Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
No. 23 -
M a rc h
1 9 8 1
S im u lta n e o u sO p tic a l/X -r a y B u rs ts
J a n
v a nP a ra d ijs , A s tr o n o m ic a l In s titu te , U n iv e r s ityo f A m s te r d a m
In tro d u c tio n
T h e
m a jo rity
o f th e
b r ig h t g a la c tic
X -ra y
s o u rc e s
a re
m a s s - e x c h a n g in g
b in a ry
s ta rs
in
w h ic h
a n o rm a l
com \ue000
p a n io n
s ta r
is
tra n s fe rrin g
m a tte r to
i t s
com pact
com \ue000

p a n io n ,inm o s tc a s e s a n e u tro n s ta r. A n e u tro ns ta r is a n e x tre m e ly d e n s e c o n c e n tr a tio n o f m a tte r: a m a s s e q u a l to th a t o f th e s u n ( d ia m e te r 1 .4 m illio n k m ) is c o n c e n tr a te din a

s p h e re
w ith
a
d ia m e te r
o f
o n ly
a b o u t
2 0km .
T h e
g ra v ita tio n a l fo rc e
near such
a
s ta ris
v e ry

s tro n g , a n d , u p o n fa llin g o n th e n e u tr o ns ta rs u rfa c e , th e in fa llin g m a tte r re a c h e s

a v e lo c ity o f a b o u t h a lf th a t o f lig h t. T h e
k in e tic
e n e rg y
o f
th is
m a tte r
is
tra n s fo rm e d
in to
h e a t
(th e
te m p e ra tu re
re a c h e s
v a lu e s
in
e x c e s s
o f1 0 m illio n
d e \ue000
g re e s ) a n d
ra d ia te d
in
th e fo rm
o f X -ra y s .
A lm o s t
a ll b rig h t X -ra y
s o u rc e s
b e lo n g
t o
o n e
o f th e
fo llo w in g
tw og ro u p s :
-
M a s s iv e
X -ra y
b in a r ie s .
T h e
c o m p a n io n
s ta r
o f

th e n e u tro n s ta r is m o re m a s s iv e th a n a b o u t1 0M o. These s y s te m s

a re
young. The
(ro ta tin g )
n e u tro n
s ta rh a s
a
( n o n - a lig n e d ) s tr o n g m a g n e tic fie ld , w h ic h
show su pin
p u ls a tio n s
0 1th e
X - r a y e m is s io n .
-
L o w -m a s s
X -ra y b in a rie s . T h e
m a s s o f th e c o m p a n io n
s ta risle s s th a n 1 M o . M a n y o fth e s e s y s te m s e m it X -ra y
b u rs ts , w h ic h
a re th e
re s u lt o f th e rm o n u c le a r ru n a w a y
p ro c e s s e s
in
th e
fre s h ly
a c c re te d
s u rfa c e
la y e r s
of a
n e u tro n
s ta r.
X -ra y
p u ls a tio n s
a n d
X -ra y
b u rs ts
h a v e
n e v e r
b e e n
o b s e rv e d
fro m
th e
sam e
s o u rc e .
T h is
a g re e s
w ith

th e th e o re tic a le x p e c ta tio nth a ta s tr o n g m a g n e tic fie ld in h ib its u n s ta b le n u c le a r b u rn in g .

D u rin g
s im u lta n e o u s o b s e rv a tio n s o f X -ra y b u rs t s o u r\ue000
c e s( u s in g
X - r a y s a te llite s a n d o p tic a l te le s c o p e s ) itw as
d is c o v e r e d
th a t
c o in c id e n t
w ith
X -ra y
b u rs ts
a
s u d d e n
in c r e a s e o f th e o p tic a l b r ig h tn e s sta k e sp la c e .
In

th is a rtic le I w illd is c u s s th e s ec o in c id e n t X -ra y a n d o p tic a l b u rs ts , a n d s h o w th a t s u c h e v e n ts c o n ta in in fo rm a \ue000 tion on the structure oflo w - m a s sX -ra y b in a rie s .

O b s e rv a tio n s o f O p tic a l B u rs ts

T h e firs t s im u lta n e o u s X -ra y a n d o p tic a l o b s e rv a tio n s o f X -ra y b u rs te rs w e re m a d e d u rin g th e s u m m e r o f 1 9 7 7 . T h e X -ra y

o b s e rv a tio n s
w e re
m ade
w ith
th e
S A S -3
X -ra y
s a te llite
b y
a
g ro u p
o f
a s tro n o m e rs
a t
M IT
(W . L e w in ,
J .H o ffm a n
a n d
c o -w o rk e rs ).
O p tic a l
a s tro n o m e rs
fro m
m any
c o u n trie s
p a rtic ip a te d
in
th is
"b u rs tw a tc h ",a n d
in
s o m ec a s e s X -ra y b u rs ts w e re d is c o v e re d fro m
th e s o u rc e
4 U 1 8 3 7 + 0 5
(S e rp e n s
X -1 )
d u rin g
o p tic a l
c o v e ra g e .
( A
"h it"inb u rs te rja rg o n ).In n o n e o f th e s ec a s e sw as th e re

a n y s ig n ific a n t in c r e a s e o f th e o p tic a l s ig n a l d u rin g th e X \ue000 ra y b u rs t, a n d o n ly u p p e r lim its to th e a m o u n t o f e n e r g y in a p o s s ib le o p tic a l b u r s t c o u ld b e g iv e n . A s tr o n o m e r s a t th e o b s e r v a to r ie s o f A s ia g o (Ita ly ), C rim e a ( S o v ie t U n io n ) a n d K a g o s h im a

(J a p a n ) fo u n d
th a tle s s th a n
o n e
p a rtin
te n
th o u s a n d
o f
th e
X -ra y
b u rs t
e n e rg y
w as
e m itte d
in
a
p o s s ib le o p tic a l b u rs t.
D u rin g
th e
sum m er of 1978,J .G r in d la y
(H a rv a rd ) a n d
J .M c C lin to c ka n dC . C a n iz a r e s (M IT ) m a d e a n e wa tte m p t
u s in g a v e ry s e n s itiv e p h o to m e te r a t th e 1 .5 m te le s c o p e a t
C e rro T o lo lo . T h e X -ra y o b s e rv a tio n s w e re a g a in
m ade by
th e
M IT
g ro u p
u s in g
S A S -3 .
O n
J u n e
2 ,
1 9 7 8 , th e
firs t
s im u lta n e o u s
o p tic a l/X -ra y
b u rs tw as
d e te c te d
fro m
th e
s o u rc e4 U /M X B
1 7 3 5 -4 4
( s e e F ig . 1 ) .
T h e
a m o u n t o f e n e rg y
in
th e
o p tic a lb u rs tw as
m uch
s m a lle r
th a n
th e
u p p e r
lim it
fo u n d
d u rin g
th e
1 9 7 7
o b s e rv a tio n s .
T h e
ra tio
f of the
a m o u n t o f e n e rg y
in
th e
o p tic a l
a n d
X -ra y
b u rs ts
w as
2 x
1 0 -5
.
A n
e x tre m e ly
im p o rta n t re s u lt o f th is
o b s e rv a tio n
w as
th a tth e
o p tic a l
F ig .1 :
S im u /ta n e o u s
o p tic a // X -ra y
b u rs t
o b s e rv e d
o n
J u n e
2 8 ,
1 9 7 9
tro m
M XB
1 6 3 6 -5 3 .
T h e
o p tic a l b u rs t (u p p e r p a n e l)
w as
o b s e rv e db yH o /g e r P e d e rs e n
w ith
th e
D a n is h
1 .5m
te le s c o p e
a t
E S O .
T h e
X - r a y b u r s t w a s o b s e r v e d in
s e v e ra l X -ra y d e te c to rs o n
b o a r d th e J a p a n e s e s a te llite H a k u c h o .T h eH a k u c h o te a m
ish e a d e d
b yM in o r uO da. T im e g iv e n is U r .
E .S .O .
1 5 0
O P T IC A L
1 0 0
5 0
FM C
1 5 0
X -R A Y
l1 -1 0
k e V }
1 0 0
ct s
I .75 seconds
5 0
tio n s
s h o w
th a tth is c o n tr ib u tio n
to th ed e la y is p ro b a b ly
a few
te n th so fas e c o n d o n ly .
B e c a u s e
o fth e
fin ite
s iz e
o fth e
a b s o rb in g
b o d y , th e

o p tic a le m is s io n fro md iffe re n tp a rtso f it w ills u ffe rd iffe re n t d e la y s . T h e r e fo r e th e o p tic a l s ig n a l isn o t o n ly d e la y e d , b u t a ls o s m e a r e d o u t. T h ep r e c is ev a lu e so f th e d e la y a n d th e s m e a r in g

d e p e n d
o n
th e
s iz e
a n d
s h a p e
o fth e
re g io n
w h e re
th e
X -ra y sa re
re p ro c e s s e d .
F ro m
th e
o b s e rv e d
v a lu e so fd e la ya n d s m e a r in go f th e o p tic a l s ig n a l o n e m a y ,
in
tu rn , h o p e
t o
o b ta in
in fo rm a tio n
o n
th e
lo c a tio n
o f th e
a b s o rb in g
m a tte r.
o
~
~
O
+
-
-
-
-
~
" 1 " " 1 "
1 1
1
1:5 5 = 0 0 1 :5 5 :3 0
1 :5 6 :0 0
/ . 0
2 0
5 0
5 0
6 0
1 0 0
CM C
X -R A Y
(3 -1 0 k e V )
ct s/
7 5s e c o n d s
FM C
X -R A Y
{1 0 -2 5k e v }
c ts
I .75 seconds
In te rp re ta tio n o f O p tic a l B u rs t O b s e rv a tio n s
s ig n a lw as d e la y e dw ithre s p e c tt o th eX -ra yb u rs t b y 2 .5
to 3 s e c o n d s .
L a te r
in
th e
sum m er
o f
1 9 7 8
a n
o p tic a l
b u rs t
w as
d e te c te d
fro m
S er
X -1
b y
J .H a c k w e il,
D .G e h rz ,
a n d
G .G r a s d a le n o f th e U n iv e r s ityo f W y o m in g , u s in g a9 0 in c h
te le s c o p e
(w h ic h
w as
b u ilt fo r in fra re d

o b s e rv a tio n s ). A n X -ra yb u rs tw asd e te c te ds im u lta n e o u s lyw ithS A S -3 . T h e ra tio f tu rn e do u tto b e e v e ns m a lle r th a n fo r M X B1 7 3 5 -4 4 : o n ly

3 x
1 0 -6
o fth e
X -ra y
b u rs te n e rg y tu rn e d
u p
in
th e
o p tic a lb u rs t. T h is o p tic a lb u rs ta ls ow a s d e la y e d , b y~
1 .5
s e c o n d s , r e la tiv et oth e
X -ra y b u rs t.
A fte ritw as
know n
th a to p tic a lb u rs ts
d o

e x is tit w a s w o rth w h ilet om akea la rg e s c a le o b s e r v a tio n a la tta c k , to g e tab e tte rin s ig h tinth e ir p ro p e rtie s .S in c eX -ra yb u rs ts o c c u ra tin te rv a lso f h o u rs , b u ts o m e tim e s d on o ts h o w

u p fo rm u c h Io ng e r p e rio d s , m a n y n ig h ts o f o b s e r v in g tim e a re n e e d e d fo r a r e a s o n a b lec h a n c et oh a v e a"h it". D u rin g th e sum m ero f1 9 7 9

th e
D a n is h
a s tro n o m e r
H .P e d e rs e n
o f
E S O
s p e n t2 0n ig h ts
o fo b s e r v in g
tim e
w ith
th e
D a n is h
1.5 m
te le s c o p e
o n
L a
S illa
o n
o b s e rv a tio n s
o f
o p tic a l
b u rs ts
(T h e M e s s e n g e rN o . 1 8 ,1 9 7 9 ,p . 3 4 ).
S A S -3
h a tre e n te re d
th e
e a rth 's
a tm o s p h e re
in

A p ril 1 9 7 9 ,b u tfo rtu n a te lyan e wJ a p a n e s e s a te llite ,"H a k u c h o ", h a d

b e e n
la u n c h e d ,
w ith
w h ic h
th e
X -ra y
o b s e rv a tio n s
w e re
p e rfo rm e d .
T h e
J a p a n e s e
te a m
w as
h e a d e d
b y
M .O d ao f th eT o k y o In s titu te fo rS p a c e R e s e a rc h . T h e X \ue000
ra y
a n d
o p tic a l
o b s e rv a tio n s
w e re
c o o rd in a te d
b y
th e
S A S -3
g ro u p
a tM IT
(L .C o m in s k y ,G . J e r n ig a n ,W . L e w in
a n dJ .v a n
P a ra d ijs ).
T h e s e
o b s e rv a tio n s
w e re
v e ry
s u c c e s s fu l:
1 5
o p tic a l
a n d
1 6X -ra yb u rs tsw e red e te c te dfro m
th es o u rc e
M XB
1 6 3 6 -5 3 ;infiv e
c a s e sa"h it" o c c u rre d .
T o
fin is h
th is
c h a p te r:
d u rin g
th e
sum m er
o f
1 9 8 0 ,
H .P e d e rs e n ,C . M o tc h
a n d
J .v a n
P a r a d ijs
o b s e rv e d

2 5 o p tic a l b u rs ts , fo u ro f w h ic h w e red e te c te dintw oo r th re e c o lo u r ss im u lta n e o u s ly .In 6 c a s e s th e r ew as a"h it" w ith H a k u c h o . It is s till to o e a r ly to g iv ed e ta ilso n

th e s em ost
re c e n tre s u lts .
In
th e
fo llo w in g
w e
w ill
s e e
h o w
th e s e
o p tic a l
b u rs t
o b s e rv a tio n s
c a n
b e
u s e d
a s
p ro b e s
o f th e
s tru c tu re
o f
lo w -m a s sX -ra yb in a ry s y s te m s .
O p tic a l
b u rs ts
c o n ta in
o n ly
a
v e ry
m in u te
fra c tio n
(~
1 0 -5)
o fth e
e n e rg ye m itte d
in
X -ra y
b u rs ts . Y e t th is
s m a llam ountis m a n yth o u s a n d
tim e s la rg e r th a n
w hatis
e x p e c te d
fro m
a
s im p le
e x tra p o la tio n
o f
th e
o b s e rv e d
X -ra y
s p e c tru m
in
th e
b u rs t
to w a rd s
th e
lo n g e r
w ave\ue000
le n g th s
in
th e
o p tic a l p a s s b a n d .In
c o m b in a tio n
w ith
th e
o b s e rv a tio n
th a ta ll o b s e r v e d
o p tic a lb u rs ts
a re
d e la y e d ,
th is
le a d s to
th e
id e ath a tth e ya re th e
r e s u ltof atra n s \ue000
fo rm a tio n
o fp a rt o fth e
X -ra y
b u rs te n e rg y
in to

o p tic a l ra d ia tio n . T h eb a s icp ic tu reisth a tm a tte rin th e v ic in ityo f th e

X -ra yb u rs ts o u rc e
a b s o rb sa fra c tio n
o f th e
in fa llin g
X -ra y s ,
i s
th e re b y
h e a te d , a n d
a s
a
c o n s e q u e n c e
e m its
ra d ia tio n
a tlo n g e r w a v e le n g th s .
T h e to ta lp a th le n g thfo r th eX -ra y s w h ic h
firs t tra v e l to
th e
a b s o r b in g
m a tte r,
a n d
o fth e
s u b s e q u e n tly
e m itte d
o p tic a lp h o to n s
i s
lo n g e r th a n
th a to fth e
X -ra y s
w h ic h
re a c h th eo b s e rv e r d ir e c tly . T h ed e la yo f th e o p tic a l s ig n a l
i s
a
n a tu ra lc o n s e q u e n c e .
A
fu rth e r
c o n trib u tio n
t o
th e
d e la y
m ay
b e
e x p e c te d
b e c a u s e
th e
a b s o rp tio n
o f th e
X -ra y s a n d th e re a p p e a ra n c e
o fth e o p tic a lp h o to n s fro m
th e
a b s o r b in g
m e d iu m
ta k e s a fin ite
tim e . D e ta ile d c a lc u la -
2
A

m e th o d toe x tra c tth is in fo rm a tio nc o n s is tso fc a lc u \ue000 la tin gs y n th e tic o p tic a lb u rs ts fo r s e v e ra lassum edd is tri\ue000 b u tio n so f th e a b s o rb in g m a tte r, a n d c o m p a rin gth e s e w ith th e o b s e rv e d o p tic a l a n d X -ra y d a ta .Ino rd e r toc a lc u la te a

th e o re tic a l
o p tic a l
b u rs t,
a
n e tw o rk
o f
s m a ll
s u rfa c e
e le m e n ts
i s
d e fin e d
o n
th e
s u rfa c e
o fth e

re p ro c e s s in g b o d y . E a c h e le m e n t re fle c ts p a rto fth e in fa llin g X - r a y s a n d a b s o rb sth e re s t. T h e re s u ltin gte m p e ra tu re o f th es u rfa c e e le m e n td e p e n d s o n

th e X - r a y lu m in o s ity , th ed is ta n c eo f
th e
s u rfa c e
e le m e n tt o
th e
X -ra y
s o u rc e
a n d
th e
a n g le
u n d e r w h ic h th e X -ra y s re a c h th e e le m e n t. T h e fra c tio n o f
th e
a b s o rb e d
X -ra y
e n e rg y
w h ic h
re a p p e a rs
a s
o p tic a l
p h o to n s
d e p e n d s
o n
th e
te m p e ra tu re
T
o fth e
s u rfa c e
e le m e n t a n d
o n
th e
w a v e le n g th
o fth e
p h o to n s . F o r h ig h
v a lu e s
o f
T
m ost
o f
th e
ra d ia tio n
i s
re e m itte d
in

th e u ltr a v io le tp a rto fth e s p e c tru m , w h ic hc a n n o t b e o b s e rv e d w ith

g ro u n d -b a s e d
in s tru m e n ts .
B y
a rra n g in g
th e
c o n trib u tio n so fa lls u rfa c e
e le m e n ts
a c c o rd in gto th e ir d e la y e d a rriv a l tim e s w e c a nre c o n s tru c t
th e
p ro file
o fa n
o p tic a l
b u rs ta s
i t
i s
e x p e c te d
fo r
a n
in fin ite ly s h a r p X -ra y b u rs t.S in c ea re a lX -ra yb u rs t h a s a
fin ite
d u ra tio n , th e
s h a p e
o f th e
o p tic a l
b u rs t
w ill
b e
a
c o n v o lu tio no fth isc a lc u la te d o p tic a lre s p o n s e p ro file w ith
th e p ro file o f th e
X -ra y b u rs t.

W ith in th efra m e w o rko falo w - m a s s X -ra y b in a ry m o d e l, o b v io u slo c a tio n sfo r th e p ro d u c tio no f a n o p tic a lb u rs t a re th e

s u rfa c eo fth e c o m p a n io n
s ta rand ana c c re tio n

d is k o T h ela tte ris fo rm e d a ro u n d th e n e u tro n s ta r,b e c a u s e th e m a tte r

w h ic h
le a v e s
th e
c o m p a n io n
c a n n o t
re a c h
th e
n e u tro n
s ta r
d ir e c tly .
D ue
t o
th e
ro ta tio n
o fth e

b in a ry s y s te m , th isg a sflo w sina lm o s tc ir c u la r o rb its a ro u n d th e n e u tro n

s ta r.B e c a u s e
o f m u tu a l fric tio n , th e
g a s
s lo w ly
s p ira ls in w a rd , c r e a tin g ad is k -s h a p e d c o n fig u ra tio n .
T h e ra d iu so fth e c o m p a n io ns ta r is m u c h

s m a lle r th a n i t sd is ta n c et oth e n e u tro n s ta r. T h e re fo re th ed iffe re n c e s in

th e
p a th le n g th
o fa b s o rb e d
X -ra y s
a n d
s u b s e q u e n tly
e m itte d
o p tic a l
p h o to n s
a re
r e la tiv e ly
s m a ll.
T h u s
o n e
e x p e c tsth a tfo r o p tic a lb u rs ts o r ig in a tin ga t th e c o m p a n io n
T e n ta tiv e T im e -ta b le o f C o u n c il S e s s io n s
a n d C o m m itte e M e e tin g sin
1 9 8 1
M ay 4
C o m m itte eo f C o u n c il
M ay 7 - 8
F in a n c e C o m m itte e
M ay 7
S c ie n tificT e c h n ic a l C o m m itte e
M ay 8
U s e rs C o m m itte e
M ay2 1
-
2 2
O b s e rv in g P ro g ra m m e s C o m m itte e
June 4
C o u n c il,S to c k h o lm
N ovem ber1 0
S c ie n tificT e c h n ic a l C o m m itte e
N ovem ber1 1
-
1 2
F in a n c e C o m m itte e
N ovem ber1 3
C o m m itte eo f C o u n c il
N ov.3 0-
Dec. 1 -
2 O b s e rv in g P ro g ra m m e s C o m m itte e
D ecem ber3 -
4
C o u n c il
A ll m e e tin g s w ill ta k e
p la c e a t E S O
inG a r c h in g ,u n le s s
s ta te d o th e rw is e .
s ta r, th e s m e a rin g
w ill b e s m a ll c o m p a r e d

to th e a v e ra g e d e la y . F o r a d is k , o n th eo th e rh a n d , o n ee x p e c tsth a t th e s m e a rin g a n d d e la y a rea p p r o x im a te lye q u a l. T h is g iv e s u s a

p o s s ib ility
t o
d e c id e
w h e re
in
th e
b in a ry
s y s te m
th e
o p tic a lb u rs to r ig in a te s .
D e ta ile d
c a lc u la tio n s
b y
L o n d o n ,
M c C ra y
a n d
A u e r
(J F L A , B o u ld e r)
h a v e
show n
th a tth e
o p tic a l r e e m is s io n
c a n
b e
c lo s e ly
a p p ro x im a te d
b y
a
P la n c k ia n
ra d ia tio n
c u rv e .
For a
fix e d
w a v e le n g th
th e
b rig h tn e s s
th e n
o n ly
d e p e n d s
o n
th e
te m p e ra tu re
o fth e
ra d ia tin g
b o d y . T h is
te m p e ra tu re ,
in
tu rn ,
d e p e n d s
o n
th e
in te n s ity
o f
th e
in fa llin g
X -ra y s .
In
th is
w ay
a
re la tio n
c a n
b e
d e r iv e d

b e tw e e n th eb rig h tn e s so fth eX -ra ys o u rc e a n d th e o p tic a l b rig h tn e s so f a s u r fa c e e le m e n t. If w ew is h toa p p ly s u c h a

re la tio n
in
a
c o m p a ris o n
o fth e
o b s e rv e d
o p tic a l a n d
X -ra y
b u rs ts , w e
h a v e
t o
r e a liz e
th a tth e
te m p e ra tu re
in
th e P la n c k fu n c tio n
is an
a v e ra g e o v e r th e d iffe re n tp a rts
o fth e a b s o rb in g
re g io n .
.: .~
.
~
.:.,::..:....:.
\u2022
\u2022 1
~
.
:
~
.
:
:
:
:\u2022 \u2022 \u2022\
0 "
\u2022
F ig .2 :
S c h e m a tic
re p re s e n ta tio n
o fth e
o p tic a l b u rs ta s
o r ig in a tin g
fro m
re p ro c e s s in g
o fX -ra y s
in
a n
a c c re tio n
d is k
s u rro u n d in g
th e
X-ray source.
3
Search History:
Searching...
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
  • p.
  • More From This User

    Notes
    Load more