T H E U K R A IN IA N W E E K L Y
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER
6 ,1 9 8 8
-N o .
4 5
A
G L IM P S E O F S O V IE TR E A L IT Y
Radio Kiev broadcast calls for
re -e s ta b lis h m e n to f n a tio n a l S o v ie ts
b y B o h d a n N a h a y lo
R a d io
K ie v
h a s
broadcast an
o u t\u00ad
s p o k e n
c o m m e n ta ry
on aspects of the
n a tio n a litie s
q u e s tio n
in
w h ic h
it n o t
o n ly advocated the re-establishm ent of
national Soviets (councils) but also
c ritic iz e d
th e
p riv ile g e d
p o s itio n
th a t
R u s s ia n s e n jo y
in th e U n io n re p u b lic s
com pared
w ith n o n - R u s s ia n s liv in g
o u ts id e
th e ir
re p u b lic s . T h e ite m
w as
in c lu d e d in a b r o a d c a s t b y R a d io K ie v
in
th e
U k ra in ia n
la n g u a g e fo r U k ra i\u00ad
n ia n s a b r o a d o n th e e v e n in g o f O c to b e r
2 7 .The unsigned com m entary addressed
itself to the problem s faced
by repre\u00ad
s e n ta tiv e s o f th e d iffe re n t n a tio n a litie s
of the
S o v ie t U n io n
w h o liv e o u ts id e
th e ir n a tio n a l te rrito rie s , o r w h o d o n o t
h a v e th e ir o w n n a tio n a l te rrito ria l u n its .
I t
d re w
a tte n tio n
t o
a
fa c t
th a t
i s
fre q u e n tly
being stressed these days in
th e S o v ie tp r e s s :2 0 p e rc e n t o f th e S o v ie t
p o p u la tio n , th a t is o v e r
55 m illion
p e o p le , fa ll in to th is c a te g o ry .
E x a m in in g
th e p o s s ib ilitie s th a t th e
n o n -R u s s ia n s in th is s itu a tio n
have to
" p re s e rv e th e ir tra d itio n s , la n g u a g e a n d
n a tio n a l c u ltu re ," R a d io K iev a c k n o w \u00ad
le d g e d
th a t
th in g s
w ere
n o t
a s
th e y
should be.
" R e g re tta b ly , th e
representatives of
a ll th e s e n a tio n a litie s , w h ic h liv e o n th e
t e r r i t o r y
o f a n o th e r p e o p le , fre q u e n tly
s till d o n o t h a v e p o s s ib ilitie s fo r th e fu ll
re a liz a tio n
o f
th e ir
n a tio n a l-c u ltu ra l
n e e d s , especially in the area of obtain\u00ad
in g e d u c a tio n in th e ir n a tiv e la n g u a g e ,
c re a tin g
c e n te rs
o f
n a tio n a l
c u ltu re ,
m a k in g
full use of the m eans of m ass
c o m m u n ic a tio n
and satisfying
th e ir
religious needs. A ll this, of course,
c a n n o t
f a il
b u t
t o
m ake
th e m
fe e l
c o n s tric te d ," R a d io K iev n o te d .
W h ile th is p ro b le m
h a s re c e n tly b e e n
re c e iv in g
in c re a s in g
a tte n tio n
in
o n e
fo rm
o r
a n o th e r
in
th e
Soviet press.
R a d io
K ie v w e n t o n t o
m a k e a p o in t
th a t is ra re ly m a d e q u ite s o b lu n tly .
" L e g a lly ,
a ll
th e
c o u n try 's
n a tio n s
a n d
n a tio n a litie s a re e q u a l. W h y
is it
th e n
th a t
R ussians
in
A zerbaidzhan,
A rm enia,
U z b e k is ta n
a n d
a n y
o th e r
rep u b lic are ab le to satisfy th eir cu ltu ral
re q u ire m e n ts w ith o u t a n y p ro b le m . Y et
w h e n re p re s e n ta tiv e s o f o th e r n a tio n a li\u00ad
tie s ,fo r
in s ta n c e , in
M oscow
\u2014
th e
c o u n try 's c a p ita l, d e m a n d th e s a tis fa c \u00ad
tion of thesam en e e d s , iti s deem ed to be
n a tio n a lis m .
C e rta in ly , p o s in g
th e
q u e s tio n
in
this w ay reveals w ith
fu ll
clarity the defects w hich w e have in this
s p h e r e ," it s ta te d .
R a d io
K ie v
n o te d
th a t
th e re
h a v e
re c e n tly
b e e n
som e
im p ro v e m e n ts
in
th is
re g a rd .
W ith o u t
g o in g
in to
a n y
details, itm e n tio n e d
th a t U k ra in ia n s ,
A r m e n ia n s
a n d
G e o rg ia n s
h a v e
e s ta \u00ad
blishedth e ir own "cultural centers" in
M oscow , and that U k ra in ia n sh a v e a ls o
s e tu p as im ila r c e n te r inth e L a tv ia n
c a p ita l, R ig a . In fa c t, o n
O ctober 12,
R a d io K ie v b r o a d c a s ta n in t e r v ie w w it h
th e p h ilo lo g is t Z in o v iy a
F r a n k oi n
w hich sh e revealed th at th e first U krai\u00ad
nian school has recently been openedi n
M oscow .
T h is is, of course,ju s t a m odest start.
E ver since glasnost began to take hold,
U k r a in ia n w riters have been expressing
c o n c e r na b o u t th e la c k o f a n y c u ltu ra l
fa c ilitie s
fo r
the 6 m illion
U k ra in ia n s
w ho
liv e o u ts id e
th e
U k ra in ia n
S S R .
T h e y
h a v e
p ro te s te d
th a t
th e ir
com \u00ad
patriots have in effect been condem ned
t od e n a tio n a liz a tio n .
R e c e n tly , a le a d in g U k ra in ia n w rite r.
R om an
Ivanychuk, appealed
t o
th e
K azakh
a u th o ritie s to
o p e n
at least a
fe w
U k ra in ia n -la n g u a g e
s c h o o ls
a n d
c u ltu ra l c e n te rs fo r th e a p p ro x im a te ly 1
m illio n U k r a in ia n s w h o liv e in K a z a k h \u00ad
s ta n . H e p o in te d o u t th a t o th e r n a tio n a l
m in o ritie s in
K azakhstan, such as the
G erm ans,
K oreans
a n d
Uigurs, have
been given at leastsom e culturalc o n c e s \u00ad
sio n s, w h ile th e U k ra in ia n s , w h o b y fa r
o u tn u m b e r th e la tte r tw o g ro u p s , h a v e
o n ly ju s t o p e n e d th e ir v e ry first s c h o o l
a n d
still have
n o
c u ltu ra l
c e n te rs
o r
lib r a r ie s .
T he
s itu a tio n
of the
U k ra in ia n s ; in
M o ld a v ia ,
w here
th e y
c o n s titu te
th e
re p u b lic 's la rg e s t n a tio n a l m in o rity , is
just as difficult.
A
year ago, the
f ir s t
s e c re ta ry
o f
th e
M o ld a v ia n
W riters'
U nion stressed that it w as "neglectful"
th a t
" 6 0 0 ,0 0 0
U k ra in ia n s
liv in g
in
M o ld a v ia d o n o t h a v e a s in g le s c h o o l o r
n e w s p a p e r." H e re a g a in , a lth o u g h s o m e
cultural concessions have recently been
m ade
t o
M o ld a v ia 's
sm aller
G augaz
a n d B u lg a ria n m in o ritie s , th e re d o n o t
s e e m
t o
have been any
im p ro v e m e n ts
fo r th e U k ra in ia n s .
S ig n ific a n tly , R a d io K ie v w e n t o n to
recom m end
that "perhaps
it is w orth
returning" to the practice of establish\u00ad
ing national Soviets for com pact groups
o f n a tio n a litie s liv in g o u ts id e th e ir o w n
re p u b lic , o r w ith o u t a
n a tio n a l te rri\u00ad
to ry .
I n
th e
1920s, after
a ll, S o v ie t
U k ra in e
le d
th e
w ay
i n
s e ttin g
a n
^e x a m p le o f h o w a re p u b lic c o u ld sa tisfy
th e n e e d s o f its n a tio n a l m in o ritie s in
a c c o rd a n c e
w ith
" L e n in is t
p rin c ip le s "
o f n a tio n a litie s p o lic y a s th e y w e re th e n
u n d e rs to o d .
R a d io
Kiev recalled that in U kraine
in the 1920s and first half of the 1930s
th e re
w ere "R ussian, G erm an, Jew ish
and Polish schools, theatres, clubs and
l i b r a r i e s . "
It also
s a y s
th a t
th e
to ta l
n u m b e r o f n a tio n a l ra io n s in
U k ra in e
a n d
th e
R u ssian
S F S R
in th e s e y e a rs
w as over 300, and that there w ere m ore
th a n3 ,0 0 0 n a tio n a l ru ra l S o v ie ts.
A ccording to Jam es M ace, a W estern
s c h o la r o f th is p e rio d , " n o n -U k ra in ia n s
in S o v ie t U k ra in e w e re g u a ra n te e d th e
rig h t to s e p a ra te c u ltu ra l d e v e lo p m e n t,
th e rig h t to p rim a ry e d u c a tio n in th e ir
n a tiv e
to n g u e , th e
rig h t to
a p p e a r in
c o u rt a n d to d e a l w ith a ll a d m in is tra tiv e
o ffic e s
u s in g
th e ir n a tiv e to n g u e , a n d
th e rig h t to th e ir o w n p o litic a l in s titu \u00ad
tio n s
in
re g io n s w h e re th e y
fo rm ed
a
m ajo rity
o f
th e
to ta l
p o p u la tio n .
I n
a c c o rd a n c e
w ith
th is
la s t
g u a ra n te e
their w ere, as of June
1928, 388 Rus\u00ad
s ia n v illa g e S o v ie ts in S o v ie t U k r a in e ,
2 5 1
G erm an
S o v ie ts ,
1 4 3
P o lis h , 7 7
Jew ish,
5 7
M o ld a v ia n
(n o t
c o u n tin g
th o s e
in
th e
A u to n o m o u s
M o ld a v ia n
S o c ia lis t
R e p u b lic ), 4 3
B u lg a ria n , 3 0
G reek,
13 Czech, three
B yelorussian,
a n d o n e S w e d is h ."
A s if fo rs e e in g th e lik e ly o b je c tio n st o
its p ro p o s a l. R a d io K ie v s ta te d th a ti t
d id
n o t
th in k
th a t
th e
c re a tio n
o f
n a tio n a l S o v ie ts w o u ld n e c e s s a rily le a d
t o
" th e
is o la tio n
of nations" and
th e
g ro w th o f n a tio n a lis m . It a rg u e d :
" I n
a c c o r d a n c e
w ith
o u r
C o n s titu \u00ad
tio n , e a c h n a tio n a n d e a c h n a tio n a lity
h a v e
th e
sam e
rig h ts
a s
re g a rd s
th e
s a tis fa c tio n o f th e ir c u ltu ra l n e e d s . T h e
c re a tio n
of such cultural centers, espe\u00ad
cially if conditions lead to the establish\u00ad
m ent of
n a tio n a l ra io n s a n d
n a tio n a l
v illa g e
a n d
s e ttle m e n t S o v ie ts , w ill
p ro v id e th e o p p o rtu n ity to e n su re th a t
n a tio n a l-c u ltu ra l n e e d s a re m e t.
E v id e n tly to d a y , a s th e S o v ie t a u th o -
(C o n tin u e d o n p a g e 1 5 )
M akars e e k s ...
(Continued from
page 1)
m ocratic
refo rm s
w a s v io le n tly d is \u00ad
persed by local riot police.
A
le a d e r o f th e D e m o c ra tic F r o n t to
P ro m o te
Perestroika, M r. M akar was
c h a rg e d w ith " a n ti-S o v ie t s la n d e r " a n d
d is o rd e rly c o n d u c t u n d e r A rtic le s 1 8 7 -1
a n d
1 8 7 -3 o f th e
U k ra in ia n
S S R
C ri\u00ad
m in a l
C o d e fo r o rg a n iz in g th e s e p u b lic
ra llie s , w h ic h re p o rte d ly a ttra c te d u p to
5 0 ,0 0 0 p e o p le a t th e ir p e a k .
T he
y o u n g
a c tiv is t is re p o rte d ly
in
s o lita r y
confinem ent
in
B ry g id k y
a w a itin g tria l. N e ith e r a tria l d a te n o r a
p re s id in g
ju d g e
h a v e
y e t
b e e n
d e te r\u00ad
m in e d ,
a c c o rd in g to N a d ia S v itly c h n a
o f th e E x te rn a l R e p re s e n ta tio n
of the
U k ra in ia n
H e ls in k i U n io n .
F o llo w in g
M r. M akar's
arrest, a
C itizen s' C om m ittee in D efense of Ivan
M akar, headed
b y U k ra in ia n
n a tio n a l
rig h ts
a c tiv is t
B ohdan
H o ry n , w as
fo rm ed
in Lviv. T hrough the resources
of th is co m m ittee, M r. M a k a r's fam ily
re q u e s te d
th e
h e lp
o f
th e
U k ra in ia n
c o m m u n ity
i n
th e
U n ite d
S ta te s in
fin d in g
A m erican
co-counsel adept in
in te rn a tio n a l h u m a n
rig h ts la w , a s th e
activist saw his case as a m atter of basic
in te rn a tio n a l
hum an
rights, said
M r.
S ta n to n
in
a
N ovem ber
3
te le p h o n e
in te rv ie w .
I n
re s p o n s e
t o
th e
M akar
fam ily 's
request, m em bers of the
U k ra in ia n
C ongress C om m ittee of A m erica turned
t o
th e
U k ra in ia n
A m erican
Bar A s\u00ad
so ciatio n to assist in lo catin g a crim in al
la w y e r s p e c ia liz in g in
in te rn a tio n a l
h u m a n rig h ts la w a n d S o v ie t la w . W ith
just such a background
in both fields,
p a rtic u la rly h is le a d e rs h ip in th e C a m \u00ad
b o d ia n G e n o c id e P ro je c t, th e first c a se
b ro u g h t to th e W o rld C o u rt u n d e r th e
1948 Genocide
A ct, M r. Stanton
w as
approached by the UA BA .
"M y
f ir s t
re a c tio n
was that
it w as
u n p re c e d e n te d ," sa id M r. S ta n to n , " b u t
I 'd
b e
w illin g
t o
tr y
t o
s e e
if it w as
p o s s ib le . S o I c h e c k e d th e S o v ie t la w s
a n d fo u n d th a t th e re w a s n o s ta tu te th a t
w o u ld
p re v e n t
fo re ig n
c o -c o u n s e l
t o
assist lo cal.rep resen tatio n in a trial of a
S o v ie t c itiz e n . T h e S o v ie t le g a l s y s te m
is o p e n
t o
p e o p le w h o a r e n o t S o v ie t
la w y e rs
fo r
a s s is ta n c e
in
a
crim inal
c a s e ," he said.
T he
S o v ie t
a u th o ritie s
d o
re q u ire ,
h o w e v e r, a n o ta riz e d w ritte n s ta te m e n t
b y
th e
a c c u s e d
s p e c ify in g
c e rta in
in \u00ad
d iv id u a ls a s h is le g a l c o u n s e l.
T h e U A B A , h e a d e d b y P h ila d e lp h ia
attorney Andrew Fylypovych,agreed in
e a rly O c to b e r to s p o n s o r M r. S ta n to n
t o
th e
S o v ie t
U n io n
a s
M r.
M a k a r 's
d e fe n s e
la w y e r, a n d
d e c id e d
a ls o
t o
d e s ig n a te
a n
e x p e rie n c e d
tra n s la to r
a n d
crim inal
la w y e r
fro m
D etro it,
Y aroslaw
D obrow olsky, to accom pany
him .
M r.
S ta n to n
su b m itted
h is a p p li\u00ad
c a tio n
t o
th e
S o v ie t
E m bassy
in
W a s h in g to n fo r a b u s in e s s v isa fo r th e
purpose of co-defending M r. M akar at
h is c rim in a l tria l o n O c to b e r 1 1 , w h ile
M r.
D o b ro w o ls k y
a p p lie d
so m etim e
later. T he attorneys cabled a request for
perm ission
a n d
th e
n e c e s s a ry
o ffic ia l
sponsorship to the M inistry of Justice in
M oscow , but had received no replya s of
N ovem ber
3 ,
re p o rte d ly
d e s p ite
p o \u00ad
litic a l
p r e s s u r e
fro m
th e
S ta te
D e\u00ad
p a rtm e n t
a n d
m em bers
o f
th e
U .S .
Congress who
s u p p o rte d th e ir e ffo rt.
L v ivg irl...
(Continued from
page 1)
th a t
a
v ic tim
liv e s
b e y o n d
a g e
3 0 .
S u rg e ry fo r th e c o n d itio n is c u ra tiv e .
O lesia underw ent a successful opera\u00ad
tio n
t o
c o rre c t
th e
s tru c tu ra l
a b n o r\u00ad
m alities
o f
h e r
h e a r t
o n
T u e s d a y ,
N ovem ber 1. A s of N ovem ber3 , she w as
doing fine and w as back in her regular
h o s p ita l
ro o m .
S h e
is e x p e c te d
t o
rem ain in the hospital for seven to 10
days after her surgery.
A
spokesperson for D eborah H ospi\u00ad
ta l,
L o rra in e
R y a n , to ld
T h e W e e k ly
th a t
d o c to r s , in c lu d in g
D r.
L y n n
B .
M c G ra th , w h o
perform ed
th e
fo u r-
h o u r
o p e ra tio n ,
a n d
D r.
M aria
C o-
lo m b i, th e
a tte n d in g
c a rd io lo g is t a n d
c h a irm a n
o f
th e
p e d ia tric
c a rd io lo g y
departm ent, expect a full recovery.
D r. W o ro c h , a S o u th
O range, N .J.,
c a rd io lo g is t, a n d
D r.
A ndrew
O lear-
chyk, a
c a rd io -th o ra c ic
s u rg e o n
fro m
th e
P h ila d e lp h ia
a re a ,
w ere
b o th
in \u00ad
s tru m e n ta l
in
a rra n g in g
fo r
O lesia's
tre a tm e n t a t th e w o rld -fa m o u s
D e\u00ad
b o ra h
H o s p ita l.
T he
tw o
p h y s ic ia n s
a c te d o n b e h a lf o f th e U k ra in ia n M e d i\u00ad
c a l
A s s o c ia tio n
o f
N o rth
A m erica.
D eborah
H o s p ita l
i s
know n
fo r
a c c e p tin g
p a tie n ts
w ith o u t
re g a rd
fo r
th e ir a b ility
t o
p a y
fo r
m edical care.
O lesia's
m e d ic a l tr e a tm e n t is b e in g
c o v e re d
b y th e C h ild re n
of th e W orld
Fund of th e Deborah Hospital Founda\u00ad
tio n .
0 !e s ia
a rriv e d
in
th e
U n ite d
S ta te s
w ith h e r m o th e r , O k s a n a , o n
S u n d a y ,
O c to b e r 2 3 ,
T he
e ffo rts
b e g a n
a fte r
O lesia's
grandm other, M rs. K ovalyshyn, also of
L v iv , w h o w a s v is itin g h e r s is te r in N e w
Y o rk , c o n ta c te d
D r. W o ro c h a n d to ld
h im o f O le s ia 's p lig h t.
The surgery that O lesia needed is not
ro u tin e in th e U S S R : th e m o rta lity ra te
i s
m uch
h ig h e r a n d
th e re
a re
fe w
h o s p ita ls th a t c a n p ro v id e it. In th e U .S .
the success rate is 90 percent for such
surgery. D r. W oroch explained.
L y d ia S a v o y k a o f th e U .S . C a th o lic
C onference
h a n d le d
th e re q u is ite c o n \u00ad
ta c ts b e tw e e n
th e U .S . a n d th e S o v ie ts .
u lc ra in ia n W e e y y
FOUNDED 1933
A n
E n g lis h - la n g u a g e
U k r a in ia n
n e w s p a p e r
p u b lis h e d
b y
th e
U k r a in ia n
N a tio n a l
A s s o c ia tio n
In c ., a n o n - p r o fit a s s o c ia tio n , a t 3 0 M o n tg o m e ry S t., J e rs e y C ity , N .J .
0 7 3 0 2 .
S e c o n d - c la s s p o s ta g e p a id a t J e rs e y C ity , N .J . 0 7 3 0 2 .
(IS S N -
0 2 7 3 -9 3 4 8 )
Y e a rly s u b s c r ip tio n ra te : S 2 0 ; fo rU N A m e m b e rs -
\u0428
.
A ls o p u b lis h e d b y th e U N A : S v o b o d a , a U k r a in ia n - la n g u a g e d a ily n e w s p a p e r .
T h e W e e k ly a n d S v o b o d a :
(201) 434-0237, -0807, -3036
U N A :
(2 0 1 )4 5 1 - 2 2 0 0
P o s tm a s te r, s e n d a d d re s s
changes to:
T h e U k r a in ia n W e e k ly
P .O . B o x
3 4 6
J e rs e y C ity , N ,J . 0 7 3 0 3
E d ito r: R o m a
H ad zew ycz
A s s o c ia te
E ditors: IM arta
K o lo m a y e ts
C h ry s ty n a
L a p y c h a lc
T h e U k r a in ia n W e e k ly /N o v e m b e r
6 , 1 9 8 8 , \u0406\u0427 \u043e . 4 5 , V o l. L V I
C o p y rig h t 1 9 8 8
b y T h e U k r a in ia n
W e e k ly
Leave a Comment