• Embed Doc
  • Readcast
  • Collections
  • CommentGo Back
Download
 
THE ETHICAL PERSPECTIVE OF WATER: DILEMMAS AND FUTURECHALLENGES
Muhammad Mizanur Rahaman
1
and Olli Varis
Water Resources Laboratory, Helsinki University of Technology, 02015 Espoo, Finland
ABSTRACT
No sector of the society is value free and immune to ethical consideration, water sector is not anexception. Questions of access and deprivation underlie most water decisions. Current water resourcesmanagement approaches are facing various ethical dilemmas. The purpose of this paper is to focussome key ethical issues related to water, which are crucial to water resources development andmanagement. One of the future challenges for water professionals is to find out logical linkagesbetween water policies and ethics to achieve an effective, efficient and sustainable water resourcesdevelopment and management.
[Citation: Rahaman
, M. M. &
Varis
, O. (2005) The Ethical perspective of Water:Dilemmas and Future challenges, In: Afgan, N., Bogdan, Z., Duic, N. & Guzovic, Z.(Eds.):
Sustainable Development of Energy, Water and Environment Systems
 
 –Volume II,
pp. 39-51
 
(University of Zagreb, Croatia).
]
 
1
Corresponding author, email:muhammadmizanur@gmail.com 
 
ETHICS OF WATER: RAHAMAN, M.M. AND VARIS, O. (2005)
INTRODUCTION
Water is life- no one can survive without water. Water is the common symbol of humanity, socialequity and justice. Unequal distribution of water, poor water management, lack of ethical framework,inadequate knowledge and resources are the main reasons for the water crisis in the world. The worldfresh water resources are under sledge. Less than 1 percent of the planet’s water is available for humanconsumption. More than 1 billion people still have no excess to safe drinking water, 3 billion peopleare deprived of basic sanitation services and more than 800 million people, 15 percent of the worldpopulation do not have enough food to meet their basic nutritional needs [1]. Competition for wateramong agricultural, domestic and industrial users, and between them and the natural environment, willbecome more and more acute. For many countries the availability of water may become a majordeterminate of economic growth. The use of freshwater resources presents numerous problems, whosesolution requires ethical reflection.
 Age old knowledge of water conservation and management within the ecosystem, occasionallyconfronted with technological choices, drawn from principles of precaution, responsibility and transparency, should be at forefront 
” [2]. In order to pursue the goal of sustainable and equitable waterresources development, we have to manage water resources in a sustainable way, taking environmentalas well as economic, social, geographical, political and spiritual aspects into account and learn to treatsocial and practical decisions ethically. Without an ethical framework, all efforts towards sustainablewater resources management would be piecemeal, fragmented and ephemeral.Water ethics is still in its infancy and the literature pertinent to water ethics is rather fragmented. Thereis no extensive research or publication for water ethics, yet the floor has been opened by UNESCO inthe form of two prominent publications, “The Ethics of Freshwater: A survey” by Lord Selborne andthe upcoming monograph on Water and Ethics. The Selborne report is important opening of thediscussion and thus highly influential. However, it is very general in nature and fails to focus somecrucial areas of water ethics in the context of developed world and developing world, which arecertainly vital for an effective and efficient water resources management.
 
The chapters included in the forthcoming UNESCO monograph [3] are written from the point of viewof experts on different aspects of the occurrence and use of freshwater, yet no profess to beauthoritative discussions of the basic ethical principles is involved. It offers a wide range of dialoguesand discussions in the field of water ethics, and more precisely it will help to understand the waterethics in a broader sense. It does not intend to compare ethical perspective between developed anddeveloping world
.
The scope of this paper is to analyse six major concern areas of water sector i.e. water for agriculture,water for nature, water infrastructure, water pricing, transparency and financial support for developingworld’s development from the ethical viewpoint. We figure out the ethical dilemmas related to theseareas of water resources management in the context of developed and developing world viewpoints. Inconclusion, we recommends six ethical initiatives that are need to be taken into account by waterprofessionals and decision makers for coming out from these discussed ethical dilemmas and to achievean effective, balanced and ethically acceptable water resources management.
 
ETHICS OF WATER: RAHAMAN, M.M. AND VARIS, O. (2005)
ETHICS AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Ethics are moral principles and values that govern the actions and decisions of an individual or group.They serve as guidelines on how to act rightly and justly when faced with moral dilemmas. Ethicaldilemmas arise in situation, when
Each alternative choice or behaviour has some undesirable elements due to potentially negativeethical or personal consequences.
Right or wrong cannot be clearly identified.Ethical behaviour comprises of honesty, trust, treating others fairly and loyalty. One commonlyaccepted ethical cornerstone is “
 Always treat others, as you would like them to treat you
” [4].The Brundtland report [5], defined the principles of sustainable development such as: “
The earth is onebut the world is not. We all depend on one biosphere for sustaining our lives. Yet each community,each country, strive for survival and prosperity with little regards for its impacts on other 
” and
 Meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their needs
.” Now sustainable development means not only development that takes account of the needs of future generations, but also requires us to share the “ecological space” of the planet more fairlybetween people and countries.Thus sustainable development requires ethical framework in the management of all transboundarynatural resources of a finite nature. The equitable distribution and access to water, the most precioustransboundary resource, is our basic fundamental human right as well as our economical, social andcultural asset. We have to find out common ethical principles that will balance among water uses,among the traditional and technological solutions and among regions. We have to use our wisdom forsharing, caring and conserving our water resources in a new light of morality. We have to ensure everypeople in this world that we are treating others, as we would like to be treated by others. To achievesustainable water resources development, we have to set ethical framework by using our sense of responsibility, honesty, transparency and loyalty.
UNESCO INITIATIVES TOWARDS WATER ETHICS
Although water ethics are now becoming important for water management, there is lack of discourse onwater ethics. The World Commission on the Ethics of Scientific Knowledge and Technology, known asCOMEST set by UNESCO in 1997, played pioneer role in this regard. COMEST seeks to motivatescientists by adding an ethical dimension to their intellectual freedom. A COMEST sub-commission onthe ethics of fresh water was established in October 1999. It tried to find out common ethical principlesrelated to water, which can be accepted as applicable in all geographies, in all stages of economicdevelopment and for all time. In 25
th
October 2000, Lord Selborne, Chairperson of the COMEST sub-commission on the ethics of fresh water, published his historical “The Ethics of Freshwater Use: ASurvey”. The survey draws on a rich and varied body of discussion and documentation to provide anoverview of the practical areas of concern so as to move relevant ethical stances. The aim of the surveyis to help lay a foundation of trust, justice and equity in the availability of and access to freshwaterresources for the entire community of nations [2].The Universal ethical principles that are directly acceptable to the issue of water were pointed out inthe paper. These are as follows:
of 00

Leave a Comment

You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...
You must be to leave a comment.
Submit
Characters: ...