Difference between the two is that the Difference is that the u.s. Differs from the other countries in the world. The Difference between them is that they are not the same thing, they are the same thing - they are different things - and they are different from each other.
Difference between the two is that the Difference is that the u.s. Differs from the other countries in the world. The Difference between them is that they are not the same thing, they are the same thing - they are different things - and they are different from each other.
Difference between the two is that the Difference is that the u.s. Differs from the other countries in the world. The Difference between them is that they are not the same thing, they are the same thing - they are different things - and they are different from each other.
v_y±f mS ;r_0g'rSm or±d;k ustawG; a&;yHpk aH wGrmS wd;k jri‡ w hf m0ef,al &; tac:awGtm;vH;k udk xd;k azmuf & txd yg0ifvmygawmhw,f? 'Dvekd @J r,fqdkayrJhvnf; owdjyK&rSmu or±d;k us Edik if aH &;qdik &f mt"dyg` ,f awmh vpfb&,fvpfZife@J qd±k , S f owfrw S cf suaf wGukd pdeaf c:wmjzpf vpfZifqw kd hJ 0g'}uD; 2 ckay:rSm rl w,f? txl;ojzifh yk*v ~ u d b0/ wnf+yD; trsKd ;uGaJ wGe@J wefz;kd xm; wOD;csi;f qdik &f m yk*Kd~ vaf &;/ rdom;pke@J r_ r wl n D w mawG jzpf a y:vmyg vdifydkif;qdkif&mðyrlqufqHa&;awG w,f? qdw k m Edik if aH &;eJ@ trsm;}uD;ouf Feminism qdw k hJ trsKd ; qdik af ewJt h wGuf Edik if aH &;qdik &f m orD;wef;wla&; v_y&f mS ;r_0g'&Jh vuQ cGJjcrf;pdwfjzmr_awGvkyfwJhtcgrSm %mawGxrJ mS vl@tzG@J tpnf;wGi;f trsdK;orD;-trsKd;om;wef;wla&; rSm&Sw d hJ Gender Divisions vd@k ac: qdw k hJ qENoabmxm;awGuykd g t wJh vlrb _ 0 usm;-r vuQ%mcGJ xl; tav;ay;vmygawmhw,f? jcm;r_ukd t"du OD;pm;ay; qef;ppf Feminism qdw k hJ trsKd ;orD;wef;wl avh±Sdwwf=uygw,f? aemuf+yD; a&;v_y±f mS ;r_0g'rSm 'Dvckd jJG cm;r_awGuv kd nf; or±d;k us r[kwb f J Edik if aH &;tjrife@J =unf+h yD; trsm;qdkifESifh yk*~vdu vlrb _ 0 usm;rvuQ%mcGjJ cm;r_qkd wOD;csi;f qdik f cGjJ cm;r_ The wm usm;eJ@r rwlwhJ vdi2f ck=um; Public/Private Divide u tm%mqufqaH &;&Jh a&mifjyef a,musmf ;}u;D pd;k r_ (zd0k g') [wfra_ wGv@kd ,lq=uygw,f? 'DcJG Patriarchy jcm;r_awG[m b,fu tajccHo obm0 vdiv f uQ%meJ@ vJ/ bma=umifh qufvufvufcH vl r _ b 0vd i f v uQ % m usio hf ;kH ae=uwmvJ/ 'gukd b,fvkd Sex and Gender pdeaf c:ausmjf zwf=urvJqw kd mawG wef ; wl n D r #a&;ES i f h udk ar;cGe;f xkwaf vh&+dS y;D Edik if aH &;qdik f rwlncD surf sm; Equality 26
Dovejune2006.pmd 26 7/8/2006, 4:31 PM
and Difference qdkwJh =um; qufqaH &;awGrmS vnf; Edik if H t"du r¾dKif}uD; (4)ck&dS a&;&Sdw,fvdk@ qdk&rSmjzpfygw,f? ygw,f? EdkifiHa&;udk t"dy`g,fzGifhwm[m trsm;qdkifESifh yk*~vdu “Ed k i f i H a &;ud k wwfoyd nm±Siaf wG&hJ e,fy,fv@kd wOD;csi;f qdik f cGjJ cm;r_ The Public/ t"d ` g,f z G i f h w m[m owfrw S x f m;vd@k r&ygb;l ? vl@tzG@J Private Divide tpnf;wckv;kH rSm vdiyf ikd ;f tajccH wwfodynm&SifawG&Jh tpdk;&tkyfcsKyfa&;Xme tvkycf jJG cm;r_awG jzpfay:aewmudk awG/ Edik if aH &;ygwaD wG/ twdu k t f cH e,fy,fvdk@ owfrSwf Edik if aH &;taeeJ@ xnfrh pOf;pm;=ubJ tkypf ak wGe@J trsm;jynfoq l ikd &f m xm;vdk@ r&ygbl;? vl@ obm0taetxm;a=umifhjzpf tajctwif aqG;aEG;jiif;ckrH p_ wJh vl wmygv@kd om em;vnfxm;r,fqkd trsm;eJ@qikd w f hJ e,fy,fawGukd Edik if H tzGJ@tpnf;wckvHk;rSm &ifawmh vdifydkif;qdkif&m rnDr#r_ a&;qd+k yD; or±d;k us em;vnfwwf vdifydkif;tajccHtvkyf awGjzpfaewmudk qufvuf xdr;f =uygw,f? yk*~vdub0eJ@qdkifwJh cGJjcm;r_awG jzpfay:ae odr;f umuG,af y;vdu k o f vdk jzpfae e,fy,fawGukd Edik if aH &;qd+k yD; pOf; ygw,f? 'Dupd eP @J ygwo f uf+y;D *sib f D pm;wwfwmrsKd ;u tawmhu f kd &Sm; wmudk EdkifiHa&;taeeJ@ t,fpwde;f (Jean B. Elshtain)u J =uygw,f? rdom;pkb0eJ@ yk*K~ vdu xnfh rpOf;pm;=ubJ trsm;qdik af ,musmf ;/ yk*v ~ u d qdik f wOD;eJ@wOD; qufqaH &;awGuakd wmh rde;f r Public Man, Private Wo- obm0 taetxm; wOD;csif;qdkif&m e,fy,ftjzpf man qdw k hJ pmwrf;xJrmS tus,f owfrw S +f yD; Edik if aH &;eJ@rqdik b f ;l vd@k a=umif h jzpf w mygvd k @ w0ifh rD;armif;xd;k jycJyh gw,f? t qdk=uygawmhw,f? 'gayrJhvnf; om em;vnfxm;r,f pOftvmt& trsdK;orD;awGu vlom;awG&v hJ rl b _ 0 tpdwt f ydik ;f awmh jyifytvkyaf wGe@J rywfouf wdkif;rSm EdkifiHa&;qdkwm&SdygowJh? qd k & if a wmh vd i f y d k i f ; wJh rdom;pkb0eJ@ tdrw f iG ;f wm0ef tpd;k &tkycf sKyfa&;qdik &f mawG 'grrS qd k i f & m rnD r #r_ a wG awGrmS ta&;}uD;w,fq+kd yD; uef@ [kwf tjcm;aom trsm;jynfol owfxm;cHxm;&pOfrmS vltrsm;eJ@ jzpf a ewmud k quf qdik &f mtzG@J tpnf;awGuo kd m Edik if H yg0ifygwo f ufwhJ v_y&f mS ;r_awG/ Edik f a&;vdk@ owfrSwfvdk@r&Edkifygbl;? vuf x d r f ; od r f ; um iHa&;qdik &f m e,fy,fawG/ pmayeJ@ vlry_ ÉdyuQawG&w dS hJ ae&mwdik ;f rSm uG , f a y;vd k u f o vd k tEkynmqdik &f mqdw k mawGukd t Edik if aH &;qdw k m &Syd gw,f? rD;vuf rsK;d om;awGtwGuf oD;oef@owf (Millet)u Edi k if aH &;udk t"dyg` ,zf iG hf jzpfaeygw,f” rSwx f m;ovdjk zpfaeygw,f? trsK;d xm;wmu vltyk pf w k ckukd tjcm; orD;awGukd tdraf xmifxrd ;f odr;f tkypf w k cku xdr;f csKyfz@kd pDraH qmif a&;eJ@ rdcifqw kd hJ yk*v ~ u d wOD;csi;f &GufwJh tm%mtajccHqufqH qdik &f m tcef;¾wm0efe@J csKyx f m; a&;vd@k qykd gw,f? tpd;k &eJ@ jynfol vdu k o f vdjk zpfaewJt h wGuf aemuf vlx=k um; qufqaH &;udk Edik if aH &; qufwGJ&vm'fuawmh EdkifiHa&; vd@k vufcEH ikd pf rG ;f &S=d uovdk vkyif ef; e,fy,fuae z,f±mS ;cHvu kd &f jcif; cGiw f cktwGi;f u tvky&f iS ef @J t ygb?J vkyo f rm;=um;/ rdom;pktwGi;f u 'ga=umifh trsKd ;orD;wef; cifyeG ;f eJ@ ZeD;=um;/ rdbeJ@ om;orD; wla&; v_y±f mS ;olawG[m trsm; 27
Dovejune2006.pmd 27 7/8/2006, 4:31 PM
qdik af ,musmf ;eJ@ yk*v ~ u d qdik f rde;f r a=umif;r_tm;vHk;udk vl@tzGJ@t vlr@_ tqift h wef;/ vlrsKd ; qdw k hJ cGjJ cm;r_ukd ±du k cf sK;d zd@k óud;pm; pnf;wm0eftjzpf v$aJ jymif;jcif;vd@k (od@k r[kw)f bmoma&; pwJt h ajc =u&ygawmhw,f? 'gayrJv h nf; ol qdEk ikd yf gw,f? tpPa&;Edik if u H upf cHay:rSm cGJjcm;qufqHjcif;wdk@wGif wd@k awG=um;rSm trsm;qdik ef @J yk*v ~ d bwfZpf epf (Kibbutz System) yHpk H awG@&ouJo h @kd vlrb _ 0 usm;rvuQ uqdik q f w kd hJ ESpcf =k um;rSm&Sw d hJ pnf; rsKd ;udq k v kd w kd mjzpfygw,f? %mcGjJ cm;qufqrH q _ w kd muvnf; jcm;csuu f kd b,fypkH rH sK;d eJ@ z,f±mS ; 'gayrJvh nf; 'kw, d v_id ;f vlrb _ 0qdik &f m uGm[csuaf wGukd =ur,f/ bma=umifh z,fSm;ypf& (Second Wave)trsKd ;orD; wef;wl odoo d mom jzpfay:apygw,f? vl r,fqw kd hJ tay:rSmawmh oabm a&;v_y±f mS ;olawGe@J yxrv_id ;f v_yf r_b0 cGjJ cm;r_awG avhvmjcif;qdk xm;uGv J rJG a_ wG tpOft+rJóuHawG@ ±Sm;olawG=um; uGmjcm;oGm;wJt h wm Edik if aH &;xufy+kd y;D ta&;}u;D o wwfygw,f? usO;f =uyfvw S hJ tdrf csufawGuawmh EdkifiHa&;qdkwm vdk teuf±_dif;qHk;jzpfw,fqdk+yD; wGif;eJ@ rdom;pkqdkif&mudk,fa&; tdrrf u _ pd aP wGe@J rygwo f ufb;l qdk tcsKd @u av;av;eufeuf aumuf ud, k wf mudpaP wGukd azmufxu G f wJt h csuu f kd jiif;y,fvu kd jf cif;jzpf csufcsygw,f? 'ga=umifh qdk±S,f ypfatmifvyk Ef ikd rf o S m vGwaf jrmuf ovdk yk*v ~ u d wOD;qdik u f pd q P w kd m vpfawGu vlwef;pm; tajccHEikd if H r,fvdk@ wcsdK@olawGu ,lqyg [m Edik if aH &;jzpfw,fqw kd hJ aºuG; a&; tawG;tac:udk wifjycJ=h uo w,f? 'ga=umifh ynmavhvmcGi/hf ausmo f u H kd t±Sed jf rifjh cif;vd@k ajym& vdk vdiyf ikd ;f tajccHEikd if aH &; oDt&kd D tvkyv f yk yf ikd cf iG ehf @J trsm;eJ@ ygwf ygr,f? vlrb _ 0 rsuEf mS aygi;f pHek @J ae wckukd trsKd ;orD;wef;wla&; v_yf oufwhJ v_y&f mS ;r_awGrmS yg0ifciG phf &mtawmfrsm;rsm;rSm trsKd ;orD; &Sm;olawGu azmfxkwfcJhygw,f? wJh trsm;qdik &f m e,fy,fawGrmS rsm; zdEydS cf x H m;&r_[m rdom;pkyikd ;f usm;rcGjJ cm;qufqjH cif; (Sexism) trsKd ;orD;awG[m trsKd ;om;awGe@J qdik &f mu tajccHwmjzpfygw,f? [mvnf; zdEydS rf y_ pkH w H ck jzpfaewJh twl wef;wlcpH m;&,lyikd cf iG &hf adS &;qdk 'ga=umifh vuf±dS trsKd ;orD;wef;wl twGuf vlrsKd ;a&;cGjJ cm;r_ od@k r[kwf +y;D trsKd ;orD; vGwaf jrmufa&;v_yf a&; v_y±f mS ;olawGtaeeJ@ ae@w"l0 vlrsKd ;a&;zdEydS rf _ (racism or racial &Sm;r_ukd t"dyg̀,af umuf,yl gw,f? aexdik rf a_ wGxu J kd eufeuf±id_ ;f ±_id ;f oppression) eJ@ E_i d ;f ,Of+yD; csed x f ;kd yk*~vduqdkif&mwm0ef avhvmqef;ppf tuJjzwf=uyg pOf;pm;=uygw,f? or±d;k us Edik if H awGxu J tcsKd @ (od@k r[kw)f tm;vH;k awmhw,f? 'gukd or±d;k us vlrb _ 0 a&; oDt&kd aD wGrmS awmh yHrk eS t f m; udk Edik if aH wmf (od@k r[kw)f trsm; Edik if aH &; (the politics of everyday jzifh vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m zdEydS rf u _ kd tav; jynf olqikd f tzG@J tpnf;awGqu D kd life) qd+k yD; trnfwyfygw,f? u ay;avhr&So d nft h jyif ‘*si'f g’qdw k hJ v$t J yfxm;vdu k rf o S m vGwaf jrmuf av;awGukd a,musmf ; - rde;f rt vlrb _ 0 usm;-r vuQ%m owf atmifvyk Ef ikd rf mS ygv@kd ,H=k unfae cef;u¾awGukd vufczH @kd vlro _ rSwcf suaf wGqw kd m Edik if aH &;rSm t wJholrsm;vnf; &Sdygw,f? Oyrm bm0vuQ%mawGtjzpf ,Ofyg; a&;}uD;wJh tcef;u¾wcktaeeJ@ rdom;pkawGtwGuf tpdk;&vlr_ atmif aqmif&u G w f hJ jzpfpOfawG todtrSwðf ycJygw,f? 'ga=umifh axmufyahH &;p&dwaf wGukd ydrk w kd ;kd jri‡ hf txdyg0ifygw,f? rdom;pktwGi;f vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m rnDr#ra_ wGe@J zdEydS f ay;jcif; (od@k r[kw)f tvkycf iG af wG u tdrfr_tvkyfawGudk cGJa0jcif;/ r_awGtay:rSm tajcwnfxm;wJh xJrmS uav;ðypkapmifah ±SmufwhJ a* vlwOD;csi;f qdik f Edik if aH &;eJ@ vdiyf ikd ;f vl@tzG@J tpnf;eJ@ ygwo f ufwhJ t [m/ uav;xde;f XmeawG xm;ay; qdik &f m em;vnfvufc, H =kH unfr_ awG;tac: tdik 'f , D mawGukd csjy jcif;jzifh uav;ðypkapmifha±Smuf awGuv kd nf; tav;ay;tuJjzwf xm;wJh oDt&kd t D opfawGukd azmf xde;f a=umif;r_ 0efxw k 0f efy;kd awGukd =uygw,f? xkwzf @kd óud;pm;cJyh gw,f? aygah tmifvyk yf pfEikd w f ,fv@kd olw@kd a,musmf ;}u;D pd;k r_ (zd0k g') tJ't D xJrmS trsKd ;om; u ,l q ygw,f ? uav;xd e f ; (Patriarchy) awGe@J trsKd ;orD;awG=um;u tm 28
Dovejune2006.pmd 28 7/8/2006, 4:31 PM
%mqufqaH &;udk &Si;f vif;wJh t wJhvuQ%mawGeJ@ yHkazmfxm;wJh awGudk blrdaA'±kyfºuGif;awGeJ@ xJrmS a,musmf ;}uD;pd;k r_ - zd0k g' vl@tzG@J tpnf;udk zd0k g'}u;D pd;k wJh vl@ axmufjyygw,f? 'gayrJh 'Dtcsuf t,ltqudk udk;um;ajymqdkyg tzG@J tpnf;vd@k owfrw S &f ygr,f? zdk wckwnf;eJ@awmh trsdK;orD;awG w,f? bmomaA't& tztkypf ;kd 0g't,ltq[mvnf; tifrwef [m trsKd ;om;awGtay: v$r;f rd;k cJh jcif;qdw k hJ zd0k g'udk tedrq hf ;kH tqifh us,f0ef;ygw,f? trsdK;om;awG zl;w,f (od@k r[kw)f wef;wl&nfwl rdom;pkwnfaqmufry_ pkH t H xd tp [m vl‹tzG@J tpnf;&Jh ae&mtm; aexdkifcJh=uw,fqdkwJhtcsufudk aumufjyef=unfrh ,fq&kd if rdom; vH;k rSm trsKd ;orD;awGtay: v$r;f rd;k oufaorxlEdkifygbl;? 'ga=umifh pkxrJ mS vifa,musmf ; (od@k r[kw)f xm;w,fv@kd trsKd ;orD;wef;wla&; vl@tzGJ@tpnf;udk trsdK;orD;awG zcifu qH;k jzwfyikd cf iG t hf m%m t v_ y f & S m ;ol a wG u ,l q wwf y g }uD;pdk;cJh=uw,fqdkwJh tcdkiftrm ºuGi;f rJ&h ,lxm;+yD; tdraf xmif&iS f w,f? 'gayrJv h nf; zdEydS rf y_ pkH eH @J t axmufjyEdik w f hJ tcsuq f w kd m&Sm rde;f reJ@ om;orD;tm;vH;k [m vuf wdkif;twmawGuawmh rwlwJh azGae=uwm[m b,fvrkd S rjzpfEikd f atmufcjH zpfw,fqw kd hJ t"dyg` ,u f kd ,Ofaus;r_e@J tcsed u f mveJ@twl ygb;l ? qENwck pdwu f ;l ,Ofrw _ ck n$e;f qdak eygw,f? wenf;tm;jzifh xifxif&mS ;&Sm;ajymif;vJomG ;+yDqkd qd+k y;D jyefvnfjiif;qeforl sm;vnf; 'Dvekd @J vlrt _ zG@J tpnf;xJrmS us,f wmudak wmh vufc=H u&ygr,f? rJ &Syd gw,f? 'gq&kd if acwfumvw us,fjyefjyef@ usm;-r vuQ%m ay;ydkifcGifh &&Sdjcif;/ ynma&;wGif av#mufv;kH eJ@ ordik ;f qdik &f m vl@tzG@J owfrw S cf suaf wG xGuaf y:vm+yD; us,fus,fjyef@jyef@ cHpm;Edkifjcif;/ pnf;awGtm;vH;k rSm a,musmf ;}u;D ynma&;/ vkyif ef;cGief @J Edik if eH ,fy,f vufxyfxrd ;f jrm;r_ ajymif;vJvm pd;k r_om&Sw d ,fq+kd yD; ,lqvdu k =f u pwJh tjcm;vlr_b0e,fy,ftm; jcif;/ uGm&Si;f cGihf Oya'/ Oya't& tH;k awmh trsKd ;om;v$r;f rd;k r_qw kd m vH;k rSmyg a,musmf ;}uD;pd;k r_ukd yHpk H w&m;0if oaE<zsucf sciG hf pojzifh obm0a=umifh 'grrS [kwf tajccH oGi;f cHvu kd &f ovdk jzpfomG ;ygawmh tajymif;tvJrsm;.aemufwGif w&m; wckcak =umifq h wkd t hJ csuu f kd w,f? 'ga=umifh zd0k g'qdw k m rdom; taemufEikd if H trsKd ;orD;awG[m vnf; tcdik t f rm oufaoxkwjf y pke@J rdom;pkjyifyrSmyg trsKd ;om;rsm; 20 &mpkxrJ mS olw@kd &hJ vlra_ &;tae zd@k vdw k ,fq+kd yD; jyefvnfacsy=uyg u tkycf sKyjf cif;qd+k y;D ajym&rvdyk gb?J txm;awG odoo d mom wd;k wuf w,f? 'gukd vlO;D a&&Jh xuf0ufjzpfwhJ t cJyh gw,f? 'gayrJv h nf; zG‹H òz;d qJEikd if H 'Fv d ekd @J trsKd ;om;v$r;f rd;k r_ rsdK;orD;(r)awG[m tjcm;xuf awG&t hJ pdwt f ydik ;f awmfawmfrsm; udk pdeaf c:zsuo f rd ;f ypfz@kd ,E &W m;jzpf 0ufjzpfwhJ trsKd ;om;(usm;)awG&hJ rsm;rSm zd0k g'[m quf}uD;pd;k xm; ay:vmr_&hJ tajccHta=umif;awGe@J txdrf;csKyfcHjzpfae&wmudk ‘rD; qJjzpfw,fv@kd qdyk gw,f? qufvufwnf&rdS a_ wGtay: em; vuf’u trsKd ;om;rsm; tkycf sKyf a,musmf ;}u;D pd;k r_,E &W m; vnfoabmayguzf @kd óud;pm;=uyg xm;wJh vl@tzG@J tpnf;qd+k yD; t"d udk tajccHtaeeJ@ (od@k r[kw)f vdu k f awmhw,f? trsKd ;om;v$r;f rd;k r_qkd y`g,zf iG yhf gw,f? trsKd ;om;u trsKd ; em&rJh tcsuq f +kd yD; vufcu H sio hf ;kH wmuvnf; rwlnDwJhtaet orD;udk v$r;f rd;k Edik jf cif;eJ@ touf}u;D wmrsdK;udk trsdK;orD;wef;wla&; xm;awGeJ@ vlr_taqmufttHk trsKd ;om;u toufi,fol v$r;f rd;k v_y&f mS ;olawG[m oabmrwl=u awGtm;vHk;rSm jzpfwnfaewJht ydik cf iG q hf w kd hJ tajccHoabm(2)ck&dS ygb;l ? a±S;OD;umv vl@tzG@J tpnf; wGuf 'guekd m;vnfz@kd avhvm&wm w,fq+kd yD; zd0k g'tay:rSm olru awGrmS trsKd ;orD;awGu }uD;pd;k cJh [m tifrwefcufcyJ gw,f? Oyrm aumufcsufcsygw,f? 'ga=umifh w,f/ Am[D&0g'vdk tapmqH;k ,Hk or±d;k us rdom;pk yHpk aH wGxrJ mS eJ@ }uD;pOfi,fvdkuf t±dktaoay;& =unfu;kd uG,rf r_ mS ewfb&k m;rudk vlr_p±dkuf yHkazmf=uwJhjzpfpOfrSm ovdk vdifydkif;qdkif&mrSmeJ@ vuf ud;k uG,jf cif;/ trsKd ;orD;wefqmudk trsKd ;orD;awGqw kd m rdcifrsm;/ tdrf atmufi,fom;tay:rSm zdEydS rf q _ kd txGwt f jrwfxm;jcif;qdw k hJ "avh axmif±iS rf sm;/ Edik if aH &; - vkyif ef;cGif 29
Dovejune2006.pmd 29 7/8/2006, 4:31 PM
- toufarG;0rf;a=umif;r_e@J trsm; ajymif;vJEikd w f hJ 0rf;wGi;f yg p±du k f [m wenf;tm;jzifh ZD0aA'vuQ jynfoq l ikd &f m e,fy,fawGrmS t vuQ%mawGeJ@ arG;zGm;vm=u %mjzpfv@kd 'g[m uHw&m;a=umifh qifeh rd +hf y;D ud, k pf m;ðy yg0if=u&jcif; w,f? od@k r[kwf vlrb _ 0 tawG@ vdk@ qdkvdkygw,f? vufawG@rSm qdw k hJ yHak oum;us yHpk o H iG ;f wJh ,Of tóuHawGu yHpk aH vmif;+yD; yHak zmfcH awmh 'DqifajcrSm b,fvrkd S t"d aus;r_rsKd ; jzpfvmwmuawmh t &wmvm;qdw k t hJ ay: tjyeftvSef y`g,f r±Syd gb;l ? rde;f rwa,muf&hJ OD; xift&Sm;ygb?J pOf;pm;tajz&Sm&ygawmhr,f? trsKd ; aESmuft&G,t f pm;[ma,musmf ; 'ga=umifh trsKd ;orD;v_yf orD;wef;wla&;v_yf&Sm;olawGt wa,muf&hJ OD;aESmuft&G,x f uf &Sm;r_awG=um;rSm trsKd ;om;v$r;f rd;k aeeJ@ a,musmf ;}uD;pd;k r_atmufu ao;i,faew,fq+kd yD; trsKd ;om; r_ukd axmifw h ckwnf; 'grrS [kwf trsKd ;orD;awG vGwaf jrmufz@kd óud; (usm;) vuQ%m}uD;pd;k a&; tpG±J dS or±d;k us qef;ppfavhvmwmrsKd ; pm;=ur,fq&kd if ZD0urRaA'qdik &f m olawGu axmufjyygw,f? 'Dvkd vkyv f @kd rjzpfEikd af wmhygb;l ? tcsut f vufa=umifv h m;/ vl‹o qd&k if rdrcd E<mud, k f t&G,t f pm;eJ@ tcsdK@u 'Dvdkjzpf&wm bm0t& b,fvrkd S rajymif;vJEikd f E_id ;f ,Of=unfv h ukd rf ,fq&kd if rde;f r&Jh [m rdom;pktwGif;eJ@ vlr_b0 wJh tcsut f vufawGa=umifv h m; OD;aESmuft&G,[ f m yd+k y;D }u;D rm;ae usm;r vuQ%m yHpk o H iG ;f jzpfpOft qdw k hJ rsn;f ESpaf =umif; jcm;em;csuf wmjzpfv@kd Om%fynm todawGykd ay:rSm jrpfzsm;cH=uvdk@qdk+yD; ,Hk udk aoaocsmcsm&SmazG azmfxw k f ºuG,f0w,fqdkwm twdtus =unf=uovdk ynma&;wd;k wufr_ =u&ygw,f? aemuf+yD; vlr_tzGJ@ n$ef;qdkvdkufovdkjzpfaeygw,f? eJ@ tvkyv f yk yf ikd cf iG hf tcGit hf a&;awG tpnf;u jyXmef;csrSwfxm;wJh yHkrSeftm;jzifh trsdK;orD;awG[m ydrk vkd rf;zGiahf y; vkyaf qmifay;jcif; tjyKtrlawG&hJ OD;wnfcsuef @J yHpk H trsKd ;om;awGxuf ºuu G o f m;zG‹H òz;d jzifh tckvkd rnDr#ra_ wGukd jyKjyif awGukd &SmazGEikd rf o S m jyKjyifajymif; r_enf;wJhtwGuf um,ydkif;t& ajymif;vJypfEdkifygw,fqdk+yD; ,Hk vJra_ wGukd vkyaf qmifomG ;Edik rf mS tm;enf;ygw,f? 'g[mvnf; t =unfoal wGvnf;±Syd gw,f? pD;yGm; jzpfygw,f? rsKd ;om;awG[m tdrjf yify um, a&;pepf[m zdESdyfr_&Jh t&if;cHjzpf obm0vdiEf iS hf vlrb _ 0 vdiv f uQ qdik &f mvkyif ef;awG/ tm;upm;/ ,l w,fqw kd hJ tjrifrsKd ;±Sw d hJ trsKd ;orD; %m (Sex and Gender) qowfrw S xf m;wJh usm;vuQ%m wef;wla&; v_y&f mS ;olawGvnf; ±Syd g a,bl,stm;jzifh trsKd ; wckjzpfz@kd yHak zmfay;wJh vlrb _ 0t w,f? trsKd ;orD;awG v$r;f rd;k cHxm; orD;wef;wla&;v_y&f mS ;r_ukd qef@ ajctaeawGa=umifjh zpfw,fv@kd t &wm[m trsKd ;om;awG&hJ t=urf; usifajymr_tm;vHk;[m vlr_b0 csKd @u ,lqygw,f? um,cGet f m; zufre_ @J t"rRðyusichf &H r_ (Fear of usm;-r vuQ%mcGjJ cm;owfrw S f qdw k m v,f,meJ@ pufrv _ @l tzG@J Rape) tay: pd;k &drx f w d v f ef@ra_ wG wm[m obm0w&m;a=umifjh zpf tpnf;rSm ta&;}u;D ayrJv h nf; wl u xdr;f csKyfxm;vd@k ygq+kd yD; qifajc w,fqdk+yD; tcdkiftrmqkwfudkif awG/ aqmufawG/ wGicf akH wGae&m ay;olu ay;ygw,f? xm;wwfygw,f? usm;eJ@rqdw k m rSm vl@tpGr;f tpu yd+k yD;ae&m ,l tckvdk tajccH,lqyHk vl‹tzG@J tpnf;wm0efawGukd jznfh vmwJh zGH@+zdK;+yD;EdkifiHawGrSmawmh awG uGv J v JG mwJt h wGuf vlawG&hJ qD;zd@k obm0u owfrw S yf akH zmf toH;k 0ifr_ av#meh nf;vmygw,f? tðytrlawGukd jyXmef;wJah e&mrSm xm;vd@k ygw?hJ 'ga=umifh trsKd ;orD; ºuGuo f m;awG tajrmuftrsm;eJ@ ta&;}uD;wJh obm0eJ@ jyKpkysdK; wOD;&Jh ±kyfydkif;eJ@ cE<maA'qdkif&m wnfaqmufxm;wJh trsdK;om; axmifjcif;qdw k t hJ ay: tjrifrwl wnfaqmufr_udku vl@tzGJ@t [m uGejf yLwm tdik w f eD nf;ynm nDra_ wG vH;k 0&Sad ew,fqw kd m jyae pnf;twGi;f rSm wqifeh rd ahf eovdk qdik &f m urBmxJrmS tJ'ºD uGuo f m; ygw,f? tdrw f iG ;f r_ tcef;u¾wm0efawGe@J awGukd toH;k csp&m ae&mr±Syd gb;l ? vlom;awG[m jyKjyif r vduk zf ufygw,fv@kd qifajcay;wm 'ga=umifh =urf;wrf;wJh um, 30
Dovejune2006.pmd 30 7/8/2006, 4:31 PM
vkyfief;awG[m trsdK;om; cE<m aqmifEdkifovdk 'grSr[kwf trsKd; owWd pGr;f tifawG ysujf y,fuek u f m udk,feJ@ ydk+yD;tH0if*Gifusjzpfae+yD; om;eJ@ trsKd ;orD;=um;rSm wm0ef trsKd ;om;awG[m trsK;d orD;awG 'g[m vlrb _ 0tqift h wef; edrhf awG nDwrl #wl cGaJ 0,l=uwmrsK;d udk xdr;f csKyx f m;vdu k o f vdk jzpfomG ; yg;wJh tajctaea=umifjh zpfovdk vnf; vkyv f @kd jzpfEikd yf gw,f? 'gjh yif ygw,f? =oZmtm%ma=umifh jzpfay:vm uav;ðypkapmifx h ed ;f wmawGukd vl ZD0aA'u uHw&m;udk r wm r[kwyf gb;l ? r_tzG@J tpnf; od@k r[kwf Edik if aH wmf qH;k jzwfEikd bf ;l vd@k qx kd m;ayrJh trsK;d cE<mZD0aA' oabmt& u wm0ef,w l mrsKd ; vkyEf ikd +f y;D aqG om;eJ@ trsK;d orD;=um;rSm wnf±adS e trsKd ;orD;awG&hJ vlrb _ 0tajct rsKd ;om;csi;f awGu aqmif&u G w f m wJh cE<mud, k ±f yk yf ikd ;f qdik &f m rwljcm; ae[m uav;arG;jcif;qdkwJh pGrf; rsKd ;awGvnf; vkyEf ikd yf gw,f? 'Dvrkd S em;csuaf wG±w dS ,fqw kd mudak wmh aqmifEikd rf e_ @J trsm;}uD;ygwo f uf r[kw&f ifawmh trsK;d orD;awGukd vH;k 0rjiif;Edik yf gb;l ? tJ'v D kd obm0 aew,fv@kd q&kd ygr,f? 'g[m "rR trsm;qdik &f m tvkyw f m0efawGukd rwlnrD a_ wGukd odro f rd af rG@arG@e@J pOf; wmvmjcif;/ Ed@k csKd wdu k af u|;jcif;qdk pGr;f aqmifEikd pf rG ;f r±Sad tmif vkyf pm;tajzxkww f m[m trsKd ;orD; wJh tcsuaf wGe@J wGzJ uf+y;D b,fvkd vdkufwJhtwGuf uav;arG;zGm;& wef;wla&; v_y±f mS ;olawGtwGuf rS a±Smifvv J$ ‹kd r&Edik wf hJ robm0 wm[m vlrb _ 0qdik &f m tm;enf; tifrwefta&;}u;D wJh udpw P ckjzpf vdifvuQ%m xl;jcm;csufjzpfyg csufwcktjzpf owfrSwfvdkufo ygw,f? 'gro S m trsKd ;orD;awG&hJ w,f? vdk wv$pJ Of;pm;&rvdjk zpfaeygw,f? tcef;u¾udk jri‡ w hf ifay;a&;eJ@ rdrd 'gayrJh tckvkd cE<mZD0aA zGH‹òzd;qJEdkifiHawGrSm&SdwJh eJ@ vdirf wlorl sm;udk cGjJ cm;csKd ;ESrd jf cif; ' vuQ%ma=umifh trsKd ;orD;awG trsKd ;orD;wOD;&Jh tvkycf iG b f 0udk uif;onfh usm;rcGjJ cm;qufqjH cif; udk wqifeh rd hf qufqw H mrsKd ; 'grrS uav;arG;zGm;jcif;qdw k hJ ta=umif; uif;onfh vl@tzGJ@tpnf;wckudk [kwf vlrb _ 0uH=urRmudk qH;k jzwf tcsuu f vH;k 0zsuq f ;D ypfwwfyg wnfaqmufEikd rf mS jzpfygw,f? 'g wmrsKd ;qdw k m vH;k 0 vufcEH ikd zf , G f w,f? ud, k 0f efaqmif/ arG;zGm;Edik w f hJ a=umifh trsKd ;orD;wef;wla&;v_yf r±Syd gb;l ? trsKd ;orD;wdik ;f [m rdcif pGrf;tifqdkwm wu,fwef;us ±Sm;olawG[m obm0 vdiv f uQ awGjzpfaumif;jzpfEikd yf gw,f? 'gayrJh awmh tifrwefjrifhjrwfwJh vlr_ %meJ@ vlrb _ 0 vdiv f uQ%mESpcf k uav;rsm; ðypkapmifha&Smufjcif;/ tqift h wef;jzpf+y;D tifrwef pGe@f =um;u rwlnDwJhtcsufawGudk tdraf xmifxed ;f odr;f jcif;/ ynmoif pm;&ovdk vlom;rsdK;EG,fpkawG ±Si;f ±Si;f vif;vif; azmfxw k af vh&ydS g =um;jcif;/ }u;D xGm;zG‹H òz;d atmif wm toufquf&Sifoefa&;twGuf w,f? obm0vdif vuQ%mqdk 0ef,&l jcif; pwJt h vkyaf wGukd rdrw d @kd tmrcHcsuv f @kd qd&k rSmjzpfygw,f? wm ZD0aA'oabmqdkif&m t taejzifh tdref @J rdom;pkb0xJrmS 'ga=umifh a,musmf ;}uD;pd;k r_qw kd m a=umif;tcsufrsm;tjzpf a,m ðrwfEyHS pf&jcif;qdw k hJ txd rdcifb0 trsdK;orD;awG&Jh uav;arG;zGm; usmf ;eJ@ rde;f r=um; uGv J cJG surf sm; wm0efawGtm;vHk;udk vufcHzdk@r Edik jf cif;eJ@ rdciftjzpf cH,El ikd jf cif;qdw k hJ jzpf+y;D b,fvrkd S ajymif;vJEikd w f hJ udpP vdyk gb;l ? uav;arG;jcif;qdw k m cE<m robm0vdiyf ikd ;f qdik &f m pGr;f &nft r[kwfygbl;? vlr_b0vdifvuQ ZD0aA'oabmjzpfayrJh ðypkapmifh ay: trsKd ;om;awG&hJ ta=umufw %muawmh ,Ofaus;r_qdkif&m a&Smufjcif;qdw k muawmh ,Ofaus; &m;u tajccHvmw,fv@kd tcsKd @ "avhx;kH wrf;owfrw S cf sujf zpf+yD; r_oabmvd@k trsKd ;orD;wef;wla&; trsKd;orD;wef;wla&; v_yf±Sm;ol a,musmf ;eJ@ rde;f rawGtay: rwl v_yf±Sm;olawGu axmufjy=uyg rsm;u qdyk gw,f? 'Dvekd @J tusKd ; nDwhJ tcef;u¾awGtjzpf vlr_ w,f? qufuawmh rdom;pke@J tdrrf a_ &; tzG@J tpnf;u rSw, f x l m;csurf sm; tdrfwGif;vkyfief;wm0ef &m wm0efawGxrJ mS ydwx f m;vdu k f om jzpfygw,f? awGukd trsK;d om;awGvnf; xrf; jcif;tm;jzifh trsK;d orD;awG&hJ rlv a,musmf ;v$r;f rd;k a&; o 31
Dovejune2006.pmd 31 7/8/2006, 4:31 PM
abmw&m;rSmawmh tckvkd obm a=umifh vdirf wlnrD q _ w kd m ZD0aA' csufawGeJ@ ar#mfvifhcsufawGeJ@t 0vdifvuQ%meJ@ vlr_b0 vdif qdkif&m tcsuftvufrsm;jzpf+yD; nD yHak vmif;cH&ygw,f? rdcif/ tdrf vuQ%mESpcf =k um; uGv J cJG suaf wG vlra_ &;/ Edik if aH &;eJ@ pD;yGm;a&;qdik &f m ±Sirf / tysKpd ifrif;orD;/ jynfw h efqm udk taotcsm razmfxkwfbJ xl;jcm; owfrw S cf surf sKd ; r&Syd gb;l ? pojzifh trsKd ;om;a,musmf ;awG&hJ a,musmf ;eJ@ rderf =um;rSm wnf±dS vdifvuQ%ma=umifh trsdK;orD; tjyXmef;cHjzpfaeygw,f? 'Dtwdik ;f aewJh vlro _ bm0 vuQ%mtm; awGe@J trsKd ;om;awGq+kd yD; rowf om qufjzpfaer,fqdk&ifawmh vH;k [m ZD0aA' od@k r[kwf cE<maA' rSwo f ifb h J olw@kd [m vly*k Kd v ~ w f OD; obm0vdiEf pS cf pk vH;k eJ@ ygwo f uf u ta=umif;cHvmwmjzpfw,f csi;f qdik &f mrsm;taeeJ@bJ owfrw S f aewJh wOD;csif;qdkif&m t&nft qd+k y;D ,lqygw,f? trsKd ;orD;wef; &r,fv@kd qykd gw,f? 'ga=umifh trsKd ; aoG;awGrrl rSeaf tmifzsuq f ;D vdu k f wla&;v_yf&Sm;olawGzufuawmh orD;wef;wla&;v_y±f mS ;olawG&hJ OD; ovdjk zpfaeygw,f? obm0 vdiv f uQ%meJ@ vlrb _ 0 wnfcsuyf ef;wdik [ f m wOD;csi;f qdik f trsK;d orD;awG[m olw@kd vdif vuQ%m ESpcf =k um;rSm quf &m vGwaf jrmufa&;vd@k qd&k ygr,f? toHrxGuaf tmif/ wGe;f wGe;f wdu k f pyfrq _ w kd m r±Syd gb;l ? vlrb _ 0 vdif vlrb _ 0 vdiv f uQ%m cGjJ cm;owf wduk rf vkyEf ikd af tmif olw@kd &o hJ bm vuQ%m cGjJ cm;r_qw kd m,Ofaus;r_ rSwrf /_ rwlnrD a_ wGqw kd m tm;vH;k 0jzpfwhJ usm;vuQ%m owfrw S f eJ@ vHk;0 oufqdkifaeygw,f? 'g twkta,mifawGomjzpf+yD; zkH; csuaf wGukd ydjym;oGm;atmif vkyzf @kd a=umifh vlrt _ zG@J tpnf;u vlwOD; v$r;f xm;csurf sm;jzpfygw,f? ‘pDreG f wGe;f tm;ay;&ygr,f? 'gukd wzuf csi;f pDtay: csrw S jf yXmef;csuo f m 'DAl;0g;’uawmh tckvdk aumuf uvSn=hf unf&h ifawmh a,musmf ; jzpf&r,fq+kd yD; tcdik t f rm,H=k unf csucf sygw,f? trsKd ;orD; (rde;f r) av;qdw k m rid&k bl;qdw k hJ pdwcf pH m; =uygw,f? qdw k m owfrw S cf sujf zpfw,f? arG; r_qkid &f m/ xdv, G cf ukd v f , G jf zpfwhJ trsKd;orD; wef;wla&; wke;f u owfrw S rf xm;ygb;l ? odraf rG@whJ wke@f jyefra_ wGukd csK;d ESrd f v_yf±Sm;olawG[m a,musfm;eJ@ vlr_b0 vdifvuQ%m xm;zd@k qw kd hJ olw@kd &hJ robm0 vuQ rde;f r=um; obm0t& vdiv f uQ rwlnjD cm;csuq f wkd mawG[m vlr_ %mawGukd vufrcHz@kd trsKd ;om; %mrwlnDwJhtcsufqdkwm odyf tzG@J tpnf;u wnfaqmufxm; awG[m zdtm;ay;cHae&ygw,f? 'g ta&;ygvw S u hJ pd P r[kwyf gb;l vd@k wmjzpfygw,f? tm;aysmhoGm; uawmh trsK;d orD;wef;wla&; v_yf ,lq=uayrJv h @kd vlrb _ 0 vdiv f uQ atmifeJ@ usdK;EGHoGm;atmif/ tdrf ±Sm;olawG&Jh oabmxm;jzpfyg %mxl;jcm;csuaf wGtay:rSm b,f wGi;f eJ@ro d m;pkqikd &f m wm0efawGe@J w,f? vdn k , ‡d =l urvJqw kd meJ@ ygwo f uf vdu k zf ufoifah wmfwhJ b0wckt 'gayrJv h nf; vpfb&,f/ +yD; jyefvnf&Sif;vif;wifjyr_rsdK; jzpf trsKd ;orD;awGukd yHo k iG ;f zd@k t uGeq f maA;wpf/ qd±k , S v f pf/ zuf vnf; r&S=d ubl;? vdiEf pS cf pk vH;k eJ@ rsdK;orD;vuQ%m owfrSwfcsuf qpf/ zD;rD;epf/ zef',frefw,fvpf ygwo f ufwhJ vuQ%mawG tm; tjzpf yHak zmfxm;ygw,f? tiftm; pojzifh Edik if aH &;tjrif tajccH,q l vH;k vlwikd ;f rSm yg0ifae=uw,fv@kd &Sw d ,f/ }uchH ikd w f ,f/ wGe;f wGe;f wdu k f csuu f vJG o JG vdk vlrb _ 0 vdiv f uQ vl@obm0udk ,lq=uygw,f? vl wdu k ef @J tòyid t f qdik &f w dS ,f/ tvkyf %m owfrw S cf sut f ay:rSm wefz;kd om;tm;vH;k [m rdcife@J zcifEpS Of ;D cGi/f Edik if aH &;eJ@ trsm;eJ@ygwo f ufwhJ xm; owfrw S cf suaf wG[m wlnD pvH;k &Jh ADZawGukd tarGqufc=H u& vkyif ef;awGe@J oifah wmfw,f po wmawG&o dS vdk uGv J aJG ewmawGukd wmjzpfwJhtwGuf a,musfm;eJ@ jzifh trsKd ;om;awGuakd wmh tm;ay; vnf; xyfqifah wG@&ygao;w,f? rde;f r ^mOfp±du k f (od@k ) *k%jf 'yf t xm;ygw,f? trsKd ;om;rsm; }uD;pd;k qufvufwifjyygr,f?Ù &nftaoG;ESpcf pk vH;k a&maESmaygi;f xm;wJv h rl t_ zG@J tpnf;xJrmS trsK;d - 10;15 em&D pyf zG@J pnf;xm;jcif;jzpfygw,f? 'g orD;awG[m trsK;d om;awG vdt k yf 2006 ckEpS /f ZGev f (9) &uf?