Revolution would be considered "liberal nobles." Theywished to see an end to royal absolutism but not necessarilythe end of the monarchy. These liberal nobles tended to look to France's traditional enemy, England, as a model for whatFrance ought to become, a limited or constitutional monarchy.
C.The Third Estate
The Third Estate consisted of the commoners. It includedthe bourgeoisie, peasants and city workers. The bourgeoisie,or the middle class, were by far, the wealthiest. In the bourgeoisie, there were the merchants and manufacturers,lawyers, doctors and others similar to those types of professions. Peasants made up the largest group within theThird Estate. They were forced to pay hefty taxes, tithes tothe church, and rents to their landlords for the land that theylived on. The last group within the Third Estate was the cityworkers. They were servants, apprentices, and householdmaids.As a class, the bourgeoisie - merchants, manufacturers, bankers, doctors, lawyers, intellectuals - had wealth; in somecases, enormous wealth. But, wealth in the
Ancien regime
didnot mean status or privilege and it should be clear by nowthat "success" in 18th century France meant status and privilege. Wealth was nothing without status. The bourgeoisiewere influenced by the nobility and tried to imitate themwhenever possible. So, they tried to improve their status by becoming land owners themselves. By 1789, the bourgeoisiecontrolled 20% of all the land. They were upwardly mobile, but they felt frustrated and blocked by the aristocracy, anaristocracy whose only interest was that everyone maintaintheir place in society.By 1789, the bourgeoisie had numerous grievances theywished addressed. They wanted all Church, army andgovernment positions open to men of talent and merit. Theysought a Parlement that would make all the laws for thenation. They desired a constitution that would limit the king's powers. They also desired fair trials, religious toleration andvast administrative reforms. These are all liberal ideas thatwould certainly emerge after the summer of 1789.The peasantry consisted of at least twenty-one millionindividuals during the 18th century. Their standard of livingwas perhaps better than the European peasantry in general.However, the French peasant continued to live in utmost poverty. Collectively, the peasantry owned 30-40% of theavailable land but mostly in small, semi-feudal plots. Most peasants did not own their land but rented it from those peasants who were wealthier or from the nobility. They triedto supplement their income by hiring themselves out as daylaborers, textile workers or manual laborers. Peasants werevictimized by heavy taxation - taxes were necessary to payfor the costs of war, something that had already consumed theFrench government for an entire century. So, the peasants paid taxes to the king, taxes to the church, taxes and dues tothe lord of the manor, as well as numerous indirect taxes onwine, salt, and bread. Furthermore, the peasants also owedtheir lord a labor obligation. And throughout the 18th century,the price of rent was always increasing, as did the dutieslevied on goods sold in markets and fairs. By 1789, the plightof the French peasant was obvious. Taxes were increased aswas rent. Peasants continued to use antiquated methods of agriculture. The price of bread soared and overall, pricescontinued to rise at a quicker rate than wages. To makematters worse, there was the poor harvest of 1788/89. Theurban workers or artisans, as a group, consisted of all journeymen, factory workers and wage earners. The urban poor also lived in poverty, a poverty that was intensified by1789. By that time, wages had increased by 22% while thecost of living increased 62%. The major cause of theRevolution was the differences these three groups had.However, there was another important factor during thesetimes. France suffered from harsh economic problems. Poor farm harvests by farmers hurt the economy, and trade rulesfrom the Middle Ages still survived, making trade difficult.However, the most serious problem was the problem facingthe government during this time. The French government borrowed much money to pay for the wars of Louis XIV.Louis still borrowed money to fight wars and to keep French power alive in Europe. These costs greatly increased thenational debt, which was, at the time, already too high.
Political disorder:
Politics itself was another major cause of the revolution.The political institutions were so bound up with social andfiscal privilege that reform was a dangerous enterprise likelyto arouse fierce opposition. A divided political elite whosefactional maneuvers undermined reform, was closelyidentified with the monarchy. The king and queen badlymismanaged the situation, along with their ministers. TheParlements resisted reform on the grounds that it was adespotic extension of central government, and the ParisParlement blocked loans that might have seen the monarchythrough without major reform. Once reform was attemptedfrom 1787, the political crisis snowballed, until cries for theEstates General to meet, as the only body competent to doroot and branch reform, were too loud to resist. The ministryhad no choice but to capitulate to these calls as the financialcrisis was so severe that there was no further room for maneuver. The electoral process in early 1789 certainlyhelped to politicize the lower orders, if only in an elemental3
Fig.2. This graph shows the percentage of the total population, total landowned and income paid in taxes by the Three Estates in France in 1789.
Add a Comment
Kay Jayleft a comment