Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.

Language:

Download

Go BackAdd Note

Link

Embed

Save for later

;

"So`~ E~`j`ej)

EC]EDFT ]FTA/ 4>>2Spookdvs

JE]F7 Ybftf `} `s lfks`dof/ k spookdvs "bfkmje}f) yòo df tfofksfm/ ks `sdf`ji mejf `j cejjfc}èj y`}b }b`s cksf/ k} }bf }àf }bf e~`jèj `s `ssvfm*]bf spookdvs cejs}`}v}fs je ~kt} el }bf e~`jèj el }bf Cevt} dv} bks dffj~tf~ktfm dp }bf Tf~et}ft el Mfc`sèjs let }bf cej|fj`fjcf el }bf tfkmft*Sff

Vj`}fm S}k}fs

Mf}te`} ]`adft , Ovadft Ce*/

4>> V* S* 34;/ 339*

SV^TFAF CEVT] EL ]BF VJ@]FM S]K]FS

Spookdvs

T@CC@

F] KO

* M

S]FLKJE

F] KO

CFT]@ETKT@ ]E ]BF VJ@]FM S]K]FS CEVT] EL K^^FKOS LET]BF SFCEJM C@TCV@]Je* >9–;=42* Ktivfm K~tò 44/ 4>>0”Mfc`mfm Gvjf 40/ 4>>0'Jfy Bk|fj/ Cejj* "C`}p)/ vsfs edgfc}`|f frka`jk}èjs }e `mfj}`lp }besfl`tflìb}fts dfs} {vko`l`fm let ~teae}èj* Ybfj }bf tfsvo}s el svcb kjfrka }e lòo |kckj} o`fv}fjkj} kjm ck~}k`j ~es`}èjs sbeyfm }bk}yb`}f ckjm`mk}fs bkm ev}~ftletafm a`jet`}p ckjm`mk}fs/ k tkjcetevs~vdo`c mfdk}f fjsvfm* Cejltej}fm y`}b ktivafj}s de}b let kjmkik`js} cft}`lp`ji }bf }fs} tfsvo}s”kjm }btfk}s el k okysv`} f`}bftykp”}bf C`}p }btfy ev} }bf tfsvo}s dksfm ej }bf s}k}`s}`cko tkc`kom`s~kt`}p* ^f}`}èjfts/ yb`}f kjm B`s~kj`c l`tflìb}fts ybe ~kssfm}bf frkas dv} yftf mfj`fm k cbkjcf k} ~teae}èjs dp }bf C`}p‐s tf!lvsko }e cft}`lp }bf }fs} tfsvo}s/ svfm }bf C`}p kjm tfs~ejmfj} ell`c`kos/koofi`ji }bk} m`scktm`ji }bf }fs} tfsvo}s m`sctà`jk}fm kik`js} }bfadksfm ej }bf`t tkcf `j |èok}èj el/

`j}ft ko`k/

]`}of \@@ el }bf C`|òTìb}s Kc} el ;0<=* ]bf mflfjmkj}s tfs~ejmfm }bk} bkm }bfp cft}`l`fm}bf }fs} tfsvo}s/ }bfp cevom bk|f lkcfm ]`}of \@@ o`kdò`}p let kme~}`jik ~tkc}`cf bk|`ji k m`s~ktk}f à~kc} ej a`jet`}p l`tflìb}fts* ]bfM`s}t`c} Cevt} itkj}fm svaaktp gvmiafj} let }bf mflfjmkj}s/ kjm}bf Sfcejm C`tcv`} kll`tafm*

Bfom7

]bf C`}p‐s kc}èj `j m`scktm`ji }bf }fs}s |èok}fm ]`}of \@@*^~* ;<–3=*"k) ]`}of \@@ ~teb`d`}s `j}fj}èjko kc}s el fa~oepafj} m`sctà`jk!}èj dksfm ej tkcf/ ceoet/ tfoìèj/ sfr/ kjm jk}èjko etì`j/ =4 V* S* C*©4>>>f–4"k)";) "m`s~ktk}f }tfk}afj})/ ks yfoo ks ~eo`c`fs et ~tkc}`cfs}bk} ktf je} `j}fjmfm }e m`sctà`jk}f dv} `j lkc} bk|f k m`s~te~et!}èjk}fop km|ftsf fllfc} ej a`jet`}`fs/ ©4>>>f–4"h)";)"K)"`) "m`s~ktk}fà~kc})* Ejcf k ~ok`j}`ll bks fs}kdo`sbfm k ~tàk lkc`f cksf el m`s~k! ”””””” ']eif}bft y`}b Je* >2–342/

T`cc` f} ko*

MfS}flkje f} ko*/

kose ejcft}`etkt` }e }bf skaf cevt}*

4 T@CC@

S]FLKJESpookdvstk}f à~kc}/ }bf fa~oepft akp mflfjm dp mfaejs}tk}`ji }bk} `}s~eo`cp et ~tkc}`cf `s ‟ged tfok}fm let }bf ~es`}èj `j {vfs}èj kjm cej!s`s}fj} y`}b dvs`jfss jfcfss`}p*‑

@d`m*

@l }bf fa~oepft aff}s }bk}dvtmfj/ }bf ~ok`j}`ll akp s}òo svccffm dp sbey`ji }bk} }bf fa~oepfttflvsfs }e kme~} kj k|kòkdof ko}ftjk}`|f ~tkc}`cf }bk} bks ofss m`s~k!tk}f à~kc} kjm sft|fs }bf fa~oepft‐s ofi`}àk}f jffms* ©©4>>>f– 4"h)";)"K)"``) kjm "C)* ^~* ;9–;0*"d) Vjmft ]`}of \@@/ dfletf kj fa~oepft ckj fjikif `j `j}fj}èjkom`sctà`jk}èj let }bf kssft}fm ~vt~esf el k|e`m`ji et tfafmp`ji kjvj`j}fj}èjko/ m`s~ktk}f à~kc}/ }bf fa~oepft avs} bk|f k s}tejidks`s `j f|`mfjcf }e dfo`f|f `} yòo df svdgfc} }e m`s~ktk}f!à~kc} o`!kdò`}p `l `} lkòs }e }khf }bf tkcf!cejscèvs/ m`sctà`jk}etp kc}èj*]bf Cevt}‐s kjkops`s dfi`js y`}b }bf ~tfa`sf }bk} }bf C`}p‐s kc}èjsyevom |èok}f ]`}of \@@‐s m`s~ktk}f!}tfk}afj} ~teb`d`}èj kdsfj} seaf|ko`m mflfjsf* Koo }bf f|`mfjcf mfaejs}tk}fs }bk} }bf C`}p tfgfc}fm}bf }fs} tfsvo}s dfckvsf }bf bìbft scet`ji ckjm`mk}fs yftf yb`}f*Y`}bev} seaf e}bft gvs}`l`ck}èj/ }b`s fr~tfss/ tkcf!dksfm mfc`sèj!akh`ji `s ~teb`d`}fm* ]bf {vfs}èj/ }bftfletf/ `s ybf}bft }bf ~vt!~esf }e k|e`m m`s~ktk}f!à~kc} o`kdò`}p frcvsfs ybk} e}bfty`sf yevomdf ~teb`d`}fm m`s~ktk}f!}tfk}afj} m`sctà`jk}èj* ]bf Cevt} bkscejs`mftfm cksfs sàòkt }e }bf ~tfsfj} o`}ìk}èj/ dv} `j }bf cej}fr}el }bf Levt}ffj}b Kafjmafj}‐s F{vko ^te}fc}èj Cokvsf* Svcb cksfsckj ~te|`mf bfo~lvo iv`mkjcf `j }b`s s}k}v}etp cej}fr}* Sff

Yk}sej

Let} Yet}b Dkjh , ]tvs}

/ =29 V* S* 099/ 003* @j }besf cksfs/ }bfCevt} bfom }bk} cft}k`j ie|ftjafj} kc}èjs }e tfafmp ~ks} tkc`ko m`s!ctà`jk}èj”kc}èjs }bk} ktf }bfasfo|fs dksfm ej tkcf”ktf cejs}`!}v}èjko ejop ybftf }bftf `s k ‟s}teji dks`s `j f|`mfjcf‑ }bk} }bf tf!afm`ko kc}èjs yftf jfcfssktp*

T`cbaejm

G* K* Ctesej Ce*

/ =22V* S* =<0/ 6>>8 sff kose

Ypikj}

Gkchsej Dm* el Fm*

/ =9< V* S* 4<9/499* @j kjjevjc`ji }bf s}teji!dks`s!`j!f|`mfjcf s}kjmktm/ }bf

Yp! ikj}

~ovtko`}p tfceij`wfm }bf }fjsèj df}yffj foà`jk}`ji sfitfik!}èj kjm m`sctà`jk}èj ej }bf ejf bkjm kjm me`ji kykp y`}b koo ie|!ftjafj}koop à~esfm m`sctà`jk}èj dksfm ej tkcf ej }bf e}bft* =9<V* S*/ k} 499* @} tfksejfm }bk} ‟XfQ|`mfj}`ktp sv~~et} let }bf cejcov!sèj }bk} tfafm`ko kc}èj `s ykttkj}fm dfceafs ctvc`ko ybfj }bf tf!afm`ko ~teitka `s cbkoofjifm `j cevt} dp jeja`jet`}p fa~oepffs*‑

@d`m*

]bf skaf `j}ftfs}s ktf k} yeth `j }bf `j}ft~okp df}yffj ]`}of \@@‐s m`s~ktk}f!}tfk}afj} kjm m`s~ktk}f!à~kc} ~te|`sèjs* K~~op!`ji }bf s}teji!dks`s!`j!f|`mfjcf s}kjmktm }e ]`}of \@@ i`|fs fllfc} }ede}b ~te|`sèjs/ kooey`ji |èok}èjs el ejf `j }bf jkaf el cea~o`kjcfy`}b }bf e}bft ejop `j cft}k`j/ jkttey c`tcvas}kjcfs* @} kose kooeys}bf m`s~ktk}f!à~kc} ~teb`d`}èj }e yeth `j k akjjft }bk} `s cejs`s!}fj} y`}b e}bft ]`}of \@@ ~te|`sèjs/ `jcovm`ji }bf ~teb`d`}èj ej km! gvs}`ji fa~oepafj}!tfok}fm }fs} scetfs dksfm ej tkcf/ sff ©4>>>f–

Cevt}fsp el Gevtjko Hfj}vchp Ofr`ji}ej Aej`}etyyy*GHOA*vsCeaafj} et if} ltff meyjoekmsGevtjko Hfj}vchp Ofr`ji}ej Aej`}etkose ej Sct`dm*

Ltff meyjoekm ellfts akp fjmy`}bev} je}`cf*

3C`}f ks7 669 V* S* UUUU "4>>0)Spookdvs4"

)/ kjm }bf sfc}èj }bk} fr~tfssop ~te}fc}s dejk l`mf ~teae}èjko fr!kas/ sff ©4>>>f–4"b)* ]bvs/ }bf Cevt} kme~}s }bf s}teji!dks`s!`j!f|`mfjcf s}kjmktm ks k ak}}ft el s}k}v}etp cejs}tvc}èj `j etmft }etfseo|f kjp cejlo`c} df}yffj ]`}of \@@‐s m`s~ktk}f!}tfk}afj} kjm m`s!~ktk}f!à~kc} ~te|`sèjs* ^~* ;0–4<*"c) ]bf C`}p‐s tkcf!dksfm tfgfc}èj el }bf }fs} tfsvo}s ckjje} sk}`slp}bf s}teji!dks`s!`j!f|`mfjcf s}kjmktm* ^~* 4<–3=*"`) ]bf tkc`ko km|ftsf à~kc} `j }b`s o`}ìk}èj yks sìj`l`ckj}/kjm ~f}`}èjfts me je} m`s~v}f }bk} }bf C`}p yks lkcfm y`}b k ~tàklkc`f cksf el m`s~ktk}f!à~kc} o`kdò`}p* ]bf ~tedofa let tfs~ejmfj}s`s }bk} svcb k ~tàk lkc`f cksf”fssfj}`koop/ k }btfsbeom sbey`ji el ksìj`l`ckj} s}k}`s}`cko m`s~kt`}p/

Cejjfc}`cv}

]fko

/ =69 V* S* ==>/==</ kjm je}b`ji aetf”`s lkt ltea k s}teji dks`s `j f|`mfjcf }bk}}bf C`}p yevom bk|f dffj o`kdof vjmft ]`}of \@@ bkm `} cft}`l`fm }bf}fs} tfsvo}s* ]bk} `s dfckvsf }bf C`}p cevom df o`kdof let m`s~ktk}f!à~kc} m`sctà`jk}èj ejop `l }bf frkas k} `ssvf yftf je} ged tfok}fmkjm cejs`s}fj} y`}b dvs`jfss jfcfss`}p/ et `l }bftf fr`s}fm kj f{vkoop|ko`m/ ofss m`sctà`jk}etp ko}ftjk}`|f }bk} sft|fm }bf C`}p‐s jffms dv}}bk} }bf C`}p tflvsfm }e kme~}* ©©4>>>f–4"h)";)"K)/ "C)* Dksfm ej }bftfcetm }bf ~kt}`fs mf|foe~fm }btevib m`sce|ftp/ }bftf `s je svds}kj!}`ko dks`s `j f|`mfjcf }bk} }bf }fs} yks mfl`c`fj} `j f`}bft tfs~fc}*^~* 4<–42*"``) ]bf C`}p‐s kssft}èjs }bk} }bf frkas k} `ssvf yftf je} ged tf!ok}fm kjm cejs`s}fj} y`}b dvs`jfss jfcfss`}p ktf dok}kj}op cej}tk!m`c}fm dp }bf tfcetm/ yb`cb mfaejs}tk}fs }bf mf}kòfm s}f~s }khfj }emf|foe~ kjm kma`j`s}ft }bf }fs}s kjm }bf ~k`js}kh`ji kjkopsfs el }bf{vfs}èjs kshfm }e kssvtf }bf`t tfof|kjcf }e }bf ck~}k`j kjm o`fv}fj!kj} ~es`}èjs* ]bf }fs}àejp kose sbeys }bk} cea~ok`j}s }bk} cft}k`jfrka`jk}èj {vfs}èjs yftf cej}tkm`c}etp et m`m je} s~fc`l`ckoop k~!~op }e l`tflìb}`ji ~tkc}`cfs `j }bf C`}p yftf lvoop kmmtfssfm/ kjm }bk}}bf C`}p }vtjfm k do`jm fpf }e f|`mfjcf sv~~et}`ji }bf frkas‐ |ko`m!`}p* ^~* 42–40*"```) Tfs~ejmfj}s kose okch k s}teji dks`s `j f|`mfjcf sbey`ji kjf{vkoop |ko`m/ ofss m`sctà`jk}etp }fs}`ji ko}ftjk}`|f }bk} }bf C`}p/ dpcft}`lp`ji }bf }fs} tfsvo}s/ yevom jfcfssktòp bk|f tflvsfm }e kme~}*Tfs~ejmfj}s‐ }btff ktivafj}s }e }bf cej}tktp koo lkò* L`ts}/ tfs~ej!mfj}s tflft }e }fs}àejp }bk} k m`llftfj} cea~es`}f!scetf ckocvok}èjyevom bk|f kooeyfm }bf C`}p }e cejs`mft dokch ckjm`mk}fs let }bfj!e~fj ~es`}èjs/ dv} }bfp bk|f ~temvcfm je f|`mfjcf }e sbey }bk} }bfckjm`mk}f yfìb}`ji kc}vkoop vsfm yks `jmffm ktd`}tktp/ et }bk} }bfm`llftfj} yfìb}`ji yevom df kj f{vkoop |ko`m ykp }e mf}fta`jfybf}bft ckjm`mk}fs ktf {vko`l`fm let ~teae}èjs* Sfcejm/ tfs~ej!mfj}s ktivf }bk} }bf C`}p cevom bk|f kme~}fm k m`llftfj} `j}ft~tf}k!}èj el `}s cbkt}ft ~te|`sèj oà`}`ji ~teae}èjs }e }bf bìbfs} scet`ji

Ricci et al. v. Destefano et al., Case No. 07-1428 U.S. Supreme Court Slip Opinion Full Text

New Haven, Connecticut reverse discrimination case. Official full text of U.S. Supreme Court opinion reversing 5 to 4 in favor of white applicant.

Landmark case also reverses the Court of Appeals vote of Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor.

Download or Print

Add To Collection

1.8K

Reads

Readcasts

Embed Views

Published by

Journal Kentucky Lexin...

Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.

See Premium Plans

Info and Rating

Category:	Government Docs
Rating:	5.0 (1 Rating)
Upload Date:	06/29/2009
Copyright:	Attribution No Derivatives
Tags:	Test and of have an New City to action debate threats Civil United s rights the for (more tags) Test and of have an New City to action debate threats Civil United s rights the for text In A with On At who Opinion States by full April June race 4 out practice When That et al 5 exams No Second promotion Summary exam tests Circuit positions Sonia act white Official reverse connecticut Supreme case Landmark based court Vote Impact candidates Best liability haven hispanic uses v 22 against u VII title racial discrimination lawsuit vs FILL had results Appeals Statistical 29 favor promotions chance such Officials their Identify but judgment also They 1964 captain qualified having examinations Arguments Ricci violation district objective were both showed city’s could threw slip Certiorari disparate faced certifying vacant minority firefighters Held denied 2009 disparity inter granted respondent refusal reversing defendants Applicant decided reverses responded argued sued Nominee violated ensued confronted lieutenant destefano alia sotomayor affirmed certify discarding 07–1428 071428 conn thosefirefighters thatwhite outperformed rancorouspublic results—and eitherway petitioners passedthe alleging discriminated thembased certifiedthe adoptinga andthe (fewer)

Free download as PDF File (.pdf) or readfalse online for free.

Flag for inappropriate content

Download and print this document

Read offline in your PDF viewer
Edit this document in Adobe Acrobat
Keep a copy in case this version is deleted from Scribd
Read and print without ads
Email the file

Choose a format to download in

Download

Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.

See Premium Plans

Ricci et al. v. Destefano et al., Case No. 07-1428 U.S. Supreme Court Slip Opinion Full Text

Info and Rating

Download and print this document

Choose a format to download in

Choose a format to download in

Download and print this document

Choose a format to download in

More From This User

Other login options

Why Sign Up?

Login Successful

Sign Up Successful