Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
P. 1
The other side of the Métis story

The other side of the Métis story

Ratings: (0)|Views: 18|Likes:
Paul L.A.H. Chartrand comments on the Supreme Court decision regarding Metis lands under the Manitoba Act of 1870. Paul L.A.H. Chartrand is a retired professor of law and a historian who resides in his home community of St. Laurent on Lake Manitoba on a part of the land that was originally allotted to his great-grandfather pursuant to the Manitoba Act 1870.
Paul L.A.H. Chartrand comments on the Supreme Court decision regarding Metis lands under the Manitoba Act of 1870. Paul L.A.H. Chartrand is a retired professor of law and a historian who resides in his home community of St. Laurent on Lake Manitoba on a part of the land that was originally allotted to his great-grandfather pursuant to the Manitoba Act 1870.

More info:

Categories:Types, Brochures
Published by: Lawrence J. Barkwell on Jul 24, 2013
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
See more
See less

02/13/2014

 
Pbg ktbgr sh`g kj tbg Nèths stkry
Fy1 ]iul Cbirtrie`
FKVHS NHEOGZHCB + THEEH]GD JVGG ]VGSS IVCBHZGS "THEEH]GD JVGG ]VGSS(
Ke Jrh`iy, tbg Suprgng Ckurt kj Ciei`i divg hts `gchshke he tbg Niehtkfi NèthsJg`grithke cisg, driethed i `gclirithke tbit tbg jg`gril dkvgrenget jihlg` tk prkpgrlyhnplgnget Sgc% 39 kj tbg Niehtkfi Ict 924=% Pbhs hs i lie`niro cisg ie` i shdehjhcietstgp he tbg cketgnpkriry eithkeil `gfitg ifkut tbg plicg kj tbg Nèths pgkplg he tbgbhstkry ie` lhjg kj kur ckuetry%I `gclirithke hs ekt lgdilly fhe`hed kj htsglj fut ht `gclirgs wbit tbg liw kj tbgCkesthtuthke rgquhrgs% He Ciei`i, dkvgrengets irg gxpgctg` tk ifh`g fy tbg liw kj tbgCkesthtuthke ie` tbg rulg kj liw% Pbg `gclirithke he tbg NNJ cisg nust lgi` tk prk`ucthvg ie` dkk` jihtb egdkthithkes ie` nust gedidg fktb tbg jg`gril ie` prkvhechildkvgrengets% Pbg ihn kj tbg egdkthithkes whll fg ke rgng`hil ngisurgs tk icckuet jkr tbgdkvgrenget$s jihlurg tk rgspgct tbg liw kj tbg Ckesthtuthke he `gilhed whtb tbg lie` rhdbtskj tbg Nèths rgsh`gets kj tbg krhdheil &pkstidg stinp& pkrthke kj Niehtkfi% Egdkthithkes whll ekt fg gisy% Pbg prkvhecg$s fkue`irhgs bivg fgge gelirdg`% Pbg ckurt,cketriry tk ill rgiskeiflg kpthkes, he ny vhgw, `h` ekt iccgpt tbg irdunget tbit tbg purpksg kj Sgc% 39 wis tk crgitg i Nèths lie` fisg he Niehtkfi% Keg kj tbg rgsults hs tk9
 
hevhtg i jkcus ke he`hvh`uil `gscge`iets kj tbg krhdheil drietggs kj Sgc% 39, wbk ekw lhvghe tbg Nèths `hispkri he Sisoitcbgwie ie` he ktbgr plicgs%Fgbhe` tbg au`hchil vhgws lhgs i shehstgr tilg tbit jihls tk gxpksg tbg gxtget ie` drivhty kj tbg stkry kj tbg drgit Nèths `hspkssgsshke ie` `hispkri% Pbg NNJ cisg cie fg gxpgctg`tk dgegritg i stkrn kj cketrkvgrsy inked bhstkrhies, wbksg crijt sk kjtge clisbgs whtbtbg ckurts$ pricthcil rklg kj rgsklvhed `hsputgs hestgi` kj `gfithed cketgstg` bhstkrhciljicts% Pbg ktbgr sh`g kj tbg stkry egg`s tk fg rgvgilg`%He Ciei`i$s ckurts tbg hssug bis fgge ckecgreg` whtb i`vieched tbg rgckechlhithke kj tbgckejlhcthed hetgrgsts kj tbg ifkrhdheil pgkplgs he tbghr bknglie`s whtb tbg hetgrgsts kj tbgrgst kj Ciei`i% He tbg pist tbg ckurts bi` hetgrprgtg` ktbgr prkvhshkes kj tbg Niehtkfi Icttbit bi` fgge hetrk`ucg` tk prktgct tbg rhdbts kj tbg Nèths is i jkue`hed pgkplg he tbg prkvhecg, heclu`hed `geknheithkeil scbkkl rhdbts ie` nkrg rgcgetly Jrgecb lheduhsthcrhdbts he tbg jinkus Niehtkfi Lieduidg Vgjgrgecg Cisg he 9827% Pbhs au`hchil bhstkryilkeg rgvgils tbg rgsults kj tbg Nèths `hspkssgsshke1 tbg rhdbts sgcurg` fy kur iecgstkrsirg ekw fghed geakyg` fy egwckngrs tk kur bknglie`s wbk bivg bi` tbg ngies ie`kppkrtuehthgs tk geakhe tbg isshstiecg kj tbg ckurts he issgrthed tbgn% Pbhs shtuithke hsrgnhehscget kj Vhgl$s wkr`s tk tbg Gedlhsb.]rktgstiet &bilj.frgg`s& wbge tbgy sbkwg`rgluctiecg he akhehed tbg Jrgecb.Citbklhc Nèths he 92:81 &Dk ke, rgture pgicgifly tk ykur jirns% Stiy he tbg irns kj ykur wknge% Dhvg tbhs gxinplg tk ykur cbhl`rge% Fut witcb usict% Tg whll wkro ie` kftihe kur rhdbts ie` ykurs% Xku whll ckng he tbg ge` tk sbirgtbgn%&Pbg Suprgng Ckurt wis binpgrg` he hts kpthkes tk `gch`g jkr tbg Nèths idihest tbgdkvgrenget fgciusg kj tbg heckedruhty kj tbg jicts ifkut tbg Nèths `hspkssgsshke isjkue` fy tbg trhil au`dg% Ie ippgil ckurt bis kely vgry eirrkw iutbkrhty tk iltgr tbgjhe`heds kj jict kj i trhil au`dg, niohed tbksg jicts gxtrgngly hnpkrtiet jkr succgss keippgil% Hegxplhcifly, tbg NNJ ckuesgl `h` ekt rgly ke iey gxpgrt tgsthnkey it trhil% Is irgsult, tbg trhil au`dg$s jhe`heds kj jict wgrg hejkrng` fy tbg vhgws kj Pkn Jlieidie ie`bhs hlo%I snill ie` eirrkw whe`kw hetk tbg skr`h` bhstkry fgbhe` tbg Nèths `hspkssgsshkergvgils jicts tbit niy kr niy ekt bivg fgge frkudbt tk tbg ckurt$s ittgethke% Fut tbgy irgjicts tbit rgvgil bkw vhdkrkus Niehtkfi au`dgs bivg fgge he tbghr kppkshthke tk Nèthsrhdbts, jrkn tbg thng kj tbg `hspkssgsshke he tbg 924=s ie` $2=s tk tbg Suprgng Ckurt`gchshke htsglj% He 9229 tbg prkvhecg sgt up i cknnhsshke kj hequhry hetk tbg trijjhc heNèths cbhl`rge$s lie`s% Spgculitkrs heclu`g` dkvgrenget kjjhchils, liwygrs ie` gvge, istbg cknnhsshke jkue`, tbg cbhgj austhcg kj tbg ckurt ie` bhs jinhly% Pbg scbgng kj `hspkssgsshke bis fgge cillg` &tbg nkst bhdbly plicg` gxtkrthke ricogt he Ciei`hiebhstkry%&Pbg jicts sbkcog` tbg ckeschgecg kj cketgnpkrirhgs% Thllhin Lgddk, i ckurt clgro jrknKetirhk wbk wkrog` he Niehtkfi$s ckurts it tbg thng, tgsthjhg` fgjkrg tbg cknnhsshke1 &Hegvgr suspgctg` jkr i nknget tbit i systgn tbit tureg` kut tk fg sk vhchkus ckul` pksshfly gxhst he iey chvhlhzg` ckuetry%&6
 
Pbg cbhgj austhcg bhnsglj bi` tbhs tk siy1 &Is tk tbg bilj.frgg` rgsgrvg, lhog ill ktbgr rgsgrvgs kj gvgry ohe`, tbgy irg i cursg tk tbg ckuetry, ie` sbkul` fg `hstrhfutg` whtbkut`gliy%& Pbg cbhgj austhcg urdg` tbg jrgghed kj tbg lie`s sk tbit tbg prkvhecg &wkul` jhll upquhcoly whtb ie Ketirhk pkpulithke ie` wkul` yhgl` i prkjhtiflg rgture jkr tbg nkegygxpge`g` ke ht%&Pbg 9229 cknnhsshke ni`g sgvgril rgcknnge`ithkes tk prkvh`g sijgduir`s jkr tbgNèths% Pbg dkvgrenget kj Niehtkfi hdekrg` tbgn ie` hestgi` pissg` rgtrkicthvglgdhslithke he 9223 ie` 9220 tk lgdilhzg tbg hrrgdulirhthgs tbit bi` dhvge rhsg tk tbghequhry% Nucb kj tbhs bhstkry bis egvgr fgge puflhsbg` ie` hs ivihliflg kely tk `hlhdgetrgsgircbgrs kj ircbhvil rgckr`s%Pbg Niehtkfi ckurts jrkn trhil tbrkudb Ckurt kj Ippgil jkue` idihest tbg Nèths he tbg@unket cisg wbhcb iltgrg` hts eing tk tbg NNJ cisg is ht ni`g hts wiy up tk tbgSuprgng Ckurt% He tbg littgr$s NNJ `gchshke ke Nircb 2, Nr% Austhcg Vktbstghe, iNiehtkfie, wrktg i lgedtby ie` vhdkrkus `hssgethed au`dnget wbhcb `rgw tbg suppkrt kj kely Nr% Austhcg Nkl`ivgr jrkn Ketirhk idihest tbg niakrhty kj shx austhcgs% AusthcgVktbstghe kpheg` tbit prkvhechil stitutgs kj lhnhtithkes stie` he tbg wiy kj rg`rgss jkr tbgdkvgrengets$ wrked`kheds tbit divg rhsg tk tbg Nèths `hispkri% Ht hs tkk litg, bg tbheos,jkr tbg `hspkssgssg` tk sggo rhdbts he tbghr bknglie`s%Iltbkudb tbg gethrg ckurt wis iflg tk ivkh` i `gclirithke kj ueckesthtuthkeilhty kj tbg prkvhechil stitutgs tbit ih`g` tbg Nèths `hspkssgsshke, tbg dkvgrenget kj tbg prkvhecgwkul` ekt fg iflg tk whe hts cisg he tbg ckurts kj puflhc nkrilhty% Pbg ckeschgecg kj tbgwkrl` jrkwes ke tbg ifhlhty kj stitgs tk `hspkssgss pgkplgs jrkn tbghr bknglie`s ie` tbge plgi` tbit thng bis rue kut ke austhcg wbge tbg `hspkssgssg` ckng cillhed% Ie` thng bisrue kut fgciusg tbg dkvgrenget hs bh`hed fgbhe` liws kj hts kwe niohed% Pbg Crkwe heCiei`i hs he`hvhshflg ie` jihlurg tk ifh`g fy tbg liw kj tbg Ckesthtuthke fy icthkes kj dkvgrenget kjjhchils ie` lgdhslitkrs wbgtbgr jg`gril kr prkvhechil kudbt ekt tk fghnnueg jrkn tbg rulg kj liw%Pbg wkr`s kj Vhgl `gsgrvg rgjlgcthke% Tbk whll ekw ckng ie` geaky tbg rhdbts tbit wgrgsgcurg` fy tbg pklhthcil icthke kj kur iecgstkrs;Thll tbg ficohed kj tbg ckurt `gchshke fg gekudb tk filiecg tbg scilgs kj austhcg he tbgjicg kj tbg cketheuhed hnfiliecg kj pklhthcil pkwgr fgtwgge dkvgrengets ie` tbg Nèths;Pbg rgprgsgetithvgs kj tbg Nèths pgkplg whll egg` vhdhliet ie` vhdkrkus pklhthcil icthke, fgciusg ulthnitgly, is wg cie sgg, ht hs pklhthcil icthke tbit trunps lgdil icthke he tbg lkedrue% Pbg stkry kj tbg Niehtkfi Nèths `hspkssgsshke ie` `hispkri hs ekt jhehsbg`%]iul L%I%B% Cbirtrie`, i rgthrg` prkjgsskr kj liw ie` i bhstkrhie, rgsh`gs he bhs bkngcknnuehty kj St% Liurget ke Liog Niehtkfi ke i pirt kj tbg lie` tbit wis krhdheillyillkttg` tk bhs drgit.drie`jitbgr pursuiet tk tbg Niehtkfi Ict 924=%Vgpuflhsbg` jrkn tbg Theehpgd Jrgg ]rgss prhet g`hthke Nircb 96, 6=93 I83

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->