Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Joe Osborne
GASP Legal Director
Lauren Burge
GASP Staff Attorney
Matt Walker
Clean Air Council Community Outreach Coordinator Buffalo Township Municipal Building Washington County June 20, 2012
Presentation Topics
Why air emissions from the natural gas industry are a concern What pollutants are associated with the industry
Details about proposed expansion to the Welling Compressor Station How individuals can participate in the decisionmaking process by commenting on proposed air permits
Why Air?
Natural gas burns cleaner than coal per unit of energy generated. But must consider air impact from entire natural gas production process. Air pollution is generated from:
Well pad, impoundment construction Well drilling, fracking, venting, and flaring Truck traffic Natural gas extraction, processing, transmission, and storage
Individually, these sources and activities may seem insignificant, but there are many sources and the total impact is astounding.
The Oil and Gas Sectors Contribution to Ambient NOx and VOC can be Enormous
Consider other areas where drilling is common: Southern Methodist University study (2009) in Dallas-Fort Worth area, NOx and VOC emissions from oil and gas sector exceeded emissions from all motor vehicles. Colorado Dept. of Public Health and Environment (2008) NOx and VOC emissions from O&G development exceeded motor vehicle emissions for entire state. Wyoming DEQ (2009) WY failed to meet federal health-based standards for ozone for first time, primarily due to O&G development.
ource: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/08/wyoming-ait-pollution-gas-drilling_n_833027.html
the gas industry released more smog-forming emissions than all cars and trucks in the Dallas-Fort Worth metropolitan area
New York Times article citing Armendarizs 2009 report, supported by Texas Commission on Environmental Quality
http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2011/05/27/27greenwire-could-smog-shroud-the-marcellus-shales-natural-3397.html?pagewanted=all
The Marcellus Shale play and other shale formations in the region are perfectly situated to worsen existing ozone and PM nonattainment areas in the Midatlantic and Northeast.
Hydrogen sulfide
Causes eye, nose, and throat irritation Exposure at high concentrations results in permanent brain damage, death Generally not present in Marcellus areas
Formaldehyde
Known human carcinogen Can cause asthma, coughing, fatigue, allergic reactions
Emissions Sources
1. Compressor Engines
Fugitive emissions Engine exhaust A modern 1200 hp compressor will emit approximately: NOx 6 TPY CO 1.5 TPY VOCs 1.5 TPY HAPs 0.5 TPY (mostly formaldehyde) Engines at Welling are larger two at 1380 bhp and nine at 1980 bhp
Emissions Sources
2. Condensate tanks Source of VOCs
Emissions Sources
3. Production and Transmission Fugitive emissions
Leaking pipes, valves, flanges
4. Gas Processing
Dehydrators Heaters
Emissions Sources
5. Well Completions
http://www.npr.org/2012/04/05/150055142/science-and-the-fracking-boom-missing-answers
Truck Traffic
Flaring/Venting
HAPs, CH4
Source: DPCusa.org
Pipeline Leakages
CH4
Fugitive Emissions/Leakages
Compressor Stations
Dehydration Units
Methane, VOCs, HAPs
Condensate Tanks
Unplanned Events
High levels
rapid burning, spasms, and swelling of throat and upper respiratory tract reduced O2 in tissues fluid build-up in lungs death
Source: http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxfaqs/TF.asp?id=396&tid=69
Aldehydes (formaldehyde)
-- Skin, eyes, nose, and throat irritation
VOCs: http://www.epa.gov/iaq/voc.html, Formaldehyde: http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/tfacts111.pdf , Hydrogen Sulfide: http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxfaqs/tf.asp?id=388&tid=67
Source: http://www.epa.gov/air/ozonepollution/health.html American Lung Association, Health Effects of Ozone and Particle Pollution, State of the Air, 2011; Presidents Cancer Panel, Reducing Environmental Cancer Risk: What We Can Do Now, 2008-2009 Annual Report (National Cancer Institute, May 2010).
Dry gas: natural gas with lower quantities of NGLs and a low moisture content
Lower amounts of VOCs Marcellus gas is generally dry except for the western end
Source: http://www.epa.gov/airtransport/whereyoulive.html
http://epa.gov/airquality/qa/monprog.html#SLAMS
http://www.dep.state.pa.us/dep/deputate/airwaste/aq/aqm/docs/Final_PA_Air_Monitoring_Network_Plan_2013.pdf
Ozone, PM
Location
Location
Location
The Welling Station is open for public comment until June 25th Comments can generate an official public hearing with DEP and MarkWest
Benzene
controlled benzene emissions from the associated glycol dehydration unit process vent will be 0.12 tpy (5.97 tpy uncontrolled). Since MarkWest has demonstrated that the actual average benzene emissions from the glycol dehydration unit process vent associated with the 130 MMscfd TEG dehydrator at Welling are less than 1 tpy, MarkWest is exempt from the control, monitoring, and recordkeeping requirements for the dehydrator.
Potential Issues
Proper (detailed) greenhouse gas analysis Proper Aggregation Analysis Public health impacts Impacts on regional air quality
Technology Example #1
Redesign Blow Down Systems and Alter ESD Practices
Technology Example #2
Zero Emissions Dehydrators
Technology Example #3
Use electric engines
Public Participation
comment on natural gas equipment like compressor stations and achieve public hearings and stronger permits observe and report possible air quality issues or violations to prevent pollution Request and attend DEP public hearings and local township meetings pressure gas companies to adopt best available technologies
Why Comment?
Air Quality permits affect local air quality and public health Participate in decision making process DEP issued stronger permits Public pressure can sway DEP decisions
Testimony
Oral Usually limited to 5 minutes Public Education (of audience) Can respond to Public Meeting discussion
The Basics
(comments/testimony) How do you start?
Read the DEPs Review Memo
Required Info:
Name Address Phone number Plan Approval #
Air monitoring requirements Call the Clean Air Council or GASP for help
Writing Tips
Focus your testimony on using your strengths tell your own story in your own voice Always relate your points back to the specific piece of equipment you are commenting on Use your experiences and local knowledge Dont worry about having to include legal or technical arguments Nothing is too simple or short to write Dont be intimidated
Citizen Monitoring
Common Senses Monitoring
Monitor about once a week On property or normal route Use form to document relevant information Make a Pollution Complaint to DEP
1-866-255-5158
Use keywords to identify the call, such as: natural gas operations, drilling, Marcellus Shale, hydrofracturing
Questions?
Contact Info
Matt Walker, Community Outreach, Clean Air Council
mwalker@cleanair.org Lauren Burge, Staff Attorney, GASP: lauren@gasp-pgh.org