IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF LEHIOH COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA

CIVIL DIVISION

WILLIAM VILLA and BARBARA

MAQUERA, individually an as co-
administrators of the Estate of SHEENA
VILLA, their daughter,

Plaintiffs,
No. 2007-C-2985
(Hon. Edward D. Rerbmaa) •£ flK-'
§ fi i -n
ROBERT LABARRE and MR. OGO BAR
INC., d/b/a J.P. O'MALLEY'S PUB,

Defendant. 2
^ 55 tJ
MOLDED VERDICT ' '*"

AND NOW, this // fayof May, 2009, it appearing by response to jury

interrogatories that the jury found Defendant Mr. Ogo Bar Inc. d/b/a J.P. O'Malley's Pub

negligent, but determined that said negligence was not a cause of factual harm to

Plaintiffs; and it farther appearing that upon stipulation of the parties that Defendant

Robert LaBane's negligence was a factual cause of harm to Plaintiffs, the jury

determined that 85 % of the total causal negligence was attributable to Defendant Robert

LaBarre and that 15% of the total causal negligence was attributable to Plaintiffs'

decedent, Sheena Villa; and it further appearing that the jury awarded compensatory

damages against Defendant Robert LaBarre in the amount of $1,300,000.00; and it

ftuther appearing that the jury determined the conduct of Defendant Robert LaBarre was

outrageous and awarded Plaintiffs punitive damages against Defendant Robert LaBarre in

the amount of $2,000,000.00, IT IS ORDERED that the verdict of May g, 2009, is

molded to read as follows: NOW,

COPIES OF THE WITHIN COURT
ORDER OR DECREE MAILED TO
ALL INTERESTED PARTIES BY: &?
 VERDICT

"AND NOW, May 8,2009, we the jurors impaneled in the

above-entitled case find for Defendant Mr. Ogo Bat Inc. d/b/a
J.P. O'Malley's Pub and against the Plaintiffs in no amount and
we iurther find in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendant
Robert LaBarre in the amount of $1,105,000.00 for compensatory
damages and in the amount of $2,000,000 for punitive damages."

BY THE COURT:

EDWARD D. RKIBMAN, J