N o .3 4
-
TH E
U K R A IN IA N W E E K L Y
SUNDAY, AUGUST2 6 ,1 9 9 0
\u0437
FO R
T H E R E C O R D : W C F Uo n U k r a in ia n fa m in e
in q u ir y
F o llo w in gi sth e o f f ic ia l c o m m u n i\u2013
q u eo f th e
W orld Congresso fF ree
U k r a in ia n so n th eF a m in e - G e n o c id e
in U k r a in e1 9 3 2 - 1 9 3 3 .
O n M ay 9, 1990,i n G eneva, P ro f.
J a c o b S u n d b e r g o f S to c k h o lm ,i n h is
c a p a c itya s p re s id e n to f th e in te rn a \u2013
tio n a l C o m m is s io n
o fin q u iry
in to
th e
1 9 3 2 -1 9 3 3
F a m in e
in
U k ra in e ,
to g e th e r w ithth e c o m m is s io n 's v ic e -
p re s id e n t, P ro f. J o e v e rh o e v e n fro m
B e lg iu m , p re s e n te dth e firs t c o p yo f
th e ir c o m m issio n 's fin a l re p o rt a t th e
G eneva O fficeo f M r.J . M artenson,
the U .N . undersecretary general fo r
h u m a n rig h ts .
T h is p re s e n ta tio nw as m a d e in th e
p re s e n c eo f a d e le g a tio n o f th e W o rld
Congresso f Free U krainians, repre\u2013
s e n te d b y its p re s id e n t, Y u ri S h y m k o ,
M r.W . K ereliuk, D r. W .G . D anyliw
a n dD r. S .J. K a lb a .
T his rep o rt confirm s th at in accor\u2013
d a n c e
w ith
th e
S o v ie t
p o p u la tio n
censuseso f 1926a n d 1939, as a result
.o fth e F a m in e in1932-1933, U kraine
lo s t
m ore
th a n
6
m illio n
v ictim s,
w h ic h
re p re s e n ts
2 0
p e rc e n t
of its
p o p u la tio n . A t the sa m e tim e ,a n d
liv in g
u n d e r
th e
sam e
c o n d itio n s ,
U k ra in e 's
n e ig h b o rs
w ere
a b le
t o
s u b s ta n tia lly
in c re a s e th e ir p o p u la \u2013
tio n s :
R ussians
by 28p e r c e n t and
B y e lo ru s s ia n sb y 1 1 .2 p e rc e n t.
i n
re g a rd
t o
th e
q u e s tio n
o f
w h e th e r
th efam in e
w as an
act of
g e n o c id e ,th e c o m m is s io n
m ajo rity
\u2014
Profs, verhoeven, H um phrey and
L e v e n e-
d e e m si t p la u s ib le th a t th e
c o n s titu e n t e le m e n tso f g e n o c id e
w e rei n e x is te n c e at the tim eo f th e
fam in e
i n
U k ra in e , a lth o u g h
th e
G e n o c id e
C o n v e n tio n
w as
n o t
c re a te d
u n til1948. T he ille g a lityo f
w hat
w as
c a lle d
g e n o c id e
in
th e
c o n v e n tio n
th u s
p re -e x is te d
th e
c o n v e n tio n .
T he
com m ission
m ajo rity
a ls o
w ishest o underscore that the policies
w h ic h w e re a p p lie dt o th e U k ra in ia n
p e o p le and led to the fa m in eo f 1 9 3 2 -
1933 disregardth e preceptso f basic
m o ra lity w h ic h a re b in d in g o n S o v ie t
a s
o n a lla u th o ritie s , a n d
th a tth e
S o v ie t
a u th o ritie s
m ust
in
c o n se \u2013
q u e n c eb e v ig o ro u s ly c o n d e m n e d .
P ro f.
S u n d b e rg
s ta te d
th a t
h is
fin d in g s a re s u c h as to c o in c id e w ith
w hat
is
c a lle d
g e n o c id e
in
th e
G e n o c id e
C o n v e n tio n .
H e
m ade
som e
o b s e rv a tio n s
o n ly
o f
a
p ro c e d u ra l
n a tu re ,
a s
d id
P ro f.
O liver a n d P ro f. L evasseur.
T he
fam in e
in
U k ra in e
w as
c e rta in ly m a n -m a d e in th e se n se th a t
its
im m ed iate
o rig in
lie si n h u m a n
b e h a v io r.
M o re o v e r,
it
fo u n d
it
in d is p u ta b le a ls o th a t, a lth o u g hth e
S o v ie t a u th o ritie s w e re a w a reo f th e
d r a m a tic c o n d itio n si n U k ra in e ,.th e y
re fra in e d
fro m
s e n d in ga n y re lie ft o
U kraine, officially
denying eventh e
e x is te n c e of the fa m in e .
T h e lo g ico f th e p o s itio n th a t th e re
w as
n o
fam in e
p re c lu d e d
c o o p e ra \u2013
tion w ith international relief efforts
t o
re lie v eth e fa m in e . T h e re fo re ,a s
P ro f.S u n d b e rg th in k s , th e s e d e n ia ls
adda considerable consistency to the
in te n tt o d e s tro y ,a n d p ro v e th a t th is
fam in e
w as an
a c tp la n n e d
in ad\u2013
v a n c e .
A sa result, com m ission cam et o
th e c o n c lu s io n th a t th e S o v ie t a u th o \u2013
r itie s
u s e d
th e
fam in e
v o lu n ta rily ,
w hen
ith a p p e n e d ,
t o
crow n
th e ir
p o lic y
o f
d e n a tio n a liz a tio n
of U\u2013
k ra in e .A nd, re g a rd le sso f th e ro le
fu lfille d
by thelo c a l a u th o ritie s , to
the com m ission
m ajo rity
ita p p e a r s
o b v io u s th a t th e p rim e re s p o n s ib ility
re s ts w ithth e S o v ie t c e n tra l a u th o ri\u2013
tie s .
F orth e great accom plishm enti n
v e rify in g
a n d
cross-exam ining
th e
e n o rm o u s q u a n tity
o fd o c u m e n ta ry
e v id e n c e
a n d
te s tim o n ie s
a n d
th e
p re p a ra tio n
o f
th is
fin a l
re p o rt,a
p ro c e d u re
w h ic h
to o k
m ore
th a n
th re e y e a rs o f w o rk , th e in te rn a tio n a l
C om m issiona n d its seven m em bers
have deserved
th e highest apprecia\u2013
tio n
a n d
re s p e c t
o f a llU k ra in ia n
c o m m u n itie s liv in g o u ts id e U k r a in e ,
as well as of the U krainian
p e o p le
in U k ra in e .
W ith o u t
a n y
re m u n e ra tio n ,
th e
com m ission
w orked
fo r
over three
y e a r s
u n d e r
th ele a d e rs h ip
of its
p re s id e n t,P ro f. S u n d b e rgo f S to c k -
h o lm ,a n d
th ev i c e - p r e s i d e n t
P ro f,
v e rh o e v e n
fro m
B e lg iu m , w ho p re \u2013
p a re d
th em ajo rity
report, w ithth e
fo llo w in g
m em ber-com m issioners:
P ro f. C o l. G .l.A .D . D ra p e r fo rm erly
B ritish p ro s e c u to ra t th e N u re m b e rg
Trials (deceasedi n July 1989); P ro f.
J .P .
H um phrey,
C anada,
fo rm erly
d ire c to r
o f
th e
U n ite d
N a tio n s
D iv isio n
o f H um an
R ig h ts ,a n d
a u th o r of the U n iv e rsa l D e c la ra tio n
of H um an
R ig h ts;P ro f. G . L ev as\u2013
seur, F rance, form erly m em ber of the
C o m m is s io nfo r th e R e v is io no f th e
French Penal Code;P ro f. R . Levene
(h ),
A rg e n tin a , p re s e n tly
J u s tic eo f
th e
Suprem e
C o u rt
o f
A rg e n tin a ;
a n dP ro f. C .T . O liv e r, U .S .,
fo rm erly
assistant secretaryo f statea n d am \u2013
b a s s a d o r.
T he
s e le c tio n
of the
m em ber-
com m issioners
a n d
th e
fin a l
e s ta \u2013
b lish m e n to f th e in te rn a tio n a l C o rn -
m is s io n ,a s w e lla s c o lle c tio nof the
enorm ous international evidence
m a te ria la n d o rg a n iz in ga ll se ssio n s
o f
th e
com m ission
h e ld
i n
fo u r
d iffe re n t
c o u n trie s w as a c h ie v e db y
th e W o rld C o n g re ss C o m m issio no f
F a m in e G e n o c id ei n U k ra in e1 9 3 2 -
-1 9 3 3 .
T o
a c c o m p lis h
th is
s u c c e s s
th e
com m ission
w orked
c o n tin u o u s ly
fo r
fiv e
years underth e chairm an-
s h ipo f ig n a tiu s B illin s k y , h is d e p u ty
W . Kereliuk
a n d th es e c r e t a r y a n d
e x e c u tiv e
d ire c to r
D r. S.J.
K a lb a ,
w ithth e a s s is ta n c e of the fo llo w in g
m em bers:M . B arabash, D r. W .G .
D a n y liw ,D r. A . L o z y n s k y , D r. M .
K u s h p e ta , D r. M . S n ih u ro w y c h ,
P rof. M .S te p a n e n k o , L . F il, a n d D r.
B .A . F u te y .
i n
1 9 8 7 -1 9 8 8 th is c o m m is s io n w as
assisted bya Ju rist C o m m ittee head\u2013
e d
b y
J .
S o p in k a ,Q .C ., p re s e n tly
ju s tic e
o f
th e
Suprem e
C o u rt
o f
C a n a d a , w ith
1 4 U k rain ian ju ristsa s
m em bers:
fiv e
fro m
C a n a d a , fiv e
fro m
th e
U .S . a n d
fo u r
fro m
th e
fo llo w in g
c o u n trie s :
E n g l a n d , B e l\u2013
g iu m , A rg en tin aa n d A u stra lia , w ith
D r . D a n y liw s e rv in g as its c o o rd in a \u2013
to r.
T h e le g a l c o u n s e ls w ere:P ro f. L A .
H u n te r
fro m
C anada
a sg e n e r a l
counsel of the com m ission. C ounsels
to th e p e titio n e r, th e W o rld C o n g re s s
of Free U krainians,w ere:J . Sopinka,
Q .C ., a s s is te db y A le x a n d r a C h y c z ij,
a n d
W illiam
L ib e r,Q .C ., a ll fro m
C a n a d a . C o m m is s io n
p e r s o n n e l
w ere:A .J e n k a la , la w y e r fro m
E n-
g la n d ,S . W e rb o w y , la w y e r,a n d
(C o n tin u e do n p a g e4 )
iN T E R v iE W : M in e r s c h a r t c o u r s e to w a r d in d e p e n d e n t tr a d e u n io n s
b yM ic h a e l K lo n s k y
T h e tw o - p a r t in te r v ie w
b e lo w
to o k
p la c e a t th e o f f ic eo f th e
M iners
1
S tr ik e
C o m m itte e o f f ic e in D o n e ts k e ,U kraine,
o n
J u ly
2 8 .
T h espokesm en fo r
th e
m inersa r eth e co-chairm en o f th e S tr ik e
C o m m itte e , A le x a n d e r K o lla n e ts e v a n d
N ic o la i \u0423 \u0430 \u0456\u0435 \u043f \u043a \u0430 . in c lu d e d
in the
d is \u2013
c u s s io na re e ig h t
o th e r r a n k - a n d - f ile
m em berso f the com m ittee.
M ic h a e l K lo n s k yi s a f r e e la n c ew rite r
fro m
C h ic a g o
w ho
r e c e n tly
v is ite d
U k r a in e w itha d e le g a tio no f A th le te s
fo r
P eace,
i n
D o n e ts k e ,
th e
g r o u p
p a r tic ip a te d in a 1 0 - k ilo m e te rr a c e a n d
w a s h o s te d
b yin te r c o m p u te r a n d th e
lo c a l r u n n in g c lu b .
P A R T\u0406
H ave yo u m et w ith m any A m ericans?
K ollanetsev:A t our F irst C ongress of
M in e rsi n D o n e ts k e , th e re p re s e n ta tiv e s
o f
th e A F T(A m erican
F e d e ra tio no f
Teachers)a n d som e independent trade
u n io n is ts
w ere
h e re .
A FT
P re s id e n t
R ic h a rd
W ilsona n d
L u d m illa T h o r n e
who represented
th ec h a rity fu n d
w ere
p re s e n t
a t
th e
c o n g re s s ,
i t
w asv e ry
d iffic u ltfo r th e m in e rs to get v is a sfo r
th e s e p e o p le .
B u tw e h a v e b e e n w o rk in g to g e th e r
w ith s o m e A m e ric a n u n io n le a d e rsfo r
s o m e tim ea s w e lla s p e o p le fro m
th e
A m erican
Em bassy. T he second secre\u2013
taryo f the A m erican E m bassy, M ichael
F o w ler, isa friendo fo u rs.W e w ere also
in v ite d
t o
th eA m erican
E m bassyfo r
th e c e le b ra tio n of the F o u r tho f J u ly .
H o wd idth e s trik e m o v e m e n t b e g in ?
K o lla n e ts e v :
i t
d id n 't
start herei n
D onetske,b u t rather in the K uzbas,in
the U rals. T he m iners were displeased
w ith
d iffic u lt
c o n d itio n so f w o rka n d
lo w
liv in g s ta n d a r d sa n d d e c id e d to go
o n
s trik e . W e had no e x p e rie n c ea n d
w eren o t su reh o w to d o it. O n e can say
th at it (th e strike) started
in c id e n ta lly .
W hat w ereth e dem andsa t first?
valenka: They w ere purely econom i\u2013
c a l.
W e w a n te d
h ig h e r
w ages, higher
p ric e s
fo r
th e ir
c o a l,
b e tte r
liv in g
c o n d itio n s , h ig h e r p e n s io n s , h ig h e rp a y
fo r n ig h t w o rka n d b e tte r fo o d s u p p lie s .
K o lla n e ts e v :
H erei n
D onetske, th e
S trik e C o m m itte eh a d b e e n w o rk in gfo r
overa year. A ftera num bero f strikes,
a n
agreem entw as signed
b e tw e e nth e
w o rk e rs a n d th e g o v e rn m e n t. T h e re su lt
o f th is a g re e m e n t w as th e d e c is io n o f th e
governm ent, N o. 60A , w hich
becam e
la w
on A ugust 3, 1989.
Butas we have gone ahead step-by-
s te pw e h a v e re a liz e d
th a tth e g o v e rn \u2013
m ent
o n ly
s ig n e d
th is
agreem entb e \u2013
c a u s e th e y w e re frig h te n e d a n d th a t th e y
didn't intendt o stick by it. T his agree\u2013
m ent covered m any areasa n d levelso f
governm ent
u p
th ro u g h
th e
Suprem e
S o v ie ta n d th e p re s id e n to f th e
c o u n try .
D id the agreem ent co ver all m in e r si n
the country?
v a le n k a :
N o , o n ly inD onetske. B u t
th e rea re c o m m itte e s lik e th isi n p ra c ti\u2013
c a lly
e v e ry
m in in g
c ity ,a n d
s e p a ra te
agreem ents
h a v e
b e e n
w orked
o u t in
m any
o fth e m . H o w e v e r, th eg o v e r n \u2013
m ent
has notb e e n
a b le
t o
fu lfill
i t s
o b lig a tio n s .
A s its ta n d s
to d a y ,th e
m in e r s w ill fillth e g o v e r n m e n ta l o b li\u2013
g a tio n s th e m s e lv e s . T h a t m e a n s th a ti f
w e
w ant
t o
g e ts o m e th in g
fro m
th e
D o n e ts k e m in e rs N ic o la i v a le n k a (left)a n d Alexander K ollanetsev (right) with
fr e e -la n c e w r ite r M ic h a e l K lo n s k y .
g o v e rn m e n tw e h a v e tofig h t th e la w , th e
bureaucracy, and so on. This m adeu s
realize thati n order to w in oureconom ic
dem ands,w e also
h a d
t o
p u t
fo rth
p o litic a l d e m a n d s .
O n N ovem ber 2, (1989)w e w ent ona
2 4 -h o u r s trik et o s u p p o rt o th e r s trik in g
m iners,i n February, w e held three days
o f p o litic a l m e e tin g st o fo rc e th e D o n e t\u2013
ske Regional Com m unist Party Com\u2013
m itte et o re s ig n . W e d id n 't n e e d th e mt o
m a n a g e D o n e ts k e . T h is c o in c id e d w ith
th e n a tio n a l e le c tio n s .
W e th e n w e n t on a h u n g e r s trik ei n
fronto f the officeso f the party com m it\u2013
te e
t o
g e tth e m
t o
re s ig n
o rf a c e
a
p la n n e d
s trik e
o n th ef i r s t o f M arch.
T he party headquarters didn4 m ake any
d e c is io n
s o
th e
s trik e
to o k
p la c e
a s
s c h e d u le d .
W hat is th e situation presently?
K o lla n e ts e v : W e ll, to d a y
in
D o n e t\u2013
s k e ,
th ep o w e r b e lo n g s to th eS o v ie ts ,
n o t to the p a rty c o m m itte e . T h e rea re
n o t v e ry m a n y c itie s in the S o v ie t U n io n
w here
th e
s itu a tio n
is
lik e
th is .T he
p o w e rn o lo n g e r is in th e h a n d s of the
C o m m u n is t
P a rty
b u t inth o s e
of the
p e o p le s ' d e p u tie s .T he m a jo rity
of the
fo rm er
p a rty
p e o p lew ho w e re in the
territo rial p arty co m m ittee failedt o get
e le c te d .
R a n k -a n d -file
m in e r: O n ly
two or
th re e w e re e le c te d . B ut th e p a rty le a d e rs
w e ren o t e le c te d .
W hat
is the
s ig n ific a n c e
o f
th is
n a tio n a lly ?
K o lla n e ts e v :
i t
m eans
th a t
th e
C o m m u n is t
P a rty
is n o w
ju s t one of
(C o n tin u e do n p a g e1 5 )
Leave a Comment