Professional Documents
Culture Documents
": Pearse's C Chulainn Author(s): Philip O'Leary Source: Proceedings of the Harvard Celtic Colloquium, Vol. 3 (1983), pp. 21-38 Published by: Department of Celtic Languages & Literatures, Harvard University Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/20557129 . Accessed: 21/08/2013 11:20
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Department of Celtic Languages & Literatures, Harvard University is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Proceedings of the Harvard Celtic Colloquium.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Philip
O'Leary
Any Statues"
discussion will, of
of course,
Yeats's tell
famous us a
great
question deal
from more
"The about
Yeats
pearse
and
or
his
Cu
rough
Chulainn.
beasts
For
than
those
it
will
about
in
either
Pearse or
interested
uses of made in the of this century, years When Pearse be: might to he expect what did
He from very had had early years in his
Irish in the material epic early a better if less elegant question to his Cu Chulainn summoned side, the Post stalk Office? through
to refine career?and those his expectations, career for began very
on with the of his Three Lectures publication ? he had in 1898 when he was only nineteen Topics to the hero fascinated References by Cu Chulainn.
in his writings on all topics, and he was eventu
to write two ally Deeds (The Boyhood Ford (1913) of the In all of acter.
for ary that artist Pearse model, ideal and a moral
Chuchulainn Macghniomhartha pageants, of Cu Chulainn, and The Defence 1909) as the char with C? Chulainn central Cu Chulainn these writings represented
and ethical his valuable ideal as attempts insight well to into as a liter as incarnate Pearse
one who learned Not Irish from for his surprisingly in Dublin, with direct encounter Pearse's first books was Fenian heroic Irish literature the through Cycle was just then than the Ulster much of which rather Cycle, In the for the 1900 issue June edited first time. being na Gaedhilge, text of a he published the of Irisleabhar he had delivered lecture at a Gaelic "An meeting, League
Fhiann agus an Fhiannaidheachd," a paper largely con
cerned
references
with
to
the
historicity
of
Celticists.
Fionn
and
bristling
a few
with
years
continental
Within
he had sufficiently mastered the of the later language of three them: Torai to edit and publish Fenian tales in dheacht Fhiacail 6 Neachtain (with Eoghan R?ogh Gr?ag an Chota and Bruidhean Lachtna 19 04), Bodach (1906), Chaorthainn (1908). even Yet while his he was establishing scholarly
credentials with the Fenian material he was beginning to
immerse himself through In his 1897 lecture March the New Ireland Literary
eighteen-year-old the Red Branch,"1 president, quoted
discussed
Philip
O'Leary
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
22
and, in words he could have restated unchanged at old the to Gael," Fionn, mere time: this heart theme the end
of
value ...
his
of may
life,
the still
affirmed
early be the literature: inspiring
his
faith
"These and
in
rejuvenating
the
self-same
inspirational
epics of
man,
October "The
and
lifting
of
him
same
to
year, Future the
higher
he of
and
returned the than
nobler
ideals."2
declaring: Oscar? Oisin, names they of represented great
In
in
Cuchulainn, Gael of a
former two
to rol
ours,
him led
men away
yet are
who
had
though
gone those
before, mighty
is not
who heroes
dead: conviction
had
thousand
fought
years
the land
on we, in
good
have
fight....
And their
well-nigh
since
trod
it lives
this
that
of
our as a
things."3
At Literary
spoke lecture on
was
of the brother
Branch has
and Dudley
signs an
and
of Lae,
traced The
Patrick's Willie
its feats from ... The
hand."4 origin
Irish
historic
Not
Patrick
and, that
found
seconding the noble
the
the
lecture
vote of personality
an
of
entirely
thanks Cuchu to
lainn
is Club of
type
and delivered
of
Gaelic
vigour to
nationality,
and the on 5 Lae what hope...."*> Catholic January
full
Commercial 1899,
as
it
life
Saga
Pearse
was
Gaelic point thought,
a bit
more
explicit
he directed
on C? Chulainn
as
reported: was the was
"a true
elevation and
type
"The last
of
of
chivalrous
great
noble;
the
whole
purity
Saga and
and
delicacy
were and and, in
of
conception
heroes, inspirations, what would invariably
that
while
marked
their
men of a
Their
represented be
sometimes as
impulse
'thorough Catholic
rather clothes whom or
gentleman'
as a worthy
(sic)."?
candidate
This no
of
bathetic
for admission
picture
to
of
the
Commercial
priggish at Father young formal Dinneen a reference academic ensuing
Club
man functions invariably
is
who
doubt
insisted the called
the
on Gaelic "P.
creation
wearing League8 Haitch fondness
of
morning
the
and
listing"
to degrees.* years of
young literary,
Pearse's
political,
especially
educational
work,
and
with
his
founding
of
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
23 in 1908, Pearse's ?anna of the pedagogi conception Scoil Irish value literature and his of early of Cu cal image as an inspirational model both focused and deep Chulainn
ened. No longer gentleman." was Cu Chulainn
type ?
of
Gaelic
nationality"
Writing
or when
merely
the Claidheamh
shadowy
"true on
the
in
absurdly
An
anachronistic
Soluis
thorough
at a time 1906, 27 October on educational fixed entirely at Scoil later would adopt
readers:
?r
uasal, naidhe
gcead
chomhairle
'ideal' a os mar gcomhair Biodh realt
do
Ghaedhealaibh,
Bearl?ir,
biodh
i Cuirohnighmis a agus
cusp?ir
gcomh ar r?idhte
Chuchulainn.
sin,
mar ?,
no os first
gn?omhartha
'n-a eolais
agus
r?idhte
ag lonnradh
gaisgidhigh
go glormhar
eile
sa
sp?ir (Our
before speaker
?r
gcomhair.11 counsel
a noble say.
to
Gaels,
an us
let
"ideal" remember
them
as
always
the Cu
have
them would
goal, Let
English Chulainn.
sayings light he
entered
he
opened
?anna
September
the new
19 08,
students
put
beliefs
a large at Cullenswood faced hall the main House, they C? Chulainn of the for Pearse mural arms, young taking be a noble "it would to set somewhere that believed thing entered that the school see it a where every boy might in which the boy Cuchulainn be the central should picture the somehow be Lest he began point lost, figure."12 on their Cu Chulainn the his students very telling story
first Irish story morning speaker writer in from Padhraic their Rosmuc, ?g ? new the school.13 future A novelist claims the young and native short students
Conaire,
learned
this
N?orbh an ag l?inn
lesson
fhada bPiarsach mar bhi
quickly:
ann duinn "Cuchulainn" Cuchulainn ina gur thuigeamar a dh?anamh eisiomplair gur de chuspoir gach aige....14 mac
(We weren't
was lainn," Pearse's for
there
long
until
make
we
understood
student exemplar....) a
that
"Cu Chu
it
to goal Cu Chulainn
cess,
religious truer ours."15
In his Pearse
oneness
history said
community of
of
of
together
purpose
This
purpose
perpetuate
in
Eire
the
knightly
tradition
of
the
macradh
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
24
of the tradition Emain noble Macha tradition of Colm ... the of Cille...."16 high the tradition Fianna For ... Pearse of Cuchulainn the now, Christlike the edu ...
cational Ulster
Chulainn, ration
of as
a never
as its
and and but kind
the Cu
and
Boy-Corps idealisation
the
picture environment
the
hero."1? perfect
kind
of
hero,
fostering
When he Pearse makes
which
is
go
clear a long
to
the
the
way
making
qualities from the
of
a perfect
of such a "thorough
gentleman" desiderate
struggle, only however, practiced warrior does
of is
1900: effort
rise
of of
the the
school child
for
life itself,
by these
All
was
for his facing
not
the virtues
Spartan
emphasis with
at
perfection."18
Cullenswood
on the boy and To Cu
House
Chulainn, not the
in
1908,
who doomed
was
overwhelming
exuberance, odds.
celebrate
the
end
of
life,
this
school
Pearse
year,
wrote,
one
and
of
his
the of
periods
performed
of
on the
his
the
students motive
school
eants. in his It
grounds,
Pearse school may be
the
explained magazine wondered ambitious in to our crown and
first
his An
Cu Chulainn
writing
pag
play
Macaomh: we have of The first undertaken a Cuchulainn is work to send that with our the com
project
worthy
home with the knightly of Cuchulainn in their image ears. words in their hearts and his knightly ringing the of leave under the St. Enda's They will spell
magic is, their the Pearse in of after country, of epic stressed play. about often opinion are true their all, the most the indeed, world.'9 his absolute fidelity it makes question and his Those who discussions of the of to his sense Pearse's entire Pearse, of personally source at Ulster dif early this sour beloved greatest as I hero, figure think, the in the Macaomh the greatest epic who of in
this writing to investigate point ces for ideas his Cycle. ferences Irish As of literature is
concerning sharp.
were
ship.
impressed
Desmond
by
Ryan
the
breadth
said of Irish
and
him:
depth
"His
of
close
his was
scholar
study of
Irish
make
gave
him Cuchulainn one
him
of
that
the
mastery
great
over
it
writers
which
of
later the
to
He
to-day.
steeped
and
his the
mind
in
the
heroic
Stephen
literature
MacKenna
of
claimed
Fionn
Pearse
cycles."20
knew
native
literature
"as
other
men
know
their
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
25
arithmetic,"21 was "He other the and deeply hand, read Father more in recently early Francis was Irish lists of Irish Shaw David Greene wrote that On
"To
Gaelic
judge
past his
by
of
his
the
writings
country
Pearse's
slight
knowledge
rather than was and over his not
of impression
and case
the
pro very over
found.
that wide. again
Certainly
acquaintance He falls uses Shaw to in the is
his
back same on
written
with
work
gives
the
literature names
he While
here, Cycle
it
pearse texts to hardly this the for
is
impossible
refers and that the surprising.
to
a
ignore
very
the
limited
fact
that
of instance in of This the Ulster
in
it is,
his
Ulster is of
writings
possible course, years tales, edited of of
number
trace
early Cycle
of first
many
Eleanor
Hull's
a copy Literature
(1898), translations
The Father Phantom
for
he quotes collected
Chariot Hogan's of
two of Emer,24
quotes of Rosna
the and
from
Edmund
from ree Eugene (1892);26 O'Curry's Cuchulainn and Only Sick-bed 2? from the of translation (1859);"Z7
Ford" section of the Tain in A. H.
the in
Irish
Arthur
writings,
Hutton1"^
apart
verse
from the
translation
those done
when
home itself.31 yses quotations topics pieces lectures
he
with of
was
still
Irish, He was
a
was not
teenager
Pearse attempting rather his to as
just
dealing
beginning
with
to
scholarly references
feel
anal
at
wide
Since many politics. or editorials public newspaper a perhaps deadline with pressing was a notorious procrastinator?he of his for translations not making of It the brief also be should passages noted that
renderings to hand.
he
when could
shown ship,
he went find.
a good and he
he 1900
contemporary with up
looked lecture
the
he had
ob
vious,
Stokes statement ed source"
for
in
example,
An that of
in
his
editorial
Soluis.32 largely reliant for
eulogy
Thus, on of "many
of
Father "the his
Whitley
Shaw's infect romantic
O'Grady
notions
about
early
Ireland"33
is
misleading.
Of
course,
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
26 no one growing
time and epic writers the
up with
could young of
an
have Pearse
interest
avoided was
in
the
the
Irish
influence
past
in
of
Gwynn between
move in
that
he knew own had
he
the book. Of
would
known correct course,
have
the
written
correct sound and
an
sound was
entirely
of thus of the able
different
name."35 to produce mature
book
Pearse his Pearse's
if
the
clearest
proof
the
ability is the
three his was
to fact
scenes
work that
with his
original a play
at of
in
earning written
of the Book of Leinster (henceforth language text German edited with translation by Ernst in his in 1905.36 wrote Pearse published for notes the first of the play publication
magazine great part An of Macaomh: the dialogue "I have from extracted the the Tain,
ising cent
(but phrase
altering of the
for that a
as little original."37
of
as
his
possible) In this
pageant changes the modern
he
the is
with he
magnifi entirely
the made intelli as after the origi we LL were
audience
nal
else
due
I Before
largely
have
to
staging
problems,
the changes
that
he
"For
did
everything
we may
authority."39 investigating
make,
over LL Tain the the ask why he chose version na hUidre and The Ye 1 low Book of Lecan Lebor not LU and YBL).4u too much should Naturally,
this material tically poses. were convenient choice, have crafted The available form for writers Tain of to of him generally LL wishing found the a better the in LU-YBL the original Stories to more text adapt unified for which in from the the Irish
source
sections
Strachan's
na Gaedh i Ige in book in Iri^sleabhar in 190 3 and in Winifred in and in translation 1908) Faraday's the LU-YBL Raid of Cualnge Cattle (1904). However,
of the tale simply did not suit Pearse's purpose,
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
27
parents servant under who Conchobar's to wake couch, too him and early Conchobar his in slaying the from a of morning. a
dared rescue
It field
also
includes and
of
two
of
entire
the wounded
episodes supernatural
twenty-seven
absent foes,
invaders
from
LL:
battle
Cu his
the
Chulainn's defence
his
Ulster
fight
against
with his
and
from
Isles
pearse lainn light unnecessary his
of
thus in or
Faiche.
also a negative, are which venture chosen had "a
With
rejected
rejection
episodes an by crude supernatural. claimed obvious which
of
excessively
the
present
LU-YBL
Cu
Tain
Chu an from One
violent, or
Having original
sufficiently
of such is his of omission of the most striking changes and of the with hound Culann's Cu Chulainn's fight single in the Deeds" section of the episode "Boyhood longest Cu Chulainn's to the border his and Tain, expedition
combats with the sons of Nechtan Scene, although these
fights
scene.42
are
A
referred
"sufficiently
to
in
the might
choral be
wild
song
purpose"
which
for
opens
the
the
omis
sion
and able One not
of
the
these
incidents
of resources
that
the
beasts
combat
were
scenes
unstage ?anna. decision bizarre Pearse's a subur re
could to
perhaps attempt
the command of Scoil at same in the the way explain a presentation of Cu Chulainn's of the the end at appearance episode.43 a bevy women to naked onto send of an lawn of before audience adolescents further are, pageant explanation.44 several however, for which the from are less
changes reasons
the
ciently
First
obvious"
all, when
and
Pearse's
for
which
Cu
he
had
not
arrives
authority.
at
Chulainn
him to take invite the boys freely in their he interferes the LL Tain, in the invitation. Also, original
clearly and of newcomers equals. never adds, against fic. "Da have heard "If I them."45 Having mb'eol, done it.") told dheanfainn But their then has acting chosen under When of had on their he this later the to assumption disregard protection informs the I should Cu ignorance e."46 again, LL their
accepting Chulainn been is the whole invitation from the in Tain and the
geis,
arrogantly on my guard more far paci he geis, says: I would known, business to of
geis
already,
must the
An in
baffle
through
him
since
the
boys
themselves
have
him,
laid
occurs Chulainn
injunction
even the first and more scene takes
aside.
striking of arms. pageant LL the it, original which in notable all Cu
translations
adaptations
with
exception
of
O'Grady's
History
of
Ireland:
The
Heroic
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
28
Period, prophecy Cu Chulainn the accidentally future overhears one Cathbad's who takes and Pearse's arms thus
concerning
fame
of
on
he gains
that
is
day.
The
arms
boy
then
at
disingenuously
instruction In trickery.
tells
Conchobar
pageant,
Cathbad's
through
as
sented ar radh
in
an
O'Grady's
as bhfaiche ar cheana a member
History,
of agus ina Cuchulainn thimpeal
C?
Cathbad's
Chulainn
class: agus l."47 Fol
is
explicitly
"Cafach lun ag agus comes
pre
teacht an mac on it off having purpose the
("Cafach
green
around Conchobar himself overheard
with
Cu
Chulainn
Furthermore, comes to the prophecy, class,
and
where whereas sets
Fol
in Cu off
lun
and
the
other
boys
is by
immediately
ful
Pearse's
ly to
to
win
version
arms
through
Cu
verbal
druid's
trickery.40
has a later right anger
Thus,
to at hear
in
the with
Cathbad's
teaching,
use
Pearse
which
also does
his
not
instruction
Cu
has
been where
put through
and to
is
unjust. trickery
encounter leave
Conall
he value compels
Cernach
Conall
at
?th
to
na
return
Foraire,
to Scoil
the
honorific
on
guard
truthfulness
duty
to
at
himself. live up to
Pearse
and
placed
was
a high oath
the
constantly
urging
"truth
his
on and No text The
students
our lips."
to sources
even of of to the part
the
when
Fenian
he found
of
C?a
Apparently,
Chulainn
simply, incidents.
of
his
perhaps survives Defence
trifling
unconsciously, Pearse's Ford. We
with
the
truth,
he
the
pageant,
the Irish in
of
from
the
action
Sean will O'Casy
in
take
An Claidheamh
this
Soluis49
Worker: pageant.
and
in
hundred
letter
per be
formers
Here
will
on the The shown the of Ulster field. hurling Boy Corps news the march of the body to of Cuchulainn's wounding; scene the defend the frontiers till the Hero recovers; of the men of Ireland the attack their around Camp Fires; by the Boy Corps and final last the of Ulster; act, ly in the
'Battle and of the Ford' between the two calls and such drama What Feardiadh."50 O'Casey An in Claidheamh Soluis,, "parts" an enormous cast with and such was a spectacle rather than a a Heroes, "acts" it is Cuchulainn are called plain action, it may that, this well
have
Chulainn
had
no
set
text
to
or
play
dialogue.
prominent
With by
this
role
pageant,
in Pearse's
Cu the
ceases
writings,
heroes As have gression of a
which
physical result too through
come
of
to
such
be
dominated
politics
and
force
perhaps
ist;
canism late
political
but as 1912; still
activist
believer
moving
address
towards
a
radically
Home blood Rule sacrifice;
Republi
meeting as or,
messianic
to
define
his
development
in
terms
of
his
successive
role
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
29
models: Cu Chulainn, Robert Emmet, Jesus Christ. Pearse
himself wrote
farnham:
gave Scoil
he when in Rath
oftenest
Cullenswood
to our prime,
Robert lainn Emmet Desmond such writings, a
of boys I have
was Emmet our
his to
the
Gaelic of here
Cuchu Robert Yet against in his a stu
but
Pearse: no essential
"Development
at Scoil felt dent ?anna, to the Hermitage, ?anna Sgoil member of the an invisible with moved the Cu Chulainn
and his like had also been
"Cu Chulainn moved with settled down and became if staff."53 Further, to Rathfarnham, Emmet
Ryan describes
Cullenswood.
how,
at Gaelic cle Sarsfield, McHale,
after
Scoil the
passing
?anna, he
the
names
Cu Chulainn
main the heroes, Brian of the of
mural
saints, Tributes, Patrick, mantlepiece
on his
and
first
"where sages Owen a
day
in cir Roe, John pic
entered
classroom,
Davis.
Colmcille, Over
Keating, hangs
ture
Pearse's
child."54 to the
indeed
Christ
to some a
us
assi
to
blasphemous,
milation, fication
"Some lainn The personal less Aspects
that of is most
of
identi lecture
Cuchu God. and power curse,
akin
divine, comes
with
from
them
redeems it.
through
them I do not
his
by his mean
mother
but
through
and Tain his is a
his
own
father
death
conscious
allegory: like is
story one of for
is
and it of the
a of new An
Calvary."55^ Pearse
was
1913,
he first which Macghniomhartha published in he had written all Irish that 1909, the example of Cu Chulainn, do follow "?ir in
sin a he bheatha sul da gcail lfeadh heroic se a
eineach"
("for
honor"),
that
youth
and
lost
had
his
compared
life
before
this
he would
sacrifice
lose fein
sins
fallen
"Christ, capital
Exemplar, nation."5'
in of
urged for
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
30
of the natural main and lobby Christian at Cul lenswood ethics."58 House The may boys have entering been most
impressed by the Cu to not have failed same hai 1 of Christ out arms stretched
must tion religious soon of have stories instruction.6^ noticed of
could Chulainn also but they mural, in the see Beatrice picture Elvery's as a boy, naked and with to the waist and they in the cruciform position,5^
that Cu the time was for Pearse's invariably recita after Chulainn
Gaelic other
tor's was
While Pearse's of 1900 and his "thorough gentleman" seem Messiah of each 1913 and after to resemble are rooted crea if at all, both in their little
lifelong seeking some correct search noble Victorian for a Gaelic worthy model ideal. to assert In 1900 in the Pearse face
of
the
tawdriness if of
around
Dublin
him,
upbringing,
and,
given
one
his
can
stolidly
hardly of the
maturity ceased the a
in terms increasing
idealism as became At
however, to what C?
soullessness symbol
Chulainn
antique
Scoil
"struggle,
?anna
he
was
up
to
the
boys
as
a model
and
for
they
self-sacrifice,
self-discipline,"62
at
the
As
expense
of
despair
fidelity
over
to
the
original
political
text.
and,
Ireland's
importantly, of C? Chulainn
individualistic
her
spiritual underwent
and
servility a further
deepened, transformation.
self-sacrifice
his
view The
of
character-building
of self the messianic became offering pageant of the and the of The Defence people Ford;64 in at and Christ hinted between Cu" Chulainn
writings Indeed, were as eventually early as 1910 asserted Pearse as was a virtual beginning
country"
ing
I
his
pride
them for
in have and
his
any
boys,
great
he
wondered
they
"whether,
rally,
if
ever
as
need
service,
do
... I
of
final an
cess. he had remained his life consistent Throughout he felt ethos of to revive to be the what attempting If his Cu Chulainn heroic changed during period.
literary that career of the native of his and was tales, sources always this on radically was not Pearse's due different a conscious to but
in the his
from
manipulation
part,
rather
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
31 to what standing
Patrick inspiration to him an out As
he of
felt the
from enthusiasm
was real
Cu
Pearse
cultural
live G.P.O. Easter to there.
and
a
literary
of the
past,
then
led
of
him
inexorably
to
myth he read
self-sacrifice well
Monday summon Cu
morning, Chulainn
02664
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
32
NOTES
Patrick
Pearse,
"Gaelic
Prose
Literature"
in
Three
Lectures
on
2Pearse,
Gaelic
"Gaelic "The 35. Dudley
Topics
Prose Intellectual
(Dublin,
Literature,"
1898),
14.
31. of the Gael" in
Three
Future
Edwards,
Patrick
Pearse:
The
Triumph
of
Failure
(London, 5"Gnotha na
5
1977), Gaedhilge"
March
22. ("Irish
7.
Language 7.
Affairs")
in
Fainne
an
Lae,
1898,
6Fainne
an
Lae,
5 March
14 this January lecture eulogistic
1898,
1899, and
Joseph in his
subject,
of
and
which reason listeners....
the
adjectives
he read the It is from stuff this when
he
employed
the so absurd, Sagas praised
to
were
describe
beyond became
the
the known almost
his
unmeaning,
fanatical
language
praise
left to
that
us so
makes
unbearable
the
few
and
lovers
impractical
of
the
to
Irish
all
Cited from
Holloway's Journal
Robert Hogan
Abbey "im
and
Playgoer,
Michael
J.
C^Neill 89.
(Carbondale,
1967),
4).
8Edwards,
An
A Significant
o f P^
Irish
?U Pearse,
The
Educa
la
Writings
S?amas
Bu a chai
(Dublin,
1980),
101-17;
"Seanm?ir"
280-99.
("A Sermon") in An Claidheamh
27 October Soluis, 1906, are tions in this paper the text and are followed
12Pearse, "Our Heritage
11Pearse,
Irish All 3. quota language in in the original Irish given translation. by the English
of Chivalry" in An Claidhe
amh Soluis,
14 November
1908,
9.
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
33 13?esmond 14Padhraic
("Memories of St.
Ryan, 6g Pear
letter
Remembering 6 Conaire,
in
Sion
(London, Scoil
bPiarsach
1934),
97.
"Cuimhn?
Cuimhn? na
?anna"
(Memo
Enda's")
ries
5. concert;
of
This
the
booklet the
ses),
was from
Cu id
issued
3
for
(Baile
an Pearse
Xtha
annual at
Cliath,
Pearse the
n.d.),
memorial beginning
Margaret
of
the
text
is
dated
The Col
11 January
of a
1958.
Success Padraie 1-2. in St. H. Enda's Pearse, and ed.
Its Desmond
Story leeted
Works~of n.d.),
(Dublin, Story of of of of
a a a a
1919), Piarais
is Three no
Man Ca 11 ed The 20Desmond (Dublin, Ryan, Pearse^ Mac See Seamas also 30. 6 Searcaigh, P?draig 53. ?tha (Baile Cliath, 1938), 38, "?~Searcaigh
doubt Lectures: unconscious "Nocht of se his smaointe irony ... when n?r he writes of a cluineadh
leith?id never
("He revealed
thoughts of the
of
(Stephen
19.
MacKenna),
See also
Memories
the comments
Dead
(Dublin,
Pearse's Pearse
in The Press in
1972),
Francis
Shaw,
"The
Canon
of
Irish
History:
A Reappraisal,"
24See Pearse,
Studies
The
(Summer
of
1972),
a Success,
130.
22, 34; and
Story 14 An Claidheamh "Our Heritage of Soluis, Chivalry, of Emer November The translation of The Wooing 9. 1908, in Hull found is that of Kuno Meyer published originally in the Review Archaeological (1888). 25See Pearse, The Phantom Story of a Success, which first 35; and "Our
Heritage
translation
of
Chi valry7r
of The
9.
Hull
Chariot,
uses
J. ?'?eirne and
Crowe's
appeared
of the Ireland
Archaeological
Pearse,
"Gaelic
Literature,"
15.
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
34
27See Pearse, "Some Aspects of lecture Irish Literature" in
Songs
Pearse,
of tale
to
the
134-35.
Irish
In Emer
Rebels,
this sends
Collected
same
Works
Pearse
of
Padraic
refers
H.
to
the
woman
of
whom
Cu Chulainn's the
Pearse,
death
C?
and (135).
incorrectly
for protection
calls
the
Fann
Chulainn
instead
2?See and
of
correct
"From
Niamh
a
ings 158-59.
Speeches,
Collected
Hermitage" Works
in of
Political Padraic
Writ Pearse,
"Gaelic "Our 6
Prose
15-16.
Heritage
Buachalla, in Sgoil
that have
twice,
"l?rs. on rolls
and
it a third Pearse reviewed time" (87). on in An Claidheamh Soluis favorably was he himself time, however, By this tale in the original. 31 The
Aspects confuses See note of
single
Irish names above. in
exception
Literature." this lecture,
is
the
Oddly a
1913
sure
"Some
also haste.
27
"Whitley 9. 130.
Stokes"
in
An Claidheamh
Soluis,
writes whom
of
obvious
picture have
in Ireland. early schooling of Cuchulainn Coming (London, a The of 32-34. Success, Story 35Dennis Gwynn, Edward Martyn
1894),
49-50,
and
the
Irish
Revival
(London, Cattle
1 930),
of the in Ryan
could
159-60.
se,
"By
Way
of
Comment"
in
An
Macaomh
1.1
(Midsummer
19 09):15.
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
35
3?For example, when Cathbad gives Setanta his new n-ainm anmuin ?ireann ?ireann identical will and
name
edition): sin, sin." agus
C?
ocus Pearse Alban
Chulainn,
"Con bat an cechlabat lana renders t-ainm den and
he
be?il this
says
fir fer
in
n?rend h?rend
the
LL
ocus ocus "Cluinfidh
Tain
Alban Alban b?il
(Windisch's
inn don fir fear is Scotland
beidh
the
Ireland
Scotland
will
be
full
of
that
name." 15.
mural LL Tain. at Cull ens
39Pearse,
4?The House motto was
"By
Way of
the wording
Comment,"
Cu Chulainn of the
under in the
wood
41
Pearse,
"By
Way of
Comment,"
Deeds Padraig
Pearse), 150.
Chuchulainn Macghn?omhartha 42Pearse, in Na Scr?bhinn? of: Cu Chulainn) Mac Piarais (The Literary Writings
ed. Seamas "? Buachalla (Corcaigh,
distorted
head, in a not
Cu Chulainn
and river 155). his of a his so face he
thus:
was quaked
"His
fearful and
eyes
to trembled" even is he of had
blazed
look more on
terribly
upon. Like (The Coming revisionist: him, but [London,
in
a of the
Muirthemne
1902;
refers
Colin
to the
Smythe
edh.,
as
1973],
"a sort
169).
of
Pearse
Berserker
himself
rage"
("From
44 O'Grady
Hermitagerr~in
Pearse's women
Political
reticence order crossed 159). the
Writings,
is men not to their ish to troop Mrs. in out Hutton her
158).
unique retire, here. after
Again has
the
which
exposed Coming
they
of
go
to
and
meet
hands
Cu Chulainn
on Stand
"in
lowly
Hayes
wise,
breasts"
with
(The O'Grady
bosoms
Cuchulainn,
lapses
his and women without
into
virtual
"reduce
incomprehensibility
themselves of Saga, womelvs any critically kind
at
this
to meet omits rendering
point;
garb, him" all of
nature's
153). nakedness
C?cile
45 Ta in Bo ?^ahilly 46Pearse,
Cualnge, (Dulbin,
ed.
from 1967),
of
Leinster
by
Macghn?omhartha
Ch?chulainn,
145.
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
36
Pearse, Macghn?omhartha Ch?chulainn, 150-51.
48Pearse,
de Ver? presents
Macghn?omhartha
a garbled version
Ch?chulainn,
of to arm this
151.
incident
Aubrey
in
H?1?.
K9.L?L1. 9.L
??a?H
by
??eave
Cathbad
1882),
a new
in
Conchobar,
urged
"knight,"
after
denied
of
the
Ford"
in
An
Claidheamh
So
luis,
31 May 50"To
1 91 3,
9. Worker," 7 June
ed. David
Irish
1913,
Krause
The was
Letters
(New York,
of in
in An
Sean
O'Casey
1 910-1941,
1975),
just one
78.
Apparently
hour. See
all
"Touching
this
the
action
St.
completed
Fete"
Enda's
Macaomh
51
2.2(May
Pearse, The of ideas change."
1913):46.
Story Man Pearse: underwent See of a Success, Pearse, was an a process 53-54. 10. Eavan Boland rather in Dublin
Called ^He
consistent
"Aspects
Magazine
53Ryan,
5.1 (Spring
The Man
1966):49.
Called Pearse, Sion, Emmet list at of 95. here. the 83. Ryan Domhnaill names he See has saw An
Remembering 54Ryan, omitted unintentionally in includes his Emmet's in the main classroom
Ua
Cullenswood
House.
Claidheamh
55Pearse,
Soluis, Irish
S?amus
12 September
"Some ? he in Aspects Grianna
1908,
of Irish
3.
Literature" in
Songs
Pearse,
of by
the
156.
Rebels,
Collected
("M?ire")
Works
was
of ar
Padraic thuig
1933),
H. se
See
particularly
taken
Cuchulainn." "Padraig 124.
this
Mac
idea,
("How Piarais"
exclaiming
understood Feara Fail
"An
Cu
d?igh
(Dun
Chulainn.") Dealgan,
56 Pear 1.1:5-6.
se,
"Reamhsg?al"
("Preface")
in
An
Macaomh
57Pearse,
"A
Christmas
Sermon"
in
An
Claidheamh
Soluis
23,
58Pearse,
December
"'Seoda
1905,
na
7.
Sean' and Some Reflections" in
An Claidheamh 59Padhraic
A reproduction
Soluis, ?g
of
12 May ? Conaire,
1906,
7. Scoil
several
"Cuimhn?
along with
?anna,"
photo
6.
this
painting
graphs
of
Scoil
?anna,
including
some
from
the
pageants,
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
37
can be seen in Searnas ? Buachal la's P?draig Mac Piarais
(Patrick 1979),
to the of
Pearse 39-64.
Ireland of enough,
picture An Claidhe was
amh
Soluis,
60Desmond
23 August
Ryan, by Ryan slightly from
1913,
The after An Story
9.
of a Success, of 90. the "By the In this first of Way final
Pearse's revised
Macaomh,
chapter
is
61Pearse, 62Pearse, 63pearse, 640ne
by
Ryan.
Story Story Story of of of also is central a a a note Success, Success, Success, that in the Pearse's 63. 36. 7. theme play of messianic An R? (The
should
self-sacrifice
of on the first students grounds presented by his in The more strikingly in June and even ?anna 1912, life written in 1915 but never in his produced
Pearse Irish-language also wrote Passion what was Play apparently was which a staged very at
Week of No text of this 1911. Holy play a fairly can be found in detailed synopsis 8 April Soluis for 1911.
The Pearse's Dennis Story of a Success, of perhaps at Scoil 69-70. students Pearse's ?anna, The is most stated entire una aca of
his
successful
Pearse
myself, less
after
three consciously,
1914:
years
"Even
earlier, and with
before
he the to educate to The one idea had
had
left
the
begun that
school
more he the or was idea in a
a sacred performing duty, that forward must look they war of Irish independence.
in
part logically
grown
enough
begun."
out
See
of
the
"Patrick
interesting
1923, Pearse," 95-96. has Sion, that "I like the a boys...." he do
programme
Dublin
with
which
he
had
prize
pupils,
Review, Desmond Ryan, Yet, refuted explicitly 118 ever not and tried mean But 161). to that or a he added: must
political
revolutionary "We
allowed
hoards in service, up
them
life and
to
too
feel
withal
that
joyous,
no
one
that
can
one
finely
be even
live
generous supreme
who
jealously;
accounting
sacrifices November
a Success, a body
78). Na of
On 28 Fianna
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
38
?ireann at Scoil ?anna, whose officers included John
the brother of the C? Chu Dowling, boy who had played in Macghniomhartha lainn Ch?chulainn 2.3 (An Macaomh were on the Fianna exercises [sic] [Christmas 1910]:79). of the Scoil fete of at which ?anna The Defence programme was the Ford 191 3]: 46). (An Macaomh performed 2.2[May
Indeed, ... later Sion, his ism, of among heroes" to share the cast of the along fate never of pageant in was "a whole Colbert," Remembering recruited Republican unaware of army brought Pearse's he While for can the bold "the by 1916 (Ryan, have actively force have been
may cause
physical hardly
nevertheless
the
school
influence
and of
on
his
them
own
of
the
pervasive
personality.
philosophy
His
of
dream,
the on
(see of A
forceful
shared
the Story the
by
a
him
with
for
his
Ireland
students,
is, who of
of
course, and he served
a Scoil
well was in Patrick
?anna
known deeply the
body
proud
gallows of Scoil
Success, Sanna
76-77); students
Rising.
list
ing
of
can
the
be
Scoil
found
?anna
in Louis
boys
Le
who
Roux,
took 372.
part
in
the
H?_
fight
Pearse,
trans.
Desmond
66Joseph and not from
Ryan
Lee his has
(Dublin,
said of
1932),
Pearse: spring expediency"
was
an
honest
thinker, sion,
non-sequiturs idealogical
of
Pearse
Irish
was
Society
quick of figures
1848-1918
to criticize from the
[Dublin,
what early he
1973],
saw literature as
148).
a in Strand' 'seadh Cuchulainn, Hamlet
Indeed,
misunder modern
standing
adaptations.
"Innistear chur nil os de ?r locht
In
dhuinn gcomhair againn cheapann do
19 05 he
go bhfuil ar?s. air an r?ir
wrote
Drama acht gur
in
'On
An Claidheamh
Baile's an-?luinn cosmhala ?, na le
Soluis:
le ? 'na e n-a seo: do le (An
sean-Ghaedhil
Claidheamh in English:
presented no fault
Soluis, ''we're
again. with This it
reads to be
find author
except
conceives
lainn In as the the
of
him
ancient following
is
more
Gaels year,
like
Hamlet
of
than
him." commented
like
on
C? Chu
Yeats1s
think review
Deirdre by interesting:
essay we the lose
An t-Athair "Perhaps
old more theme. and As more
Tom?s it is
we of
are for
away crea
breathed Soluis,
clay, 1909,
making 9).
This content downloaded from 131.247.201.91 on Wed, 21 Aug 2013 11:20:10 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions