The Population Issue: Marx Vs.Malthus
Revised version of a paper presented at the Pacific Sociological Association Meeting inHonolulu, April 1971 published in DEN NY VERDEN (Journal of the Institute for Development Research), Copenhagen, Denmark, December 1973.It has currently become fashionable to argue that excessive population growth stands inthe way of economic growth and that underdeveloped countries should take measures toreduce their rates of natural increase. Population growth appears today as the major factor determining underdevelopment and population control is advocated as the mosturgent and necessary step if development is to be eventually achieved.Within the context of the developed countries it is argued that their pressing problemssuch as urban blight, crime, pollution, environmental deterioration, etc. would havegreater possibilities of being satisfactorily solved if population growth were to becurtailed.From a Marxist viewpoint, such "self-evident truths" are but reifications of concretehistorical, social, political, and economic relations, which should be taken into account if the population issue is to be at all understood. Just as in the 18th century the Englishruling classes fought the impact of the French Revolution with military and ideologicalweapons among which Malthus' "Essay on Population" was perhaps the most important,today the ruling classes are bringing back the Malthusian argument in an effort toincrease their control over the growing number of the dispossessed. Like Malthus,contemporary socio-economic theorists view excessive population rather than socialinstitutions and social relations as the main source and barrier to the solution of social problems. It is, therefore, necessary to show light on the Marxist critique and a Marxistalternative to the Malthusian and Neo-Malthusian approaches to the study of population.
The Malthusian Argument
Malthus' argument rests upon two propositions; unchecked population increases in ageometrical ration while subsistence increases in an arithmetical ratio. The two propositions together constitute the famous principle of population which, according toMalthus, is "one of the causes that have hitherto impeded the progress of mankindtowards happiness" (Malthus, 1933:5). This cause is "intimately united with the very3
Leave a Comment