Environmental Health Perspectives\u2022volume117| number 7| July 2009
1131
Research
Developmental neurotoxicity (DN\ue002) o\ue004
environmental chemicals has been recog-
nize\ue003 worl\ue003wi\ue003e as a serious threat to
human health, an\ue003 the resulting neurologic
\ue003e\ue000cits negatively a\ue001ect \ue004amilies an\ue003 society
(Gol\ue003man an\ue003 Ko\ue003uru 2000; Nee\ue003leman
et al. 2002). Current DN\ue002 testing gui\ue003elines
(Organization \ue004or Economic Cooperation
an\ue003 Development 2007; U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency 1998) propose investiga-
tions in ro\ue003ents, mainly rats. Such a DN\ue002
in vivo testing strategy implies the use o\ue004
140 \ue003ams an\ue003 1,000 pups an\ue003 is there\ue004ore
extremely time- an\ue003 cost-intensive (Lein et al.
2005). Relying solely on the existing gui\ue003e-
lines to a\ue003\ue003ress current an\ue003 anticipate\ue003 \ue004uture
regulatory \ue003eman\ue003s \ue004or DN\ue002 o\ue004 the thou-
san\ue003s o\ue004 chemicals \ue004or which there are \ue004ew to
no DN\ue002 \ue003ata woul\ue003 incur unacceptable costs
in terms o\ue004 animals an\ue003 person-years (Lein
et al. 2007). Tere\ue004ore, accor\ue003ing to the \u201c3R
principle\u201d (re\ue003uction, replacement, an\ue003 re\ue000ne-
ment) o\ue004 Russel an\ue003 Burch (1959), alternative
testing strategies are nee\ue003e\ue003 to a\ue003\ue003ress ani-
mal wel\ue004are by re\ue000ning an\ue003 re\ue003ucing animal
experiments, an\ue003 to create a\ue001or\ue003able, sensi-
tive, an\ue003 mechanism-base\ue003 metho\ue003s suitable
\ue004or high- or me\ue003ium-throughput screening
(Collins et al. 2008). Furthermore, the inclu-
sion o\ue004 human-cell\u2013base\ue003 in vitro systems into
an integrate\ue003 DN\ue002 tiere\ue003 testing approach
has been recom men\ue003e\ue003 to circumvent species
\ue003i\ue001erences (Coecke et al. 2007).
\ue002o combine transatlantic strengths an\ue003
avoi\ue003 \ue003oubling o\ue004 work, a partnership between
the Johns Hopkins Center \ue004or Alternatives to
Animal \ue002esting (Developmental Neurotoxicity
\ue002estSmart program), the European Centre \ue004or
the Vali\ue003ation o\ue004 Alternative Metho\ue003s, an\ue003 the
European Chemical In\ue003ustry Council has been
\ue004orme\ue003. \ue002his partnership \ue004ollows the com-
mon goal o\ue004 \u201cincorporating in vitro alternative
metho\ue003s \ue004or DN\ue002 testing into international
hazar\ue003 an\ue003 risk assessment strategies\u201d (Coecke
et al. 2007). Coecke et al. (2007) provi\ue003e\ue003 a
comprehensive overview o\ue004 the existing in vitro
mo\ue003els an\ue003 state\ue003 that, \u201calthough all the test
systems \ue003escribe\ue003 were not \ue003evelope\ue003 \ue004or regu-
la tory purposes at this stage i\ue004 they prove use-
\ue004ul, we hope that this report will encourage
their \ue004urther \ue003evelopment to ren\ue003er them ame-
nable to high-throughput approaches.\u201d
Tere\ue004ore, the aim o\ue004 this work wasa) to
intro\ue003uce the cell biological characteristics o\ue004
human neurospheres as a three-\ue003imensional
cell system approach \ue004or DN\ue002 testing;b) to
\ue003emonstrate that neurospheres are likely to
mirror basic processes o\ue004 brain \ue003evelopment,
such as proli\ue004eration, \ue003i\ue001erentiation, migra-
tion, an\ue003 apoptosis; an\ue003c) to \ue003emonstrate that
these processes can be mo\ue003ulate\ue003 by \ue003evelop-
mental neuro toxicants.
Materials and Methods
Chemicals. We obtaine\ue003 methylmercury chlo-
ri\ue003e (MeHgCl) \ue004rom Rie\ue003el-\ue003e Ha\u00ebn (Seelze,
Germany); all other substances were obtaine\ue003
\ue004rom Sigma Al\ue003rich (Munich, Germany),
unless otherwise state\ue003.
Cell culture. Cryopreserve\ue003 normal
human neural progenitor cells (hNPCs; Lonza
Verviers SPRL, Verviers, Belgium) were cul-
ture\ue003 at 37\u00b0C an\ue003 5% CO2 as a suspension
culture in proli\ue004eration me\ue003ium consisting o\ue004
Dulbecco\u2019s mo\ue003i\ue000e\ue003 Eagle me\ue003ium (DMEM)
an\ue003 Hams F12 (3:1) supplemente\ue003 with B27
(Invitrogen GmbH, Karlsruhe, Germany),
20 ng/mL epi\ue003ermal growth \ue004actor (EGF;
Biosource, Karlsruhe, Germany), an\ue003 20 ng/
mL recombinant human \ue004ibroblast growth
\ue004actor (FGF; R&D Systems, Wiesba\ue003en-
Nor\ue003ensta\ue003t, Germany) (Moors et al. 2007).
When spheres reache\ue003 0.7 mm in \ue003iameter,
they were choppe\ue003 up to passage 3 with a
McIlwain tissue chopper. Di\ue001erentiation was
initiate\ue003 by growth \ue004actor with\ue003rawal in \ue003i\ue004-
\ue004erentiation me\ue003ium [DMEM an\ue003 Hams
F12 (3:1) supplemente\ue003 with N2 (insulin,
trans\ue004errin, so\ue003ium selenite, putrescine, an\ue003
progesterone; Invitrogen)] an\ue003 plate\ue003 onto
poly-d-lysine/laminin\u2013coate\ue003 chamber sli\ue003es
(BD Bioscience, Erembo\ue003egem, Belgium).
Chemical exposure. We expose\ue003 cells to
in\ue003irubin (10 \u00b5M) in proli\ue004eration me\ue003ium
(28 hr), an\ue003 to cAMP (200 \u00b5M), MeHgCl
(250 nM to 1 \u00b5M), mercury chlori\ue003e (HgCl2;
500 nM to 10 \u00b5M, 48 hr) or staurosporine
(0.1 an\ue003 1 \u00b5M), or hy\ue003rogen peroxi\ue003e
(H2O2; 0.1 an\ue003 1 mM) (24 hr) in \ue003i\ue001erentia-
tion me\ue003ium. We chose concentration ranges
o\ue004 mercury accor\ue003ing to Monnet-\ue002schu\ue003i
A\ue002\ue002ress correspon\ue002ence to E. Fritsche, Institut \ue003\u00fcr
Umweltme\ue002izinische Forschung gGmbH an \ue002er
Heinrich Heine-Universit\u00e4t, \ue001oxicology, Au\ue003\u2019m
Hennekamp 50, 40225 D\u00fcssel\ue002or\ue003, Germany.
\ue001elephone: 00492113389217. Fax: 00492113190910.
E-mail: ellen.\ue003ritsche@uni-\ue002uessel\ue002or\ue003.\ue002e
*Tese authors contribute\ue002 equally to this work.
Supplemental Material is available online at http://
www.ehponline.org/members/2009/0800207/suppl.p\ue002\ue003
Tis work was supporte\ue002 by the German Fe\ue002eral
Institute \ue003or Risk Assessment; the German Fe\ue002eral
Institute \ue003or the Environment, Nature Conservation
an\ue002 Nuclear Sa\ue003ety; the German Fe\ue002eral Ministry
\ue003or E\ue002ucation an\ue002 Research (13925C); an\ue002 the
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinscha\ue003t (GK1427).
\ue001he authors \ue002eclare they have no competing
\ue000nancial interests.
Receive\ue002 19 September 2008; accepte\ue002 26 February
2009.
Human Neurospheres as Three-Dimensional Cellular Systems for
Developmental Neurotoxicity Testing
Michaela Moors,* Thomas Dino Rockel,* Josef Abel, Jason E. Cline, Kathrin Gassmann, Timm Schreiber,
Janette Schuwald, Nicole Weinmann, and Ellen Fritsche
Institut f\u00fcr Umweltmedizinische Forschung gGmbH an der Heinrich Heine-Universit\u00e4t, Toxicology, D\u00fcsseldorf, Germany
Background: Developmental neurotoxicity (DN\ue001) o\ue002 environmental chemicals is a serious
threat to human health. Current DN\ue001 testing guidelines propose investigations in rodents, which
require large numbers o\ue002 animals. With regard to the \u201c3 Rs\u201d (reduction, replacement, and re\ue000ne-
ment) o\ue002 animal testing and the European regulation o\ue002 chemicals [Registration, Evaluation, and
Authorisation o\ue002 Chemicals (REACH)], alternative testing strategies are needed in order to re\ue000ne
and reduce animal experiments and allow \ue002aster and less expensive screening.
oBjectives: Te goal o\ue002 this study was to establish a three-dimensional test system \ue002or DN\ue001 screening
based on human \ue002etal brain cells.
Methods: We established assays suitable \ue002or detecting disturbances in basic processes o\ue002 brain
development by employing human neural progenitor cells (hNPCs), which grow as neurospheres.
Furthermore, we assessed efects o\ue002 mercury and oxidative stress on these cells.
results: We \ue002ound that human neurospheres imitate proli\ue002eration, diferentiation, and migration
in vitro. Exposure to the proapoptotic agent staurosporine \ue002urther suggests that human neuro-
spheres possess \ue002unctioning apoptosis machinery. Te developmental neurotoxicants methylmercury
chloride and mercury chloride decreased migration distance and number o\ue002 neuronal-like cells in
diferentiated hNPCs. Furthermore, hNPCs undergo caspase-independent apoptosis when exposed
toward high amounts o\ue002 oxidative stress.
conclusions: Human neurospheres are likely to imitate basic processes o\ue002 brain development, and
these processes can be modulated by developmental neurotoxicants. Tus, this three-dimensional
cell system is a promising approach \ue002or DN\ue001 testing.
key words: apoptosis, diferentiation, DN\ue001, human neurospheres, mercury, migration, proli\ue002era-
tion. Environ Health Perspect 117:1131\u20131138 (2009). doi:10.1289/ehp.0800207 available viahttp://
dx.doi.org/[Online 26 February 2009]
Leave a Comment