• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
S\u00c9RIE ANTROPOLOGIA
325
THE SINS AND VIRTUES OF ANTHROPOLOGY
A reaction to the problem of methodological nationalism
Mariza Peirano
Bras\u00edlia
2003
2
THE SINS AND VIRTUES OF ANTHROPOLOGY
A reaction to the problem of methodological nationalism
Mariza Peirano

Neste n\u00famero da S\u00e9rie Antropologia est\u00e3o publicadas as vers\u00f5es em ingl\u00eas e em portugu\u00eas da comunica\u00e7\u00e3o \u201cThe sins and virtues of anthropology\u201d, apresentada na \u201cConference on Methodological Nationalism\u201d, London School of Economics, 26 e 27 de junho de 2002.

\u00cdndice
Vers\u00e3o em ingl\u00eas.................................................................................................. 3
Vers\u00e3o em portugu\u00eas............................................................................................ 14
3
The sins and virtues of anthropology\u2297
A reaction to the problem of methodological nationalism

During the past decade, anthropology has been accused of many sins and mal- practices in the course of its development. Indeed, for many practitioners anthro- pology is no more\ue000 in the United States at least, anthropology is considered to be doomed to extinction. Personifying the worst of the \u201cpolitically incorrect\u201d social disciplines, for the past two decades anthropology has slowly but relentlessly been replaced by alternatives, such as \u201ccultural studies,\u201d \u201cSTS (science, technology and society) programs,\u201d \u201cculture critique,\u201d \u201csituated knowledges,\u201d and so on, all within the context ofpost-anthropology. In other places, however, such as Brazil and India, anthropology blooms and flourishes. Besieged at the center, it looks like anthro- pology is well and thriving in the periphery, providing a positive, critical, constructive approach. How this situation relates to the question of \u201cmethodological nationalism\u201d and what anthropology has to contribute to this pressing problem is my concern here.

Sins
The present idea of \u201cincorrectedness\u201d is often related to past sins. Amongst these
sins, I want to mention four.
(i)
The first sin relates to power relations: for a long time anthropology
was defined by the exoticism of its subject matter and by the distance,
\u2297 This paper was presented at the Conference on Methodological Nationalism, London

School of Economics, 26-27th June 2002. I want to thank James Ito-Adler, Wilson Trajano Filho and Michael Fischer for precious suggestions and reactions to its first version. I wrote this text during the spring semester of 2002, as a Visiting Scholar at the David Rockefeller Center for Latin American Studies, Harvard University, which provided me worderful working conditions. During this period, I also profitted from a Senior Scientist Fellowship from CNPQ, Brazil.

of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...