources
stewardship
6 To practice an adaptive
management approach
25
Planning for Business
Early in its integrated stewardship planning process, the Tsleil-Waututh Nation made a
decision to separate business from politics. However, the Nation still wanted to ensure
that all planning and development would remain rooted in the traditions and vision of
the community. With these two goals in mind, the Nation created a model that blends
corporate structure with community leadership.
• All Tsleil-Waututh forest stewardship operations are managed
by an independent company, Inlailawatash Forest Products
Limited (IFP). The company is governed by a Board of
Directors made up of prominent community members.
• Operational activities are directed by the Tsleil-Waututh
Treaty, Lands and Resources Caucus. The Caucus includes
Along with forest tenure
elected and traditional leaders, technical staff, and consultants.
management and
stewardship planning, IFP • Tsleil-Waututh forest stewardship operations are also the
has a highly successful
subject of consultations with the community as a whole.
vegetation management
program that provides a IFPs’ first harvest took place in 2002. Since then, IFP emphasis
positive alternative to
has been on creating forest management plans and a 10-year
herbicide use in the
territory. IFP has secured harvest plan for the woodlot tenure. The company’s long-term
contracts with government goal is to keep the complete processing of each tree – from the
and industry for utility and initial harvest to the finished product – in the hands of
right-of-way brushing, as the Nation.
well as for storm clean-up
and restoration.
27
Uqqurmiut Inuit
w w w
High in Canada’s Arctic, in theTerritory of Nunavut,
is the Inuit village of Pangnirtung. The community
is known for its spectacular surroundings on the
edge of a Baffin Island fjord, sheltered by a sheer
rock face from the bitter winter wind. The
community is also known as the home of some of
Along with
the world- the finest Inuit artists and craftspeople in the
famous prints,
Pangnirtung
world. Pangnirtung prints, tapestries, stone
Man Holding Inukshuk, Simo Kilabuk
crafts include sculpture and woven art have been displayed in The
woollen clothing
and blankets, National Gallery of Canada and the Canadian
© All images are the property of Urrqurmiut Centre for Arts and Crafts and are not to be reproduced without their written permission.
woven tapestries,
and carvings. Museum of Civilization, and can be found in
commercial art galleries in many countries. Each
year, art collectors look forward to the release of a
new collection of Pangnirtung prints.
The 2003 collection of prints by Pangnirtung artists celebrated 30 years of
printmaking in this community. This 30th-anniversary collection was also a
symbol of the perserverance and achievement of a group of artists who were
determined to keep printmaking, along with other arts and crafts, a vibrant
part of their community and their economy. Through the decades these
artists faced and overcame many business and administrative
challenges, and even literally pulled printmakng from the ashes to
create a successful arts and crafts enterprise.
Crafts includes a print shop, tapestry studio, a gallery and retail
space, and administrative offices. The Centre provides the
community of Pangnirtung with a major share in one of
the most important economic activities on Baffin
Island. As a fully Inuit-directed operation, the
Uqqurmiut Centre for Arts and Crafts is
firmly rooted in Pangirtung – but its
reach extends to markets around
the world.
w w w
30
. . . and Local Benefits
Uqqurmiut Arts and Crafts leases the studio and
“Celebrating a Gathering”
Ishmael Naulalik/Geetee Maniapik/Kawkysie Kakee
31
The Art of Community Development
The economic contribution made by the Centre to the
33
Acknowledgements
Jason Forsyth
Marine Stewardship Coordinator
Tsleil-Waututh Nation
Terry Helary
General Manager
Northern Lights Foods
Larry Johnson
Economic Development Manager
Huu-ay-aht First Nation
Trevor Jones
Chief Executive Officer
Hupacasath First Nation
Evan Stewart
Natural Resources Management
Coordinator
Tsleil-Waututh Nation
Peter Wilson
General Manager
Uqqurmiut Centre for Arts and Crafts
34
Interviews and text by Darcy Dobell and David Pitt-Brooke
Design and layout by Marion Syme